Kinetics, Mechanisms, Rate Laws

The investigation of the kinetics of a chemical reaction serves two purposes. A first goal is the determination of the mechanism of a reaction. Is it a first order reaction, A—or a second order reaction, 2A— Is there an intermediate A— /— and so on. The other goal of a kinetic investigation is the determination of the rate constant(s) of a reaction. 

The first aspect is much more difficult, it needs good experimentation as well as chemical knowledge and intuition. The second aspect is comparatively much simpler and we deal with it in the next chapter. A complete analysis, comprising both aspects, allows accurate predictions of the time behaviour of a reaction for any initial conditions. This can be an invaluable tool e.g. the optimisation of an industrial chemical process. 

The core of all the above tasks is the modelling of the chemical reaction for a given mechanism and the corresponding set of rate constants, i.e. the computation of the concentration profiles of all reacting species as a function of time. In this sub-chapter, we demonstrate how to perform the 

Similar to the modelling of equilibrium titrations, we compute a matrix C that contains, as columns, the concentration profiles of the interacting species. There is one significant difference in equilibrium modelling each solution is treated independently, i.e. each row of C is computed 

---

To continue with arguments based on kinetics the rate law for the reaction 37 of Cr2 (aq) with V(H20)6 is equation (81). A simple interpretation of this form of the rate law is that one of the reaction partners undergoes proton dissociation, and in this case b would be identified with the dissociation constant. This interpretation of the rate law can be dismissed because the value of b is too large to answer even for Ad of the more acidic partner. The alternative general interpretation is that the reaction involves two activated complexes of different compositions, and though the order in which they appear in the reaction sequence is not specified by the rate law (an important point recognized by Haim, and dealt with him by him in detail ) this particular issue does not affect the validity of the conclusions which will be reached on the matter of whether an inner- or outer-sphere path operates. Each mechanism requires an intermediate to be formed which contains one V, one Cr, less one proton and which has a charge of 4+. The values of the specific rates apd specific rates ratios which follow from the experimental rate law are quite unrealistic if... 

As we have seen, the study of the stereochemistry of the debromination reaction is the key choosing between the two mechanistic pathways. Both proposals could justify the kinetic data (rate law, nucleophilicity of the telluride, effects of solvent polarity) however, only Mechanism 2 could satisfactorily explain the stereoselectivity in all cases. The intermediacy of a bromonium ion and the role of the telluride as a scavenger of the Br seem to be the best option with all the data in hand. 

The system of coupled differential equations that result from a compound reaction mechanism consists of several different (reversible) elementary steps. The kinetics are described by a system of coupled differential equations rather than a single rate law. This system can sometimes be decoupled by assuming that the concentrations of the intennediate species are small and quasi-stationary. The Lindemann mechanism of thermal unimolecular reactions [18,19] affords an instructive example for the application of such approximations. This mechanism is based on the idea that a molecule A has to pick up sufficient energy... 

Complex chemical mechanisms are written as sequences of elementary steps satisfying detailed balance where tire forward and reverse reaction rates are equal at equilibrium. The laws of mass action kinetics are applied to each reaction step to write tire overall rate law for tire reaction. The fonn of chemical kinetic rate laws constmcted in tliis manner ensures tliat tire system will relax to a unique equilibrium state which can be characterized using tire laws of tliennodynamics. 

In writing Eqs. (7.1)-(7.4) we make the customary assumption that the kinetic constants are independent of the size of the radical and we indicate the concentration of all radicals, whatever their chain length, ending with the Mj repeat unit by the notation [Mj ], This formalism therefore assumes that only the nature of the radical chain end influences the rate constant for propagation. We refer to this as the terminal control mechanism. If we wished to consider the effect of the next-to-last repeat unit in the radical, each of these reactions and the associated rate laws would be replaced by two alternatives. Thus reaction (7. A) becomes... 

Mechanisms. Mechanism is a technical term, referring to a detailed, microscopic description of a chemical transformation. Although it falls far short of a complete dynamical description of a reaction at the atomic level, a mechanism has been the most information available. In particular, a mechanism for a reaction is sufficient to predict the macroscopic rate law of the reaction. This deductive process is vaUd only in one direction, ie, an unlimited number of mechanisms are consistent with any measured rate law. A successful kinetic study, therefore, postulates a mechanism, derives the rate law, and demonstrates that the rate law is sufficient to explain experimental data over some range of conditions. New data may be discovered later that prove inconsistent with the assumed rate law and require that a new mechanism be postulated. Mechanisms state, in particular, what molecules actually react in an elementary step and what products these produce. An overall chemical equation may involve a variety of intermediates, and the mechanism specifies those intermediates. For the overall equation... 

