Mechanistic information

The quantitative prediction of the stereochemistry of a chemical reaction by strain energies requires knowledge of the reaction mechanism, i.e., the selective intermediates and/or transition states involved, and an accurate force field for the transient species. As discussed above, these are two demanding problems and so far there are no reports of studies in this area that have used molecular mechanics for quantitative predictions at the same level of accuracy as for conformational analyses. The application of empirical force field calculations to the design of asymmetric transformations clearly is a worthy task, and some examples of studies in this area have been discussed above. On the basis of two examples we will now discuss some general aspects highlighting the limitations of the qualitative considerations emerging horn molecular mechanics calculations for the interpretation and support of assumed reaction pathways. 

The OH-promoted exchange of the a-proton of amino acids is catalyzed by metal ions[60]. If the amino acid is coordinated to a chiral complex fragment, the ratio of the two enantiomeric forms of the amino acid is controlled by a chiral intermediate1611. 

The copper(II)-mediated condensation of primary amines with formaldehyde and nitroethane (Fig. 7.6) is highly stereoselective. With [Cu((S),(/ )-ala)2] as starting material only one out of three possible isomeric products is formed (A in Fig. 7.6), and with [Cu(en)2]2+ one out of two isomers (B in Fig. 7.6) is obtained135,64 1. One possible intermediate is shown in Fig. 7.6[65]. Molecular mechanics calculations indicated that the intermediates leading to the observed species are less strained than any others. However, these calculations are only of limited value since the exact nature of the intermediate responsible for the selectivity is not known with certainty. 

Peter ComSa, Trevor W. Hambley copyright VCH Verfagsgesellschaft mbH, 1995 

The application of empirical force field calculations to the design of asymmetric transformations is a worthy task, and some examples of studies in this area have been discussed above. On the basis of two examples we will now discuss some general aspects highlighting the limitations of qualitative considerations emerging from molecular mechanics calculations for the interpretation and support of assumed reaction pathways. 

The copper(II)-mediated condensation of primary amines with formaldehyde and nitroethane (Fig. 8.6) is highly stereoselective. 

Before vitrification, a heat capacity change as a result of chemical reaction, ACp,react, is noticcd. For the anhydride-cured epoxy and the polyester-styrene resin a minor, but reproducible, and almost linear decrease of Cp with conversion is observed. The former system is supposed to be an anionic chain-growth living polymerisation (without termination), the latter is a chain-growth copolymerisation with termination. 

On the contrary, a rather important positive ACp Kact is seen for the amine-cured epoxy and for the melamine-formaldehyde resin. These 

It is clear that A Cp react provides information on the reaction mechanism. Instead of normalising the heat capacity signal in terms of a mobility factor (DF = 1 if no mobility restrictions before vitrification), the information available in ACp,react can be exploited for mechanistic modelling. 

---

Studies of inelastic scattering are of considerable interest in heterogeneous catalysis. The degree to which molecules are scattered specularly gives information about their residence time on the surface. Often new chemical species appear, whose trajectory from the surface correlates to some degree with that of the incident beam of molecules. The study of such reactive scattering gives mechanistic information about surface reactions. 

Time—intensity emission profiles have provided quantitative mechanistic information on the effects of the oxalate stmcture, catalyst, oxidant, and... 

Many enzymes have been the subject of protein engineering studies, including several that are important in medicine and industry, eg, lysozyme, trypsin, and cytochrome P450. SubtiHsin, a bacterial serine protease used in detergents, foods, and the manufacture of leather goods, has been particularly well studied (68). This emphasis is in part owing to the wealth of stmctural and mechanistic information that is available for this enzyme. 

Certain nucleophilic sp ies add to carbonyl groups to give tetrahedral intermediates that are unstable and break down to form a new double bond. An important group of such reactions are those with compounds containing primary amino groups. Scheme 8.2 lists some of the more familiar classes of such reactions. In general, these reactions are reversible, and mechanistic information can be obtained by study of either the forward or the reverse process. 

An abundance of mechanistic information in the literature suggests this scheme ... 

Kinetic evidence in the hydroxide-catalyzed halogenation of acetone provides definitive mechanistic information. The overall reaction is... 

The activation volume can be positive or negative, and its sign is a valuable piece of mechanistic information. Although the measurement of AV is not commonly... 

JesJ73 Jesson, J. P., Meakin, P. Determination of mechanistic information for nuclear magnetic resonance line shape for intramolecular exchange. Accounts of Chem. Res. 6 (1973) 269-275. 

