Theoretically valid relationships

It is usual to record data in absorbance units and, although a straight line relationship is theoretically valid, the effective linear range does not usually exceed 1.0 absorbance unit and in many cases may be only up to 0.5 absorbance units. In order to increase the versatility of an instrument, some manufacturers incorporate a concentration mode in which it is possible to alter the sensitivity of the instrument and so work over various concentration ranges. If a direct read-out of concentration is used, the problem of non-linearity becomes more serious and in order to try to overcome this, some instruments incorporate a curvature correction device. 

Although a good correlation was found between the accessibility of the celluloses to a 30 A. molecule and their susceptibility to enzymatic attack, a further relationship was sought between reactivity and the surface area accessible to a molecule of a particular size. This would seem to be a more theoretically valid correlation to establish since the rate of a heterogeneous chemical reaction between molecules in solution and a solid is usually proportional to the available surface. The surface areas were calculated by incremental analysis of the accessibility curves in Figure 10, using the method discussed in the Experimental section and assuming that the surfaces in question are those associated with sheets... 

The theoretical predictions of drop deformation and breakup are limited to infinitely diluted, monodispersed Newtonian systems. However, it is possible to obtain valid relationships between processing parameters and morphology. Thus it was found that in the system PS/HDPE the viscosity ratio, blend composition, screw configuration, temperature, and screw speed significantly influence the blend morphology [Bordereau et al., 1992]. For more detail on the topic see Chapter 9, Compounding Polymer Blends, in this Handbook. 

It should be remembered, however, that a linear relationship between T and n is only valid within the limits of binary impact theory. Its restrictions have already been discussed in connection with Fig. 1.23, where the straight line drawn through zero corresponds to relation (3.46). The latter is acceptable within the whole region of the gas phase up to nearly the critical point. Therefore we used Eq. (3.46) to plot experimental data in Fig. 3.8. The coincidence of maxima in theoretical and experimental dependence Aa)i/2(r) is rather good, as it is achieved by choice of cross-section (3.44), which is the only fitting parameter of the theory. Moreover, within the whole range of the gas phase the experimental widths do not fall outside the narrow corridor of possible values established by the theory. The upper curve corresponds to strong collisions and the lower to the weak collision limit. As follows from (3.23), they differ by a factor... 

The physical meaning of the constant (3, connected with the reversal of reactivity at the temperature T = /3, is a puzzling corollary of the isokinetic relationship, noted already by older authors (26, 28) and discussed many times since (1-6, 148, 149, 151, 153, 163, 188, 212). Especially when the relative reactivity in a given series is explained in theoretically significant terms, it is hard to believe that the interpretation could lose its validity, when only temperature is changed. The question thus becomes important of whether the isokinetic temperature may in principle be experimentally accessible, or whether it is merely an extrapolation without any immediate physical meaning. 

Since its discovery (23), the isokinetic relationship has attracted the attention of theoretical chemists who attempted to give reasons for its existence or to predict its range of validity. They used quite different approaches in the framework of various theoretical disciplines. For this reason, the individual arguments cannot be discussed here, and an attempt is made only to confront the main results with the experimental evidence now available. 

Another simple approach assumes temperature-dependent AH and AS and a nonlinear dependence of log k on T (123, 124, 130). When this dependence is assumed in a particular form, a linear relation between AH and AS can arise for a given temperature interval. This condition is met, for example, when ACp = aT" (124, 213). Further theoretical derivatives of general validity have also been attempted besides the early work (20, 29-32), particularly the treatment of Riietschi (96) in the framework of statistical mechanics and of Thorn (125) in thermodynamics are to be mentioned. All of the too general derivations in their utmost consequences predict isokinetic behavior for any reaction series, and this prediction is clearly at variance with the facts. Only Riietschi s theory makes allowance for nonisokinetic behavior (96), and Thorn first attempted to define the reaction series in terms of monotonicity of AS and AH (125, 209). It follows further from pure thermodynamics that a qualitative compensation effect (not exactly a linear dependence) is to be expected either for constant volume or for constant pressure parameters in all cases, when the free energy changes only slightly (214). The reaction series would thus be defined by small differences in reactivity. However, any more definite prediction, whether the isokinetic relationship will hold or not, seems not to be feasible at present. 

Ritchie and Sager (124) distinguish three types of reaction series according to whether the Hammett equation or the isokinetic relationship is obeyed, or both. The result that the former can be commonly valid without the latter seems to be based on previous incorrect statistical methods and contradicts the theoretical conclusions. Probably both equations are much more frequently valid together than was anticipated. The last case, when the isokinetic relationship holds and the Hammett equation does not, may be quite common, of course, and has a clear meaning. Such a series meets the condition for an extrathermo-dynamic treatment when enough experimental material accumulates, it is only necessary to define a new kind of substituent constant. 

At sufficiently low strain, most polymer materials exhibit a linear viscoelastic response and, once the appropriate strain amplitude has been determined through a preliminary strain sweep test, valid frequency sweep tests can be performed. Filled mbber compounds however hardly exhibit a linear viscoelastic response when submitted to harmonic strains and the current practice consists in testing such materials at the lowest permitted strain for satisfactory reproducibility an approach that obviously provides apparent material properties, at best. From a fundamental point of view, for instance in terms of material sciences, such measurements have a limited meaning because theoretical relationships that relate material structure to properties have so far been established only in the linear viscoelastic domain. Nevertheless, experience proves that apparent test results can be well reproducible and related to a number of other viscoelastic effects, including certain processing phenomena. 

