Method for scaling

According to this method, it is not necessaiy to investigate the kinetics of the chemical reactions in detail, nor is it necessary to determine the solubihties or the diffusivities of the various reactants in their unreacted forms. To use the method for scaling up, it is necessaiy independently to obtain data on the values of the interfacial area per unit volume a and the physical mass-transfer coefficient /c for the commercial packed tower. Once these data have been measured and tabulated, they can be used directly for scahng up the experimental laboratory data for any new chemic ly reac ting system. 

It would be desirable to reinterpret existing data for commercial tower packings to extract the individual values of the interfacial area a and the mass-transfer coefficients fcc and /c in order to facilitate a more general usage of methods for scaling up from laboratory experiments. Some progress in this direction has afready been made, as discussed later in this section. In the absence of such data, it is necessary to operate a pilot plant or a commercial absorber to obtain kc, /c , and a as described by Ouwerkerk (op. cit.). 

The performance of a chemical plant depends upon an enormously high number of design and operating variables. This great number of process variables makes it impossible to find optimal conditions within the region of safe operation if no quantitative relationships (defined in terms of mathematics) between performance indices and process variables are known. In general, optima are complex functions of process variables, and therefore quantification of experimental ressults is needed. The methods for scale-up that were conventionally used at the time of Perkin chemistry resulted in successful commercialization of many laboratory recipes. This evolutionary, step-by-step method of scale-up is illustrated in Fig. 5.3-1 (after Moulijn et al. 2001). 

Just as there is no prescription in the algorithm that defines the fitness function itself, we are free to choose a method for scaling that seems to be... 

A general comment that affects all statistical multivariate data analysis techniques, namely that each of the variables should be given equal chance to influence the outcome of the analysis. This can be achieved by scaling the variables in appropriative way. One popular method for scaling variables is autoscaling, whereby the variance of each variable is adjusted to 1. 

Overall, the microreactor provides greater safety for individuals and equipment and reduces the likelihood of loss of process and the consequent disruption and even loss of sales that can follow. In common with other fine chemical manufacturers, most pharmaceutical companies have programs to capture the benefits of flow microreactors as adjuncts to or even replacements for their current batch methods for scaling up production of candidate molecules to satisfy clinical and manufacturing needs. This paper attempts to demonstrate that microreactors can be deployed more widely in pharmaceutical R D than as a tool for enhanced production and that they have the potential to underpin significant paradigm shifts in both early- and late-phase R D. 

Different methods for scale-out have been collected and presented (Lob et al. 2006a). The two main methods are a smart scale-up, at best after having intensified the process, or the internal numbering-up concept. The first route was shown long ago by the Merck production case for an organometallic reaction, changing from micro- to mini-mixers (Krummradt et al. 2000). This route seems to be feasible, as long as... 

In Chapter 3, the reaction system is discussed using the heat and mass balances, and interaction with the equipment. Scale-up affects both temperature and pressure profiles, which vary with types of reactor systems and sizes. Relevant test methods for scale-up and for process design are covered, including discussions on the methods as well as the relative advantages and disadvantages. Typical approaches for safe design and for defensive measures are presented. The theoretical and experimental subjects in Chapters 2 and 3 are illustrated by the use of examples. 

The transition speeds (rotation rates) were determined for the change from the small out pattern to stripes at 50% filling for all the blenders listed in Table 2 (Figure 7 shows results from the 1.9 and 12.9 qt. blenders). As discussed earlier, the most commonly accepted methods for scaling tumbling blenders have used one of two parameters, either the Fr or the tangential speed of the blender. Earlier, we derived V = and showed that... 

In complex systems such as three-phase reactors, the methods of mathematical modeling cannot provide the required information for process design and scale-up since it is practically impossible to take into account all existing phenomena and safely predict the influence of hydrodynamics, heat and mass transfer, or kinetics on each other (Datsevich and Muhkortov, 2004). Thus, models are almost always approximate in nature. They are based on a number of assumptions that cannot be met during scale-up. So, it is not surprising that industrial unit designers do not completely trust the results obtained from mathematical modeling. Thus, several systems cannot be fully modeled mathematically and other methods for scale-up are followed. 

