Experimental error analysis

A preliminary experimental error analysis indicated that the flowrate control and, to a lesser degree, the temperature control would be critical. It is necessary to change the off-the-shelf flow controllers for commercial chromatographs and desirable to change the temperature controller. 

If the experimental error is random, the method of least squares applies to analysis of the set. Minimize the sum of squares of the deviations by differentiating with respect to m. 

When designing and evaluating an analytical method, we usually make three separate considerations of experimental error. First, before beginning an analysis, errors associated with each measurement are evaluated to ensure that their cumulative effect will not limit the utility of the analysis. Errors known or believed to affect the result can then be minimized. Second, during the analysis the measurement process is monitored, ensuring that it remains under control. Finally, at the end of the analysis the quality of the measurements and the result are evaluated and compared with the original design criteria. This chapter is an introduction to the sources and evaluation of errors in analytical measurements, the effect of measurement error on the result of an analysis, and the statistical analysis of data. 

An emphasis on critical thinking. Critical thinking is encouraged through problems in which students are asked to explain why certain steps in an analytical procedure are included, or to determine the effect of an experimental error on the results of an analysis. 

The goal of any statistical analysis is inference concerning whether on the basis of available data, some hypothesis about the natural world is true. The hypothesis may consist of the value of some parameter or parameters, such as a physical constant or the exact proportion of an allelic variant in a human population, or the hypothesis may be a qualitative statement, such as This protein adopts an a/p barrel fold or I am currently in Philadelphia. The parameters or hypothesis can be unobservable or as yet unobserved. How the data arise from the parameters is called the model for the system under study and may include estimates of experimental error as well as our best understanding of the physical process of the system. 

The sampling of solution for activity measurement is carried out by filtration with 0.22 pm Millex filter (Millipore Co.) which is encapsuled and attached to a syringe for handy operation. The randomly selected filtrates are further passed through Amicon Centriflo membrane filter (CF-25) of 2 nm pore size. The activities measured for the filtrates from the two different pore sizes are observed to be identical within experimental error. Activities are measured by a liquid scintillation counter. For each sample solution, triplicate samplings and activity measurements are undertaken and the average of three values is used for calculation. Absorption spectra of experimental solutions are measured using a Beckman UV 5260 spectrophotometer for the analysis of oxidation states of dissolved Pu ions. 

Mitra et al.AS have also re-refined the structures of the regular (26) and relaxed 4-fold sodium hyaluronate (27) helices for direct comparison with their own analysis of the relaxed 4-fold helix of potassium hyaluronate (29). Within experimental error, their final models strongly support the original results, which have been described here. 

A good model is consistent with physical phenomena (i.e., 01 has a physically plausible form) and reduces crresidual to experimental error using as few adjustable parameters as possible. There is a philosophical principle known as Occam s razor that is particularly appropriate to statistical data analysis when two theories can explain the data, the simpler theory is preferred. In complex reactions, particularly heterogeneous reactions, several models may fit the data equally well. As seen in Section 5.1 on the various forms of Arrhenius temperature dependence, it is usually impossible to distinguish between mechanisms based on goodness of fit. The choice of the simplest form of Arrhenius behavior (m = 0) is based on Occam s razor. 

The natural and correct form of the isokinetic relationship is eq. (13) or (13a). The plot, AH versus AG , has slope Pf(P - T), from which j3 is easily obtained. If a statistical treatment is needed, the common regression analysis can usually be recommended, with AG (or logK) as the independent and AH as the dependent variable, since errors in the former can be neglected. Then the overall fit is estimated by means of the correlation coefficient, and the standard deviation from the regression line reveals whether the correlation is fulfilled within the experimental errors. 

As an example of the use of MIXCO.TRIAD, an analysis of comonomer triad distribution of several ethylene-propylene copolymer samples will be delineated. The theoretical triad Intensities corresponding to the 2-state B/B and 3-state B/B/B mixture models are given In Table VI. Abls, et al (19) had earlier published the HMR triad data on ethylene-propylene samples made through continuous polymerization with heterogeneous titanium catalysts. The data can be readily fitted to the two-state B/B model. The results for samples 2 and 5 are shown In Table VII. The mean deviation (R) between the observed and the calculated Intensities Is less than 1% absolute, and certainly less than the experimental error In the HMR Intensity determination. 

The value given in Table II for adrenals 21 days following administration suggests that this tissue may concentrate TCDD- C and/or a metabolite. This observation results probably from experimental error. The disintegrations per minute (dpm) above background for this tissue were only 17, 29, and 90. Since the total amount of tissue available for analysis was less than 20 mg, the multiplication factor may have magnified the error many fold. 

Statistical testing of model adequacy and significance of parameter estimates is a very important part of kinetic modelling. Only those models with a positive evaluation in statistical analysis should be applied in reactor scale-up. The statistical analysis presented below is restricted to linear regression and normal or Gaussian distribution of experimental errors. If the experimental error has a zero mean, constant variance and is independently distributed, its variance can be evaluated by dividing SSres by the number of degrees of freedom, i.e. 

Error analysis of Eq. (4) shows that the value for D is sensitive to small changes in Cave because the term in parentheses is squared. Therefore, it is of critical important to minimize variation related to assay or any other experimental... 

The ability of any experimental method to produce accurate and reproducible results and provide the sensitivity needed to discern differences between transport mechanisms depends on minimizing variability intrinsic to the method. However, formal error analysis is rarely undertaken, even for commonly used methods. Fawcett and Caton [45] performed an error analysis of the capillary method for determining diffusion coefficients more than 25 years after the method was introduced. The value of the analysis is that it reveals which factors contribute the greatest variability to the dependent variable of interest. In the case of transport studies, the dependent variable of primary interest is diffusant concentration, C(t), where... 

The slight excess of titanium determined by elemental analysis may be within the experimental error of the TGA and elemental analysis. 

Literature data for the suspension polymerization of styrene was selected for the analysi. The data, shown in Table I, Includes conversion, number and weight average molecular weights and initiator loadings (14). The empirical models selected to describe the rate and the instantaneous properties are summarized in Table II. In every case the models were shown to be adequate within the limits of the reported experimental error. The experimental and calculated Instantaneous values are summarized in Figures (1) and (2). The rate constant for the thermal decomposition of benzoyl peroxide was taken as In kd 36.68 137.48/RT kJ/(gmol) (11). 

In the molecule of 4-methylene-3-borahomoadamantane derivative 79, the structure of which was determined by X-ray analysis, the six carbon atoms of the triene system, the two boron and two silicon atoms all lie in one plane within experimental error (mean deviation 1.4 pm). The boron atoms deviate from the trigonal-planar geometry, since the sum of bond angles around the atoms is only 355.8° instead of 360°, as usually encountered in triorganoboranes. Considerable distortions of the bond angles at the terminal C-C double bond occurs in the vicinity of the boron atoms B-C(4)-C(ll) 130.60(19)° and B-C(4)-C(5) 107.38(17)° <2002CEJ1537>. 

For 8,9,10,11-tetrahydro-BA the lifetimes measured with and without DNA are the same within experimental error ( 2 nsec). Without DNA the decay profile of trans-7,8-dihydroxy-7,8-dihydro-BP follows a single-exponential decay law. With DNA the decay profile has a small contribution from a short-lived component (x = 5 nsec) which arises from DNA complexes. This indicates that Equation 1 is not strictly valid. However, the analysis of the decay profile with DNA also indicates that the short lifetime component contributes less than 11% to the total emission observed at [POa ] 5 x 10 M. Under these conditions Equation 1 still yields a good approximate value to the association constant for intercalation. 

---