Separation flowsheet synthesis

Further, we call triangles 1-2-13 and 3-2-13 product simplexes Regsmp- This notion has great significance for separation flowsheets synthesis, because for a feed point xp located inside the product simplex one can get all the components and azeotropes that are vertexes of this simplex in a sequence of (n - 1) columns. 

In industry, it is necessary to deal with very complicated mixtures for which structural matrices can serve as an instrument of separation flowsheets synthesis. In Wahnschafft (1997), the example of plant for separation of coal tar in South Africa (20 components, more than 200 azeotropes) consisting of 40 columns is given. 

This chapter is the central one of the book all previous chapters being introductory ones to it, and all posterior chapters arising from this one. Distillation process in inhnite column at finite refiux is the most similar to the real process in finite columns. The difference in results of finite and infinite column distillation can be made as small as one wants by increasing the number of plates. Therefore, the main practical questions of distillation unit creation are those of separation flowsheet synthesis and of optimal design parameters determination (i.e., the questions of conceptual design) that can be solved only on the basis of theory of distillation in infinite columns at finite reflux. 

The geometric distillation theory also allowed the development of the general methods of separation flowsheets synthesis for azeotropic mixtures and design calculation of simple and complex distillation columns, which is examined in the chapters to follow. 

This is especially important for the solution of the task of separation flowsheet synthesis of multicomponent azeotropic mixtures (see Chapter 8) because this, in many cases, uses autoextractive distillation (i.e., to exclude the application of entrainers). 

Laroche L, Bekiaris N, Andersen HW and Morari M (1992) Homogeneous Azeotropic Distillation Separability and Flowsheet Synthesis, Ind Eng Chem Res, 31 2190. 

Consider a simple process in which FEED is reacted to PRODUCT via the reaction in Equation 13.1. The flowsheet synthesis is started at the reactor. The effluent from the reactor contains both PRODUCT and unreacted FEED that must be separated. Unreacted FEED is recycled to the reactor via a pump if the recycle is liquid, or a compressor if the recycle is vapor. 

Figure 2.13 illustrates the variation of the economic potential during flowsheet synthesis at different stages as a function of the dominant variable, reactor conversion. EPmin is necessary to ensure the economic viability of the process. At the input/output level EP2 sets the upper limit of the reactor conversion. On the other hand, the lower bound is set at the reactor/separation/recycle level by EP3, which accounts for the cost of reactor and recycles, and eventually of the separations. In this way, the range of optimal conversion can be determined. This problem may be handled conveniently by means of standard optimization capabilities of simulation packages, as demonstrated by the case study of a HDA plant [3]. 

Tier II environmental assessment is employed for flowsheet synthesis on a smaller number of design alternatives. This provides an opportunity to evaluate the impacts of separation and other units in the process in addi-... 

Most of the applications discussed here were based on algorithmic systematic generation approaches to process synthesis. There also exist a number of heuristic rule-based or expert-systems-based approaches including PIP for total flowsheet synthesis, SPLIT for separation schemes (Wahnschafft et ai, 1991),... 

A different approach to process synthesis is offered by means-ends method. It is based on the observation that the purpose of material processing is to apply various operations in such a sequence that the differences in properties between the raw materials and the products are systematically eliminated. As a result, the raw materials are transformed into the desired products. The means-ends method starts with an initial state and successively applies transformation operators to produce intermediate states with fewer differences until the goal state is reached. The hierarchy for the reduction of property differences is as follows identity, amount, concentration, temperature, pressure, and finally form. This property changing method has its limitations, as it ignores the influences and the impacts on other properties. Moreover, the search method takes an opportrmistic approach, which cannot guarantee the generation of a feasible flowsheet. The means-ends analysis approach has been used as a systematic process synthesis method for overall process flowsheet synthesis, as well as for the more detailed case of a separation system to resolve the concentration differences in nonideal systems that include azeotropes. 

The phenomena-driven method for the process synthesis analyzes not the processing units, the so-called building blocks, but the phenomena that occur in those blocks. This method is based on opportunistic task identification and integration. It was applied to separation process synthesis, based on thermodynamic phenomena. It explored the relationship between the physicochemical properties, separation techniques, and conditions of operation. The number of alternatives for each separation task is reduced by systematically analyzing these relationships. Then, possible flowsheets are produced with a list of alternatives for the separation tasks. 