What happens is here that the floes evidently move into the thin boundary layers adjaeent to the hydraulieally smooth surfaees, where mueh of the energy is dissipated, with the result that the partieles are subjeeted to strong stresses beeause of the small volume of the boundary layers. This hypothesis is supported by the good eorrelation of the results for the smooth disc with the results for various impellers in Fig. 6 it was assumed here that in the case of the disc, the majority of the power is dissipated in the boundary-layer volume V5, and the relationship nj/e V/V5 is approximately valid. The volume of the boundary layer (Eq. (21)) was obtained by integration from the theoretical solution [65] for the thickness of the boundary layer (Eq. (21)) of a smooth disc with turbulent flow. 

The diametral compressive strength has been used to estimate the tensile strength of certain AB cements (Smith, 1968). In this test, the load is applied diametrically across a cylinder of cement. Theoretical consideration of the test geometry shows that for a perfectly brittle material the failure that occurs is tensile in character. The difficulty in applying this test to AB cements is that they are not sufficiently brittle for this to hold true. In particular, the zinc polycarboxylate and glass-ionomer cements show sufficient plastic character to make the relationship between diametral compressive and tensile strength vary between AB cements of different types like the compressive strength test, this test is valid only as a means of comparison between similar materials (Darvell, 1990). 

It should be emphasized that the specific relationship between the variables or groups that is implied in the foregoing discussion is not determined by dimensional analysis. It must be determined from theoretical or experimental analysis. Dimensional analysis gives only an appropriate set of dimensionless groups that can be used as generalized variables in these relationships. However, because of the universal generality of the dimensionless groups, any functional relationship between them that is valid in any system must also be valid in any other similar system. 

In addition, one must choose the most appropriate geometrical form for such an electrode. The most common forms for fast voltammetric techniques are the planar geometry and the spherical (or hemispherical) geometry. In this regard, we have seen (Chapter 1, Section 4.2.2) that the simplest theoretical relationships describing the kinetics of electrode processes are valid under conditions of linear diffusion (even if we have briefly discussed also radial diffusion). 

A number of empirical relationships have been published which could be used to predict partition coefficients from solubility data [19-29, 65, 72, 78-97]. Comparisons among these relationships may be confusing since different sets of compounds and different solubility terms are used. A theoretical analysis of partition coefficient with reference to aqueous solubility is important because it illustrates the thermodynamic principles underlying the partitioning process. The objective of that relationship is its utility for both predicting and validating reported values for partition coefficients. 

The applicability of Eq. (45) to a broad range of biological (i.e., toxic, geno-toxic) structure-activity relationships has been demonstrated convincingly by Hansch and associates and many others in the years since 1964 [60-62, 80, 120-122, 160, 161, 195, 204-208, 281-285, 289, 296-298]. The success of this model led to its generalization to include additional parameters in attempts to minimize residual variance in such correlations, a wide variety of physicochemical parameters and properties, structural and topological features, molecular orbital indices, and for constant but for theoretically unaccountable features, indicator or dummy variables (1 or 0) have been employed. A widespread use of Eq. (45) has provided an important stimulus for the review and extension of established scales of substituent effects, and even for the development of new ones. It should be cautioned here, however, that the general validity or indeed the need for these latter scales has not been established. 

The context in which the localization method is defined has already been explained in the introductory Section I, but although the method itself is well known the physical basis of its premises remains in many ways obscure. In particular, the concept of localization of tt electrons requires clarification, and the validity of theoretical relationships between reactivity indices of the isolated molecule and localization methods needs further discussion. In this Section we recall the original statement of the method in some detail, and then review some subsequent developments the relationship between the two methods is discussed in Section VI. 

Although the theory of polyelectrolyte dynamics reviewed here provides approximate crossover formulas for the experimentally measured diffusion coefficients, electrophoretic mobility, and viscosity, the validity of the formulas remains to be established. In spite of the success of one unifying conceptual framework to provide valid asymptotic results, in qualitative agreement with experimental facts, it is desirable to establish quantitative validity. This requires (a) gathering of experimental data on well-characterized polyelectrolyte solutions and (b) obtaining the relationships between the various transport coefficients. Such data are not currently available, and experiments of this type are out of fashion. In addition to these experimental challenges, there are many theoretical issues that need further elaboration. A few of these are the following ... 

Checks on the relationships between the axial coefficients were provided in empty tubes with laminar flow by Taylor (T2), Blackwell (B15), Bournia et al. (B19), and van Deemter, Breeder and Lauwerier (V3), and for turbulent flow by Taylor (T4) and Tichacek et al. (T8). The agreement of experiment and theory in all of these cases was satisfactory, except for the data of Boumia et al. as discussed previously, their data indicated that the simple axial-dispersed plug-flow treatment may not be valid for laminar flow of gases. Tichacek et al. found that the theoretical calculations were extremely sensitive to the velocity profile. Converse (C20), and Bischoff and Levenspiel (B14) showed that rough agreement was also obtained in packed beds. Here, of course, the theoretical calculation was very approximate because of the scatter in packed-bed velocity-profile data. 

As the definition says, a model is a description of a real phenomenon performed by means of mathematical relationships (Box and Draper, 1987). It follows that a model is not the reality itself it is just a simplified representation of reality. Chemometric models, different from the models developed within other chemical disciplines (such as theoretical chemistry and, more generally, physical chemistry), are characterized by an elevated simplicity grade and, for this reason, their validity is often limited to restricted ranges of the whole experimental domain. 

---