The normal course of a kinetic investigation involves postulating likely mechanisms and comparing the observed rate law with those expected for the various mechanisms. Those mechanisms that are incompatible with the observed kinetics can be eliminated as possibilities. Let us consider aromatic nitration by nitric acid in an inert solvent as a typical example. We will restrict the mechanisms being considered to the three shown below. In an actual case, such arbitrary restriction would not be imposed, but instead all mechanisms compatible with existing information would be considered. 

These examples illustrate the relationship between kinetic results and the determination of reaction mechanism. Kinetic results can exclude from consideration all mechanisms that require a rate law different from the observed one. It is often true, however, that related mechanisms give rise to identical predicted rate expressions. In this case, the mechanisms are kinetically equivalent, and a choice between them is not possible on the basis of kinetic data. A further limitation on the information that kinetic studies provide should also be recognized. Although the data can give the composition of the activated complex for the rate-determining step and preceding steps, it provides no information about the structure of the intermediate. Sometimes the structure can be inferred from related chemical experience, but it is never established by kinetic data alone. 

If (A i[X ]/A 2[Y ]) is not much smaller than unity, then as the substitution reaction proceeds, the increase in [X ] will increase the denominator of Eq. (8-65), slowing the reaction and causing deviation from simple first-order kinetics. This mass-law or common-ion effect is characteristic of an S l process, although, as already seen, it is not a necessary condition. The common-ion effect (also called external return) occurs only with the common ion and must be distinguished from a general kinetic salt effect, which will operate with any ion. An example is provided by the hydrolysis of triphenylmethyl chloride (trityl chloride) the addition of 0.01 M NaCl decreased the rate by fourfold. The solvolysis rate of diphenylmethyl chloride in 80% aqueous acetone was decreased by LiCl but increased by LiBr. ° The 5 2 mechanism will also yield first-order kinetics in a solvolysis reaction, but it should not be susceptible to a common-ion rate inhibition. 

Evidence for the mechanism shown in Figure 22.4 includes the observation that acid-catalyzed halogenations show second-order kinetics and follow the rate law... 

The rate of a chemical reaction is always taken as a positive quantity, and the rate constant k is always positive as well. A negative rate constant is thus without meaning. An equation such as Eq. (1-4), which gives the reaction rate as a function of concentration, usually at constant temperature, is referred to as a rate law. The determination of the form in which the different concentrations enter into the rate law is one of the initial goals of a kinetic study, since it allows one to infer certain features of the mechanism. 

Each of these variables will be considered in this book. We start with concentrations, because they determine the form of the rate law when other variables are held constant. The concentration dependences reveal possibilities for the reaction scheme the sequence of elementary reactions showing the progression of steps and intermediates. Some authors, particularly biochemists, term this a kinetic mechanism, as distinct from the chemical mechanism. The latter describes the stereochemistry, electron flow (commonly represented by curved arrows on the Lewis structure), etc. 

Steady-state kinetics. The reaction of methylthiamine (MT+) in the presence of a large excess of SO3 and of 4-thiopyridone (= ArS-) is believed to follow the mechanism shown here,15 in which A" and B are steady-state intermediates. Derive the steady-state rate law. 

The route from kinetic data to reaction mechanism entails several steps. The first step is to convert the concentration-time measurements to a differential rate equation that gives the rate as a function of one or more concentrations. Chapters 2 through 4 have dealt with this aspect of the problem. Once the concentration dependences are defined, one interprets the rate law to reveal the family of reactions that constitute the reaction scheme. This is the subject of this chapter. Finally, one seeks a chemical interpretation of the steps in the scheme, to understand each contributing step in as much detail as possible. The effects of the solvent and other constituents (Chapter 9) the effects of substituents, isotopic substitution, and others (Chapter 10) and the effects of pressure and temperature (Chapter 7) all aid in the resolution. 

The two rate laws are kinetically indistinguishable, because they give the same functional dependence on concentration. The transition states for the two mechanisms contain the elements of acetal and a proton ( H20). Other features may allow one mechanism or the other to be assigned to a given acetal, but kinetics alone will not... 