Important mechanistic information can be obtained from the reaction rates of the two diazoates with acid. The older literature, e. g., publications by Grachev (1947 a, 1947 b, 1948), by Porai-Koshits (1960), and by Porai-Koshits et al. (1946, 1960), will not be reviewed here because it is outdated and in some cases the results were not reproducible (see Lewis and Suhr 1958 b, footnote 5). On the basis of the above discussion of the formation of the (Z)-diazoate from the diazonium ion by reactions 1 and 2 of Scheme 5-14, one might assume that the reverse process should be easy to follow experimentally. This is not the case, however, as was first shown simultaneously by Lewis and Suhr (1958 b) and by Passet and Porai-Koshits (1958). The investigation of the acidification of (2i)-4-nitrobenzenediazoate is difficult due to irreversible decomposition, particularly at pH >5. Lewis and Suhr (1958b) observed,... 

There is an extensive literature devoted to the preparation and structure determination of coordination compounds. Thermal analysis (Chap. 2, Sect. 4) has been widely and successfully applied in determinations [1113, 1114] of the stoichiometry and thermochemistry of the rate processes which contribute to the decompositions of these compounds. These stages may overlap and may be reversible, making non-isothermal kinetic data of dubious value (Chap. 3, Sect. 6). There is, however, a comparatively small number of detailed isothermal kinetic investigations, together with supporting microscopic and other studies, of the decomposition of coordination compounds which yields valuable mechanistic information. 

Mechanistic information from the effect of pressure on thermal and photochemical substitution reactions. R. van Eldik, Comments Inorg. Chem., 1986, 5,135 (33). 

Two different kinetic approaches have been used to obtain mechanistic information about this phenomenon. Oxidizability values, fcp/(2fct), are in... 

Several types of mechanistic information can be obtained from kinetic studies. 

Studies on the formation and reactivity of P-centered radicals continue to be a versatile source of mechanistic information and reactions of interest in synthetic chemistry. Various new persistent or stable P-centered radicals have been described and could find applications as paramagnetic probes. The possibility of influencing the properties of organic free radicals bearing an appropriately located phosphorus group should find interesting applications. 

GLYCOSIDE HYDROLASES MECHANISTIC INFORMATION FROM STUDIES WITH REVERSIBLE AND IRREVERSIBLE... 

Clewell HJ, Gentry PR, Gearhart JM, et al. 1995. Considering pharmacokinetic and mechanistic information in cancer risk assessments for environmental contaminants Examples with vinyl chloride and trichloroethylene. Chemosphere 31 2561-2578. 

To prevent this contamination, there were several approaches which this mechanistic information suggested. But the one which the manufacturers proposed ( ) was to stop using nitrite to control corrosion of the container. Most dimethylamine phenoxyalkanoic acid products now contain non-detectable NDMA (18). 

The motivation for an industrial investigation was to gather kinetic and mechanistic information for a very fast and highly exothermic reaction [127]. In particular, by-product formation was analyzed. 

The hydrogenation of nitroacetophenones has been studied and considerable kinetic and mechanistic information obtained. Differences in reaction rate, bonding and selectivity have been observed. The formation of 1-indolinone from 2-NAP was unexpected and revealed the presence of a surface nitrene. This intermediate has not been postulated in nitroaromatic hydrogenation previously. Hydrogenation in the presence of deuterium revealed, as well as a kinetic isotope effect, that it is likely that... 

We saw in Chapter 3 that bisubstrate reactions can conform to a number of different reaction mechanisms. We saw further that the apparent value of a substrate Km (KT) can vary with the degree of saturation of the other substrate of the reaction, in different ways depending on the mechanistic details. Hence the determination of balanced conditions for screening of an enzyme that catalyzes a bisubstrate reaction will require a prior knowledge of reaction mechanism. This places a necessary, but often overlooked, burden on the scientist to determine the reaction mechanism of the enzyme before finalizing assay conditions for HTS purposes. The importance of this mechanistic information cannot be overstated. We have already seen, in the examples of methotrexate inhibition of dihydrofolate, mycophenolic acid inhibiton of IMP dehydrogenase, and epristeride inhibition of steroid 5a-reductase (Chapter 3), how the [5]/A p ratio can influence one s ability to identify uncompetitive inhibitors of bisubstrate reactions. We have also seen that our ability to discover uncompetitive inhibitors of such reactions must be balanced with our ability to discover competitive inhibitors as well. 

Further mechanistic information concerning type 1 cleavage reactions has been obtained by Yang in a study of alkyl-t-butyl ketones.(13) Irradiation of these ketones in hexane solution results in a mixture of products corresponding to both type I and type II cleavage, for example,... 

---