Screening and Optimization

There are really two phases in the pursuit of protein crystals for an X-ray diffraction investigation, and these are (1) the identification of chemical, biochemical, and physical conditions that yield some crystalline material, though it may be entirely inadequate, and (2) the systematic alteration of those initial conditions by incremental amounts to obtain optimal samples for diffraction analysis. The first of these is fraught with the greater risk, as some proteins simply refuse to form crystals, and any clues as to why are elusive or absent. The latter, however, often proves to be the more demanding, time-consuming, and frustrating. 

Once some crystals, even if only microcrystals, are observed and shown to be of protein origin (and one ardently hopes for this event) then optimization begins. Every component in the solution yielding crystals must be noted and considered (buffer, salt, ions, etc.), along 

---

Micro reactors are continuous-flow devices consuming small reaction volumes and allowing defined setting of reaction parameters and fast changes. Hence they are ideal tools for process screening and optimization studies to develop solution-based chemistries. 

Wu et al. [46] used the approach of an artificial neural network and applied it to drug release from osmotic pump tablets based on several coating parameters. Gabrielsson et al. [47] applied several different multivariate methods for both screening and optimization applied to the general topic of tablet formulation they included principal component analysis and... 

Figure 11.21a shows the different sequences for the separation of a five-product system. Four simple columns are needed for this separation and there are 14 possible sequences, as shown in Figure 11.21a. If an approach is to be followed that will allow screening and optimizing networks, then 14 possible networks each with 4 columns would have to be considered, involving 56 column sizing and costing calculations. An alternative way to analyze...

High-throughput methods for catalyst screening and optimization, as described in the literature even for hydrogenations [35], are not suitable for kinetic analyses in most cases. 

Center is unique across the network in having the capability to perform NMR-based small-molecule screening and optimization. NMR-based methods are exceptionally valuable when investigating molecular targets that are not easily tractable by other methods, such as protein-protein interactions and protein targets that cannot be formatted for the classical HTS environment. 

Catalysts were tested for oxidations of carbon monoxide and toluene. The tests were carried out in a differential reactor shown in Fig. 12.7-1 and analyzed by an online gas chromatograph (HP 6890) equipped with thermal conductivity and flame ionization detectors. Gases including dry air and carbon monoxide were feed to the reactor by mass flow controllers, while the liquid reactant, toluene was delivered by a syringe pump. Thermocouple was used to monitor the catalyst temperature. Catalyst screening and optimization identified the best catalyst formulation with a conversion rate for carbon monoxide and toluene at room temperature of 1 and 0.25 mmolc g min1. Carbon monoxide and water were the only products of the reactions. 

An experimental design approach was also used in Reference 26 for the chiral analysis of amino acid derivatives. The screening and optimization schedule followed... 

The short-end injection was also used in a paper by Perrin et al. [28]. They saw a very high chiral recognition capability of highly sulfated cyclodextrins (HS-CD). Using a test set of 27 amino acid derivatives, the application of HS-a-CD, HS-fl-CD, and HS-y-CD in a 5% w/v concentration allowed the separation of 26 compounds, of which 22 had a Rs > 2. From their experiments, a screening and optimization scheme was derived (Figure 3.3), and based on this scheme, a separation strategy was defined... 

FIGURE 3.3 Screening and optimization scheme developed in Perrin et al. [28]. Other conditions Injection 0.5 psi, 3.5 s Fnsed-sihca capillary or polyacrylamide-coated capillary of 30 cm X 50 xm. (Reprinted from Perrin et al. Electrophoresis 2001, 22, 3203-3215. With permission from Wiley VCH.)... 

A strategy for the enantioseparation of basic compounds was described by SokolieP and Koller [35] and is displayed in Figure 3.7. All steps from method development till validation are included in the flow chart. Perhaps a disadvantage in this approach is that sequential screening and optimization steps are used (i.e., every factor is optimized individually). The use of the developed scheme was demonstrated for one compound, for which the method was developed, optimized, and validated. The generic applicability of this approach was not considered and is unknown. 

Most screening and optimization approaches in HPLC were defined using polysaccharide chiral stationary phases (CSP), thanks to their broad chiral recognition ability toward a large number of compounds. 

Mangelings, D., Maftouh, M., Massart, D.L., Vander Heyden, Y. Generic capillary electrochromatographic screening and optimization strategies for chiral method development. LC-GC Europe, 2006, 19, 40 7. 

Other compounds reported were conjugates with vasoactive intestinal peptide (VIP) and derivatives thereof [65, 67]. Based on VIP as the lead structure, it was shown that peptide conjugates with cyanine dyes could be prepared on solid cellulose supports to generate peptide libraries for drug screening and optimization [67]. 

Automation of non-conventional crystallization techniques for screening and optimization... 

Microbatch can be performed either manually or automatically (Chayen et ah, 1992). It is the simplest crystallization method and therefore can be easily performed in high-throughput trials. Current robots can dispense microbatch trials down to 1 nl volumes. Depending on the type of oils used to cover the trials, this technique can be harnessed for both screening and optimization experiments. 

The liquid-liquid free interface diffusion (FID) method, in which protein and precipitant solutions are carefully superimposed and left to slowly mix diffusively, was least used in the past due to handling difficulties. However, in the last 4 years the free interface technique has experienced a revival for both screening and optimization procedures. The... 

Adams N, Gans B-JD, Kozodaev D, Sanchez C, Bastiaansen CWM, Broer DJ, Schubert US (2006) High-throughput screening and optimization of photoembossed relief structures. J Comb Chem 8 184-191... 

Automated parallel experiments were carried out to rapidly screen and optimize the reaction conditions for ATRP of methyl methacrylate (MMA) [34]. A set of 108 different reactions was designed for this purpose. Different initiators and different metal salts have been used, namely ethyl-2-bromo-tTo-butyrate (EBIB), methyl bromo propionate (MBP), (1-bromo ethyl) benzene (BEB), and p-toluene sulfonyl chloride (TsCl), and CuBr, CuCl, CuSCN, FeBr2, and FeCl2, respectively. 2,2 -Bipyridine and its derivatives were used as ligands. The overall reaction scheme and the structure of the used reagents are shown in Scheme 2. 

Li, L., Mustafi, D., Fu, Q., Tereshko, V., Chen, D. L., Tice, J. D., and Ismagilov, R. F. 2006. Nanoliter microfluidic hybrid method for simultaneous screening and optimization validated with crystallization of membrane proteins. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 103 19243M8. 

---