Esterification practice

ESTERIFICATION PRACTICE Design and Operation of Esterification Plants 

The first of these types of processes may be operated either in batches or continuously. Both methods require eflicient distilling columns, which may be of perforateiji plate or bell-cap design or even of the packed t3q e. In every case, it is now customary to employ a catalyst, which is usually sulfuric acid, in admixture with the alcohol and acid that are to react. In making ethyl acetate industrially, ethyl alcohol of 95 per cent by volume and acetic acid of 80 per cent or less concentration are generally used. There being no definite lower limit of acid concentration, it is merely a matter of economic balance as to how far the exhaustion of the acetic acid may be carried. In a continuous process such as that of Backhaus, the concentration of the acetic acid may be reduced to 1 per cent. 

Layout batch process for ifxanufacturing ethyl acetate. 

As less water is carried over than is formed in the reaction and as the acid 

A continuous process for making ethyl acetate, which is especially adapted to the utilization of dilute acetic acid, is illustrated in Fig. 12-6. In thi4 process, the residual acid water, exhausted of its acid and alcohol to as low a point as is economical, is promptly and continuously discharged from the apparatus. The regulation of the still is thus practically fixed. 

---

V. ESTERIFICATION PRACTICE Design and Operation of Esterification Plants... 

Most large-scale industrial methacrylate processes are designed to produce methyl methacrylate or methacryhc acid. In some instances, simple alkyl alcohols, eg, ethanol, butanol, and isobutyl alcohol, maybe substituted for methanol to yield the higher alkyl methacrylates. In practice, these higher alkyl methacrylates are usually prepared from methacryhc acid by direct esterification or transesterification of methyl methacrylate with the desired alcohol. 

Several variations of the above process are practiced. In the Sumitomo-Nippon Shokubai process, the effluent from the first-stage reactor containing methacrolein and methacrylic acid is fed directiy to the second-stage oxidation without isolation or purification (125,126). In this process, overall yields are maximized by optimizing selectivity to methacrolein plus methacrylic acid in the first stage. Conversion of isobutjiene or tert-huty alcohol must be high because no recycling of material is possible. In another variation, Asahi Chemical has reported the oxidative esterification of methacrolein directiy to MMA in 80% yield without isolation of the intermediate MAA (127,128). 

Herm/es/Djnamit JS obe/Process. On a worldwide basis, the Hercules Inc./Dynamit Nobel AG process is the dorninant technology for the production of dimethyl terephthalate the chemistry was patented in the 1950s (67—69). Modifications in commercial practice have occurred over the years, with several variations being practiced commercially (70—72). The reaction to dimethyl terephthalate involves four steps, which alternate between liquid-phase oxidation and liquid-phase esterification. Two reactors are used. Eirst, -xylene is oxidized with air to -toluic acid in the oxidation reactor, and the contents are then sent to the second reactor for esterification with methanol to methyl -toluate. The toluate is isolated by distillation and returned to the first reactor where it is further oxidized to monomethyl terephthalate, which is then esterified in the second reactor to dimethyl terephthalate. 

This procedure is restricted mainly to aminodicarboxyhc acids or diaminocarboxyhc acids. In the case of neutral amino acids, the amino group or carboxyl group must be protected, eg, by A/-acylation, esterification, or amidation. This protection of the racemic amino acid and deprotection of the separated enantiomers add stages to the overall process. Furthermore, this procedure requires a stoichiometric quantity of the resolving agent, which is then difficult to recover efficiendy. Practical examples of resolution by this method have been pubUshed (50,51). 

Methyl salicylate is produced synthetically for commercial purposes by the esterification of salicylic acid with methanol or by extraction by steam distillation of wintergreen leaves or sweet birch bark. The source, natural or synthetic, is declared on the label. The methyl salicylate NF must assay not less than 98.0% and not more than 100.5% and be processed by Good Manufacturing Practice described in USP (20). 

There are two main processes for the synthesis of ethyl alcohol from ethylene. The eadiest to be developed (in 1930 by Union Carbide Corp.) was the indirect hydration process, variously called the strong sulfuric acid—ethylene process, the ethyl sulfate process, the esterification—hydrolysis process, or the sulfation—hydrolysis process. This process is stiU in use in Russia. The other synthesis process, designed to eliminate the use of sulfuric acid and which, since the early 1970s, has completely supplanted the old sulfuric acid process in the United States, is the direct hydration process. This process, the catalytic vapor-phase hydration of ethylene, is now practiced by only three U.S. companies Union Carbide Corp. (UCC), Quantum Chemical Corp., and Eastman Chemical Co. (a Division of Eastman Kodak Co.). UCC imports cmde industrial ethanol, CIE, from SADAF (the joint venture of SABIC and Pecten [Shell]) in Saudi Arabia, and refines it to industrial grade. 

