Active Catalyst Systems

It is difficult to predict a priori which preparative method will produce the most active and selective catalyst or which preparative method will affect which, if any, of the previously mentioned properties. A great number of recipes have appeared in the patent literature, but any detailed description of the methods which yield the most active and selective catalyst, at least from a commercial viewpoint, remains proprietary. Of course, this makes it very difficult to make comparisons between experimental catalysts and commercial catalysts. Nevertheless, a number of general chemical variables have been identified as important in attempting to produce a specific catalyst. For example, for molybdate catalysts prepared by precipitation, these variables include the temperature of the precipitation, the concentration of the reagents, the aging of the precipitate, and the temperature of the calcination (6J). For supported catalysts, the nature of the support also becomes an important variable in determining the final catalytic activity and selectivity. 

While it is recognized that preparative methods play a vital role in determining catalytic activity and selectivity, few in-depth investigations, relating catalyst structure to catalytic activity and selectivity and comparing one system with another, have appeared in the literature. Consequently, the approach used in this section will be to examine the catalyst systems which have been associated with the historical development of the selective oxidation of propylene. 

This system is more accurately defined as a multiphase (Cu-Cu20-CuO) system. Consequently, it has proven to be very difficult to characterize. The catalyst undergoes changes in its bulk chemical composition, activity, and selectivity during the oxidation of propylene. The final stationary-state composition is a function of the reaction mixture, the temperature, and the duration of the experiment. 

As a catalyst for propylene oxidation, Bi203 itself has fairly low activity and yields primarily the products of complete oxidation. Pure molybdenum trioxide has an even lower activity, but is fairly selective. In combination, however, remarkable activity and selectivity for propylene oxidation is obtained. Although industrial catalysts contain silica and phosphate as well as Bi203 and Mo03, many fundamental studies have employed catalysts containing only bismuth and molybdenum oxides in an attempt to determine the structure of the catalytically active phase. As a result of such studies, it is now known that bismuth molybdate catalysts display their superior properties only if the catalyst composition lies within the composition range of Bi/Mo = f to f (atomic ratio). 

In contrast, Van den Elzen and Rieck (79) reported a monoclinic structure for Bi2Mo209 with space group P21/c and lattice parameters a = 11.946 A, b = 10.795 A, c = 11.876 A, and 0 = 90.15°. The inability of several researchers to prepare single crystals and the existence of metastable modifications of the /3 phase of bismuth molybdate are apparently the main determents to additional clarity concerning its structure. 

---

In an effort to develop more active catalyst systems for the oxidative kinetic resolution of non-activated alcohols, Stoltz et al. discovered a modified set of conditions that accomplishes similar resolutions in a fraction of the time [43]. 

Scheme 16 Use of 54/FeCl3 and MAO as a highly active catalyst system...

The number of phosphine ligands on the active catalyst system is also subject to speculation. In Scheme 9 Hata postulated an active complex consists of only one chelating phosphine. However, he (66) and others (70, 71, 83) also observed that 2 moles of the bisphosphine 32 per mole of Co are needed for best selectivity. Sarafidis (55) suggested that a more desired structure might consist of two bisphosphines, with one of the Co—P bonds having the ability to dissociate to provide coordination sites for incoming monomers (see structure 34). 

These catalysts require temperatures above 100° and usually 150-200° for reasonable rates. Alkylsodium compounds at their decomposition temperatures (50-90°) have also been used by Pines and Haag (9). Lithium reacted with ethylene diamine has also been reported by Reggel et al. (4) as a catalyst for this reaction. The homogeneous system thus formed seems to lower the temperature requirement to 100° (4), whereas the use of potassium amide in liquid ammonia requires 120° (S). Sodium reacted with ethylene diamine has been reported to be an ineffective catalyst (4)- The most active catalyst systems reported so far are high-surface alkali metals and activated-alumina supports. They are very effective at or near room temperature (10-12). 

