Enantioselectivity limitation

Nitrilases catalyze the synthetically important hydrolysis of nitriles with formation of the corresponding carboxylic acids [4]. Scientists at Diversa expanded the collection of nitrilases by metagenome panning [56]. Nevertheless, in numerous cases the usual limitations of enzyme catalysis become visible, including poor or only moderate enantioselectivity, limited activity (substrate acceptance), and/or product inhibition. Diversa also reported the first example of the directed evolution of an enantioselective nitrilase [20]. An additional limitation had to be overcome, which is sometimes ignored, when enzymes are used as catalysts in synthetic organic chemistry product inhibition and/or decreased enantioselectivity at high substrate concentrations [20]. 

Developments along these three lines can be expected to greatly extend the yet limited utility of catalysis by hard Lewis acids in aqueous media. The work described in this thesis has demonstrated drat these efforts can be rewarded by increased in rate and most importantly, enantioselectivity. 

Although the limited examples of AE reactions on 2,3Z-substituted allyl alcohols appear to give product epoxides in good enantioselectivity, the highly substituted nature of these olefins can have a deleterious effect on the reactivity. For example, Aiai has shown that the 2,3E-substituted allyl alcohol 30 can be epoxidized with either (-)-DET or (+)-DET in good yields and enantioselectivity. However, the configurational isomer 32 is completely unreactive using (-)-DET, even after a 34 h reaction time. 

The catalytic enantioselective cycloaddition reaction of carbonyl compounds with conjugated dienes has been in intensive development in recent years with the main focus on synthetic aspects the number of mechanistic studies has been limited. This chapter will focus on the development and understanding of cycloaddition reactions of carbonyl compounds with chiral Lewis acid catalysts for the preparation of optically active six-membered ring systems. 

Finally, there is the enantioselectivity of the 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition reactions. This chapter is limited to describing only the metal-catalyzed asymmetric 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition reactions that involve non-chiral starting materials. The only fac-... 

Dipolar cydoadditions are one of the most useful synthetic methods to make stereochemically defined five-membered heterocydes. Although a variety of dia-stereoselective 1,3-dipolar cydoadditions have been well developed, enantioselec-tive versions are still limited [29]. Nitrones are important 1,3-dipoles that have been the target of catalyzed enantioselective reactions [66]. Three different approaches to catalyzed enantioselective reactions have been taken (1) activation of electron-defident alkenes by a chiral Lewis acid [23-26, 32-34, 67], (2) activation of nitrones in the reaction with ketene acetals [30, 31], and (3) coordination of both nitrones and allylic alcohols on a chiral catalyst [20]. Among these approaches, the dipole/HOMO-controlled reactions of electron-deficient alkenes are especially promising because a variety of combinations between chiral Lewis acids and electron-deficient alkenes have been well investigated in the study of catalyzed enantioselective Diels-Alder reactions. Enantioselectivities in catalyzed nitrone cydoadditions sometimes exceed 90% ee, but the efficiency of catalytic loading remains insufficient. 

Accordingly, cyclic nitronates can be a useful synthetic equivalent of functionalized nitrile oxides, while reaction examples are quite limited. Thus, 2-isoxazoline N-oxide and 5,6-dihydro-4H-l,2-oxazine N-oxide, as five- and six-membered cyclic nitronates, were generated in-situ by dehydroiodination of 3-iodo-l-nitropropane and 4-iodo-l-nitrobutane with triethylamine and trapped with monosubstituted alkenes to give 5-substituted 3-(2-hydroxyethyl)isoxazolines and 2-phenylperhydro-l,2-oxazino[2,3-fe]isoxazole, respectively (Scheme 7.26) [72b]. Upon treatment with a catalytic amount of trifluoroacetic acid, the perhydro-l,2-oxazino[2,3-fe]isoxazole was quantitatively converted into the corresponding 2-isoxazoline. Since a method for catalyzed enantioselective nitrone cycloadditions was established and cyclic nitronates should behave like cyclic nitrones in reactivity, there would be a good chance to attain catalyzed enantioselective formation of 2-isoxazolines via nitronate cycloadditions. 

It may be concluded from die different examples sliown here tiiat die enantio-selective copper-catalyzed allylic substitution reaction needs ftirdier improvemetiL High enantioselectivities can be obtained if diirality is present in tiie leaving group of die substrate, but widi external diiral ligands, enantioselectivities in excess of 9096 ee have only been obtained in one system, limited to die introduction of die sterically hindered neopeatyl group. 

