Theoretical decision rule

In Step 5 of the DQO process, the planning team will develop a theoretical decision rule that will enable the decision-maker to choose among alternative actions. The following activities are part of Step 5 ... 

Develop a theoretical decision rule in the form of if... then statement... 

A theoretical decision rule If a true mean concentration (p) of lead (parameter of interest) in the stockpile (scale of decision-making) is below the action level of 100 mg/kg, then the soil will be used as backfill. 

Excavated soil suspected of containing lead has been stockpiled. We may use this soil as backfill if the mean lead concentration is below the action level of lOOmg/kg. To decide if the soil is acceptable as backfill, we will sample the soil and analyze it for lead. The mean concentration of lead in soil will represent the statistical population parameter. The theoretical decision rule, the baseline and the alternative conditions, and the null and alternative hypotheses have been stated in Examples 2.1 and 2.2. The assigned probability limits are a —ft — 0.05. This means that the false acceptance error rate is 0.05. The probability of making a correct decision is 0.95 or the confidence level is 95 percent. 

The decision rule assumes that perfect information has been obtained from an unlimited number of samples and that the sample mean concentration (x) is equal to the true mean concentration (p). (The definitions of sample mean and true mean concentrations can be found in Appendix 1). The reality is that we never have perfect information and unlimited data, and that is why this decision rule is only a theoretical one. In fact, environmental project decisions are made on data that are obtained from... 

Here we can see that for AUC = 0.5, then A = 0. Equal values for negative and positive reference populations indicate a noninformative diagnostic test. Theoretically, AUC < 0.5 if A is negative. In practice, such situations are not encountered, or the decision rule is converted to obtain positive values for A. 

The performance curve presents graphically the relationship between the probability of obtaining positive results PPRy i.e. x > xLSp on the one hand and the content x within a region around the limit of discrimination xDIS on the other. For its construction there must be carried out a larger number of tests (n > 30) with samples of well-known content (as a rule realized by doped blank samples). As a result, curves such as shown in Fig. 4.10 will be obtained, where Fig. 4.10a shows the ideal shape that can only be imagined theoretically if infinitely exact decisions, corresponding to measured values characterized by an infinitely small confidence interval, exist. 

Inductive Learning (RuleMaker). Experts are best able to explain complex concepts to human apprentices implicitly by using examples of the expert s decision-making, rather than by explicitly stating fundamental theoretical principles. The apprentice quickly generalizes these example decisions to form working rules, which he applies when similar situations are encountered. 

First, Bahners does not make clear how an intention to agitate can be recognized, if not by errors of form. It is stated in the German constitution that science is free without restriction. Decisions of the German Federal Constitutional Court have stated that science is defined by formal rules alone and not by content. These decisions are in agreement with fundamental theoretical works on the nature of scientific knowledge. If Bahners thinks differently, he is anti-constitutional, anti-scientific, and anti-human rights. 

If this is not possible, for either practical or theoretical reasons, document trails are needed to show what course of action was considered, and the rationale for the decisions made. A good basic rule is always that the manufacturers should be more aware of the shortcomings of their materials or products than their customers, and should share the knowledge with the public. Product liability lawyers make it their business to care how manufacturers test for flammability to ensure that the public is adequately protected. 

There is good evidence that combinations of chemicals are able to cause significant mixture effects at doses well below NOAELs, irrespective of perceived similarity or dissimilarity of the underlying modes of action. On the basis of the available experimental evidence as well as theoretical considerations, the possibility of combination effects therefore cannot easily be ruled out. On the other hand, this possibility cannot readily be confirmed either. Knowledge about relevant exposures, in terms of the nature of active chemicals, their number, potency, and levels is essential for a proper decision on this issue. 

One of the first general rules of chemistry established theoretically within a qualitative CSA has been the HSAB principle [16, 17], which can be summarized in a short general rule among A—B reactants Hard (H) likes hard and soft (S) likes soft . The first CS rationalization of Parr and Pearson [18], based upon the Ecr expression (61), have explained the S-S part of this rule, stressing the decisive role of the covalent part of the bond (large Ncr) in interactions... 

We shall not be concerned here with the exact treatment of spectra by normal coordinate analysis 24, 29). Instead an attempt will be made to give some semiempirical rules, which will enable us to predict the correct number and types of vibrations in the infrared or Raman spectrum for a given symmetry. If the observed spectrum coincides with theoretical expectations, we can be reasonably sure that we predicted the correct symmetry. However, we cannot be absolutely certain, since one can never be sure that the number of frequencies found is not too low (or more seldom too high) for an assumed symmetry. It is not so much the correct application of the rules, but rather the interpretation of the experimental findings that is decisive. It is, therefore, in most cases involving hydrocarbon complexes, advisable and sometimes necessary to obtain additional evidence from measurements on deuterated compounds, from comparisons of the spectra of similar compounds, or from considerations of chemical facts, in order to make sure that the determination of a symmetry group is well-founded. 

---