Chemisorphon of the complexes [Cp MR2], [Cp MR3] or [MR4] (Cp = Cp, Cp M = Zr, Ti, Th R = Me, CH2 Bu, CH2TMS) onto superacidic sulfated zirconia (ZRS , where x refers to activation temperature) [81, 91] and sulfated y-alumina (AIS) [90] afforded active benzene hydrogenation catalysts and ethylene polymer-izahon catalysts. The most active catalyst system for the hydrogenation of benzene (arene Zr = 1.5 1, 25 °C, no solvent, 0.1 MPa H2) was [Cp ZrMe2] -ZRS400, which achieved a TOP of 970 h. The activity of this adsorbate catalyst rivals or exceeds those of the most active heterogeneous arene hydrogenahon catalysts known. The... 

MPa O2). The role of the encapsulated [Co(salophen)] complexes is to catalyze the aerobic oxidation of hydroquinone to p-benzoquinone, which in turn oxidizes Pd(0). For the oxidation of 1,3-cyclohexadiene to l,4-diacetoxy-2-cyclohexene, the most active catalyst system involved the encapsulated complex [Co(tetra-tert-butyl-salophen)], which afforded product yields of 85-95% after 3 h at room temperature with greater than 90% trans-selectivity. This complex displayed significantly higher activity than the encapsulated [Co(salophen)] complex (72% yield in 3h) and the analogous homogeneous complex (86% yield in 5h). The increased activity of the t-butyl substituted catalyst was attributed to distortion of the bulky complex by the... 

Whether or not such electrophilic organometallic species can be identified, or indeed isolated, depends primarily on the stability of the counteranion. The per-fluorophenyl boron compounds B(C,sF5)3 and [B(C6F5)4] , first prepared by Stone and co-workers in 1963 [33], proved particularly useful in this respect. Their use in metallocene polymerisation catalysis [34, 35] led to significantly more active catalysts and well-defined catalyst systems that proved mechanistically informative. These results have then enabled similar species to be detected in the more complex MAO-activated catalyst systems (vide infra). 

A Au-coated substrate is another model surface, to which many surface characterization methods can be applied. To achieve surface-initiated ATRP on Au-coated substrates, some haloester compounds with thiol or disulflde group were developed [80-84]. Self-assembled monolayers (SAM) of these compounds were successfully prepared on a Au-coated substrate and used for ATRP graft polymerization. Because of the limited thermal stability of the S - Au bond, the ATRP was carried out at a relatively low temperature, mostly at room temperature, by using a highly active catalyst system and water as a (co)solvent (water-accelerated ATRP). 

Very recently, Hu et al. claimed to have discovered a convenient procedure for the aerobic oxidation of primary and secondary alcohols utilizing a TEMPO based catalyst system free of any transition metal co-catalyst (21). These authors employed a mixture of TEMPO (1 mol%), sodium nitrite (4-8 mol%) and bromine (4 mol%) as an active catalyst system. The oxidation took place at temperatures between 80-100 °C and at air pressure of 4 bars. However, this process was only successful with activated alcohols. With benzyl alcohol, quantitative conversion to benzaldehyde was achieved after a 1-2 hour reaction. With non-activated aliphatic alcohols (such as 1-octanol) or cyclic alcohols (cyclohexanol), the air pressure needed to be raised to 9 bar and a 4-5 hour of reaction was necessary to reach complete conversion. Unfortunately, this new oxidation procedure also depends on the use of dichloromethane as a solvent. In addition, the elemental bromine used as a cocatalyst is rather difficult to handle on a technical scale because of its high vapor pressure, toxicity and severe corrosion problems. Other disadvantages of this system are the rather low substrate concentration in the solvent and the observed formation of bromination by-products. 

