Chiral salt resolution

The initial asymmetric synthesis (see Scheme 5.2) of pyrrolidine acid 3 suffered from a chiral HPLC bottleneck. As a result, chiral salt resolution was investigated. The rapid discovery of a crystalline di-p-toluoyl-D-tartaric acid salt provided the necessary means to resolve and purify the desired diastereomer. Using 0.65 equivalent of the acid in methyl (cr(-butyl ether (MTBE), the crystallized salt was shown to be a 92 8 ratio of (3S,4R) (3R,4S) diastereomers. The resolved tartaric acid salts were then recrystalhzed from n-butanol to ratios of >99 1 in a 42% overall yield on a 2-kg scale. Further improvements were made in the preparation of the azomethine ylide precursor 38. In step 1, using dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) as the solvent, the reaction temperature of trimethylsilylmethylation of tert-butylamine was lowered from 200°C used in the original synthesis to 80°C. In step 2, substituting n-butanol in place of methanol reduced the amount of oligomerization observed and increased the yield to 69%. Overall, these improvements allowed for the preparation of pyrrolidine acid 3 in 22% overall yield in 99% ee from cinnamate 39 (Scheme... 

Chiral crown ethers have been employed extensively (48-53, 56-60, 86, 90, 93-95, 107, no, 116, 117, 128, 143, 144, 152-155, 158-161, 163, 164, 212-227) for enantiomeric recognition of racemic primary alkyl ammonium cations including those associated with amino acid ester salts. Resolutions have been effected employing both bulk and chromatographic procedures. 

Resolution of racemic 1,3/4/6,7,llb-hexahydro-2H-pyrazino[l,2-a]iso-quinolin-4-one into enantiomers was unsuccessful either through the crystallization of diastereomeric chiral salts prepared from enantiopure acids in different solvent mixtures, or with kinetic resolution by an enzymatic acylation using different enzymes (08EJO895). 

Wong, C. H. and Wang K. T. (1978) Mutual resolution of (+/-)ephedrine and Z-DL-amino acid induced by seeding chiral salt, Tetrahedron Lett. 40, 3813-3816. 

A number of approaches to the chiral chloropentenoic ester 30 have been disclosed, with enantiomeric purity established either by chiral auxiliaries, diastereomeric salt resolution, or enzymatic resolution.35,36 The enzymatic resolution reported36 in WO 0209828 is particularly efficient and has been disclosed as part of the commercial route to aliskiren.9 The enolate of methyl isovalerate (36) is alkylated with ( )-1,3-dichloroprop-1-ene to give rac-30, which is resolved by pig liver esterase (PLE) to give 30 with the desired 25-stereochemistry in high enantiomeric purity. The undesired acid 37 is then recycled in a two-step, one-pot process involving esterification and racemization to return rac-30. 

Ferrocene behaves like an aromatic compound activated for electrophilic substitution reactions. Thus, only minor modifications of experimental procedures developed for aromatics are necessary to obtain ferrocene derivatives (a useful review on general methods is given by Schldgl and Falk [42]). For central chiral ferrocenes, resolution of the racemate is a frequently applied technique. Traditionally, resolutions are best achieved by salt formation between a chiral acid or base and the... 

In the corrin structure, the n system is interrupted between C-1 and C-19 and the macrocycle is not aromatic. C-1 (and C-19) is chiral and resolution of the ( ) isomers is possible. The naturally occurring corrin has the (IR) configuration, i.e. the Me group is on the a side of the ring. A crystal structure of a cationic corrin salt has been analyzed. The macrocycle is significantly ruffled and the pyrrole ring A is tipped out of the mean plane. The two inner protons are placed on N-21 and N-23. The deviation from the mean plane is small in the metal complexes. ... 

Schwarz Pharma (2005) [57] plan for fesoterodine US 6713464 patent gives a yield of 75% for a classical resolution step using (S,R)-ephedrine hemihydrate as a chiral salt auxiliary— the correct yield is 46%. 

Diaziridines also show slow nitrogen inversion, and carbon-substituted compounds can be resolved into enantiomers, which typically racemize slowly at room temperature (when Af-substituted with alkyl and/or hydrogen). For example, l-methyl-3-benzyl-3-methyl-diaziridine in tetrachloroethylene showed a half-life at 70 °C of 431 min (69AG(E)212). Preparative resolution has been done both by classical methods, using chiral partners in salts (77DOK(232)108l), and by chromatography on triacetyl cellulose (Section 5.08.2.3.1). 

