Systematic optimizations

A systematic optimization is always preferable to a trial-and-error approach. 

Second, the investigation of the factors and their optimization can be carried out in a systematic way. This systematic method is the subject of this chapter. The most successful experimenter will be the one able to support his expert-based policy by systematic investigations. 

Very often, the optimization criterion is simply an analytical signal or the analysis time. In more complex situations, however, objective functions that are composed of several criteria, such as selectivity, sensitivity, and precision, must be considered. The combination of objective criteria to give a single function is therefore an important topic in analytical chemistry. 

Potential factors that affect a given objective function are best selected by the domain expert in a particular analytical field. The test for significance of the factors influence should be performed on the basis of a simple experimental design, a screening design, by means of statistical tests. Factors should not be kept or eliminated solely for subjective reasons. 

To find the most suitable factor combinations, we can distinguish between simultaneous and sequential optimization approaches. 

---

Obviously, there are many good reasons to study ionic liquids as alternative solvents in transition metal-catalyzed reactions. Besides the engineering advantage of their nonvolatile natures, the investigation of new biphasic reactions with an ionic catalyst phase is of special interest. The possibility of adjusting solubility properties by different cation/anion combinations permits systematic optimization of the biphasic reaction (with regard, for example, to product selectivity). Attractive options to improve selectivity in multiphase reactions derive from the preferential solubility of only one reactant in the catalyst solvent or from the in situ extraction of reaction intermediates from the catalyst layer. Moreover, the application of an ionic liquid catalyst layer permits a biphasic reaction mode in many cases where this would not be possible with water or polar organic solvents (due to incompatibility with the catalyst or problems with substrate solubility, for example). 

Becke, A. D., 1997, Density-Functional Thermochemistry. V. Systematic Optimization of Exchange-Correlation Functionals , J. Chem. Phys., 107, 8554. 

Systematic optimization of artificial neural network and other advanced computational models for grouping strains and for classifying unknown samples as members of the most appropriate group. 

Ng et al. [107] described a simple and rapid systematic optimization scheme, known as overlapping resolution mapping scheme, which make use of nine... 

FIGURE 1.11 Systematic optimization of structural binding and stereorecognition increments of amino acid side chain (Rsa) carbamate residue (Rso)- Dependency of separation factors on the steric bulkiness of amino acid and carbamate residues as quantified by their corresponding Taft s steric parameters Es sa Eg so- (1) ionic interaction (2) jr-jr-interaction (3) hydrogen bonding (4) steric interaction. (Reproduced from M. Lammerhofer et al., J. Sep. ScL, 29 1486 (2006). With permission.)... 

In order to improve the catalytic TON, chemo-, and regioselectivity (in the case of monosubstituted alkynes), the reaction parameters have been systematically optimized for a large number of [YCoL] catalysts. This screening was performed in a continuous-flow reactor connected to a process chromatography set up (84MI12) (Fig. 1). 

Most fermentation procedures are systematically optimized in a pilot plant, which typically uses a table-top fermentor of about 30 liter capacity. These fermenters are designed to contain all the ports, valves, controls, and cleaning capabilities essential... 

Control of the HPLC pump, the autosampler, and the MS is ensured by Masslynx 3.5 software. After optimization of the measurement conditions, a list of process measurements is setup (sample list), and the desired HPLC and MS steps are called upon. After a measurement, the ESI source is automatically brought to room temperature (shut down). Using 96-microtiter plates, 576 samples can be processed per measurement. The chromatograms are integrated by the software packages Quanlynx and Openlynx and exported as an Excel table. A macro is used to calculate the absolute intensities and therefore the ee and the conversion. The E values in kinetic resolution are automatically calculated with the formula of Sih [12]. Data processing is done with the Openlynx Browser. The overall process occurs continuously and enables analysis of up to 10000 samples per day, provided that the 8-channel multiplexed sprayer system is used [20b]. It is also possible to use 384-well micro titer plates. Systematic optimization is required for each new compound. 

The efficient utilization of most, if not all, systematic optimization strategies requires an understanding of basic chromatographic principles. Such an understanding also greatly facilitates the interpretation of the results. 

Including the original results reported later in this chapter, only two systematic optimization procedures have been reported simplex (38), (this chapter) and window diagrams (39), (this chapter). Due to space limitations, a somewhat greater emphasis will be placed here on original results rather than those published elsewhere. Experimental details common to the simplex and window diagram results obtained from our laboratory are summarized here for the sake of convenience and continuity of discussion. 

Future work. As mentioned earlier, use of the simplex algorithm for the systematic optimization of SFC separations is still in its early stages. The success already achieved, however, merits continued research along these lines. Research opportunities include (i) extension of the simplex method to less ideal variables and/or greater than 4 variables (ii) investigation of the benefits of the simplex method to packed columns and modified mobile phases and (iii) development of the capability to predict, for a given type of sample, the best combination of variables to optimize. 

Density Optimization. The retention surfaces as a function of mobile phase density at a temperature of 80 °C are shown in Figure 4. The quadratic dependence of In k on density is apparent over a wide range in density. More importantly, however, there are numerous peak reversals which demonstrate the need for a systematic optimization approach. 

Shown in Figure 7 is the three dimensional retention surface for quinoline, a representative sample component Retention surfaces for the 7 other solutes, not shown for the sake of clarity, were generally as smooth and continuous, and resembled each other in a fashion analogous to the two dimensional In k /density surfaces of Figure 4. Similar peak reversals were also observed, and a systematic optimization scheme is again clearly warranted. Note that the individual effects of temperature and density, as predicted by equations 2 and 3, can be inferred from the appropriate cross sections of Figure 7. 

Systematic optimization of the Universal-IPCR protocol revealed the full potential of the flexible technique. The research group of Watanabe and coworkers, introduced in Section 3.1 with the detection of TNF -a [34, 39, 80], has excelled in adaptation of this protocol to various antigens. 

Numerical data for the temperature can be obtained from systematic optimization processes. 

In a medicinal chemistry program aiming to discover p38 MAP kinase inhibitors, the group of Skjaerbaeck introduced microwaves in order to achieve aryl decoration of the aniline backbone [81]. A systematic optimization of the catalyst, solvent, base and reaction time/temperature delivered a general procedure for the expeditious production of the desired aryl aminobenzophe-nones within 3-15 minutes, as demonstrated in Scheme 23. 

High-throughput synthesis and combinatorial chemistry employing polymer supports, with computer-based rational design, are important tools for systematic optimization of the affinity, selectivity, and bio-availability of protease inhibitors. It is very likely that currently available isosteres will not suffice for addressing the natural selectivity of proteases. Thus, synthetic methodology must be devised not only to decorate a predefined isosteric core but to define novel active site binders. 

Systematic optimization of the compression process for a given formulation is necessary, and a DOE approach can be applied to understand the critical parameters... 

Systematic optimization of program parameters Optimization without solute recognition... 

Becke AD (1997) Density-functional thermochemistry 5. Systematic optimization of exchange-correlation functionals, J. Chem. Phys, 98 1372-1377... 

The protein superfamily of proteases [78, 79], however, is an ideal framework for a directed privileged structure-based masterkey concept. It has already been reported that the 5,5-trans-fused lactam moiety was systematically optimized and explored as a serine protease-directed scaffold by GlaxoSmithKline and has delivered progressible lead compounds for various members of that target class [3], such as thrombin [80, 81], elastase [82, 83], HCMV protease [84, 85], and the hepatitis C virus-encoded NS3-4A protease [86, 87]. Here, the initially identified scaffold was engineered toward the serine protease-wide commonality in substrate binding and processing [3],... 

---