While studying the chemistry of 4,5-dichloro-l,2,3-dithiazolium chloride (Appel s salt) and its derivatives, Besson reported the synthesis of various benzothiazoles from N-arylimino-l,2,3-dithiazoles, which could be synthesised from commercially available aromatic amines28. In this work, the authors explored a variety of strategies to construct the benzothiazole ring and demonstrated that in all cases the focused microwave methodologies were more productive and under well-defined conditions provided convenient methods for scale-up (Scheme 3.17)28. Comparisons were also made between reactions performed under solvent-free conditions and in the presence of solvent29. It is noteworthy that there is no general rule and some reactions performed in the presence of solvent may sometimes be more convenient than the same dry media reaction. 

Production rates increase with elevation of a target because cosmic rays at higher elevations have traveled through less mass in the atmosphere. Several methods for scaling production with elevation have been developed (e.g., Lai and Peters 1967 Lai 1991 Dunai 2000 Stone 2000). In the simplest case, changes in production of a nuclide with elevation can be approximated by an exponential function that mimics the exponential pattern of secondary cosmic ray flux for both neutrons and muons (Gosse and Phillips 2001) ... 

Wang RH, Fan LT. 1974. Methods for scaling-up tumbling mixers. Chem. Engng 81(11) 88-94. 

A second example is provided by a semiempirical correlation for multi-component activity coefficients in aqueous electrolyte solutions shown in Fig. 2. This correlation, developed by Fritz Meissner at MIT [3], presents a method for scale-up activity-coefficient data for single-salt solutions, which are plentiful, are used to predict activity coefficients for multisalt solutions for which experimental data are rare. The scale-up is guided by an extended Debye-Hilckel theory, but essentially it is based on enlightened empiricism. Meissner s method provides useful estimates of thermodynamic properties needed for process design of multieffect evaporators to produce salts from multicomponent brines. It will be many years before sophisticated statistical mechanical techniques can perform a similar scale-up calculation. Until then, correlations such as Meissner s will be required in a conventional industry that produces vast amounts of inexpensive commodity chemicals. 

One novel method for scale control is magnetic and electrostatic technology suggested by US Department of Energy [22]. This nonchemical technology is recommended for scale and hardness control as a reliable energy saver in certain applications that can be used as a replacement for most water-softening equipment. 

Wang R, Fan L, Methods for scaling up tumbling mixers. Chem Eng 1974 8(ll) 88-94. Bates L. User Guide to Segregation. London. U.K. British Materials Handling Board, 1997. Williams J. The segregation of particulate materials A review. Powder Technol 1976 15 245-51. 

Suspension culture is the preferred method for scale-up because it is easier and cheaper, it requires less space, cell growth can be monitored and environmental parameters can be controlled more easily. However, many cell lines have higher specific productivity when attached to the substrate. In the urge to move to suspension systems, the following advantages of anchorage-dependent systems should not be overlooked ... 

A recent example of the power of this technique when applied to natural products is the development of an efficient method for scale-up produchon of epothilone D (Figure 8.6), which entered clinical trials as a potential anticancer agent but has now been disconhnued in favor of a congener, 9,10-didehydroepothilone D. Epothilone D was the most active of the epothilone series isolated from the myxobacte-rium, Sorangium cellulosum, and is the des-epoxy precursor... 

Truly satisfactory methods for scale up are not available. Purchas (1977) indicates that scale up has two meanings. While the obvious meaning refers to the prediction of the size of process equipment from small-scale tests, choice of suitable equipment is an equally important part of scale up. Purchas (1977) states none of the test or scale up procedures presented merits being called a standard procedure . The virtual total absence either of existing standards or of serious attempts to involve or develop standards in an area of such major importance can only be regarded as remarkable in the current era. ... 

As in conventional synthesis, reaction optimization is crucial for successful MAOS. Similar to traditional chemistry, the success of reactions is as dependent on factors such as solvent and reagent selection as it is upon temperature and time. These parameters can be optimized in a relatively short period of time and the optimal conditions found via MAOS optimization can in most cases be applicable to conventional heating methods for scale-up. 

---