The use of catalysts for a Diels-Alder reaction is often not necessary, since in many cases the product is obtained in high yield in a reasonable reaction time. In order to increase the regioselectivity and stereoselectivity (e.g. to obtain a particular endo- or exo-product), Lewis acids as catalysts (e.g. TiCU, AICI3, BF3-etherate) have been successfully employed." The usefulness of strong Lewis acids as catalysts may however be limited, because they may also catalyze polymerization reactions of the reactants. Chiral Lewis acid catalysts are used for catalytic enantioselective Diels-Alder reactions. ... 

As a matter of fact, the main advantage in comparison with HPLC is the reduction of solvent consumption, which is limited to the organic modifiers, and that will be nonexistent when no modifier is used. Usually, one of the drawbacks of HPLC applied at large scale is that the product must be recovered from dilute solution and the solvent recycled in order to make the process less expensive. In that sense, SFC can be advantageous because it requires fewer manipulations of the sample after the chromatographic process. This facilitates recovery of the products after the separation. Although SFC is usually superior to HPLC with respect to enantioselectivity, efficiency and time of analysis [136], its use is limited to compounds which are soluble in nonpolar solvents (carbon dioxide, CO,). This represents a major drawback, as many of the chemical and pharmaceutical products of interest are relatively polar. 

The first successful chiral resolutions through enantioselective membranes have been published recently, but few cases are applicable to the preparative scale, mainly due to mechanical and technical limitations. Low flow rates, saturation of the chiral selectors and loss of enantioselectivity with time are some of the common problems encountered and that should be solved in the near future. 

Early examples of enantioselective extractions are the resolution of a-aminoalco-hol salts, such as norephedrine, with lipophilic anions (hexafluorophosphate ion) [184-186] by partition between aqueous and lipophilic phases containing esters of tartaric acid [184-188]. Alkyl derivatives of proline and hydroxyproline with cupric ions showed chiral discrimination abilities for the resolution of neutral amino acid enantiomers in n-butanol/water systems [121, 178, 189-192]. On the other hand, chiral crown ethers are classical selectors utilized for enantioseparations, due to their interesting recognition abilities [171, 178]. However, the large number of steps often required for their synthesis [182] and, consequently, their cost as well as their limited loadability makes them not very suitable for preparative purposes. Examples of ligand-exchange [193] or anion-exchange selectors [183] able to discriminate amino acid derivatives have also been described. 

Among the existing separation techniques, some - due to their intrinsic characteristics - are more adapted than others to processing large amounts of material. Such processes, which already exist at industrial level, can be considered in order to perform an enantioselective separation. This is the case for techniques such as distillation and foam flotation, both of which constitute well-known techniques that can be adapted to the separation of enantiomers. The involvement of a chiral selector can be the clue which changes a nonstereoselective process into an enantioselective one. Clearly, this selector must be adapted to the characteristics and limitations of the process itself. 

In the elucidation of retention mechanisms, an advantage of using enantiomers as templates is that nonspecific binding, which affects both enantiomers equally, cancels out. Therefore the separation factor (a) uniquely reflects the contribution to binding from the enantioselectively imprinted sites. As an additional comparison the retention on the imprinted phase is compared with the retention on a nonimprinted reference phase. The efficiency of the separations is routinely characterized by estimating a number of theoretical plates (N), a resolution factor (R ) and a peak asymmetry factor (A ) [19]. These quantities are affected by the quality of the packing and mass transfer limitations, as well as of the amount and distribution of the binding sites. 

Temperature can also be used to optimize enantioselectivity in SFC. The selectivity of most CSPs increases as temperature decreases. For this reason, most chiral separations in SFC are performed at ambient or subambient temperatures [50, 74]. Subambient temperatures are particularly useful for compounds having low conformational stability [75]. Stringham and Blackwell explored the concept of entropically driven separations [76]. As temperature increased, enantioselectivity decreased until the enantiomers co-eluted at the isoelution temperature. Further increases in temperature resulted in reversal of elution order of the enantiomers. The temperature limitations of the CSP should be considered before working at elevated temperatures. 

Solladie-Cavallo has recently reported a two-step asymmetric synthesis of dis-ubstituted N-tosylaziridines from (R,R,R,Ss)-(-)-sulfonium salt 2 (derived from Eliel s oxathiane see Section 1.2.1.1) and N-tosyl imines with use of phosphazine base (EtP2) to generate the ylide (Scheme 1.42) [67], Although the diastereoselectiv-ity was highly substrate-dependent, the enantioselectivities obtained were very high (98.7-99.9%). The chiral auxiliary, although used in stoichiometric quantities, could be isolated and reused, but the practicality and scope of this procedure is limited by the use of the strong - as well as expensive and sensitive - phospha-zene base. 

