Medium effects interpretation

Other reactions in which cations other than protons are catalyti-cally effective are esterification and acetal formation, catalyzed by calcium salts,277 and the bromination of ethyl cyclopentanone-2-carboxylate, catalyzed by magnesium, calcium, cupric, and nickel, but not by sodium or potassium ions.278 One interpretative difficulty, of course, is the separation of catalysis from the less specific salt effects. The boundary line between salt effects (medium effects) and salt effects (catalysis) is not sharp either in concept or experimentally. 

The kinetic solvent-isotope effects on these reactions are made up of primary and secondary kinetic isotope effects as well as a medium effect, and for either scheme it is difficult to estimate the size of these individual contributions. This means that the value of the isotope effect does not provide evidence for a choice between the two schemes (Kresge, 1973). The effect of gradual changes in solvent from an aqueous medium to 80% (v/v) Me2SO—H20 on the rate coefficient for hydroxide ion catalysed proton removal from the monoanions of several dicarboxylic acids was interpreted in terms of Scheme 6 (Jensen et al., 1966) but an equally reasonable explanation is provided by Scheme 5. 

In chemical equilibria, the energy relations between the reactants and the products are governed by thermodynamics without concerning the intermediate states or time. In chemical kinetics, the time variable is introduced and rate of change of concentration of reactants or products with respect to time is followed. The chemical kinetics is thus, concerned with the quantitative determination of rate of chemical reactions and of the factors upon which the rates depend. With the knowledge of effect of various factors, such as concentration, pressure, temperature, medium, effect of catalyst etc., on reaction rate, one can consider an interpretation of the empirical laws in terms of reaction mechanism. Let us first define the terms such as rate, rate constant, order, molecularity etc. before going into detail. 

There are problems in correctly ascribing [H+] terms in the rate law to a mechanism for the reaction. First, it must be decided whether a medium effect rather than a distinctive reaction pathway might be responsible for the variation of rate with [H ], particularly if this is a small contribution. This is an important point that we shall deal with later (Sec. 2.9.2). Secondly, even when it has been established that the pH term has a mechanistic basis, there may be an ambiguity in the interpretation of the rate law. On occasion, such ambiguity has been quite severe and has led to much discussion. 

The solvent may serve only as the medium for the reaction, or it may in addition be a reactant, as in a solvolysis reaction. It is possible that the reaction mechanism may be changed by a change in solvent (e.g., from SnI to Sn2) or that the rate-determining step of a complex reaction may be altered. All of these phenomena can be studied by examining the solvent dependence. One goal of research on medium effects is to achieve a level of understanding that will allow us to make mechanistic interpretations from such data. Handbooks of solubility parameters are valuable (Barton, 1983). 

The immediate changes in UV spectra57 exhibited by the substrates on addition of mineral acids are consistent with a rapid protonation equilibrium, S+H+ < SH+, to form the conjugated acid. In order to interpret the rate data, one must first correct the observed values of k,j, for the amount of protonated substrate. Spectrophotometric methods are widely applicable for determination of the ionization ratio, I = CSH+ /Cs, of moderately basic substrates74. For A-f-butylbenzaldoxime and 2-/-butyl-3-phenyloxaziridinc, however, the rate of the hydrolysis reaction (t /2 = 1 min) at the maximum in the profile at 24.2 °C made it impossible to measure the zero-time absorption of the substrates. However, allowing for medium effects in the absorption spectra, the substrates appeared to be essentially fully protonated in solutions of CH+ > 2 M in all three acids. 

An added nucleophile may contribute a medium ejfectwhich could complicate interpretations of rate-product correlations (Equation 2.15) to avoid this, onlylow concentrations of nucleophiles should be used (< 10 2 M). Allowances can be made (at least partially) for the medium effect of added electrolytes by conducting reactions at a constant ionic strength (I) as the concentration of a reactive anionic nucleophile such as chloride or bromide... 