As indicated earlier, the effect of CO pressure is often unpredictable in carbonylations. To optimize this process, the effect of CO pressure was measured at 120°C and 130°C and the results appear in Table 4. With these highly active catalyst systems, there appeared to be an optimum CO pressure and excess CO pressures was deleterious to the reaction. While the presence of CO optima is not unknown in carbonylation chemistry, it is normally observed at significantly higher CO pressures. It is likely that the optimum observed in this study represented the transition from a mass transfer limited reaction to a chemically limited reaction. (The combination of a phosphine optima and rate reductions with increased CO likely indicate a rate determining dissociative process along the reaction pathway.)... 

Finally, the hybridization of the carbon atom also has a marked effect on its willingness to attach to the transition metal. Allyl or benzyl halides undergo oxidative addition faster than aromatic or vinyl halides. The least reactive are alkyl halides which require the use of nickel(O)9 complexes or highly active catalyst systems.10 If we start from an optically active substrate, then the oxidative addition usually proceeds in a stereoselective manner. 

The key factors that influence the ease of the reductive elimination by a late transition metal complex are listed in Figure 1-10. The understanding of their effect on the metal centre might help to design more active catalyst systems. The use of bulky ligands, for example might increase the crowdedness around the metal centre and facilitate reductive elimination,... 

From the synthetic point of view, choice of the starting halide or sulfonate is usually based on availability. Reactivity and economy usually work antiparallel with bromides being the most frequently used substrates. The recent invention of highly active catalyst systems, on the other hand, broadened the applicability of aryl chlorides considerably in cross-coupling reactions.3... 

The Heck reactions depicted so far all involve the coupling of halopyridines and other olefins. The alternate approach, coupling of a vinylpyridine with an aryl halide is also feasible, although less commonly employed. 4-Vinylpyridine was coupled successfully with diethyl 4-bromobenzylphosphonate (7.50.) in the presence of a highly active catalyst system consisting of palladium acetate and tn-o-tolylphosphine to give the desired product in 89% yield, which was used for grafting the pyridine moiety onto metal oxides.70... 

The use of the same, highly active catalyst system and microwave heating also allowed for the drastic reduction of the reaction time. The coupling of 3-chloropyridine and 4-toluidine in the presence of 1 % catalyst and sodium /ert-butoxidc gave on 10 minute irradiation the coupled product in 89% yield (7.74.). 2-Chloropyridine, 2-chloroquinoline and 2-chloropyrazine coupled equally well under the same conditions.95... 

Oxidation of Higher Alkanes. New, selective and active catalyst systems were also developed for the metal-catalyzed oxidation of higher alkanes. A carboxylate-... 

Molybdenum comprises usually 50% or a little more of the total metallic elements. Most of molybdenum atoms form (Mo04)2 anion and make metal molybdates with other metallic elements. Sometimes a little more than the stoichiometric amount of molybdenum to form metal molybdate is included, forming free molybdenum trioxide. Since small amounts of molybdenum are sublimed continuously from the catalyst system under the working conditions, free molybdenum trioxide is important in supplying the molybdenum element to the active catalyst system, especially in the industrial catalyst system. In contrast, bismuth occupies a smaller proportion, forming bismuth molybdates for the active site of the reaction, and too much bismuth decreases catalytic activity somewhat. The roles of alkali metal and two other additives are very complicated. Unfortunately, few reports refer to these elements, except patents. In this article, discussion is directed only at the fundamental structure of the multicomponent bismuth molybdate catalyst system with multiphase in the following paragraphs. 

The concept proposed by us is pictured simply in Fig. 23. The level of water represents the chemical potential of active oxygen involved in the oxidation of propylene, and the vessels connected on the tank are involved in two kinds of active sites that activate molecular oxygen to atomic species and oxidize propylene to acrolein. If active sites expressed by vessels are isolated from each other, each site must do everything by itself to convert propylene to acrolein. This situation is less convenient than the preparation of the active catalyst system. When active species of oxygen can migrate rapidly through the bulk diffusion of oxide ion as shown in Fig. 23, equal-... 

---