Supporting evidence

The phenylacetic acid derivative 469 is produced by the carbonylation of the aromatic aldehyde 468 having electron-donating groups[jl26]. The reaction proceeds at 110 C under 50-100 atm of CO with the catalytic system Pd-Ph3P-HCl. The reaction is explained by the successive dicarbonylation of the benzylic chlorides 470 and 471 formed in situ by the addition of HCl to aldehyde to form the malonate 472, followed by decarboxylation. As supporting evidence, mandelic acid is converted into phenylacetic acid under the same reaction conditions[327]. 

As supporting evidence, rapid isomerization of the ds- and maui-Tr-allylpal-ladium complexes 27 and 28 is catalyzed by Pd(Ph3P)4 in THF even at -15 C to give a 45 55 equilibrium mixture from either 27 or 28[29-31].. Actually, in the intramolecular reaction of soft nucleophiles of 29 and 30, a trans-ds mi.xttire (31 and 32) (1 1) was obtained from /raiw-allylic acetate 29. On the... 

Some supporting evidence is described in the article The Bromonium Ion in the Au gust 1963 issue of the Jour nal of Chemical Education (pp 392-395)... 

By analogy to additions of divalent carbon to the Cio aromatic framework, the molecule Cgi was expected to have the norcaradi-ene (II) or the cycloheptatriene (III) structure. Although an X-ray structure was not available, the UV-visible spectrum, NMR spectrum, and cyclic voltammetry supported the cycloheptatriene (III) structure. The researchers then calculated the relative molecular mechanics energies of II and III and found the cycloheptatriene structure stabilized by 31 kcal/mol with respect to the norcaradi-ene structure. Although the calculations do not confirm the structures, they provide additional supporting evidence. 

In Fig. 5.21, from Dawson s paper, the uptake at X for the 250°C-outgassed sample is dose to the calculated value for a monolayer of water with a (H20) = 101 A. Point X has therefore been ascribed to a close-packed monolayer of water on a hydroxylated surface of rutile. The fact that the differential entropy of adsorption relative to the liquid state (calculated from the isosteric heat of adsorption) changes sharply from negative to positive values in this region with A s 0 at X was regarded as supporting evidence. ... 

Below a temperature of Toi 260 K, the Ceo molecules completely lose two of their three degrees of rotational freedom, and the residual degree of freedom is a ratcheting rotational motion for each of the four molecules within the unit cell about a different (111) axis [43, 45, 46, 47]. The structure of solid Ceo below Tqi becomes simple cubic (space group Tji or PaS) with a lattice constant ao = 14.17A and four Ceo molecules per unit cell, as the four oriented molecules within the fee structure become inequivalent [see Fig. 2(a)] [43, 45]. Supporting evidence for the phase transition at Tqi 260 K is... 

NB Overall evaluation upgraded from 2A to 1 with supporting evidence from other data relevant to the evaluation of carcinogenicity and its mechanisms)... 

---