Controllability distillation column

West, B., Clark, J. A. (1974). Operator Interaction with a Computer-Controlled Distillation Column. In E. Edwards F. P. Lees (Eds.), The Human Operator in Process Control. London Taylor Francis. 

Additional analyzers should be considered. Temperature and pressure are no longer adequate to control distillation columns to tight specifications. Consider chromatographs on the overhead streams. One chromatograph with multiple sample streams can be adequate for most services. Ensure that qualified service is available locally. 

The compositions are controlled by regulating reflux flow and boil-up. The column overall material balance must also be controlled distillation columns have little surge capacity (hold-up) and the flow of distillate and bottom product (and side-streams) must match the feed flows. 

Many alternative methods of controlling distillation columns have been suggested and implemented 3 4 and the strategy suggested here is in the nature of an example (see also Volume 6, Section 5.8.7). 

As with chemical weapons ingredients, the chemical equipment needed to make chemical warfare agents is commercially available just about anywhere. Certainly, to set up a full-scale poison gas production line, terrorists would need reactors and agitators, chemical storage tanks, containers, receivers, condensers for temperature control, distillation columns to separate chemical compounds, valves and pumps to move chemicals between reactors and other containers. Additionally, ideally the equipment would be corrosion-resistant. For a full-scale mustard gas production plant the price tag would be between 2.5 and 5 million. Approximately 10 million would be required to set up a plant to manufacture tabun, sarin or soman.47 Terrorists, however, can be assumed to forego the scale and the safety precautions that most governments would consider essential for a weapons programme. In fact, standard process equipment or a laboratory set-up of beakers and... 

A number of alternative structures are used to control distillation columns. In this section we present some of the most commonly employed strategies and discuss when they are appropriate. The standard termi-... 

In this chapter we have presented some fundamental concepts of distillation control. Distillation columns are without question the most widely used unit operation for separation in the chemical industry. Most final products are produced from one end or the other of a distillation column, so tight control of product quality requires an effective control system for the column. However, the column is usually an integral part of an entire plant, so its control scheme must also be consistent with the plantwide control structure. 

FIGURE 5.11-1 Some besic control schemes for composition control, distillation columns. 

The distillation column is probably the most extensively studied unit operation in terms of control. An extensive literature of hundreds of papers and dozens of books has appeared over the last half century discussing methods for controlling distillation columns. 

Understand the fundamentals of various strategies for controlling distillation columns... 

Weischedel, K., and T. J. McAvoy, Feasibihty of Decouphng in Conventionally Controlled Distillation Columns, lEC Fund., 19, 379 (1980). 

The conversion of fatty alcohols is approximately 99%. The reaction product is then condensed and sent to a distillation column to remove water and high boilers. Typically, a-olefin carbon-number distribution is controlled by the alcohol composition of the reactor feed. The process is currentiy used to produce a-olefins from fatty alcohols. A typical product composition is at <5%, at 50—70%, C g at 30—50%, C2Q at <2%,... 

Ratio and Multiplicative Feedforward Control. In many physical and chemical processes and portions thereof, it is important to maintain a desired ratio between certain input (independent) variables in order to control certain output (dependent) variables (1,3,6). For example, it is important to maintain the ratio of reactants in certain chemical reactors to control conversion and selectivity the ratio of energy input to material input in a distillation column to control separation the ratio of energy input to material flow in a process heater to control the outlet temperature the fuel—air ratio to ensure proper combustion in a furnace and the ratio of blending components in a blending process. Indeed, the value of maintaining the ratio of independent variables in order more easily to control an output variable occurs in virtually every class of unit operation. 

Fig. 20. Example of constraint control operating window for a distillation column, where (-----) is the vessel pressure limit, and ( ) represents constant...

Processes involving oxygen and nitrogen oxides as catalysts have been operated commercially using either vapor- or Hquid-phase reactors. The vapor-phase reactors require particularly close control because of the wide explosive limit of dimethyl sulfide in oxygen (1—83.5 vol %) plants in operation use Hquid-phase reactions. Figure 2 is a schematic diagram for the Hquid-phase process. The product stream from the reactor is neutralized with aqueous caustic and is vacuum-evaporated, and the DMSO is dried in a distillation column to obtain the product. 

Distillation columns are controlled by hand or automatically. The parameters that must be controlled are (/) the overall mass balance, (2) the overall enthalpy balance, and (J) the column operating pressure. Modem control systems are designed to control both the static and dynamic column and system variables. For an in-depth discussion, see References 101—104. 

Whereas there is extensive Hterature on design methods for azeotropic and extractive distillation, much less has been pubUshed on operabiUty and control. It is, however, widely recognized that azeotropic distillation columns are difficult to operate and control because these columns exhibit complex dynamic behavior and parametric sensitivity (2—11). In contrast, extractive distillations do not exhibit such complex behavior and even highly optimized columns are no more difficult to control than ordinary distillation columns producing high purity products (12). 

Redux Ra.te, The optimum reflux rate for a distillation column depends on the value of energy, but is generally between 1.05 times and 1.25 times the reflux rate, which could be used with infinite trays. At this level, excess reflux is a secondary contributor to column inefficiency. However, when designing to this tolerance, correct vapor—Hquid equiUbrium data and adequate controls are essential. 

Recovery of dilute acetic acid is achieved by esterification with methanol using a sulfonated resin (Dowex 50w) in a packed distillation column (54). Pure methyl acetate is obtained. This reaction is second order in acetic acid, 2ero order in methanol, and partially diffusion controlled. 

In the chemical engineering domain, neural nets have been appHed to a variety of problems. Examples include diagnosis (66,67), process modeling (68,69), process control (70,71), and data interpretation (72,73). Industrial appHcation areas include distillation column operation (74), fluidized-bed combustion (75), petroleum refining (76), and composites manufacture (77). 

The use of high or low limits for process variables is another type of selective control, called an override. The feature of anti-reset windup in feedback controllers is a type of override. Another example is a distillation column with lower and upper limits on the heat input to the column reboiler. The minimum level ensures that liquid will remain... 

RGA Example In order to illustrate use of the RGA method, consider the following steady-state version of a transfer function model for a pilot-scale, methanol-water distillation column (Wood and Berry, Terminal Composition Control of a Binaiy Distillation Column, Chem. Eng. Sci, 28, 1707, 1973) Ku = 12.8, K = -18.9, K. i = 6.6, and Koo = —19.4. It follows that A = 2 and... 

Distillation columns have four or more closed loops—increasing with the number of product streams and their specifications—all of which interact with each other to some extent. Because of this interaction, there are many possible ways to pair manipulated and controlled variables through controllers and other mathematical functions with widely differing degrees of effectiveness. Columns also differ from each other, so that no single rule of configuring control loops can be apphed successfully to all. The following rules apply to the most common separations. 

In the use of temperature measurement for control of the separation in a distillation column, repeatability is crucial but accuracy is not. Composition control for the overhead product would be based on a measurement of the temperature on one of the trays in the rectifying section. A target would be provided for this temperature. However, at periodic intervals, a sample of the overhead product is analyzed in the laboratory and the information provided to the process operator. Should this analysis be outside acceptable limits, the operator would adjust the set point for the temperature. This procedure effectively compensates for an inaccurate temperature measurement however, the success of this approach requires good repeatability from the temperature measurement. 

---