Uncertainty appropriate methods

The deformation of polymer chains in stretched and swollen networks can be investigated by SANS, A few such studies have been carried out, and some theoretical results based on Gaussian models of networks have been presented. The possible defects in network formation may invalidate an otherwise well planned experiment, and because of this uncertainty, conclusions based on current experiments must be viewed as tentative. It is also true that theoretical calculations have been restricted thus far to only a few simple models of an elastomeric network. An appropriate method of calculation for trapped entanglements has not been constructed, nor has any calculation of the SANS pattern of a network which is constrained according to the reptation models of de Gennes (24) or Doi-Edwards (25,26) appeared. 

Several methods are available for developing OELs analogy, correlation, safety and uncertainty factors, and low-dose extrapolation (Table 14.5). The appropriate method must be selected on the basis of the appropriateness of the available data. For example, low-dose extrapolation may be appropriate only if sufficient pharmaco-... 

When estimating the uncertainty of measurement, all uncertainty components Ahich are of importance in the g/ven situation shall be taken into account using appropriate methods of analysis... 

There are many methods of analyzing variability and uncertainty and many ways of presenting the results. Inappropriate use of these methods gives misleading results, and experts differ on what is appropriate. Disagreement about which methods are appropriate will lead to wasted resources, conflict over results, and reduced credibility with decision makers and the public. There is, therefore, a need to reach a consensus on how to choose and use appropriate methods, and to present this in the form of guidance for prospective users. 

Provide guidance on how to select appropriate methods of uncertainty analysis, and how to use them... 

Choose appropriate methods of uncertainty analysis and consider their implications for other aspects of problem formulation. 

Conduct risk assessment refinements using appropriate uncertainty analysis methods based on output from the sensitivity analysis. Use appropriate experts in this process. 

The validity of nutrient flux studies as a method to establish whether saltmarsh processes have a significant effect on the productivity of coastal water should be questioned. Unless uncertainties are reduced by improvements in methodology, and an intensive sampling regime undertaken (sampling a semi-diurnal tidal cycle every few days), creek nutrient flux studies do not seem to be an appropriate method to quantify the impact of saltmarsh... 

One of the objectives of the NBA Thermochemical Data Base (TDB) project is to provide an idea of the uncertainties associated with the data selected in this review. As a rule, the uncertainties define the range within which the corresponding data can be reproduced with a probability of 95% at any place and by any appropriate method. In many cases, statistical treatment is limited or impossible due to the availability of only one or few data points. A particular problem has to be solved when significant discrepancies occur between different source data. This appendix outlines the statistical procedures which were used for fundamentally different problems and explains the philosophy used in this review when statistics were inapplicable. These rules are followed consistently throughout the series of reviews within the TDB Project. Four fundamentally different cases are considered ... 

Further research is generally needed on statistical issues related to risk assessment that is based on epidemiological data. In particular, further research to develop more appropriate methods for handling model uncertainty (e.g., the Bayesian technique of model averaging (Carlin and Louis 1998)) would be useM. Further work is also needed to develop risk assessment methods for a setting like MeHg where the study population contains no trae controls. 

Where measurement accuracy is required as part of the validation then instruments used for this function should be calibrated against a specification traceable to a standard within an uncertainty appropriate to the application. If such a calibration is not feasible, an alternative method shall be used and documented. 

No experimental data point has value unless it is accompanied by an appropriate uncertainty estimate. Experimental studies that are used for the determination of stability constants of metal-ligand complexes are inevitably encumbered with uncertainties. Most methods used today for the determination of these constants (e.g. hydrolysis constants) are based on some kind of fitting of a function and its parameters to experimentally derived data points. In such determinations, several uncertainty factors must be taken into account. The two major categories are the uncertainties associated with the actual acquisition of the data points themselves in addition to uncertainties related to the fitting of the different model parameters (e.g. the hydrolysis constants). It must be noted that in this section there will not be a discussion of the uncertainties arising from the actual hydrolysis model selected. This is a conceptual uncertainty, and, as shown by, for example, Ekberg (2002), these uncertainties often dominate but are inherently difficult to quantify. 

A difficulty in using the method is that of identifying the ptoint F, where capillary condensation commences. This is usually taken as the lower closure point of the loop but as was pointed out in Section 3.5, capillary condensation can occur without hysteresis if the pores are of an appropriate shape—such as wedge-like—before the irreversible condensation responsible for the hysteresis loop sets in. The uncertainty arising from this cause is considerable, since the curve of ln(p°/p) is very steep in this region (cf. Fig. 3.28). 

The ISO guide is particularly concerned with the establishment of reference materials which contain the analyte as a small, or even trace, quantity in a complex matrix. These reference materials serve as measurement benchmarks when applying an appropriate analytical procedure for the determination of an analyte in the sample. The value attributed to the reference material is usually the mean of residts obtained from a variety of methods and laboratories. Thus, the value attributed to the substance may have a high degree of uncertainty. A particular reference material is subjected to the same procedure as the test samples so that greater confidence can be given to the results of the test samples provided that the value found for the reference material falls within the given uncertainty. 

When more than two data points are available, the graphical method is much better to use than common averaging techniques. It gives one a visual picture of the fit of the data to 3.3.55. If one has several data points and estimates of the uncertainty in each point, a weighted least squares fit of the data would be appropriate. 

Estimates of exposure levels posing minimal risk to humans (MRLs) have been made, where data were believed reliable, for the most sensitive noncancer end point for each exposure duration. MRLs include adjustments to reflect human variability and, where appropriate, the uncertainty of extrapolating from laboratory animal data to humans. Although methods have been established to derive these levels (Barnes et al. 1987 EPA 1989a), uncertainties are associated with the techniques. Furthermore, ATSDR acknowledges additional uncertainties inherent in the application of these procedures to derive less than lifetime MRLs. As an example, acute inhalation MRLs may not be protective for health effects that are delayed in development or are acquired following repeated acute insults, such as hypersensitivity reactions, asthma, or chronic bronchitis. As these kinds of health effects data become available and methods to assess levels of significant human exposure improve, these MRLs will be revised. 

---