Sensory analysis problems

This example demonstrates the most challenging problem of flavor chemistry, ie, each flavor problem may require its own analytical approach however, a sensory analysis is always required. The remaining unknown odorants demand the most sensitive and selective techniques, and methods of concentration and isolation that preserve the sensory properties of complex and often dehcate flavors. Furthermore, some of the subtle odors in one system will be first identified in very different systems, like o-amino acetophenone in weasels and fox grapes. 

Sensory. Although the basis for multivariate analysis was developed in the early 1900 s, its use in sensory analysis is relatively recent. These types of statistics, however, have been valuable in dealing with two fundamental problems which occur in sensory testing. First there are difficulties encountered when one attempts to breakdown complex sensory parameters into single semantic terms which can be rated, and second it is difficult to achieve the goal of every panelist having the same internal understanding of each term. Approaches to minimize these difficulties included 1) evaluation of semantic terms used by the panel to determine if the variables are unique or can be condensed to a new set of unique variables 2) evaluation of the panelists use of semantic terms to determine inconsistencies as well as the relative importance of the terms to food quality or discrimination.(8)... 

The partly very low threshold levels of this class of compounds complicate instrumental analysis because the concentrations necessary to form off-odors are so low that they are covered up by other trace components. Only the combination of instrumental and sensory analysis methods leads to successful solving of the problem. 

These specialists utilize highly trained judges and sophisticated test designs and analysis to solve sensory problems. Consumer testing in most industry applications now is done with consumers. Even with the continuing development of instrumentation to replace the human judge, sensory analysis continues to expand its contribution to flavor analysis. 

Forss (1) reviewed the relationship between sensory analysis and flavor chemistry, and provided a discussion of sensory characterization of flavor. Williams et al. (2) also addressed the problem of relating the many known flavor compounds to what is actually perceived by the individual on a physico-chemical basis. This chapter will center more on reviewing advances in sensory methodology as they have been adapted by the flavor and food industry. 

To illustrate descriptive analysis, I will draw from both the wine and beer industry. Oregon State University s Sensory Science Laboratory, located in the Department of Food Science and Technology, is heavily involved in wine and beer research. The principle problems and solutions in the sensory analysis of wine and beer should be transferable to other products. Common wine descriptors, such as soft, hard, fat, are ambiguous. What do soft or hard mean when referring to wine The goal of descriptive analysis is to use precise terms, even referring to specific chemical entities when possible. In the wine industry, objective sensory analysis must overcome the historical romance of wine. 

Many varieties of red pepper, derived from plants of the genus Capsicum, are used in different cuisines around the world for their sensory properties of oral chemical "heat", volatile flavor and color. Determination of the degree of heat in a pepper sample has been a difficult problem for both sensory and instrumental analysts of flavor. Furthermore, the literature concerning the sensory physiology and perceptual responses of the "common chemical sense" (as defined later) has lagged behind other areas of study of the chemical senses. The purpose of this paper will be to review recent developments in two areas, the development of a standard method for sensory analysis of ground red pepper heat and the psychophysical characterization of observers responses to oral chemical Irritation induced by spice-derived compounds. 

The problem in quality testing is the number of assessors. In Sensory Analysis, which is closely allied with statistics here, between 7 and 11 panelists are normally required for this type of testing. But no company carries out initial quality testing with over 7 people. So a compromise has to be found. 

Sensory analysis involves using human subjects as a measuring tool. This presents an immediate problem, as individuals are innately variable, not only as a result of their experiences or expectations, but also as a result of their sensitivity. Thus, each person could genuinely perceive the same product quite differently. It is therefore essential in... 

Until recently, unfolding algorithms presented convergence problems to trivial solutions (equidistant products). But this problem seems to have been solved (Busing et al, 2005). Still rarely used in sensory analysis, unfolding appears as the most natural method to process PSP data from a continuous scale. 

Let us try to relate the (standardized) sensory data in Table 35.1 to the explanatory variables in Table 35.3. Essentially, this is an analysis-of-variance problem. We try to explain the effects of two qualitative factors, viz. Country and Ripeness, on the sensory responses. Each factor has three levels Country = Greece, Italy,... 

T. Naes and E. Risvik (Editors), Multivariate Analysis of Data in Sensory Science, Data Handling in Science and Technology Series. Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1996 P.K. Hopke and X.-H. Song, The chemical mass balance as a multivariate calibration problem. Chemom. Intell. Lab. Assist., 37 (1997) 5-14. 

BAILEY, J.C. and BEDBOROUGH, D.R. Sensory Measurement and Instrumental Analysis of Odours in Septic Sewage—Problems and Solutions Institute of Water Pollution Control, Maidstone, Kent, England, 1979. 

Within Severn Trent a modified version of this procedure is utilised for the analysis of malodorous emissions. The most significant difference in this approach compared to those already discussed is the use of high resolution gas chromatography in combination with olfactory detection. This method also combines physico-chemical and olfactometric or sensory techniques but in an alternative manner. Utilisation of gas chromatography combined with odour detection is not a new concept and has been employed fairly commonly for the analysis of food aromas, essential oils and other fragrances. The technique is equally applicable to environmental problems and is used frequently in this laboratory for the analysis of atmospheric emissions and taste and odours in water. Three important benefits accrue from this approach in the context of odour emission analysis. 

Currently available methods for determining seafood freshness have been reviewed (2,3,4,5). In general, sensory and microbiological quality of seafoods are the standards most often utilized for determining freshness. There are, however, several limitations with these methods such as the need for trained technicians, problems with subjectivity, or long analysis times. Consequently, several new methods have been proposed using chemical indices of freshness that attempt to overcome these difficulties. The purpose of the present paper is to first review these methods with particular emphasis on shrimp freshness determinations and, secondly, to present experimental evidence showing that impedance can be used to denote shrimp freshness. 

While the problem of relating sensory response to a simple mixture is difficult, this is compounded when efforts are made to relate sensory response to the thousands of components contained in cigarette smoke. As with many food systems, the differences are essentially quantitative rather than qualitative. The use of multivariate techniques are essential since they are designed to deal with all the peaks of a chromatographic profile. Fortunately, many of these components are highly correlated with others, and therefore simpler variables can be extracted through techniques such as factor analysis. 

Multivariate analysis is not a panacea for all flavor problems. It is a valuable tool which should be used in conjunction with other sensory and analytical skills to solve flavor problems. The availability of a programmable chromatographic data system makes implementation of MVA straightforward. 

One remaining problem with tissue-specific null mutants that exploit the Cre/ lox-P system is that early excision at the time of birth of sensory neurons may allow developmental compensatory mechanisms to occur, again complicating phenotypic analysis, particularly in terms of behaviour. It would thus be ideal to be able to delete genes in adult animals, whose behaviour under control conditions has already been assessed. Recent advances in gene dehvery suggest that this approach may be feasible. 

The major problem in food analysis is the complexity of the matrices. For example, coffee has a complex matrix. Acids from coffee are important for the sensory quality of the coffee beverage. For every acid identification, it is necessary to perform an electrophoretic cleanup of all organic acids followed by the use of the GC-MS technique.34... 

---