The methodology for flowsheet synthesis presented in this book combines the Hierarchical Methodology of Douglas with a knowledge-based approach, proposed by Bamicki and Fair (1990, 1992). Since distillation is the main separation method, the reader should be familiar with modem design concepts described in specialised books as written by Kister (1992), and more recently by Stichlmair Fair (1999) and Doherty Malone (2001). For a more detailed treatment of separation techniques, we recommend the book of Seader and Henley (1998). 

The Gas Separation Manager presented in this section includes both Vapour Recovery and Gas Separation systems. The flowsheet synthesis can be decomposed in subsystems following the following split selectors ... 

Choice of Process Configuration. The sequence of processing steps and flowsheet configuration must be selected concurrently with the choice of extraction chemistry. Some of the established heuristics of separation process synthesis may be helpful here. For example, in multimetal fractionation it is probably better to tiy selective stripping from a single organic stream than to do multiple selective-extraction oper-... 

A method similar to that of product simplex and considering azeotropes as pseudocomponents was proposed for synthesis of separation flowsheets in Sargent (1994). 

Petlyuk, F. B., Danilov, R. Yu. (2000). Synthesis of Separation Flowsheets for Multicomponent Azeotropic Mixtures on the Basis of the Distillation Theory. Synthesis Finding Optimal Separation Flowsheets. Theor. Found. Chem. Eng., 34,444-56. 

Synthesis of a separation flowsheet consists of determining the best sequence of distillation columns and complexes that will ensure the obtaining of the set of products of a set quality from the initial mixture. 

For azeotropic mixtures, the main difficulty of the solution of the task of synthesis consists not in the multiplicity of feasible sequences of columns and complexes but in the necessity for the determination of feasible splits in each potential column or in the complex. The questions of synthesis of separation flowsheets for azeotropic mixtures were investigated in a great number of works. But these works mainly concern three-component mixtures and splits at infinite reflux. In a small number of works, mixtures with a larger number of components are considered however, in these works, the discussion is limited to the identification of splits at infinite reflux and linear boundaries between distillation regions Reg° . Yet, it is important to identify all feasible splits, not only the spUts feasible in simple columns at infinite reflux and at linear boundaries between distillation regions. It is important, in particular, to identify the spUts feasible in simple columns at finite reflux and curvilinear boundaries between distillation regions and also the splits feasible only in three-section columns of extractive distillation. 

While synthesizing separation flowsheets, it is necessary to consider the pos-sibUity of thermodynamic improvement and thermal integration. Therefore, for each sequence, identified in the process of synthesis, it is necessary to realize possible thermodynanric improvements and thermal integration of the columns. The estimation of expenditures on separation is made taking into consideration these modifications, if these expenditures are smaller than for the sequence without modifications under consideration. This estimation of expenditures is used while comparing the sequence under consideration to all other possible sequences. 

The analysis of possible splits in the mode of infinite reflux with the purpose of synthesis of separation flowsheets was extended to multicomponent mixtures (Pet-lyuk, Kievskii, Serafimov, 1977a Petlyuk, Avetyan, Inyaeva, 1977 Petlyuk, 1979 Petlyuk, Kievskii, Serafimov, 1979 Baburina Platonov, 1990 Safrit Westerberg, 1997 Rooks et al., 1998 Sargent, 1998), (Doherty Malone, 2001). 

In the given example mixture 2,3,4, that is bottom product of the first column, is zeotropic therefore, its separation in the second and third columns presents no difficulty. Figure 8.23 shows nine preferable separation flowsheets for this example, obtained by means of synthesis. All these flowsheets separate four-component mixtures using a minimum number (three) of columns without additional entrain-ers, but with application of autoentrainer. Component 2 or 4 or mixtures 2,4 or 3,4 are used as an autoentrainer. Therefore, each of nine separation flowsheets contains one column with one or two feedings where recycle flow of autoentrainer is brought in. 

---