Quality control bioassays

While reported data on the acute and chronic toxicity of many pesticides is plentiful, few studies have been published on toxicity bioassays applied to wastewaters containing pesticides. The application of toxicity bioassays to the quality control of wastewaters offers several advantages in addition to being a... 

In subsequent chapters, we provide an overview of SPMD fundamentals and applications (Chapter 2) the theory and modeling which includes the extrapolation of SPMD concentrations to ambient environmental concentrations (Chapter 3) study considerations such as the necessary precautions and procedures during SPMD transport, deployment, and retrieval (Chapter 4) the analytical chemistry and associated quality control for the analysis of SPMD dialysates or extracts (Chapter 5) a survey and brief description of bioassays-biomarkers used to screen the toxicity of SPMD environmental extracts (Chapter 6) discussions on how HOC concentrations in SPMDs may or may not relate to similarly exposed biomonitoring organisms (Chapter 7) and selected examples of environmental studies using SPMDs (Chapter 8). In addition, two appendices are included which provide... 

SPMD dialysates (extracts), rinses of the exterior membrane surface (only SPMDs exposed to air), and aliquots thereof often contain a number of classes of chemicals. Figure 6.1 shows various levels of processing and enrichment used for SPMD derived bioassay samples. We strongly recommend the use of SPMDs with triolein purified by the method of Lebo et al. (2004) for bioassays to reduce the probability of false-positive results or for controls that fail to meet quality control... 

New, powerful techniques in chemistry, odor formulations, bioassays, and olfactometry have supplied us with deeper as well as fresh insights into olfactoiy effects on our behavior. Medicine, psychology, environmental design, occupational safety, air-quality control, marketing, and advertising now consider and contribute to human chemical ecology. 

As part of this field study, relevant quality assurance/quality control (QA/QC) criteria and guidelines (SETAC, 1993 JAMP, 1998a,b) have to be set to insure the quality of data generated during the assessments. The development of QA/QC criteria for this study involved conducting a series of replicate bioassays with each of the methods. Samples tested included a control sediment, contaminated sediments and reference toxicants. Based on the results of the bioassay replicates, the variability associated with the tests was quantified and we were able to determine what we considered acceptable QA/QC criteria for these methods. 

Quality control when applying bioassays in a licensing system... 

Extraction and determination of samples spiked with positive controls performed as quality control checks for each bioassay run. 

The optimal RIA parameters of the talc-resin-TCA test also apply to iodohormones used in bioassays and radioreceptor assays (RRA). The talc and TCA testing has been used to monitor the degradation of I-la-beled hormone used with prolactin, insulin, and growth hormone receptors. Strict adherence to the limits of >90% talc adsorption, <25% resin binding, and >90% TCA precipitation provides a rigorous quality control for the presence of bioactive and receptor-affinitive monomeric iodohormone. 

Another important characteristic is that of precision. This becomes evident only when repeat measurements are made, because precision refers to the amount of agreement between repeated measurements (the standard deviation around the mean estimate). Precision is subject to both random and systematic errors. In industrial quality control and chemical analysis, Shewhart Control Charts provide a means of assessing the precision of repeat measurements but these approaches are rarely used in ecotoxicity testing. The effect is that we generally understand little about either the accuracy or the precision of most bioassays. 

A conventional response to issues of variability in bioassays is to construct Shewhart Control Charts based on the results achieved in repeat tests within a laboratory using a reference toxicant. This effectively describes the range of results typically found within the laboratory and hence can be used to define limits within which the laboratory normally expects to operate. However, there is a flaw in such internal quality control because the more variable a laboratory s reference toxicant test results are, the wider the limits of acceptability will be. Indeed, it can serve merely to reinforce high variability or bias. 

Lansky D. Validation of bioassays for quality control. In Brown F, Mire-Sluis AR, eds. Biological Characterization and Assay of Cytokines and Growth Factors. Dev Biol Stand. Basel Karger, 1999 97 157-168. 

