Limitations and Safety Aspects

In general, most reactions that can be carried out under thermal heating can be performed and accelerated by microwave irradiation. As discussed in Section 2.2, the efficiency of the microwave heating is highly dependent on the dielectric properties of the reaction mixture. Most results suggesting rate enhancements and improved yields can be explained in terms of simple thermal effects. However, for two main reasons, some reactions may not be suitable for performance in micro-wave reactors  

To reduce the risk of container failure, the pressure vessels are equipped with several safety features. These can include an effective self-venting system where unforeseen overpressure is released by a quick open-resealing step, or the use of safety disks which rupture when their pressure limit is reached. The small vials (0.2-20 mL) of some monomode reactors are protected by the pressure limit (20 bar) of the caps used, which is significantly lower than the operating limit of the vials themselves (40-50 bar). 

Precautions should be taken, especially in a scale-up approach, when dealing with exothermic reactions in the microwave field. Due to the rapid energy transfer of microwaves, any uncontrolled exothermic reaction is potentially hazardous (thermal runaway). Temperature increase and pressure rise may occur too rapidly for the instrument s safety measures and cause vessel rupture. 

For accurate temperature monitoring when conducting a temperature-controlled program, a minimum filling volume of the vessels is crucial. In the case of IR temperature measurement from the bottom of a vessel, only a very small amount of reaction mixture (ca. 50 pL) is sufficient to obtain a precise temperature feedback in a monomode instrument (CEM Discover series). On the other hand, a rectangular mounted IR sensor, as used in Biotage instruments (see Section 3.5) requires a certain minimum filling volume (200 pL for the smallest reaction vials see Fig. 3.21). 

Multimode instruments with an IR sensor mounted in the cavity side wall (see Section 3.4) certainly need larger volumes for precise temperature monitoring. Immersion temperature probes require a well-defined minimum volume for accurate measurement, depending on the total vessel volume. It must be ensured that the temperature probe has extensive contact with the reaction mixture, even when the mixture is stirred, in order to obtain reliable, reproducible results. 

---

Kappe, O. Stadler, A. Limitations and Safety Aspects. In Microwaves in Organic and Medicinal Chemistry WUey-VCH Weinheim, 2005 Section 5.4 pp 103-105. 

Health and Safety Aspects. The U.S. EPA has significantly reduced the aHowed levels of antimony compounds in drinking water causing a toxicity cloud over the viabHity of this class of stabilizers. Presently, antimony products are no longer aHowed for use as potable water pipe stabilizers pending completion of NSE International s review (28). Eor these reasons, the future of this stabilizer technology appears limited. 

Proof-of-efficacy trials these studies should provide, within a limited time frame and with a low-cost program, sufficient information for a go/no-go decision concerning efficacy and safety aspects of a new compound. The traditional approaches are Phase lib trials based on placebo-controlled dose-finding designs. These studies need relatively high power, which means the inclusion of several dozen to several hundred patients. 

In conducting a search of records, EPA has indicated that a person required to report may limit such search to records in the location(s) where the required information is typically kept with inquiry to those employees who are responsible for keeping such records or advising on the health and safety aspects of chemicals. Persons are not required to search for reportable information dated prior to January 1, 1977, the effective data of TSCA, unless specifically directed to do so. ... 

To effectively differentiate solvents in terms of the benefit that one offers over another, or the trade-off the chromatographer faces in choosing one solvent versus another, three fundamental factors need to be considered (1) physical properties of the solvent, (2) the chemical properties of the solvent (especially with respect to system compatibility and safety aspects), and (3) the effects these properties have on the chromatographic process (i.e., system operation, chromatographic separation, detection limits, and analytical reproducibility). This chapter deals with the chemical and physical properties of HPLC solvent groups as well as important features, concerns, and limitations of individual solvents. 

Regular plant inspections or audits by personnel experienced in both operational and safety aspects of chemical plant work are an absolute essential. Experience has shown that minor points of improvement can always be made either in actual assessment or reassessment of minor operational variations or in interpretation of limits. 

The kinetics of the reaction and the properties of the catalyst, especially the thermal stability, will further narrow the range of possible reaction conditions and define a "window" of possible operating parameters. Process optimization, energy efficiency, and safety aspects will then determine at what conditions within the "window" the reactor should operate to give the optimum result. And then mathematical models are used to determine how big the reactor must be to obtain the performance (conversion and pressure drop) determined by the process optimization. Instrumentation is then considered, proper materials of construction are selected, catalyst loading and unloading is considered, possible transport limitations are determined, workshop manufacture is considered, and at last the design of the reactor is completed. The procedure is, of course, iterative since the reactor cost is one of the parameters in the economical optimization, but, as mentioned above, often a factor of minor importance for the overall result. 

The effectiveness of FTA is limited to safety aspects and is not recommended for reliability improvement. In order to apply FTA the top event must be defined very clearly. It is insufficient to describe the top event by saying, "The system failed". The method requires more accuracy "The neutron flux in the nuclear reactor suddenly increased and control rods did not fall down". Other techniques are needed for systems which do not have the ability to determine catastrophic top-events, or which have a large number of critical safety failures. 

Certain types of equipment are specifically excluded from the scope of the directive. It is self-evident that equipment which is already regulated at Union level with respect to the pressure risk by other directives had to be excluded. That is the case with simple pressure vessels, transportable pressure equipment, aerosols and motor vehicles. Other equipment, such as carbonated drink containers or radiators and piping for hot water systems are excluded from the scope because of the limited risk involved. Also excluded are products which are subject to a minor pressure risk which are covered by the directives on machinery, lifts, low voltage, medical devices, gas appliances and on explosive atmospheres. A further and last group of exclusions refers to equipment which presents a significant pressure risk, but for which neither the free circulation aspect nor the safety aspect necessitated their inclusion. 

Safety is a critical aspect in the design of phenol plants. Oxidation of cumene to CHP occurs at conditions close to the flammable limits. Furthermore, the CHP is a potentially unstable material which can violendy decompose under certain conditions. Thus, phenol plants must be carefully designed and provided with weU-designed control and safety systems. 

In the past decades, polymer materials have been continuously replacing more traditional materials such as paper, metal, glass, stone, wood, natural fibres and natural rubber in the fields of clothing industry, E E components, automotive materials, aeronautics, leisure, food packaging, sports goods, etc. Without the existence of suitable polymer materials progress in many of these areas would have been limited. Polymer materials are appreciated for their chemical, physical and economical qualities including low production cost, safety aspects and low environmental impact (cf. life-cycle analysis). 

TRL (2007). Technical Assistance and Economic Analysis in the Field of Legislation Pertinent to the Issue of Automotive Safety Evaluation of the Impact (Extended Impact Assessment) of the Introduction of Hydrogen as a Fuel to Power Motor-vehicles Considering the Safety and Environmental Aspects. Final Report for Enterprise Directorate-General, European Commission. TRL Limited. 

Recommendation 8. Future contracts should consider all aspects of performance, including (but not limited to) safety, cost, and schedule, in setting criteria for the award fee. 

---