Assessment practices

There are two major aspects to this discussion of orientation in polymers. First, there is the question of defining orientation, and the information which can be obtained in principle by any given spectroscopic technique regarding orientation in a polymer. This leads directly to the problem of relating orientation to deformation mechanisms, because this may permit comparatively limited information to be put to optimum use. Secondly, there is the relationship between orientation and physical properties, especially mechanical properties, where such information has been valuable in stimulating and assessing practical developments such as high modulus polymers. 

Sub-micro representations are used extensively in teaching the mole concept, stoichiometiy, solubihty and chemical equilibrium at UCT. Having students draw and annotate chemical diagrams representing chemical phenomena at the sub-micro level can provide some insight into their understanding of chemistiy at the macro level. The following examples are typical of the questions used to probe links between the sub-micro and symbohc levels of representations as part of the assessment practice for this course. For example, students were asked to balance the equation shown in Fig. 8.7. 

The FDA and EPA believe that the tolerance process is protective of human health because it is based on extensive testing and on a combination of conservative assumptions and risk assessment practices developed using current scientific knowledge. 

The EPA does consider health criteria when determining whether to approve or deny a manufacturer s petition to have a tolerance established. Human health risk assessment practices consider potential human exposure from all registered (and proposed) uses of the pesticide, and if the risk is deemed excessive, the EPA will deny the tolerance petition. In cases where the risks are deemed acceptable, the EPA will establish tolerances, as described in the previous paragraphs. 

Contemporary risk assessment practices for pesticides in foods require far more data than simply the residue levels evaluated in government monitoring programs. Exposure to pesticides is determined by multiplying the residue levels on food by the amount of the food item consumed once determined, exposure is compared with standard toxicological criteria derived from animal toxicology studies to determine the acceptability of the exposure. 

At every step of the way an attempt is made to present a typical approach, and the usual default assumptions it must be recognized that individual assessments often contain (usually minor) deviations from what is presented here, but what is presented should capture the most important aspects of current chemical risk assessment practice. 

Development and application of a standard for good assessment practice The quality of risk assessments and risk management information could become an element of competition in the global market. To this end an anditable and internationally recognised standard is reqnired. 

The US-EPA staff paper from 2004 titled An Examination of EPA Risk Assessment Principles and Practices (US-EPA 2004) is a product of a US-EPA staff review of how risk assessment is conducted at the Agency. US-EPA assembled a group of risk assessment professionals from across US-EPA to examine US-EPA s risk assessment principles and practices and to prepare the paper. The staff paper presents an analysis of US-EPA s general risk assessment practices and provides comprehensive and detailed information on the practices employed. 

Bergmann, P., Smith, M. and Hoffmann, N. (1995) Adolescent treatment implications for assessment practice guidelines and outcome management. Pediatr Clin North Am 42 453 72. 

Power, M. and McCarty, L.S. (1997) Fallacies in ecological risk assessment practices. Environ Sci Technol, 31, A370-A375. 

Corporate Toxicology and Risk Assessment Practice Director Montgomery, Watson, and Harza 777 Campus Commons, Suite 175 Sacramento, CA 95825... 

E. N. Jacobsen and N. S. Finney, Synthetic and biological catalysts in chemical synthesis how to assess practical utility, Chem. Biol. 1994, 1, 85-90. 

There are many cases in which the TMRC exceeds the RfD or ADI or the oncogenic risk at which the TMRC exceeds one excess cancer per million. When these cases arise, the EPA may refine its exposure assessment practices to consider factors such as more realistic estimates of pesticide use, residue levels, and/or postharvest effects upon residue levels. Studies have indicated that TMRC values often exaggerate pesticide exposure estimates by factors of 10,000 to 100,000 times. The EPA s refinements may yield a value known as the Anticipated Residue Contribution (ARC) which may be substituted for the TMRC to determine the potential risks from the pesticide. In cases where the ARC is below the RfD or ADI and the oncogenic risk at the ARC is below one excess cancer per million, the EPA will generally approve a tolerance (Winter, 1992a). 