There are at least three areas of concern that each laboratory head faces as he or she considers switching from the current bioassays using the natural substrates to ones employing synthetic peptide substrates. The first is how does one report results so that the physicians will be able to relate to them. The second is the observation that different results have been reported on the stability of standard enzyme preparations when tested by both procedures. The third is the quality control programs for the synthetic substrates. 

Enzyme linked immunosorbent assays (ELISA) have been successfully developed for the detection and quantitation of the BT kurstaki and BT israelensis toxins (11-14). These ELISA are used routinely to supplement bioassays in monitoring the production and quality control during fermentation process. Reported here are the laboratory studies of the application of ELISA for monitoring the BT toxin in environmental samples. 

The SOPs should cover all aspects of the assay from the time the sample is collected and reaches the laboratory until the results of the bioassay are reported. A description of experiments concerning the validation conducted to determine variability, limit of quantification and the quality controls should be documented for data audit and inspection the traceability is a requirement for good analytical practice. Any deviations from SOPs should be documented with justifications for deviations. 

Laboratoiy quality control procedures for sediment bioassays are listed in Ecology (2003). Here we will give a brief overview of how control procedures ensure the quality of ecotoxicological tests. 

An interesting approach was reported by Cheun et al. These authors developed a tissue biosensor for STX and TTX that consisted of a Na electrode covered with a frog bladder membrane integrated within a flow cell. Active Na" transport that takes place from the internal to the external face was found to be TTX and STX sensitive. This procedure allowed the detection of PSP toxins well below the detection limit of the mouse bioassay but no quality control data was provided in the paper. 

Development of procedures and protocols for a chemical/ vehicle quality control analysis program. Such programs are designed to insure that reliable procedures are used by the bioassay and chemistry laboratories for the analysis of bulk chemicals and chemicals in the dosage/feed mixtures. 

The proof of activity of a biological pesticide is typically evaluated by a standardized bioassay except in the case of microbial metabolites where the major active ingredient(s) may be measured by analytical methods. Biological activity measurements, besides serving as a parameter for quality control, are an essential tool in the product development and optimization process. It is important to define the assay procedure in order to compare production batches and experimental formulations. These assays are typically used for product release or may be designed to assess specific aspects of product activity such as mobility in soils, colonization on leaf surface, etc. 

The routine chemical analysis for the quality control of compost and soil will not be suitable to detect (unknown) metabolites which are harmful to the environment. Bioassays will be necessary to supplement other analyses and to complete the information about the environmental behaviour of biodegradable polymers. This requirement is already expressed in the inclusion of mandatory bioassays in the relevant standards for compostable products. 

Potential hazards caused by the introduction of toxic components (especially heavy metals) with contaminated compost are revealed very often. These typical impurities are covered by the analytical quality control of most of the national regulations in Europe and will lead to a classification as second or third quality and to a limited use of the compost. These national standards are dealing with well-known contaminants that may derive from typical biowaste and are focussing on heavy metals and a handful of halogenated or aromatic hydrocarbons. The inclusion of bioassays with higher plants in some standards is more to determine the maturity of the compost than with the appearance of ecotoxic effects caused by anything other than the chemicals being determined. 

The process of toxin inactivation by formaldehyde treatment is pooriy understood. However, it does involve the formation of a Schiff s base, either with lysine or arginine residues in the protein, foiiowed by cross-linking to residues such as tyrosine, lysine and tryptophan. The quality control for this reaction is bioassay of the resultant toxoid using an animal model but there is the possibility of using mass spectrometry to follow the modification (Fig. 27.21). ... 

The specific and robust nature of the pups response to milk allowed Keil et al. (1990) to develop a behavioural bioassay for use in characterizing the actual pheromonal substance or substances. Using the bioassay it was found that pups responsiveness declines linearly with the exponent of dilution, and that cues contained in the milk are so potent that milk diluted by as much as 10 4 still elicits significantly more responses than cow s milk or other control substances (Keil et al. 1990). However, when left at room temperature milk loses most of its behaviour-releasing quality within about 30 minutes, but retains it for several weeks when stored at -40°C (Muller 1978 Keil et al. 1990). 

---