The practice of thermodynamic measurement

We begin to understand the power of thermodynamics when we realize how often this situation arises in effect, we have made an indirect measurement - a frequent occurrence - so we need to formulate another law of thermodynamics, which we call the zeroth law. Imagine three bodies, A, B and C. If A and B are in thermal equilibrium, and B and C are in thermal equilibrium, then A and C are also in thermal equilibrium. 

While sounding overly technical, we have in fact employed the zeroth law with the example of a thermometer. Let us rephrase the definition of the zeroth law and say, If mercury is in thermal equilibrium with the glass of a thermometer, and the glass of a thermometer is in thermal equilibrium with a patient, then the mercury and the patient are also in thermal equilibrium . A medic could not easily determine the temperature of a patient without this, the zeroth law. 

From now on we will assume the zeroth law is obeyed each time we use the phrase thermal equilibrium . 

The zeroth law of thermodynamics says imagine three bodies, A, B and C. If A and B are in thermal equilibrium, and B and C are also in thermal equilibrium, then A and C will be in thermal equilibrium. 

---

The liquid temperature (Tl) corresponding to Xl is measured for practical purposes in two apparatuses known as either the closed or open cup flashpoint test, e.g. ASTM D56 and D1310. These are illustrated in Figure 6.3. The surface concentration (Xs) will be shown to be a unique function of temperature for a pure liquid fuel. This temperature is known as the saturation temperature, denoting the state of thermodynamic equilibrium... 

From a plot of the internalisation flux against the metal concentration in the bulk solution, it is possible to obtain a value of the Michaelis-Menten constant, Am and a maximum value of the internalisation flux, /max (equation (35)). Under the assumption that kd kml for a nonlimiting diffusive flux, the apparent stability constant for the adsorption at sensitive sites, As, can be calculated from the inverse of the Michaelis-Menten constant (i.e. A 1 = As = kf /kd). The use of thermodynamic constants from flux measurements can be problematic due to both practical and theoretical (see Chapter 4) limitations, including a bias in the values due to nonequilibrium conditions, difficulties in separating bound from free solute or the use of incorrect model assumptions [187,188],... 

This chapter will explore the relationship of thermodynamic and kinetic data as it pertains to characterizing the stability of various protein systems in the liquid state. Finally, from the wealth of information generated over the past few decades, it should be possible to assess the practical use of microcalorimetry for predicting stability. This technique used in combination with several other bio-analytical methods can serve as a powerful tool in the measurement of thermodynamic and kinetic phenomena.3-9 Attention will be given to limitations of the technique rendered from different applications as well as to areas where it is advantageous. Ultimately, the practical utility of this technique will rest with those familiar with the art. 

Practical measurements of temperature long preceded the theory of this important concept. Thermodynamics clearly requires the temperature concept, but thermometry (the theory of temperature measurements) is so deeply intertwined with general thermodynamic theory that we must take care to avoid logical circularity. 

The important point is, however, that from the standpoint of thermodynamics there are not ten varieties or even two varieties of hydrogen molecules so long as we deal with an equilibrium mixture of hydrogen. It is not necessary to take account of this equilibrium, any more than it is necessary to consider the various kinds of molecules present in liquid water, when we calculate the thermodynamic properties of that substance. It is only necessary to be sure that the equilibrium is attained. Fowler appears to think that this condition offers practical difficulties but as a matter of fact all of the reactions of hydrogen take place with the equilibrium mixture and it is only in the measurement of the thermal properties at low temperatures that precautions must be taken to obtain equi-... 

The numerator of the right side is the product of measured total concentrations of calcium and carbonate in the water—the ion concentration product (ICP). If n = 1 then the system is in equilibrium and should be stable. If O > 1, the waters are supersaturated, and the laws of thermodynamics would predict that the mineral should precipitate removing ions from solution until n returned to one. If O < 1, the waters are undersaturated and the solid CaCOa should dissolve until the solution concentrations increase to the point where 0=1. In practice it has been observed that CaCOa precipitation from supersaturated waters is rare probably because of the presence of the high concentrations of magnesium in seawater blocks nucleation sites on the surface of the mineral (e.g., Morse and Arvidson, 2002). Supersaturated conditions thus tend to persist. Dissolution of CaCOa, however, does occur when O < 1 and the rate is readily measurable in laboratory experiments and inferred from pore-water studies of marine sediments. Since calcium concentrations are nearly conservative in the ocean, varying by only a few percent, it is the apparent solubility product, and the carbonate ion concentration that largely determine the saturation state of the carbonate minerals. 

Clark, Nabavian, and Bromley (11) measured a heat of dilution of concentrated (7%) sea water and heat capacities of normal and concentrated sea water at room temperature. From these data and vapor-pressure data of Arons and Kientzler (I), with the aid of thermodynamic relations they calculated heats of concentration and boiling point elevations. Both of these properties are presented in graphs and tables over a temperature range of 77° to 302° F. and for salt concentrations up to 9%. Integral heat of concentration increases with the temperature up to about 180° F. substantially independent of concentration and then decreases. The maximum value for 7% salts is only about 1.0 B.t.u. per pound of original sea water and hence is negligible for most practical purposes. 