Improvements in pesticide residue risk assessment practices should improve the scientific basis for managing pesticide residues in foods and the FQPA provides a blueprint for making such improvements. While most of the FQPA provisions are considered in theory to represent improvements in the risk assessment process, the practical adoption of methods to comply with such... 

The ability to use probabilistic approaches to assess dietary pesticide exposure has also changed much of the emphasis of pesticide risk assessment practices from assessing long-term (chronic) exposure to short-term (acute) exposure. Deterministic approaches worked well with chronic assessments since the day-to-day variability in food consumption patterns and the variability of pesticide residue levels tended to average out over the course of a 70-year exposure period. Deterministic approaches have also often been used in the assessment of acute dietary risk by assuming an upper percentile level of food consumption and the maximum detected or allowable level of residue. The point estimate determined in this manner is then compared with the RfD to determine the acceptability of exposure under the specified conditions. 

The EPA developed a document titled Guidance for Data Quality Assessment, Practical Methods for Data Analysis, EPA QA/G-9 (EPA, 1997a) as a tool for project teams for assessing the type, quality, and quantity of data collected for projects under the EPA oversight. This document summarizes a variety of statistical analysis techniques and is used primarily by statisticians. DQA, however, is not just a statistical evaluation of the collected data. It is a broad assessment of the data in the context of the project DQOs and the intended use of the data, which requires a... 

US Environmental Protection Agency, Guidance for Data Quality Assessment, Practical Method for Data Analysis, EPA QA/G-9, [US Environmental Protection Agency, 1997a]. 

There is one dominant tradition used to understand satisfaction and two emerging traditions that challenge its position. The established approach is called the expectancy/ confirmation/ disconfirmation or EDP model (Oliver, 1980). This adopts the position that customers compare the actual product and service performance with their expectations. The argument is that if customers expectations are met or exceeded the customer is well satisfied. Dissatisfaction will ensue if the expectations are not met. This perspective is the orthodox one that derives from the vast literature in the wider field of consumer behaviour (cf. Schofield, 2000). In many tourism settings, businesses use some form of this EDP approach to shape their thinking and mission statements. Some examples include We aim to exceed our customers expectations and More than you can dream (cf. Hanan Karp, 1989). These views of business success in the satisfaction sphere are then often translated into assessment practices, such as shown in Figure 7.1. 

Despite its popularity in risk assessment practice, limitations of EP have been observed. The most striking deviations are discussed below ... 

The above aspects are covered in more detail in Table 16.3.1 It should be kept in mind that Table 16.3 discusses general facility designs to consider when developing a containment strategy for highly potent compounds. However, each consideration is subject to rigorous risk assessment. Practically, this means a determination of whether the consideration or practice is required or is a nice extra to control exposures to an appropriate level. 

USEPA (2000) Guidance for data quality assessment. Practical methods for data analysis. Washington, DC, United States Environmental Protection Agency, Office of Research and Development, July (EPA/600/R-96/084 http //www.epa.gov/quality/qs-docs/g9-final.pdf). 

Throughout this book, it has been emphasized that we should always try to go beyond statistical significance and also consider the extent of any difference and so assess practical significance. Unfortunately the chi-square test does not produce a 95 per cent Cl for the extent of the difference. However, so long as we are only considering a 2x2 table, some packages (including Minitab) provide a separate routine to calculate a confidence interval. 

The chi-square test only assesses statistical significance. To assess practical significance, you will need a separate routine to calculate a 95 per cent Cl for the difference between proportions. 

Risk assessment of chemical mixtures differs in several aspects from risk assessment of single substances. It therefore requires the development and implementation of other or additional risk assessment concepts and techniques specific for chemical mixtures, among other approaches to tackle the above-mentioned interactions. This is an evolving process that takes place at the interface between scientific research and risk assessment practice. 

Occupational pesticide exposure holds a peculiar status within the field of occupational health and safety, both from a scientific and regulatory perspective. Methods for personal monitoring of dermal exposure first arose in the context of pesticide applications in agriculture, pioneered by scientists in the USA Public Health Service (Batchelor and Walker, 1954 Durham and Wolfe, 1962). These methods gained worldwide recognition in the early 1960s, and remain a component of exposure assessment practice today. This work pre-dated most personal monitoring methods that were developed for industrial workplaces. 

---