The first partial chiral resolution reported in CCC dates from 1982 [120]. The separation of the two enantiomers of norephedrine was partially achieved, in almost 4 days, using (/ ,/ )-di-5-nonyltartrate as a chiral selector in the organic stationary phase. In 1984, the complete resolution of d,l-isoleucine was described, with N-dodecyl-L-proline as a selector in a two-phase buffered n-butanol/water system containing a copper (II) salt, in approximately 2 days [121]. A few partial resolutions of amino acids and dmg enantiomers with proteic selectors were also published [122, 123]. 

Early examples of enantioselective extractions are the resolution of a-aminoalco-hol salts, such as norephedrine, with lipophilic anions (hexafluorophosphate ion) [184-186] by partition between aqueous and lipophilic phases containing esters of tartaric acid [184-188]. Alkyl derivatives of proline and hydroxyproline with cupric ions showed chiral discrimination abilities for the resolution of neutral amino acid enantiomers in n-butanol/water systems [121, 178, 189-192]. On the other hand, chiral crown ethers are classical selectors utilized for enantioseparations, due to their interesting recognition abilities [171, 178]. However, the large number of steps often required for their synthesis [182] and, consequently, their cost as well as their limited loadability makes them not very suitable for preparative purposes. Examples of ligand-exchange [193] or anion-exchange selectors [183] able to discriminate amino acid derivatives have also been described. 

The most common method of resolution uses an acid-base reaction between a racemic mixture of chiral carboxylic acids (RC02H) and an amine base (RNH2) to yield an ammonium salt. 

Racemic mixtures of sulfoxides have often been separated completely or partially into the enantiomers. Various resolution techniques have been used, but the most important method has been via diastereomeric salt formation. Recently, resolution via complex formation between sulfoxides and homochiral compounds has been demonstrated and will likely prove of increasing importance as a method of separating enantiomers. Preparative liquid chromatography on chiral columns may also prove increasingly important it already is very useful on an analytical scale for the determination of enantiomeric purity. 

Chiral Recognition. The use of chiral hosts to form diastereomeric inclusion compounds was mentioned above. But in some cases it is possible for a host to form an inclusion compound with one enantiomer of a racemic guest, but not the other. This is caUed chiral recognition. One enantiomer fits into the chiral host cavity, the other does not. More often, both diastereomers are formed, but one forms more rapidly than the other, so that if the guest is removed it is already partially resolved (this is a form of kinetic resolution, see category 6). An example is use of the chiral crown ether (53) partially to resolve the racemic amine salt (54). " When an aqueous solution of 54 was... 

The lipophilicity of the TRISPHAT anion 8 also confers to its salts an affinity for organic solvents and, once dissolved, the ion pairs do not partition in aqueous layers. This rather uncommon property was used by Lacour s group to develop a simple and practical resolution procedure of chiral cationic coordination complexes by asymmetric extraction [134,135]. Selectivity ratios as high as 35 1 were measured for the enantiomers of ruthenium(II) trisdiimine complexes, demonstrating without ambiguity the efficiency of the resolution procedure [134]. 

In 2003, Sigman et al. reported the use of a chiral carbene ligand in conjunction with the chiral base (-)-sparteine in the palladium(II) catalyzed oxidative kinetic resolution of secondary alcohols [26]. The dimeric palladium complexes 51a-b used in this reaction were obtained in two steps from N,N -diaryl chiral imidazolinium salts derived from (S, S) or (R,R) diphenylethane diamine (Scheme 28). The carbenes were generated by deprotonation of the salts with t-BuOK in THF and reacted in situ with dimeric palladium al-lyl chloride. The intermediate NHC - Pd(allyl)Cl complexes 52 are air-stable and were isolated in 92-95% yield after silica gel chromatography. Two diaster corners in a ratio of approximately 2 1 are present in solution (CDCI3). 

The chiral centre first appears in cyanide (11) but the acid (10) is the ideal compound for resolution as it can form a salt with a naturally-occurring optically active base. 