For these reasons, there is a tendency to use low molecular homologues or solutions. Furthermore, it is an accepted practice to purify the polymers before measuring their thermodynamic properties. However, the industrial polymers have high molecular weights, and are modified by incorporating low molecular weight additives. Furthermore they are processed under high flow rates and stresses that preclude the possibility of thermodynamic equilibrium. For these and other reasons, a direct application of the laboratory data to industrial systems may not always be advisable. 

The practice of thermochemistry involves measurement of the heat absorbed or evolved during a chemical reaction or physical process. Such a measurement determines the amount of heat q according to the first law of thermodynamics ... 

It must be remembered that the cell potential is proportional to the In(activity) of the ion rather than its concentration. The activity is a measure of the extent of thermodynamic nonideality in the solution. The activity coefficient is usually less than unity, so the activity of a solution is generally lower than the total concentration, but the values of activity and concentration approach each other with increasing dilution. If a compound is not completely ionized, the activity is further decreased. Decreased ionization can be brought about because of a weak ionization constant, chemical complexation, or a high salt concentration in the solution. Any of these factors will cause a change in the potential of the cell, even if the ion concentration is constant. In practice, it is better to determine the relationship between the cell potential and ion concentrations experimentally. 

In spite of very diverse successful practical applications, the mechanism of com-plexation and the relationship between structure and selectivity are still at best only partly solved and remain open for discussion. Thermodynamic studies could supply some valuable information facilitating an understanding of the physicochemical basis of the complexation processes. The GC modified with CyDs is one of a variety of experimental methods employed in the determination of thermodynamic quantities for the formation of CyD inclusion complexes (see Chapters 8-10). The thermodynamic parameters for separation of the enantiomers were determined for various derivatives of CyDs dissolved in various stationary phases [63-65] or as a Uquid derivatized form [66]. Interesting observations were made by Armstrong et al. [66]. The authors postulated two different retention mechanisms. The first involved classical formation of the inclusion complex with high thermodynamic values of AH, AAH, and AAS and a relatively low column capacity and the second loose, probably external, multiple association with the CyD characterized by lower AH, AAH, and AAS values. The thermodynamic parameters of complexation processes obtained from liquid and gas chromatography measurements are collected in Table 5.2. It is clear from those data that for all the compounds presented the complexation processes are enthalpy-driven since in all cases AH is more negative than TAS. 

As will have become evident in the earlier parts of this account, energies are in general more important than forces, since it is they which appear in the equations of thermodynamics and of the quantum theory. Energies, as has been said, are derivable in principle from forces, but the calculation requires a knowledge of the variation of force with distance. They must therefore be determined in practice from calorimetric or from spectroscopic observations. Even these two methods do not always measure the same quantity. When a molecule AB dissociates under the influence of light, either or both of the atoms may be formed in one of their excited states. Thus, for example, A- -B-Di,... 

When dealing with the problem of the electronic work function at the metal-solution interface, one should also consider the possible role of formation of solvated electrons as intermediate products of cathodic reduction reactions. The hypothesis according to which this step is practically universal for a cathodic process was advanced in recent years by a number of investigators. Their reasoning, however, is not convincing, as was first shown by Conway neither the kinetic pattern nor the relations between thermodynamic parameters correspond, for the usual interval of potentials, to such a mechanism (this discussion is summarized in Refs. 38, 39 and 45). Walker s attempt " to demonstrate, with the aid of optical measurements, the appearance of solvated electrons in the cathode layer was also refuted. 

The process of measurement of volume expansivity cannot be isobaric in practice. When materials expand, the root mean square velocity of the molecules increases. For the materials with negative coefficient of thermal expansion when materials expand, the root mean square velocity of molecules is expected to decrease. In either case, forcing such a process as isobaric is not a good representation of theory with experiments. Such processes can even be reversible or isentropic. Experiments can be conducted in a careful manner and the energy needed supplied or energy released removed, as the case may be, in a reversible manner. Hence, it is proposed to define volume expansivity at constant entropy. This can keep the quantity per se from violating the laws of thermodynamics. 

Thermodynamics provided the theoretical and experimental framework for judging the characteristics of the sorbates and generalizations concerning the nature of the interactions observed. For example, van t Hoff plots (In Vg versus 1/T) were employed to calculate the heats of adsorption (—A fads) of the individual sorbates on the various inorganic packings(sorbents). In the practice of GSC, another measurement of the sorbent is its surface area. A number of techniques are available to obtain measurements of the surface area (36,37). 

The definition of thermodynamic variables adopted here has also been used by Green and Mori, and seems to be the most natural generalization of the equilibrium definitions. It should be noted, however, that there is a problem connected with the measurement of, say, the temperature for a non-equilibrium state. One is assured by the general principles of thermodjmamics that a properly calibrated thermometer will always yield correct results in an equilibrium measurement. This is no longer true in a non-equilibrium situation. The result of a temperature measurement could depend on, say, the orientation of the thermometer with respect to the temperature gradient. However, we will simply dismiss this difficulty by taking the point of view that it concerns a matter of experimental practice. Note that there is really no difficulty in principle, since one could measure the mechanical quantities and invert Eqs. (67) and (68) to obtain the thermodynamic variables. 

---