Role of theory

The diversity and lifetime of the products formed as a result of ionizing radiations add to the complexity in their detection and identification. Over the past several years, theoretical calculations on DNA model systems have significantly contributed to further determination of the chemical properties of many of the unstable species formed, [6] and hence to better our understanding of the processes involved. Ab initio and semi empirical methods were first employed in this field by Pullman s laboratory in the 1960s to investigate the electron affinities and ionization potentials of the DNA bases. Since then, rapid development of hardware and software at the end of the eighties has allowed additional and more complete theoretical studies to be performed and hence contributed to the understanding of free radical processes in irradiated components. 

In this chapter, we review recent theoretical results of studies of radiation damage to DNA obtained in gas phase and in solution with the use of ab initio molecular orbital theory which has the advantage of being free of any empirical parameters. In the first part, we discuss results from works performed on species that are predominant in the direct effect, that is the natural DNA bases and their radical ions in various environments (i.e. base pairs, stacked systems, solvent), focusing on electron affinities and ionization potentials. We then review theoretical data obtained for species which result from OH and H attack in the indirect effect (sugar radicals, hydroxyl and hydrogen base adducts). In a third part, we discuss the fate of the hydroxyl base adducts, which upon H atom addition and subsequent dehydration lead to the regeneration of the natural DNA bases. Finally, we focus on the radioprotective roles of selected thiols and the possible mechanisms by which they act. Since an excellent and comprehensive review of the tools and methods currently used in molecular orbital theory has recently appeared, [15] it will not be further discussed here. 

In DNA, radiation damage originates with the formation of anion and cation free radicals whose distribution depends respectively on the electron affinities and ionization potentials of the bases. Knowledge of the energetics and structures of the individual bases is necessary in the first step towards the 

Fewer theoretical studies have been performed on the base radical ions [6, 16, 33, 34]. They appear to undergo a strong flattening of the amino groups which become nearly planar in the radical cations [33]. In our laboratory, we have performed 3-21G and 6-3IG full geometry optimizations of the four DNA base radical ions [16, 34] and observed that geometrical relaxation and destabilization of the bases upon cation radical formation is more significant than upon anion radical formation. Such destabilization of the cation radical appears to influence the rate of interpair electron transfer and the adiabatic ionization potential [35]. 

The electron affinities of the DNA bases are fundamentally important to the understanding of electron transfer through DNA as well as the localization of excess electrons on DNA [50]. As a consequence the electron affinities (EA) of the DNA bases have been under active investigation in our laboratory [16, 34, 47, 51, 52], 

---

Radiation probes such as neutrons, x-rays and visible light are used to see the structure of physical systems tlirough elastic scattering experunents. Inelastic scattering experiments measure both the structural and dynamical correlations that exist in a physical system. For a system which is in thennodynamic equilibrium, the molecular dynamics create spatio-temporal correlations which are the manifestation of themial fluctuations around the equilibrium state. For a condensed phase system, dynamical correlations are intimately linked to its structure. For systems in equilibrium, linear response tiieory is an appropriate framework to use to inquire on the spatio-temporal correlations resulting from thennodynamic fluctuations. Appropriate response and correlation functions emerge naturally in this framework, and the role of theory is to understand these correlation fiinctions from first principles. This is the subject of section A3.3.2. 

The aim of the series is to present the latest fundamental material for research chemists, lecturers and students across the breadth of the subject, reaching into the various applications of theoretical techniques and modelling. The series concentrates on teaching the fundamentals of chemical structure, symmetry, bonding, reactivity, reaction mechanism, solid-state chemistry and applications in molecular modelling. It will emphasize the transfer of theoretical ideas and results to practical situations so as to demonstrate the role of theory in the solution of chemical problems in the laboratory and in industry. 

Williams, F.A., The role of theory in combustion science, Proc. Combust. Inst., 24, 1,1992. 

The results of these investigations are presented in Fig. 7, where the signals A5[r, x] are plotted for the bridge and anti form of the radical (C2H2I). These hgures favor neatly the bridge form. The concentrations of different species in the solution at different times were also determined. The crucial role of theory should be emphasized it would be difficult to extract this information by simple insight of the experimental data. 

Follette, W. C., St Houts, A. C. (1996). Models of scientific progress and the role of theory in taxonomy development A case study of the DSM. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 64, 1120-1132. 

Thus, theoretical modeling of bluff-body flame stabilization cannot yet compete with the experimental approaches. Partially, it is due to the fundamental problems relevant to the turbulent combustion theory. The underestimation of the role of theory is also due to the lack of systematic studies based on existing models. 

To appreciate this section and, more broadly, to appreciate the importance of this book s topic as a justification for mathematics, one should understand the role of theory in the physical sciences. While in mathematics the intrinsic beauty of a theory is sufficient justification for its study, the value of a theory in the physical sciences is limited to the value of the experimental predictions it makes. For example, the theory of the double-helical structure of... 

