Method development model validation

Much of the methods development and validation efforts in the past have been focused on evaluation of immunosuppression and contact or dermal sensitization. Currently available animal models and assays are not valid to assess the potential for systemic hypersensitivity and, at this time, reliable models to assess autoimmunity are not available. 

II. Guidelines for analytical method development and validation of biotechnological synthesis of drugs. Production of a chiral steroid as model. 

A description of the make and model of mass spectrometer used should be provided along with a description of the operating parameters used for method development. Some of the the settings for the mass analyzer or interface will depend on the optimized conditions for a particular instrument, e.g. gas flows, interface potentials, collision cell conditions, but the conditions (or range) that were used during method development and validation should be provided. Any parameter settings that are considered to be critical, such as interface temperatures, should be described in the procednre. 

Zhang, S., Golbraikh, A., Oloff, S., Kohn, H., Tropsha, A. A novel automated lazy learning QSAR (ALL-QSAR) approach method development, applications, and virmal screening of chemical databases using validated ALL-QSAR models. 

Fogli et al. developed and validated an HPLC method with fluorescence detection for simultaneous routine TDM of anthracyclines and their metabolites.27 They coupled a Waters LC Module I Plus system equipped with a WISP 416 autosampler with a Model 474 scanning fluorescence spectrophotometer. The stationary phase was a Supelcosil LC-CN column (250 x 4.6 mm, 5 /um particle size) with a /iBondapak-CN guard column. The mobile phase consisted of 50mM monobasic sodium phosphate buffer and acetonitrile (65 35 v/v), adjusted to pH 4.0 with phosphoric acid. The flow rate was 1 mL/min. The fluorescence detection was set at excitation wavelengths of 233, 254, and 480 nm and at an emission wavelength of 560 nm. 

Exposure. The presence of the -hexane metabolite 2,5-hexanedione in the urine is a reasonably reliable marker for exposure to -hexane and has been correlated with air concentrations in the workplace. This is not a specific marker since 2-hexanone is also metabolized to 2,5-hexanedione. The levels of this metabolite in the urine associated with neurotoxicity are not known. A more sensitive marker for exposure may be the presence of pyrolidated proteins in the blood or hair, a result of the reaction of 2,5-hexanedione with the side-chain amino group of lysine (Graham et al. 1995 Johnson et al. 1995). These methods have only been tested after oral exposure to 2,5-hexanedione in the rat model. It would be very useful to know if measurement of pyrrole adducts or cross-linked proteins is also feasible after inhalation exposure to u-hexane in the rat model. Further development and validation of this method in an occupationally exposed population may then be useful. 

A PDA detector provides UV spectra of eluting peaks in addition to monitoring the absorbance of the HPLC eluent like the UVA is absorbance detector. It is the preferred detector for testing impurities and for method development. PDA facilitates peak identification during methods development and peak purity evaluation during method validation. Detector sensitivity was an issue in earlier models but has improved significantly (more than ten-fold) in recent years. ... 

Pollutants emitted by various sources entered an air parcel moving with the wind in the model proposed by Eschenroeder and Martinez. Finite-difference solutions to the species-mass-balance equations described the pollutant chemical kinetics and the upward spread through a series of vertical cells. The initial chemical mechanism consisted of 7 species participating in 13 reactions based on sm< -chamber observations. Atmospheric dispersion data from the literature were introduced to provide vertical-diffusion coefficients. Initial validity tests were conducted for a static air mass over central Los Angeles on October 23, 1968, and during an episode late in 1%8 while a special mobile laboratory was set up by Scott Research Laboratories. Curves were plotted to illustrate sensitivity to rate and emission values, and the feasibility of this prediction technique was demonstrated. Some problems of the future were ultimately identified by this work, and the method developed has been applied to several environmental impact studies (see, for example, Wayne et al. ). 

However, if the test samples are sufficiently balanced to cover the sample states used to build the model without extending beyond those states, and the cost of obtaining and analyzing these test samples is not prohibitive, then the test set validation method can be very effective. In fact, in some high-stakes applications where model evaluation is the main objective, such validation is required, often with the stipulation that the known reference values of the test samples are withheld from the method developers by the testing authority - a procedure also known as blind validation. 

NIR models are validated in order to ensure quality in the analytical results obtained in applying the method developed to samples independent of those used in the calibration process. Although constructing the model involves the use of validation techniques that allow some basic characteristics of the model to be established, a set of samples not employed in the calibration process is required for prediction in order to conhrm the goodness of the model. Such samples can be selected from the initial set, and should possess the same properties as those in the calibration set. The quality of the results is assessed in terms of parameters such as the relative standard error of prediction (RSEP) or the root mean square error of prediction (RMSEP). 

Ideally, an on-line analyzer will be calibrated before it is installed in the process. It may be possible to accomplish this by calibrating it off-line with process grab samples and/or synthetic samples. It may be possible to install the analyzer in a lab-scale reactor, or in a semi-works or pilot plant. It may be possible to transfer to the on-line analyzer a method developed on an off-line analyzer or on another on-line analyzer (e.g. at a different plant site). However, sometimes none of these are possible and the analyzer will need to be calibrated on-line. The challenges of on-line model development (calibration) and validation, as well as approaches to dealing with them, are discussed below. For information related to calibration transfer issues, please see Chapter 12 of this book. 

To test the reliability of the previous method, the authors compared it to an independent measurement of oj. They thus propose an extended version of the previous mean-fleld model, valid at any stage of the coalescence regime, even in presence of broad droplet size distributions. It is obtained by considering that the variation of the total number of coalescence events is proportional to the total surface area per unit volume developed by the droplets of different sizes. The total number of drops and total surface are replaced by summations over all the granulometric size intervals ... 

In addition to the somewhat empirical and difficult development of NIR applications, thorough documentation must be produced. NIR methods have to comply with the current good manufacturing practice (cGMP) requirements used in the pharmaceutical industry. Various regulatory aspects have to be carefully considered. For example, NIR applications in classification, identification, or quantification require extensive model development and validation, a study of the risk impact of possible errors, a definition of model variables and measurement parameters, and... 

In order to better understand nonmethane hydrocarbon involvement in the processes outlined in Figure 1, researchers are using sophisticated air-quality simulation models. These models usually require individual species information. Consequently, considerable effort is currently being directed toward the development and validation of analytical methods for measuring the concentrations of vapor-phase organic compounds in various environments. 

The Siro model is a good tool in the development of constituent retrieval algorithms for limb scan measurements. However, the Monte Carlo technique requires a lot of computer time. Faster models need to be developed for near-real time processing of limb spectra to constituent profiles. Siro serves as a reference against which faster but more approximate methods can be validated. 

It would appear at this stage that a good deal of useful information has yet to be obtained by the pulse radiolysis method concerning the absorption spectra of the solvated electron in various organic liquids. Such data would help to remove uncertainties regarding the assignment of bands and would serve as criteria for the validity of developing models. 

---