Despite these significant results in azide additions, only limited success has been obtained in enantioselective addition of other sp2-hybridized nitrogen-centered nucleophiles to meso-epoxides. Bartoli et al. demonstrated that aniline was a... 

Jacobsen developed a method employing (pybox)YbCl3 for TMSCN addition to meso-epoxides (Scheme 7.22) [46] with enantioselectivities as high as 92%. Unfortunately, the practical utility of this method is limited because low temperatures must be maintained for very long reaction times (up to seven days). This reaction displayed a second-order dependence on catalyst concentration and a positive nonlinear effect, suggesting a cooperative bimetallic mechanism analogous to that proposed for (salen)Cr-catalyzed ARO reactions (Scheme 7.5). 

Enantioselective epoxidation of unfunctionalized alkenes was until recently limited to certain ds-alkenes, but most types of alkenes can now be successfully epoxi-dized with sugar-derived dioxiranes (see Section 9.1.1.1) [2]. Selective monoepox-idation of dienes has thus become a fast route to vinylepoxides. Functionalized dienes, such as dienones, can be epoxidized with excellent enantioselectivities (see Section 9.1.2). 

Aliphatic, aromatic and vinylic aldehydes can be employed in this reaction with similar yields and enantioselectivities. When chiral aldehydes are utilized, excellent diastereoselectivity is obtained for matched cases, whereas mismatched cases yield products with moderate to good diastereoselectivity (Scheme 9.13a) [67]. The limitation of the methodology is that only terminal vinylepoxides can be obtained. 

Improved methods for the preparation of reagents such as isopinocampheyl(l-isopinocam-pheyl-2-alkenyl)borinic acids will certainly lead to a more enantioselective synthesis of anti-homoallylic alcohols, since the enantiomeric purity of the reagent is the only significant limitation to the synthetic utility of this reagent system. 

The most commonly used traditional Lewis acids are halides of aluminum, boron, titanium, zinc, tin, and copper. However, there are also more complex Lewis-acids that are quite effective catalysts that can be easily modified for carring out enantioselective processes, by incorporating chiral ligands. These can overcome some limitations associated with the use of classical Lewis acids [47]. 

Of course, the influence of organic solvents on enzyme enantioselectivity is not limited to proteases but it is a general phenomenon. Quite soon, different research groups described the results obtained with lipases [28]. For instance, the resolution of the mucolytic drug ( )-trans-sobrerol (11) was achieved by transesteriflcation with vinyl acetate catalyzed by the lipase from Pseudomonas cepacia adsorbed on celite in various solvents. As depicted in Scheme 1.3 and Table 1.5, it was found that t-amyl alcohol was the solvent of choice in this medium, the selectivity was so high ( >500) that the reaction stopped spontaneously at 50% conversion giving both +)4rans-sobrerol and (—)-trans-sobrerol monoacetate in 100% optical purity [29]. 

Enzymatic KRs, as all resolutions, are limited to a maximum theoretical yield of 50%. Strategies to increase the yield are therefore of great importance. The opposite of a resolution, that is, the racemization of a chiral compound, can sometimes be highly desirable and applicable in enantioselective synthesis. By combining a... 

A novel approach was developed very recently by Kita et al. [15]. DKR of allylic alcohols was performed by combining a lipase-catalyzed acylation with a racemization through the formation of allyl vanadate intermediates. Excellent yields and enantioselectivities were obtained. An example is shown in Figure 4.4. A limitation with this approach for the substrates shown in Figure 4.4 is that the allylic alcohol must be equally disubstituted in the allylic position (R = R ) since C—C single bond rotation is required in the tertiary alkoxy intermediate. Alternatively, R or R can be H if the two allylic alcohols formed by migration of the hydroxyl group are enantiomers (e.g. cyclic allylic acetates). 

Muller et al. have also examined the enantioselectivity and the stereochemical course of copper-catalyzed intramolecular CH insertions of phenyl-iodonium ylides [34]. The decomposition of diazo compounds in the presence of transition metals leads to typical reactions for metal-carbenoid intermediates, such as cyclopropanations, insertions into X - H bonds, and formation of ylides with heteroatoms that have available lone pairs. Since diazo compounds are potentially explosive, toxic, and carcinogenic, the number of industrial applications is limited. Phenyliodonium ylides are potential substitutes for diazo compounds in metal-carbenoid reactions. Their photochemical, thermal, and transition-metal-catalyzed decompositions exhibit some similarities to those of diazo compounds. 

---