Reaction Intermediates Determined from Kinetic Data

Reaction Intermediates Determined from Kinetic Data... 

Although the condensation of phenol with formaldehyde has been known for more than 100 years, it is only recently that the reaction could be studied in detail. Recent developments in analytical instrumentation like GC, GPC, HPLC, IR spectroscopy and NMR spectroscopy have made it possible for the intermediates involved in such reactions to be characterized and determined (1.-6). In addition, high speed computers can now be used to simulate the complicated multi-component, multi-path kinetic schemes involved in phenol-formaldehyde reactions (6-27) and optimization routines can be used in conjunction with computer-based models for phenol-formaldehyde reactions to estimate, from experimental data, reaction rates for the various processes involved. The combined use of precise analytical data and of computer-based techniques to analyze such data has been very fruitful. 

These examples illustrate the relationship between kinetic results and the determination of reaction mechanism. Kinetic results can exclude from consideration all mechanisms that require a rate law different from the observed one. It is often true, however, that related mechanisms give rise to identical predicted rate expressions. In this case, the mechanisms are kinetically equivalent, and a choice between them is not possible on the basis of kinetic data. A further limitation on the information that kinetic studies provide should also be recognized. Although the data can give the composition of the activated complex for the rate-determining step and preceding steps, it provides no information about the structure of the intermediate. Sometimes the structure can be inferred from related chemical experience, but it is never established by kinetic data alone. 

Not only were the reaction rates for bromination by bromine and by hypobromous acid very similar, but the corresponding activation energies (determined over a 20 °C range) were between 11.8 and 12.6 (for Br2) and 12.5 and 12.7 (for HOBr). Thus all this kinetic data is consistent with the rapid formation of an intermediate which is identical for both brominating reagents, and from which the slow loss of a proton subsequently occurs. 

Using time-resolved crystallographic experiments, molecular structure is eventually linked to kinetics in an elegant fashion. The experiments are of the pump-probe type. Preferentially, the reaction is initiated by an intense laser flash impinging on the crystal and the structure is probed a time delay. At, later by the x-ray pulse. Time-dependent data sets need to be measured at increasing time delays to probe the entire reaction. A time series of structure factor amplitudes, IF, , is obtained, where the measured amplitudes correspond to a vectorial sum of structure factors of all intermediate states, with time-dependent fractional occupancies of these states as coefficients in the summation. Difference electron densities are typically obtained from the time series of structure factor amplitudes using the difference Fourier approximation (Henderson and Moffatt 1971). Difference maps are correct representations of the electron density distribution. The linear relation to concentration of states is restored in these maps. To calculate difference maps, a data set is also collected in the dark as a reference. Structure factor amplitudes from the dark data set, IFqI, are subtracted from those of the time-dependent data sets, IF,I, to get difference structure factor amplitudes, AF,. Using phases from the known, precise reference model (i.e., the structure in the absence of the photoreaction, which may be determined from... 

In addition to elucidating ordered or disordered intermediate phases present during a chemical reaction, TR-XAFS data are most suitable to determine the kinetics of the reaction in the solid or the liquid phase. Figure 56 shows the extent of reduction (a) obtained from XAFS experiments during isothermal reduction of M0O3 in 5 vol% propene at 723 K, 10 vol% propene at 673 K, and 10 vol% propene at 698 K (Ressler et al., 2002). From the a trace at 673 K in 10 vol% propene, a deviation from a symmetric sigmoidal trace is evident. The acceleratory regime of the reduction at 673 K (up to a 0.3) can be described by a power rate law (a f2), whereas... 

Further research (22-24) has shown that butene oxidation can produce many selective reaction products (furan, acetaldehyde, and methyl vinyl ketone), which are not detected during butane oxidation. It cannot be assumed that the oxidation of butane and of the unsaturated reactants proceed along the same pathway. The kinetics data must be viewed with this point in mind, although butane activation is widely accepted to be the rate-determining step. The intermediates are capable of desorbing from the surface (as observed in the TAP investigations), but they do not, indicating that the further reactions occur more readily than desorption. 

The manner in which kinetic data are treated in arriving at an electrode mechanism depends primarily upon whether the technique gives a direct measure of the response of the intermediate or an indirect measure, usually the effect of the chemical reaction on the electrode response of the substrate. In the former case, the conventional way of handling the data is to compare the experimental response with theoretical data in the form of a working curve and determine the mechanism from the best fit with theoretical data. The latter case usually involves the calculation of the electrode response to a particular mechanism and then comparing some measurable quantity, for example the sweep rate dependence of the peak potential, with the theoretical value. Which type of analysis is appropriate, direct or indirect, depends upon the... 

Deductions about the structure of the transition state are based on the measured values of and 02 and hence the kinetic study involves the determination of values for 0t and 02 and this can be achieved in three ways. If the kinetic data are sufficiently precise values of 0] and 02 may be obtained by fitting eqn. (127) to the experimental values of kn/k0 in different mixtures of H20 and D20 [47, 212(b)]. An alternative method involves measurement of the value of from the fraction of deuterium found in the product (product isotope effect). This method is applicable providing the product of reaction, and all intermediates along the reaction pathway after the transition state, do not exchange the proton at position 1 with solvent. If this is the case the fraction of D found in the product will be the same as the fraction of D in the transition state at position 1. This value of 4>i when combined with the rate ratio in H20 and D20 (128) will give a value for 02 [42, 47b, 122, 212(b)]. Thirdly a value for... 

Application of data obtained from simple clean reaction systems in biological or chemical studies of heme catalysis also has its problems. Chemical model systems use chelators, model hemes, and substrate structures that are quite different from those existing in foods. Reaction sequences change with heme, substrate, solvent, and reaction conditions. Intermediates are often difficult to detect (141), and derivations of mechanisms by measuring products and product distributions downstream can lead to erroneous or incomplete conclusions. It is no surprise, then, that there remains considerable controversy over heme catalysis mechanisms. Furthermore, mechanisms determined in these defined model systems with reaction times of seconds to minutes may or may not be relevant to lipid oxidation being measured in the complex matrices of foods stored for days or weeks under conditions where phospholipids, fatty acid composition, heme state, and postmortem chemistry complicate the oxidation once it is started (142). Hence, the mechanisms outlined below should be viewed as guides rather than absolutes. More research should be focused on determining, by kinetic and product analyses, which reactions actually occur and are of practical importance in specific food systems. 

Spectroscopic methods are required for free radical intermediates. Laser induced fluorescence of hydroxyl radicals has been used successfully to determine elementary rate parameters associated with the isomerization reaction RO2 QOOH [113]. Laser perturbation of hydroxyl radical concentrations in stabilized cool-flames has been used to obtain global kinetic data for chain-branching rates at temperatures of importance to the low-temperature region [79]. These methods appear to be most suited at present to combustion studies in flow systems. There are also several studies of the relative intensity from OH radical fluorescence during oscillatory cool-flames [58,114]. 

Equations (10-6) and (10-7) show that for the intermediate case the observed rate is a function of both the rate-of-reaction constant, ic and.. the mass-transfer coefficient k. In a design problem k and k would be known, so that Eqs. (10-6) and (10-7) give the global rate in terms of Cj. Alternately, in interpreting laboratory kinetic data k would be measured. If k is known, k can be calculated from Eq. (10-7). In the event that the reaction is not first order Eqs. (10-1) and (10-2) cannot be combined easily to eliminate C. The preferred approach is to utilize the mass-transfer coefficient to evaluate Q and then apply Eq. (10-2) to determine the order of the reaction n and the numerical value of k. One example of this approach is described by Olson et al. ... 

---