Whereas many scientists shared Mulliken s initial skepticism regarding the practical role of theory in solving problems in chemistry and physics, the work of London (6) on dispersion forces in 1930 and Hbckel s 7t-electron theory in 1931 (7) continued to attract the interest of many, including a young scientist named Frank Westheimer who, drawing on the physics of internal motions as detailed by Pitzer (8), first applied the basic concepts of what is now called molecular mechanics to compute the rates of the racemization of ortho-dibromobiphenyls. The 1946 publication (9) of these results would lay the foundation for Westheimer s own systematic conformational analysis studies (10) as well as for many others, eg, Hendrickson s (11) and Allinger s (12). These scientists would utilize basic Newtonian mechanics coupled with concepts from spectroscopy (13,14) to develop nonquantum mechanical models of structures, energies, and reactivity. 

As discussed in the introduction, one important role of theory in studies of reaction mechanisms in inorganic chemistry is its ability to predict or reproduce the structure of individual inorganic complexes. This is useful where the complex being studied is an experimentally well-characterized species, as calculations can provide insight into the electronic structure and the bonding patterns of the complex and help to rationalize its reactivity based on these features. It is perhaps even more valuable, though, when the focus is on a species that has not been characterized experimentally. 

The genesis and development of quantum chemistry as an autonomous subdiscipline owed much to those scientists who were able to realize that what had started as an extra bit of physics was going to become a central part of chemistry". Those that manage to escape successfully from the thought forms of the physicist [17] by implicitly or explicitly addressing issues such as the role of theory in chemistry, and the methodological status of empirical observations helped to create... 

Karna SP (2000) Electronic and nonlinear optical materials the role of theory and modeling. J. Phys. Chem. A 104 4671 1673... 

Journal of Chemical Education The Role of Theory in Chemistry (p. 365) Volume 62, Number 5, May 1985... 

Although both the laboratory and industrial scale materials science of catalysts requires an integrated approach as already mentioned above, it is customary to classify the characterization methods by their objects and experimental tools used. I will use the object classification and direct the introductory comments to analysis, primarily elemental and molecular surface analysis, determination of geometric structure, approaches toward the determination of electronic structure, characterization by chemisorption and reaction studies, determination of pore structure, morphology, and texture, and, finally, the role of theory in interpreting the often complex characterization data as well as predicting reaction paths. 

The objectives of this review are to describe the types of structures that can be formed by self-assembly in these systems, to discuss the current experimental and theoretical issues of self-assembly, to assess the current role of theory in the predicting stability of self-assembled systems, and to highlight important future directions for self-assembled structures. 

Rouelle downplayed the role of theory while he promised a great, sensational show. The last part of his course would reveal the substances that are taken from the entrails of the earth and would be the object of unusual experiments on bitumen, niter, marine salts, and the acids. The effects of all the mixtures would produce changes in colour, detonations and the production of flames ... 

As we mentioned, oxide surfaces are important in the field of nanocatalysis by supported metals. In practical applications, the support has the crucial role of stabilizing small metallic particles, which act as the actual catalysts in a chemical process. Once the oxide surface is sufficiently well characterized, one can deposit small metal clusters and study their reactivity as a function of the support, of the metal, of the size of the cluster, etc. In this way, complex catalytic processes can be divided into a series of substeps, which allow a more detailed microscopic characterization. Despite the fact that only recently well-defined metal clusters have been deposited under controlled conditions on oxide surfaces and thin films, great advances have been obtained in the understanding of the mechanisms of adhesion and growth of the metal particles to the oxide surface. In this process, the role of theory is quite substantial. 

The role of theory has been essential from concepmal as well as from a predictive point of view. Time-resolved observations are strongly dependent on the experimental conditions, such as laser wavelengths, duration of pulses and their shapes, competition between one- and many-photon processes, strength of the electric field, and so on. Here theory has the task not only to provide insight into the nature of time-dependent processes, but also to identify the conditions under which they can be experimentally observed [19-21, 44—55]. 

In our concluding remarks we would like to turn to the role of theory in the study of temporary anions In polyatomic molecules. 

As we saw in Section IIC, in order to begin the GED structure analysis one needs a trial model. In early days this model was based on the chemical intuition of the researcher while nowadays it can be calculated using some of the methods of theoretical chemistry. The role of theory is not limited, however, to calculation of only the geometrical structure as is shown in Fig. 4 it gives also Energy and Force Fields (see mote about theoretical... 

We have examined several systems chosen to illustrate the current role of theory and simulation in biomimetics and biocatalysis. It should be clear that the theory is not done in a vacuum (so to speak) but rather that the theory becomes interesting only for systems amenable to experimental analysis. However, the examples illustrate how the theory can provide new insights and deeper understanding of the experiments. As experience with such simulations accumulates and as predictions are made on more and more complex systems amenable to experiment, it will become increasingly feasible to use the theory on unknown systems. As the predictions on such unknown systems are tested with experiment and as the reliability of the predictions increases, these techniques will become true design tools for development of new biological systems. 

Philosophers of science who write about incommensurability typically focus on the role of theory. Thomas Kuhn, whose notion of paradigm shift is central to any discussion of incommensurability, saw new theories as the generators of incommensurability. Incommensurability resulted as new theories changed both the questions... 

---