Methodology estimation

We have already seen elements of the CA approach when considering the costs due to safety critical failures. A further insight into the way that failure costs can be estimated for non-safety critical failures is also used to support the CA methodology. Estimates for the costs of failure in this category are based on the experiences of a sample of industrial businesses and published material as follows. 

For inhalation exposure, an appropriate default methodology estimates respiratory deposition of particles and gases, and estimates internal doses of gases with different absorption characteristics. 

Note The serious violent crimes included are rape, robbery, aggravated assault, and homicide. Because of changes made to the victimization survey, data prior to 1992 are adjusted to make them comparable to data collected under the redesigned methodology. Estimates for 1993 and beyond are based on collection year while earlier estimates are based on data year. 

Class of Estimate Level of Project Definition (as of Complete Definition) Typical Purpose of Estimate Methodology (Estimating Method) Expected Accuracy Range (+/ Range Relative to Best Index of 1 Preparation Effort (Relative to Lowest Cost Index of 1)... 

Protein films tend to be gaseous at low concentrations, thus permitting relative molecular weight determination (see also Equation 4.10). Based on this methodology, estimate the molecular weight of the protein valinomycin from the following measurements of the surface pressure for various areas at 25 °C ... 

Introduction Theprevious sections dealt with techniques for the identification of hazards and methods for calculating the effects of accidental releases of hazardous materials. This section addresses the methodologies available to analyze and estimate risk, which is a function of both the consequences of an incident and its frequency. The apphcation of these methodologies in most instances is not trivial. A significant allocation of resources is necessary. Therefore, a selection process or risk prioritization process is advised before considering a risk analysis study. 

Human error probabilities can also be estimated using methodologies and techniques originally developed in the nuclear industry. A number of different models are available (Swain, Comparative Evaluation of Methods for Human Reliability Analysis, GRS Project RS 688, 1988). This estimation process should be done with great care, as many factors can affect the reliability of the estimates. Methodologies using expert opinion to obtain failure rate and probability estimates have also been used where there is sparse or inappropriate data. 

In a basis of modem methodology of an estimation of quality of water measurement of the generalized parameters lays. One of the most essential sueh pai ameters ai e oxidability and toxieity of eomponents of waters. 

At Cpk = 1, or approximately 1300 ppm failures expeeted, the probable eost of failure per million produets would be 364 000. At Cp = 0.8 (or 8000 ppm) the probable eost of failure would inerease by an order of magnitude to over 2.2 million. These failure eosts do not take into aeeount the eosts assoeiated with damaged eompany reputation and lost opportunities whieh are diffieult to assess, but do indieate that failure eost estimates assoeiated with produet designs are possible. This aspeet of the CA methodology is further developed in Chapter 2. 

In the next chapter, we introduce the concepts of component manufacturing capability and the relationships between tolerance, variability and cost. The Component Manufacturing Variability Risks Analysis is then introduced, the first stage of the CA methodology, from which process capability estimates can be determined at the design stage. The development of the knowledge and indices used in the analysis... 

The case studies that follow have mainly come from live product development projects in industry. Whilst not all case studies require the methodology to predict an absolute capability, a common way of applying CA is by evaluating and comparing a number of design schemes and selecting the one with the most acceptable performance measure, either estimated Cp, assembly risk or failure cost. In some cases, commercial confidence precludes the inclusion of detailed drawings of the components used in the analyses. CA has been used in industry in a number of different ways. Some of these are discussed below ... 

A methodology for assembly stack analysis 3.4.1 Application of the process capability estimates from CA... 

This valuable reference volume conveys a basic understanding of chemical reactor design methodologies that incorporate both scale-up and hazard analysis. It shows readers how to select the best reactor for any particular chemical reaction, how to estimate its size, and how to obtain the best operating conditions. 

The Committee is unable to determine whether the absolute probabilities of accident sequences in WASH-1400 are high or low, but it is believed that the error bounds on those estimates are, in general, greatly understated. This is due in part to an inability to quantify common cause failures, and in part to some questionable methodological and statistical procedures. 

The methodology for assessment of external events is qualitatively satisfactory but not quantitatively. Little confidence should be placed in any estimates of the risk from external initiators compared to those from internal initiators. This is exacerbated by the fact that the external risk is the larger of the two in many cases. 

Remember that the objectives of the pilot are to refine the integration methodology and to estimate the expected costs of the project and benefits that integration will provide. 

The report presents the findings from the analysis of the RCP failures. Estimates of the annual frequency for the spectrum of leak rates induced by RCP seal failures and their impact on plant safety (contribution to coremelt frequency) are made. The safety impact of smaller RCP seal leaks was assessed qualitatively, whereas for leaks above the normal makeup capacity, formal PRA methodologies were applied. Also included are the life distribution of RCP seals and the conditional leak rate distributions, given a RCP seal failure the contribution of various root causes and estimates for the dependency factors and the failure intensity for the different combinations of pump designers and plant vendors. 

Appendix III contains failure rate estimates for various genetic types of mechanical and electrical equipment. Included ate listings of failure rates with range estimates for specified component failure modes, demand probabilities, and times to maintain repair. It also contains some discussion on such special topics as human errors, aircraft crash probabilities, loss of electric power, and pipe breaks. Appendix III contains a great deal of general information of use to analysts on the methodology of data assessment for PRA. 

WASH-1400 is a fundamental document for PRA methodology. The data appendixes contain a great deal of useful information on methods of data assessment. A large number of sources for data are considered, and very general failure rate estimates will produce only gross approximations. Since the advent of data collection schemes across and within plants, the WASH-1400 data are solely useful as a constituent to a data aggregation process or as widely bounded figures that provide a basis for comparison. 

Acceptable Daily Intake (ADI) An estimate similar in concept to the RfD, but derived using a less strictly defined methodology. RfDs have replaced ADIs as the USEPA s (Agency) preferred values for use in evaluating potential noiicarcinogenic health effects resulting from exposure to a chemical. 

---