In recent years, the rate of information available on the use of ion-exchange resins as reaction catalysts has increased, and the practical application of ion-exchanger catalysis in the field of chemistry has been widely developed. Ion-exchangers are already used in more than twenty types of different chemical reactions. Some of the significant examples of the applications of ion-exchange catalysis are in hydration [1,2], dehydration [3,4], esterification [5,6], alkylation [7], condensation [8-11], and polymerization, and isomerization reactions [12-14]. Cationic resins in form, also used as catalysts in the hydrolysis reactions, and the literature on hydrolysis itself is quite extensive [15-28], Several types of ion exchange catalysts have been used in the hydrolysis of different compounds. Some of these are given in Table 1. 

Using excess ethylene glycol is the usual practice because it drives the equilihrium to near completion and terminates the acid end groups. This results in a polymer with terminal -OH. When the free acid is used (esterification), the reaction is self catalyzed. However, an acid catalyst is used to compensate for the decrease in terephthalic acid as the esterification nears completion. In addition to the catalyst and terminator, other additives are used such as color improvers and dulling agents. For example, PET is delustred hy the addition of titanium dioxide. 

Ethyl benzoylformate has been prepared by the direct esterification of the acid 1 and by the action of oxides of nitrogen on an alcoholic suspension of indigo.2 The acid has been prepared by many different reactions but the most practical are the hydrolysis of benzoyl cyanide,3 the oxidation of acetophenone 4 and the oxidation of mandelic acid.5... 

However, in most cases, relation (48) does not account for results obtained under experimental conditions used in industry, i.e. high reactant concentrations. Othmer carried out a detailed study in this field and suggested second-order reactions for the esterifications of n-butanol with acetic acid245 and monobutyl terephthalate246 catalyzed by sulfuric acid. Since such relations cannot be established in all cases, no reaction order could be found for the esterification of 2,3-butanediol with acetic arid247 in the presence of sulfuric add. Moreover, Othmer s reaction orders were obtained for very concentrated media and in our opinion cannot be connected to a mechanism. In fact, this was not Othmer s objective who established these relations for practical use in industrial esterifications. 

Application of sulfuric acid as the catalyst is considered more practical for esterification because of its higher boiling point, its incompatibility with benzene, and the stability of nitroacetic acid in the reaction mixture that allows the omission of the final neutralization step. 

Transesterification of fat triglycerides is the predominant method for manufacture of mixed fatty acid methyl esters, and direct esterification of fatty acids (FA) is practiced if very selective cuts of product, in general as an intermediate detergent range alcohol, are desired. Methyl cocoate is a mobile, oily liquid above 25 °C with a yellow tint and a characteristic fatty pungent odor. FAME sulfonation to FAMES is technically possible but been rarely applied up to now (1990) (Table 13). 

Alkoxylated polysiloxanes are a relatively new class of dyebath lubricants. They have practically no substantivity for the substrate, yet combine adequate lubrication with water solubility and easy rinsability. If the silicones contain primary hydroxy groups, these can be modified by esterification, phosphation, phosphonation, sulphation, sulphonation or carboxylation. These anionic substituents confer substantivity for various substrates without losing rinsability. Anionic organic sulphates and sulphonates probably offer the best overall properties for dyebath lubricants, whilst other types can be more suitable for selected applications [464]. 

The kinetics of the acid-catalyzed esterification reaction of 2,4,6-trimethylbenzoic acid in i-PrOH under microwave irradiation have been investigated [84], A simple and practical technique for MW-assisted synthesis of esters has been reported wherein the reactions are conducted either on solid mineral supports or by using a phase transfer catalyst (PTC) in the absence of organic solvents [85], The esterification of enols with acetic anhydride and iodine has also been recorded [86],... 

In these studies, chemical conversion was determined in situ by measuring the lH resonance associated with OH groups present. In practice two such resonances exist associated with chemical species inside and outside the catalyst particles, respectively. The difference in chemical shift between these intra- and inter-particle species arises because of the different electronic environment of the molecules inside the catalyst particles compared to their environment in the bulk fluid in the inter-particle space. In this work, chemical conversion was determined from the MR signal acquired from species in the inter-particle space of the bed because the signal from inside the catalyst particles is also going to be influenced, to an unknown extent, by relaxation time contrast. In addition to possible relaxation contrast effects, there will also be modifications to the chemical shifts of individual species resulting from adsorption onto the catalyst this may cause peak broadening and reduces the accuracy with which we can determine the chemical shift of the species of interest. As follows from eqn (11) which describes the esterification reaction of methanol and acetic acid to form methyl acetate and water ... 