Thus, racemic acid 12 (R = H) was obtained by [3+2] cycloaddition in 90-95% yield (Scheme 5.9) [28]. Its resolution into enantiomers could be achieved either by chiral preparative HPLC, or by fractional crystallization of its cinchonidine salts. Better results were obtained upon enzymatic kinetic resolution of its iso-butyl ester 12 (R = i-Bu) [29]. However, further work showed that racemic thiolester 13, which... 

As 29 had been recognized as the most accessible starting-material for the synthesis of racemic carba-sugars, its resolution was successfully achieved with optically active a-methylbenzylamine as chiral reagent. Reaction of 29 with (-l-)-a-methylbenzylamine gave a mixture of two diastereoisomeric salts [(+)-amine, (—)-29 and (+)-amine, (-l-)-29], which were well separated, and the former salt was converted into (—)-29, [a] -111.8° (ethanol). Analogously, (+)-29, [a] +110.7° (ethanol), was obtained. ... 

C-chiral racemic y-hydroxy sulfides were also resolved using PEL under kinetic resolution conditions. The products were transformed into optically active 3-(alkanesulfonyloxy)thiolane salts (Scheme 1). Similarly, 1,2-cyclic sulfite glycerol derivatives cis and trans) were resolved into enantiomers via a Pseudomonas cepacia-catalysed acylation with vinyl butyrate. The E values depended on the solvent used and varied from 2 to 26. ... 

Bohman and Allenmark resolved a series of sulphoxide derivatives of unsaturated malonic acids of the general structure 228. The classical method of resolution via formation of diastereoisomeric salts with cinchonine and quinine has also been used by Kapovits and coworkers " to resolve sulphoxides 229, 230, 231 and 232 which are precursors of chiral sulphuranes. Miko/ajczyk and his coworkers achieved optical resolution of sulphoxide 233 by utilizing the phosphonic acid moiety for salt formation with quinine. The racemic sulphinylacetic acid 234, which has a second centre of chirality on the a-carbon atom, was resolved into pure diastereoisomers by Holmberg. Racemic 2-hydroxy- and 4-hydroxyphenyl alkyl sulphoxides were separated via the diastereoisomeric 2- or 4-(tetra-0-acetyl-D-glucopyranosyloxy)phenyl alkyl sulphoxides 235. The optically active sulphoxides were recovered from the isolated diastereoisomers 235 by deacetylation with base and cleavage of the acetal. Racemic 1,3-dithian-l-oxide 236... 

Our approach for chiral resolution is quite systematic. Instead of randomly screening different chiral acids with racemic 7, optically pure N-pMB 19 was prepared from 2, provided to us from Medicinal Chemistry. With 19, several salts with both enantiomers of chiral acids were prepared for evaluation of their crystallinity and solubility in various solvent systems. This is a more systematic way to discover an efficient classical resolution. First, a (+)-camphorsulfonic acid salt of 19 crystallized from EtOAc. One month later, a diastereomeric (-)-camphorsulfonic acid salt of 19 also crystallized. After several investigations on the two diastereomeric crystalline salts, it was determined that racemic 7 could be resolved nicely with (+)-camphorsulfonic acid from n-BuOAc kinetically. In practice, by heating racemic 7 with 1.3equiv (+)-camphorsulfonic acid in n-BuOAc under reflux for 30 min then slowly cooling to room temperature, a cmde diastereomeric mixture of the salt (59% ee) was obtained as a first crop. The first crop was recrystallized from n-BuOAc providing 95% ee salt 20 in 43% isolated yield. (The optical purity was further improved to -100% ee by additional recrystallization from n-BuOAc and the overall crystallization yield was 41%). This chiral resolution method was more efficient and economical than the original bis-camphanyl amide method. 

Evaluation of the above route against our initial target objectives for the synthesis of taranabant indicated a high level of success, not just for the primary objectives of removing the tin chemistry and chiral chromatography, but for a number of other process improvements (Table 9.2). Of particular note was that the three crystalline intermediates were key for purification, first the phenethylamine salt 12 for the classical resolution, secondly the HC1 salt of amine 2 allowed for upgrade of diastereomeric purity, and finally the API allowed for upgrade of enantiomeric purity via initial removal of racemic material. 

---