Comparison of the various techniques

Glass electrode potentiometry was for many years the only practical method for pH measurement in seawater, and it is only within the last ten years that accurate spectrophoto-metric techniques have been developed and used. Both methods have been described in this chapter, and it is appropriate to consider the advantages and disadvantages of each. 

Indicator spectrophotometry requires somewhat more sophisticated instrumentation than potentiometry, but has the advantage that calibration depends largely on knowledge of the pK value(s) of the indicator selected. This calibration can be carried out under well-controlled laboratory conditions rather than in the field, and in principle need only be done once. Furthermore, if more accurate pK values become available in the future, previously obtained absorption data can be recalculated to give improved pH values. A problem which requires careful attention is the change in pH caused by addition of the indicator. 

Under optimum conditions a precision of 0.002 pH can be obtained with glass electrodes, compared with 0.0005 pH or better for spectrophotometry with a 100 mm path length. Systematic errors are currently estimated to be similar for both techniques, of the order of 0.004 pH. The systematic errors for spectrophotometric measurements are likely to decrease in the near future as further indicator pK determinations become available and as more accurate methods of correcting for the added indicator are developed. Spectrophotometry is therefore expected to become the method of choice for the most accurate and precise measurements of seawater pH. 

---

Table SAQ 7.3 Comparison of the various techniques used for the extraction of organic analytes from solid matrices 2... 

Surface analysis techniques are categorized in Table I. Figure 1, often called a Propst diagram, illustrates the probes and emitted species that can be measured in many of the new techniques for surface analysis. More than 40 of the possible combinations have been explored many others have not yet been tried. Figure 2 presents an approximate comparison of the various techniques with respect to their depth of analysis. Only the techniques that have shown success or show promise for use in biomaterials characterization will be considered in more detail in this review. 

Testing and comparison of the various techniques against selected test data sets. 

A comparison of the various post-ionization techniques electron-gas bombardment, resonant and nonresonant laser ionization, etc. While some of the numbers are outdated, the relative capabilities of these methods have remained the same. This is a well-written review article that reiterates the specific areas where post-ionization has advantages over SIMS. 

We have spoken frequently in this chapter about sensitivity and detection limit in reference to advantages and disadvantages of the various techniques. Sensitivity and detection limit have specific definitions in atomic absorption. Sensitivity is defined as the concentration of an element that will produce an absorption of 1% (absorptivity percent transmittance of 99%). It is the smallest concentration that can be determined with a reasonable degree of precision. Detection limit is the concentration that gives a readout level that is double the electrical noise level inherent in the baseline. It is a qualitative parameter in the sense that it is the minimum concentration that can be detected, but not precisely determined, like a blip that is barely seen compared to the electrical noise on the baseline. It would tell the analyst that the element is present, but not necessarily at a precisely determinable concentration level. A comparison of detection limits for several elements for the more popular techniques is given in Table 9.2. 

The objectives of this monograph are to provide a compilation of the newest results in this field of research, a critical evaluation of the results, a comparison of the various LC separation techniques, and the prediction of future trends in the LC analysis of pigments. The book is meant to be self-sufficient in terms of the needs of the average analytical chemist who intends to work in this fascinating field. We are confident that it will be a valuable reference book for researchers and serious students engaged in the chromatography of pigments. 

Lamb and co-workers reviewed techniques of diffusion modeling for air quality with relation to transportation-generated pollution. They discussed the theory and structure of models, presented a series of tabulated comparisons, analyzed the function and design of each model, and offered simple diagrams to illustrate the functions and problems of the various techniques. The report was intended to survey a great deal of unpublished material and therefore was important in bringing the earlier surveys up to date (to about mid-1973). 

The basic strategy of modal reduction approaches is to retain only certain modes of the high-order model in the low-order model. Wilson et al. (1974) summarized these techniques and showed that many of the published modal approaches are equivalent since they produce identical reduced models. Bonvin (1980) also provides a comparison of the various modal techniques with respect to their steady-state and dynamic accuracies as well as to the dependence of the reduced models on the retained state variables. 