The reader can show that a third scheme also gives the same answer. In it the two cations first associate (however unlikely), and this dinuclear complex reacts with Cl-. To summarize any reaction scheme consistent with the rate law is characterized by the same ionic strength effects. In other words, it is useless to study salt effects in the hopes of resolving one kinetically indistinguishable mechanism from another. 

Kinetically indistinguishable chain mechanisms can be characterized by different ionic strength profiles, as was apparently first demonstrated in a study this author conducted with D. A. Ryan on the reaction of (aqua)-2-propylchromium cation with oxygen.17 This reaction was presented in Chapter 7. Two schemes that are consistent with the rate law are as follows ... 

How does one know when the complete roster of reaction schemes that are consistent with the rate law has been obtained One method is based on an analogy between electrical circuits and reaction mechanisms.13 One constructs an electrical circuit analogous to the reaction scheme. Resistors correspond to transition states, junctions to intermediates, and terminals to reactants and products. The precepts are these (1) any other electrical circuit with the same conductance corresponds to a different but kinetically equivalent reaction scheme, and (2) these circuits correspond to all of the fundamentally different schemes. 

To verify that a proposed reaction mechanism agrees with experimental data, we construct the overall rate law implied by the mechanism and check to see whether it is consistent with the experimentally determined rate law. However, although the constructed rate law and the experimental rate law may be the same, the proposed mechanism may still he incorrect because some other mechanism may also lead to the same rate law. Kinetic information can only support a proposed mechanism it can never prove that a mechanism is correct. The acceptance of a suggested mechanism is more like the process of proof in an ideal court of law than a proof in mathematics, with evidence being assembled to give a convincing, consistent picture. 

This rate law has been found to apply. It has been noted that the 2 in Sn2 stands for bimolecular. It must be remembered that this is not always the same as second order (see p. 291). If a large excess of nucleophile is present-—for example, if it is the solvent—the mechanism may still be bimolecular, though the experimentally determined kinetics will be first order ... 

A full development of the rate law for the bimolecular reaction of MDI to yield carbodiimide and CO indicates that the reaction should truly be 2nd-order in MDI. This would be observed experimentally under conditions in which MDI is at limiting concentrations. This is not the case for these experimements MDI is present in considerable excess (usually 5.5-6 g of MDI (4.7-5.1 ml) are used in an 8.8 ml vessel). So at least at the early stages of reaction, the carbon dioxide evolution would be expected to display pseudo-zero order kinetics. As the amount of MDI is depleted, then 2nd-order kinetics should be observed. In fact, the asymptotic portion of the 225 C Isotherm can be fitted to a 2nd-order rate law. This kinetic analysis is consistent with a more detailed mechanism for the decomposition, in which 2 molecules of MDI form a cyclic intermediate through a thermally allowed [2+2] cycloaddition, which is formed at steady state concentrations and may then decompose to carbodiimide and carbon dioxide. Isocyanates and other related compounds have been reported to participate in [2 + 2] and [4 + 2] cycloaddition reactions (8.91. 

Co (NH3)5 H2 O] [Co (NH3)5 ] + H2 O (a) Propose a slow second step that completes the mechanism and gives the correct overall stoichiomehy. (b) Derive the rate law that this mechanism predicts, (c) When the rate is studied in 1 M aqueous HCl solution that is 1 mM in [Co (NH3)5 H2 O], first-order experimental kinetics are observed. Is this observation consistent with the proposed mechanism State your reasoning clearly and in detail. 

Horne has studied the kinetics of exchange in aqueous perchlorate media at temperatures down to —78 °C by the isotopic method ( Fe) and dipyridyl separation. The same rate law in these ice media as in aqueous solution was observed, although the acid dependence was small. Horne concluded that the same exchange mechanism occurs in solid and liquid solvent. Evidence for a Grotthus-type mechanism has been summarised. ... 

The values of x = 0.5 and = 1 for the kinetic orders in acetone [1] and aldehyde [2] are not trae kinetic orders for this reaction. Rather, these values represent the power-law compromise for a catalytic reaction with a more complex catalytic rate law that corresponds to the proposed steady-state catalytic cycle shown in Scheme 50.3. In the generally accepted mechanism for the intermolecular direct aldol reaction, proline reacts with the ketone substrate to form an enamine, which then attacks the aldehyde substrate." A reaction exhibiting saturation kinetics in [1] and rate-limiting addition of [2] can show apparent power law kinetics with both x and y exhibiting orders between zero and one. 

---