Nickel methanation catalyst

Carhon monoxide and hydrogen react to form CH in the presence of a nickel catalyst. Methane also is formed by reaction of magnesium methyl iodide in anhydrous ether (Grignard s rcagentl with substances containing the hydroxyl group. See also Grignard Reactions. Methyl iodide (bromide, chloride) is preferably made by reaction of methyl alcohol and phosphorus iodide (bromide, chloride)... 

This reaction is an undesirable side reaction in the manufacture of hydrogen but utilised as a means of removing traces of carbon monoxide left at the end of the second stage reaction. The gases are passed over a nickel catalyst at 450 K when traces of carbon monoxide form methane. (Methane does not poison the catalyst in the Haber process -carbon monoxide Joes.)... 

Fischer-Tropsch Process. The Hterature on the hydrogenation of carbon monoxide dates back to 1902 when the synthesis of methane from synthesis gas over a nickel catalyst was reported (17). In 1923, F. Fischer and H. Tropsch reported the formation of a mixture of organic compounds they called synthol by reaction of synthesis gas over alkalized iron turnings at 10—15 MPa (99—150 atm) and 400—450°C (18). This mixture contained mostly oxygenated compounds, but also contained a small amount of alkanes and alkenes. Further study of the reaction at 0.7 MPa (6.9 atm) revealed that low pressure favored olefinic and paraffinic hydrocarbons and minimized oxygenates, but at this pressure the reaction rate was very low. Because of their pioneering work on catalytic hydrocarbon synthesis, this class of reactions became known as the Fischer-Tropsch (FT) synthesis. 

Direct hydrohquefaction of biomass or wastes can be achieved by direct hydrogenation of wood chips on treatment at 10,132 kPa and 340 to 350°C with water and Raney nickel catalyst (45). The wood is completely converted to an oily Hquid, methane, and other hydrocarbon gases. Batch reaction times of 4 hours give oil yields of about 35 wt % of the feed the oil contains about 12 wt % oxygen and has a heating value of about 37.2 MJ /kg (16,000 Btu/lb). Distillation yields a significant fraction that boils in the same range as diesel fuel and is completely miscible with it. 

Methanation of the clean desulfurized main gas (less than 1 ppm total sulfur) is accompHshed in the presence of a nickel catalyst at temperatures from 260—400°C and pressure range of 2—2.8 MPa (300—400 psi). Equations and reaction enthalpies are given in Table 4. 

Catalytic methanation processes include (/) fixed or fluidized catalyst-bed reactors where temperature rise is controlled by heat exchange or by direct cooling using product gas recycle (2) through wall-cooled reactor where temperature is controlled by heat removal through the walls of catalyst-filled tubes (J) tube-wall reactors where a nickel—aluminum alloy is flame-sprayed and treated to form a Raney-nickel catalyst bonded to the reactor tube heat-exchange surface and (4) slurry or Hquid-phase (oil) methanation. 

Methane. The largest use of methane is for synthesis gas, a mixture of hydrogen and carbon monoxide. Synthesis gas, in turn, is the primary feed for the production of ammonia (qv) and methanol (qv). Synthesis gas is produced by steam reforming of methane over a nickel catalyst. 

Thermodynamically, the formation of methane is favored at low temperatures. The equilibrium constant is 10 at 300 K and is 10 ° at 1000 K (113). High temperatures and catalysts ate needed to achieve appreciable rates of carbon gasification, however. This reaction was studied in the range 820—1020 K, and it was found that nickel catalysts speed the reaction by three to four orders of magnitude (114). The Hterature for the carbon-hydrogen reaction has been surveyed (115). 

Nickel catalysts are also used for steam methane reforming. Moreover, nickel catalysts containing potassium to inhibit coke formation from feedstocks such as LPG and naphtha have received wide appHcation. 

In the catalytic steam reforming of natural gas (see Fig. 2), the hydrocarbon stream, principally methane, is desulfurized and, through the use of superheated steam (qv), contacts a nickel catalyst in the primary reformer at ca 3.04 MPa (30 atm) pressure and 800°C to convert methane to H2. 

Fischer-Tropsch Synthesis The best-known technology for producing hydrocarbons from synthesis gas is the Fischer-Tropsch synthesis. This technology was first demonstrated in Germany in 1902 by Sabatier and Senderens when they hydrogenated carbon monoxide (CO) to methane, using a nickel catalyst. In 1926 Fischer and Tropsch were awarded a patent for the discovery of a catalytic technique to convert synthesis gas to liquid hydrocarbons similar to petroleum. 

The chapter by Haynes et al. describes the pilot work using Raney nickel catalysts with gas recycle for reactor temperature control. Gas recycle provides dilution of the carbon oxides in the feed gas to the methanator, hence simulating methanation of dilute CO-containing gases which under adiabatic conditions gives a permissible temperature rise. This and the next two papers basically treat this approach, the hallmark of first-generation methanation processes. 

The chapter by Eisenlohr et al. deals with the results of large scale pilot operations using a newly developed high-nickel catalyst with hot-gas recycle for temperature control. This and other work, conducted by Lurgi Mineraloeltechnik GmbH, with South African Coal and Oil Limited (SASOL), are the bases of the methanation process which Lurgi is proposing for commercial plants. 

