Erosion steels

Wear owing to corrosion and/or erosion can be particularly dangerous. For example, as carbon steel corrodes, the reduced wall thickness can eventually lead to a stmctural failure. This problem can be compounded through erosive wear of the silo wall. 

A good summary of the behavior of steels in high temperature steam is available (45). Calculated scale thickness for 10 years of exposure of ferritic steels in 593°C and 13.8 MPa (2000 psi) superheated steam is about 0.64 mm for 5 Cr—0.5 Mo steels, and 1 mm for 2.25 Cr—1 Mo steels. Steam pressure does not seem to have much influence. The steels form duplex layer scales of a uniform thickness. Scales on austenitic steels in the same test also form two layers but were irregular. Generally, the higher the alloy content, the thinner the oxide scale. Excessively thick oxide scale can exfoHate and be prone to under-the-scale concentration of corrodents and corrosion. ExfoHated scale can cause soHd particle erosion of the downstream equipment and clogging. Thick scale on boiler tubes impairs heat transfer and causes an increase in metal temperature. 

Titanium resists erosion—corrosion by fast-moving sand-laden water. In a high velocity, sand-laden seawater test (8.2 m/s) for a 60-d period, titanium performed more than 100 times better than 18 Cr—8 Ni stainless steel. Monel, or 70 Cu—30 Ni. Resistance to cavitation, ie, corrosion on surfaces exposed to high velocity Hquids, is better than by most other stmctural metals (34,35). 

The level of natural versus man-made emissions to the environment are of a similar magnitude. SoH erosion is the major contributor of natural emissions with zinc mining, zinc production facHities, iron and steel production, corrosion of galvanized stmctures, coal and fuel combustion, waste disposal and incineration, and the use of zinc fertilizers and pesticides being the principal anthropogenic contributors. 

The metallurgy of the cyclone equipment has in recent years focused primarily on type 304 H stainless steel. The 304 H material is durable and easy to fabricate and repair, withstands the high regenerator temperatures, and is oxidation- and corrosion-resistant. Essentially all internal surfaces of the cyclone that are subject to erosion are protected with a 2 cm layer of erosion-resistant lining. When installed and cured, most refractory linings are highly resistant to erosion. 

Metals that depend on a relatively thick protective coating of corrosion product for corrosion resistance are frequently subject to erosion-corrosion. This is due to the poor adherence of these coatings relative to the thin films formed by the classical passive metals, such as stainless steel and titanium. Both stainless steel and titanium are relatively immune to erosion-corrosion in most cooling water environments. 

Figure 11.3 Sand dunelike erosion-corrosion patterns on the inlet end of a steel heat exchanger tube. (Magnification 7x.)...

Figure 11.10 Effect of pH of distilled water on erosion-corrosion of carbon steel at 122°F (50°C) (velocity, 39 ft/s, 12 m/s). (SOURCE M. G. Fontana and N. D. Greene, Corrosion Engineering, 2d ed., 1978, p. 75. Reprinted with permission from McGraw-Hill, Inc.)...

For inlet or outlet end erosion-corrosion, either extend tube ends 3 or 4 inches into the water box or install sleeves, inserts, or ferrules into the tube ends. These should be a minimum of 5 inches long. The ferrules may be nonmetallic or erosion-resistant metals, such as stainless steel, if galvanically compatible. The end of the ferrule should be feathered to prevent turbulence. 

Because alterations to equipment design can be cumbersome and expensive, a more economical approach may be to change the metallurgy of affected components. Metals used in typical cooling water environments vary in their resistance to erosion-corrosion. Listed in approximate order of increasing resistance to erosion-corrosion, these are copper, brass, aluminum brass, cupronickel, steel, low-chromium steel, stainless steel, and titanium. 

The resistance of a metal to erosion-corrosion is based principally on the tenacity of the coating of corrosion products it forms in the environment to which it is exposed. Zinc (brasses), aluminum (aluminum brass), and nickel (cupronickel) alloyed with copper increase the coating s tenacity. An addition of V2 to 1)4% iron to cupronickel can greatly increase its erosion-corrosion resistance for the same reason. Similarly, chromium added to iron-base alloys and molybdenum added to austenitic stainless steels will increase resistance to erosion-corrosion. 

Specify metals that are more resistant to erosion, such as cupronickel, monel, and stainless steels. Only affected tubes need to be replaced by these metals. 