As far as the velocity and the extent of the conversion are concerned, the two processes are, however, altogether different. Whereas an acid is practically instantaneously and completely converted into a salt by an equivalent amount of a sufficiently strong base (neutralisation), a process on which, indeed, alkalimetry and acidimetry depend, it is not possible to obtain from equimolecular amounts of acid and alcohol the theoretical (calculated) amount of ester. A certain maximal quantity of ester is formed, but always falls short of the theoretical, and it is impossible, even by indefinitely extending the duration of the reaction, to make the unchanged acid and alcohol produce ester in excess of that maximum. If, for example, equimolecular amounts of acetic acid and alcohol are allowed to interact in a closed system, only two-thirds of each enter into reaction, and it is impossible to induce the remaining third of acetic acid to react with that of alcohol. The maximum yield of ester therefore amounts to only two-thirds, or 66-7 per cent, of the theoretical quantity. The quantitative difference in the course of the two reactions mentioned above depends on the fact that esterification is a so-called reversible reaction , i.e. one in which the reaction products represented on the right-hand side of the equation (ester and water) also interact in the opposite direction ... 

The alkyl group of the salt of the alkylsulphuric acid can also be made available for esterification if the temperature is raised sufficiently. The formation of esters from acid chlorides or anhydrides need only be recalled here. This method also has practical importance. 

Chromatographic fixed-bed reactors consists of a single chromatographic column containing a solid phase on which adsorption and reaction take place. Normally a pulse of reactant is injected into the reactor and, while traveling through the reactor, simultaneous conversion and separation take place (Fig. 3). Since an extensive overview of the models and applications of this type of reactor was presented by Sardin et al. [ 132], only a few recent results will be discussed here. Most of the practical applications have been based on gas-liquid systems, which are not applicable for the enzyme reactions, but a few reactions were also reported in the liquid phase. One of these studies, performed by Mazzotti and co-workers [ 141 ], analyzed the esterification of acetic acid into ethyl acetate according to the reaction ... 

Before looking in detail at the mechanisms of the various reactions and processes it is worth summarizing some relevant observations about the carbonylation processes as a whole that need to be explained by these mechanisms. It should be noted that, although the overall feedstock is MeOH for an AcOH process, for practical reasons it is usual to operate with relatively high [AcOH] in the reactor and that most of the substrate is present as MeOAc through esterification (Eq. (3)). 

The method of choice for the prefixation of the aromatic halves is the very practicable esterification reaction. This type of bridge ideally fulfills the requirements demanded easy formation, high thermal stability, good electronic coupling conditions, and, finally, facile cleavage by saponification or reduction. The chiral biaryls are thus obtained as biscarboxylic acids or bisbenzyl alcohols, respectively. 

Esterification Reactions. The use of solid acids provides a practical substitute for homogeneous acid catalysts commonly employed to prepare alkyl esters. The use of homogeneous acid catalysts, such as sulfuric acid, and p-toluene- or methane-sulfonic acids, generally results in sulfur contamination of the final product, which upon combustion yield compounds that are known pollutants. 

High-pressure FT-IR spectroscopy has been used to clarify (1) the rotational isomerism of molecules, (2) characteristics of water and the water-head group, and (3) RSO3 Na4- interactions in reverse micellar aggregates in supercritical ethane. This work demonstrates interesting pressure, temperature, and salt effects on an enzyme-catalyzed esterification and/or maintenance of a one-phase microemulsion in supercritical fluids from practical and theoretical points of view (Ikushima, 1997). 

LCAT acts preferentially on lipids transported by HDL (so-called a-LCAT activity), but also on lipids transported by apoB-containing lipoproteins (so-called jS-LCAT activity) [58, 85]. In practice, LCAT activity is measured either as the activity required to esterify radioactive cholesterol that has been exogenously incorporated into native HDL or into artificial HDL-like particles (a-LCAT activity) or which has been equilibrated with endogenous lipoproteins of the plasma sample (cholesterol esterification rate, CER) [21, 58, 85]. Several variations of these assays have been reported, some of which are available as commercial test kits (e.g., Roar Biomedical, New York, USA). In addition, LCAT concentration can be determined by either laboratory-made tests or by a commercial ELISA kits [57]. However, the decrease in LCAT concentration is difficult to judge since it also decreases secondary to HDL deficiency due to causes other than LCAT deficiency. Plasma from patients with LCAT deficiency fails to esterify radioactive cholesterol provided by any substrate. By contrast, plasmas of patients with fish-eye disease show a near-normal cholesterol ester-fication rate but have a selective inability to esterify radioactive cholesterol provided to plasma with native HDL or reconstituted HDL (a-LCAT activity) [58, 85]. 

Theoretical calculation based on the equation of nitration shows that when 100 parts of glycerine are added to 205.4 parts of HN03 the yield is 246.7 parts of nitroglycerine. At the same time 58.7 parts of water are formed. In practice this yield cannot be obtained because the nitration of glycerine, like every esterification reaction, is in principle a reversible one. The yield is partly defined by the number of O-nitro groups introduced into the molecule of glycerol. 

According to Sapozhnikov, the esterification proceeds most intensively in the presence of anhydrous nitric add HN03, as in eqn. (2). In the presence of smaller amounts of sulphuric acid, nitric acid hydrates are formed in practice they are not capable of esterifying cellulose. 

---