This paper surveys the field of methanation from fundamentals through commercial application. Thermodynamic data are used to predict the effects of temperature, pressure, number of equilibrium reaction stages, and feed composition on methane yield. Mechanisms and proposed kinetic equations are reviewed. These equations cannot prove any one mechanism however, they give insight on relative catalyst activity and rate-controlling steps. Derivation of kinetic equations from the temperature profile in an adiabatic flow system is illustrated. Various catalysts and their preparation are discussed. Nickel seems best nickel catalysts apparently have active sites with AF 3 kcal which accounts for observed poisoning by sulfur and steam. Carbon laydown is thermodynamically possible in a methanator, but it can be avoided kinetically by proper catalyst selection. Proposed commercial methanation systems are reviewed. 

Kinetics. Extensive studies of the kinetics of methane synthesis were reported by White and co-workers (10,11, 12, 13, 14, 15). They studied the reaction between CO and hydrogen over a reduced nickel catalyst on kieselguhr at 1 atm and 300°-350°C (10). They correlated the rate of methane formation by the equation ... 

The synthesis of methane from C02 and hydrogen was studied by Binder and White (11) over a reduced nickel catalyst (Harshaw Ni-88). The surface reaction between the C02 and hydrogen appeared to be rate controlling. The rate of reaction can be correlated by either of the following rather awkward equations ... 

Nickel. As a methanation catalyst, nickel is presently preeminent. It is relatively cheap, it is very active, and it is the most selective to methane of all the metals. Its main drawback is that it is easily poisoned by sulfur, a fault common to all the known active methanation catalysts. The nickel content of commercial nickel catalysts is 25-77 wt %. Nickel is dispersed on a high-surface-area, refractory support such as alumina or kieselguhr. Some supports inhibit the formation of carbon by Reaction 4. Chromia-supported nickel has been studied by Czechoslovakian and Russian investigators. 

Catalyst Poisons. Hausberger, Atwood, and Knight (33) reported that nickel catalysts are extremely sensitive to sulfides and chlorides. If all materials which adversely affect the performance of a catalyst were classified as poisons, then carbon laydown and, under extreme conditions, water vapor would be included as nickel methanation catalyst poisons. 

The catalyst losses in either system are moderate and not excessively costly when inexpensive iron catalyst is used (as for production of liquid hydrocarbons). It is questionable, however, whether comparable losses of expensive nickel catalysts (for methanation) could be tolerated. For this reason, it is quite likely that the fluidized catalyst system will be used for methanation only after a cheap methanation catalyst is developed. 

The methanation process commonly operates at pressures up to 30 atm, and, with the nickel catalyst which is almost universally used for the process, the inlet temperature is about 300°C ( 570°F). Almost complete conversion of the oxides of carbon occurs giving a product synthesis gas containing less than 5 ppm CO + C02. The temperature rise for the exothermic methanation reactions is typically 35 °C (63°F). 

Flame-Sprayed Raney Nickel Plates vs. Pellets of Precipitated Catalyst in a Packed Bed. Experiments HGR-13 and HGR-14 demonstrated that the performance of the plates sprayed with Raney nickel catalyst was significantly better than that of the precipitated nickel catalyst pellets. The sprayed plates yielded higher production of methane per pound of catalyst, longer catalyst life or lower rate of deactivation, lower CO concentration in the product gas, and lower pressure drop across the catalyst bed. 

These tests demonstrated that the Lurgi Rectisol process provides an extremely pure synthesis gas which can be charged directly to the metha-nation plant without problems of sulfur poisoning of the nickel catalyst. However, in order to cope with a sudden sulfur breakthrough from Rectisol as a result of maloperation, a commercial methanation plant should be operated with a ZnO emergency catchpot on line. 

Nickel catalysts were used in most of the methanation catalytic studies they have a rather wide range of operating temperatures, approximately 260°-538°C. Operation of the catalytic reactors at 482°-538°C will ultimately result in carbon deposition and rapid deactivation of the catalysts (10). Reactions below 260°C will usually result in formation of nickel carbonyl and also in rapid deactivation of the catalysts. The best operating range for most fixed-bed nickel catalysts is 288°-482 °C. Several schemes have been proposed to limit the maximum temperature in adiabatic catalytic reactors to 482°C, and IGT has developed a cold-gas recycle process that utilizes a series of fixed-bed adiabatic catalytic reactors to maintain this temperature control. 

Dr. Moeller We have done this, and we compared an iron catalyst used for the Fischer-Tropsch plant and a nickel catalyst used in the methanation plant. By the same x-ray techniques, we found no nickel carbide on the used methanation catalyst, but we did find iron carbide on the used Fischer-Tropsch catalyst. 

Dr. Moeller A methanation plant does not have a problem of selectivity. Whether you operate at low or high temperature, when using a nickel catalyst you will form only methane and no higher hydrocarbon. But with the Fischer-Tropsch synthesis, you have a wide range of possible products which can be formed. If you want to have a certain product, you must keep your temperature at a certain constant value. 

In principle biomass is a useful fuel for fuel cells many of the technologies discussed above for using biomass as a fuel produce either methane or hydrogen directly and as highlighted below synthesis gas production from biomass for conversion to methanol is an attractive option. Cellulose-based material may be converted to a mixture of hydrogen (70% hydrogen content recovered), CO2 and methane by high-temperature treatment with a nickel catalyst. 

Couttenye, R.A., De Vila, M.H. and Suib, S.L. (2005) Decomposition of methane with an autocatalytically reduced nickel catalyst Journal ofCatalysis, 233,317-326. 

---