Dents in tubing can induce erosion failures, especially in soft metals such as copper and brass. Welding and improper heat treatment of stainless steel can lead to localized corrosion or cracking through a change in the microstructure, such as sensitization. Another form of defect is the inadvertent substitution of an improper material. 

Galvanic corrosion may also occur by transport of relatively noble metals, either as particulate or as ions, to the surface of an active metal. For example, ions of copper, perhaps resulting from corrosion or erosion-corrosion at an upstream site, may be carried by cooling water to the surfaces of aluminum, steel, or even stainless steel components. If the ions are reduced and deposit on the component surfaces, localized galvanic corrosion may result. 

After a few revolutions, the rubber lip of the oil seal beeomes an abrasive lip, w hieh eats a groove into the stainless steel pump shaft. The rubbing aetion abrades the pump shaft, removing metal, and depleting the ehromium eontent of the stainless steel, wdiieh further aeeelerates its erosion. 

Fig. 17-2 Protection current densities of uncoated steel as a function of flow rate in flowing seawater, F with undisturbed film formation F2 with disturbed film formation due to erosion.

Plate anodes were used for corrosion protection in order to avoid damage due to erosion and cavitation. These consisted of enamelled steel bodies in which a metal oxide-coated titanium anode 1 dm in surface area was fitted. The enamel... 

For erosive wear. Rockwell or Brinell hardness is likely to show an inverse relation with carbon and low alloy steels. If they contain over about 0.55 percent carbon, they can be hardened to a high level. However, at the same or even at lower hardness, certain martensitic cast irons (HC 250 and Ni-Hard) can out perform carbon and low alloy steel considerably. For simplification, each of these alloys can be considered a mixture of hard carbide and hardened steel. The usual hardness tests tend to reflect chiefly the steel portion, indicating perhaps from 500 to 650 BHN. Even the Rockwell diamond cone indenter is too large to measure the hardness of the carbides a sharp diamond point with a light load must be used. The Vickers diamond pyramid indenter provides this, giving values around 1,100 for the iron carbide in Ni-Hard and 1,700 for the chromium carbide in HC 250. (These numbers have the same mathematical basis as the more common Brinell hardness numbers.) The microscopically revealed differences in carbide hardness accounts for the superior erosion resistance of these cast irons versus the hardened steels. 

Erosion and Corrosion combined require special consideration. Most of the stainless steels and related corrosion-resistant alloys ow e their surface stability and low rate of corrosion to passive films that develop on the surface either prior to or during exposure to reactive fluids. If conditions change from passive to active, or if the passive film is removed and not promptly reinstated, much higher rates of corrosion may be expected. 

If the amount of metal removal by erosion is significant the surface will probably be continually active. Metal loss will be the additive effect of erosion and active corrosion. Sometimes the erosion rate is higher than that of active corrosion. The material selection judgment can then disregard coirosion and proceed on the basis of erosion resistance provided the corrosion rates of aetive surfaces of the alloys considered are not much different. As an example of magnitudes, a good high-chromium iron may lose metal from erosion only a tenth as fast as do the usual stainless steels. 

Sulfur dioxide emissions may affect building stone and ferrous and nonferrous metals. Sulfurous acid, formed from the reaction of sulfur dioxide with moisture, accelerates the corrosion of iron, steel, and zinc. Sulfur oxides react with copper to produce the green patina of copper sulfate on the surface of the copper. Acids in the form of gases, aerosols, or precipitation may chemically erode building materials such as marble, limestone, and dolomite. Of particular concern is the chemical erosion of historical monuments and works of art. Sulfurous and sulfuric acids formed from sulfur dioxide and sulfur trioxide when they react with moisture may also damage paper and leather. 

Chromium (total) 0.1 0.1 Some people who use water containing chromium well in excess of the MCL over many years could experience allergic dermatitis Discharge from steel and pulp mills erosion of natural deposits... 

The austenitic cast irons are in widespread use in many industries (food, pharmaceutical, petroleum, chemical, petrochemical, pulp and paper, etc.) in mildly corrosive and erosive situations where the life of unalloyed or low-alloy cast iron or steel is short, but the high cost of stainless steel and nonferrous alloys cannot be justified. 

Tower shells may be ferrous, non-ferrous, stainless alloys or clad (such as monel-clad-steel). The trays are usually light gage metal consistent with the corrosion and erosion problems of the system. The velocity action of vapors flowing through holes and slots accentuates the erosion-corrosion problems, and often a carbon steel tower will use... 

---