Reactor design fundamentals scale

Deviations from the ideal frequentiy occur in order to avoid system complexity, but differences between an experimental system and the commercial unit should always be considered carefully to avoid surprises on scale-up. In the event that fundamental kinetic data are desired, it is usually necessary to choose a reactor design in which reactant and product concentration gradients are minimized (36), such as in the recycle (37) or spinning basket reactor designs (38,39). 

Nitric acid is one of the three major acids of the modem chemical industiy and has been known as a corrosive solvent for metals since alchemical times in the thirteenth centuiy. " " It is now invariably made by the catalytic oxidation of ammonia under conditions which promote the formation of NO rather than the thermodynamically more favoured products N2 or N2O (p. 423). The NO is then further oxidized to NO2 and the gases absorbed in water to yield a concentrated aqueous solution of the acid. The vast scale of production requires the optimization of all the reaction conditions and present-day operations are based on the intricate interaction of fundamental thermodynamics, modem catalyst technology, advanced reactor design, and chemical engineering aspects of process control (see Panel). Production in the USA alone now exceeds 7 million tonnes annually, of which the greater part is used to produce nitrates for fertilizers, explosives and other purposes (see Panel). 

However, each set of factors entering in to the rate expression is also a potential source of scaleup error. For this, and other reasons, a fundamental requirement when scaling a process is that the model and prototype be similar to each other with respect to reactor type and design. For example, a cleaning process model of a continuous-stirred tank reactor (CSTR) cannot be scaled to a prototype with a tubular reactor design. Process conditions such as fluid flow and heat and mass transfer are totally different for the two types of reactors. However, results from rate-of-reaction experiments using a batch reactor can be used to design either a CSTR or a tubular reactor based solely on a function of conversion, -r ... 

Design of a commercial scale reactor from fundamental information and/or information from a laboratory scale reactor. 

Hydrodynamics, mass, and heat transfer in the commonly used three-phase fixed-bed reactors were briefly outlined. Also, scale-up rules and alternative ways to scale down trickle-bed reactors are discussed. In spite of the extensive studies on the hydrodynamics, mass, and heat transfer in three-phase fixed-bed reactors, clearly, a lot of work remains to be done in providing a fundamentally based description of the effect of pressure on the parameters of importance in three-phase fixed-bed reactors operation, design, and scale-up or scale-down. It is evident that atmospheric data and models/correlations cannot, in general, be extrapolated to operation at elevated pressures. The physics conveyed by the standard two-phase flow models is minimalistic because it insufficiently describes the role and presence of interfaces and their thermodynamic properties. The explicit inclusion of interfaces and interfacial properties is essential because they are known to have a significant role in determining the thermodynamic state of the whole system. 

The design methods de.scribed above rely on correlations of the overall reactor average quantities obtained from experimental tanks of different scales. The most important deficiency of these methods is that local effects are not taken into consideration, while these might be responsible for the overall reactor performance. Accordingly, if none of the above scale-up criteria is found satisfactory (see e.g. data of Middleton et ai, 1986) a more fundamental approach must be applied, although not necessarily as complex as the one presented in Section 5.4.S.2. Such an approach was presented by Paul et al. (1971) who found that the yield of the desired intermediate in a system of consecutive reactions (iodination of L-tjrosine) correlates reasonably with fluctuations of the velocity, So, these fluctuations could be chosen as a criterion for scale-up of the reactor. The average value for u in the upper part of the tank was evaluated from ... 

The most difficult problem to solve in the design of a Fischer-Tropsch reactor is its very high exothermicity combined with a high sensitivity of product selectivity to temperature. On an industrial scale, multitubular and bubble column reactors have been widely accepted for this highly exothermic reaction.6 In case of a fixed bed reactor, it is desirable that the catalyst particles are in the millimeter size range to avoid excessive pressure drops. During Fischer-Tropsch synthesis the catalyst pores are filled with liquid FT products (mainly waxes) that may result in a fundamental decrease of the reaction rate caused by pore diffusion processes. Post et al. showed that for catalyst particle diameters in excess of only about 1 mm, the catalyst activity is seriously limited by intraparticle diffusion in both iron and cobalt catalysts.1... 

---