Supporting evidence was later obtained from rate-product correlations for solvolyses of 2-propyl and 2-octyl sulfonates in the presence of added azide ion (Nj ). The observed rate-product correlation [47] is consistent with competing SN2 reactions ofthe covalent substrates (Scheme 2.23), rather than the trapping of a cationic intermediate by azide ion (Scheme 2.24). Although the medium effect of the added electrolyte complicates the interpretation of... 

Over the last decade, developments in high-resolution NMR techniques for solids have been extended to mercury nuclei. Solid-state NMR studies provide more definitive characterization of mercury complexes since their interpretation is not compromised by exchange processes or solvent coordination. While medium effects on spectra are not absent in the solid-state, they are generally more defined and therefore studied more readily. Furthermore, the chemical shift anisotropy, coupling constant anisotropy, and dipolar coupling constants obtained by solid-state NMR provide an additional probes into structure and bonding. Comparison of solid-state NMR spectra of structurally characterized complexes with solution-state NMR spectra promises to reveal significant differences between the solution and solid-state structures. 

The very low activation energy and frequency factor obtained for the cis-trans isomerization of 1,2-diphenylcyclopropane (Table 4) is a matter of some interest. The values were obtained for isomerization in the liquid phase, but it is unlikely that the difference can be ascribed to a medium effect. The low activation energy can be interpreted in terms of stabilization by the phenyl groups of a biradical intermediate or of an activated complex having some biradical character. 

There have been a number of studies of the reaction of diazoacetic ester in aprotic solvents, mainly with carboxylic acids (Bronsted and Bell, 1931 Hartman et al., 1946 and references cited). However, the information available hardly justifies conclusions about the mechanism. Addition of relatively basic phenols causes an acceleration in rate which can be interpreted in terms of nucleophilic catalysis of a rate-determining displacement of nitrogen, but the kinetic order in acid varies between one and two. Formally, a mixed order would result if proton loss from the diazonium ion was effected by carboxylate ions alone, while the less discriminating displacement of nitrogen involved competition between anions and unionized molecules. However, there are examples of high or mixed orders in other acid-catalysed reactions (Bronsted and Bell, 1931 Bell, 1941 1959) and in all probability large medium effects play a role. 

The main advantage of the above experimental procedure is that in Ni(C104)2 media the medium effect can be eliminated. In the case of nickel, the results are interpreted in terms of the existence of [Ni(H20)5]Cr and [NiCl(H20)5] complexes. The overall stability constant of the NiCl species (jS, = 0.37 at / = 0) is due mainly to the stability of the outer-sphere ion pair. The jS value for the inner-sphere complex was reported to be around 0.01 M . 

While the experiments with added foreign aldehyde in Table I were designed to test mechanistic possibilities, such an interpretation is complicated by the fact that these aldehydes cannot only enter into the chemistry of the ozonolysis process but may also exert a medium effect since they are considerably more polar than the pentane solvent. It is... 

General discussion of intra- and intermolecular interactions 3 van der Waals interactions 3 Coulombic interactions 5 Medium effects on conformational equilibria 5 Quantum mechanical interpretations of intramolecular interactions 7 Methods of study 8 Introduction 8 Nmr and esr spectroscopy 8 Microwave spectroscopy (MW) 12 Gas-phase electron diffraction (ED) 12 X-ray crystallographic methods 13 Circular-dichroism spectroscopy and optical rotation 14 Infrared and Raman spectroscopy 18 Supersonic molecular jet technique 20 Ultrasonic relaxation 22 Dipole moments and Kerr constants 22 Molecular mechanic calculations 23 Quantum mechanical calculations 25 Conformations with respect to rotation about sp —sp bonds 27 Carbon-carbon and carbon-silicon bonds 28 Carbon-nitrogen and carbon-phosphorus bonds 42 Carbon-oxygen and carbon-sulphur bonds 48 Conformations with respect to rotation about sp —sp bonds Alkenes and carbonyl derivatives 53 Aromatic and heteroaromatic compounds 60 Amides, thioamides and analogues 75 Conclusions 83 References 84... 

In the absence of other compelling evidence, and in light of the rather similar structural and medium effects on rate in the two ranges, the present author prefers to interpret the concentration dependence tentatively as a medium effect (possibly related to solvent activity). 

---