The comparison of the various area techniques presented later will discuss the problem of this technique. For this reason a more detailed discussion here regarding sloping baselines is not warranted. 

A comparison of the various fitting techniques is given in Table 5. Most of these techniques depend either explicitly or implicitly on a least-squares minimization. This is appropriate, provided the noise present is normally distributed. In this case, least-squares estimation is equivalent to maximum-likelihood estimation.147 If the noise is not normally distributed, a least-squares estimation is inappropriate. Table 5 includes an indication of how each technique scales with N, the number of data points, for the case in which N is large. A detailed discussion on how different techniques scale with N and also with the number of parameters, is given in the PhD thesis of Vanhamme.148... 

Semiempirical MO studies were also reported by other research groups.23 36 1 Recently, a systematic comparison of the various computational techniques for predicting the geometry and electronic spectra of spiropyrans and spirooxazines has been published.42 The validity of various semiempirical methods has been checked. This may provide a useful aid for practical uses of semiempirical methods.42 Molecular dynamics (MD) has also found use for these series of derivatives.43 5... 

The other major technology area necessary for the conversion of transportation vehicles to the use of hydrogen is the on board fuel storage. A number of differing storage techniques have been investigated. To aid in the comparison of the various storage schemes it is necessary to establish a set of criteria for a reference vehicle and its fuel tank. 

Table 1 summarizes and allows comparison between the various techniques discussed in this review. Additional data are given on the approximate cost of commercially available equipment that one would need to apply the related technique. In general the cost of home built ... 

In conclusion, the author wishes to call the reader s attention to a recent publication of Barton (75). In it, he presents a thorough and critical review of most of the approaches to solubility and cohesion parameters described in this chapter and summarizes more recent contributions contained in a large number of references published since this chapter first appeared. In his treatment. Barton provides extensive comparisons of the various methods and techniques (including GLC, liquid, liquid-solid, and gel chromatography) used to study solubility and cohesion parameters. Numerous examples as well as detailed tabulations of pertinent data are provided for a variety of systems. Barton also provides data... 

For a comparison of the various distillation techniques, the reader is referred to the paper by Boelens et al.13... 

Many reviews have been produced on the subject of mass spectrometry and imaging, while two excellent books on SIMS are from Benninghoven [112] and Vickerman [119]. Reviews are also available on SIMS [120-125], imaging SIMS [126-130], biological SIMS [131-134], and SIMS of polymers [135]. Comparisons of the various microanalysis techniques using SIMS are also available [136,137]. In the following sections, attention is focused in particular on ToF-SIMS and NanoSIMS techniques. 

The fifth and final chapter, on Parallel Force Field Evaluation, takes account of the fact that the bulk of CPU time spent in MD simulations is required for evaluation of the force field. In the first paper, BOARD and his coworkers present a comparison of the performance of various parallel implementations of Ewald and multipole summations together with recommendations for their application. The second paper, by Phillips et AL., addresses the special problems associated with the design of parallel MD programs. Conflicting issues that shape the design of such codes are identified and the use of features such as multiple threads and message-driven execution is described. The final paper, by Okunbor Murty, compares three force decomposition techniques (the checkerboard partitioning method. 

We shall examine the simplest possible molecular orbital problem, calculation of the bond energy and bond length of the hydrogen molecule ion Hj. Although of no practical significance, is of theoretical importance because the complete quantum mechanical calculation of its bond energy can be canied out by both exact and approximate methods. This pemiits comparison of the exact quantum mechanical solution with the solution obtained by various approximate techniques so that a judgment can be made as to the efficacy of the approximate methods. Exact quantum mechanical calculations cannot be carried out on more complicated molecular systems, hence the importance of the one exact molecular solution we do have. We wish to have a three-way comparison i) exact theoretical, ii) experimental, and iii) approximate theoretical. 

---