Experimental Methods and Analysis of Kinetic Data

Experimental Methods and Analysis of Kinetic Data Method of Least Squares Application to Specific Reactors Reactions of Complex Mechanism 

Assume in the development below that concentration (or the equivalent) data are available as a function of time. There are two analytical techniques that can be used to analyze the experimental data. These are the  

In the differentiation method, not to be confused with a differential reaction system, solutions have traditionally been obtained using graphical or equivalent means. Consider the elementary irreversible reaction 

Taking the logarithm of both sides of Equation (13.3) gives Iog(- = log kA+n log Ca 

The integration method requires that the rate equation be integrated analytically for an assumed reaction mechanism or order. The integrated rate equation compares most favorably with the experimental data then corresponds to the correct equation. Once again, consider Equation (13.1)  

---

Many computer libraries contain programs that perform the necessary statistical calculations and relieve the engineer of this burden. For discussions of the use of weighted least squares methods for the analysis of kinetic data, see Margerison s review (8) on the treatment of experimental data and the treatments of Kittrell et al. (9), and Peterson (10). 

Kinetic studies on micellar-catalyzed reactions form the backbone of this book, and a quantitative analysis of kinetic data requires knowledge of the exact value of CMC of the micellar solution under strict reaction conditions of kinetic runs. However, most kinetic studies on micellar-catalyzed reactions have used CMC values determined by the usual physical methods under experimental conditions not strictly similar to those of kinetic runs. Although it is not impossible, it is extremely difficult from a practical point of view to obtain CMC values under reaction kinetic conditions by using any of the various physicochemical methods. Broxton et al. have advanced a so-called kinetic graphical method to determine... 

Numerous reports are available [19,229-248] on the development and analysis of the different procedures of estimating the reactivity ratio from the experimental data obtained over a wide range of conversions. These procedures employ different modifications of the integrated form of the copolymerization equation. For example, intersection [19,229,231,235], (KT) [236,240], (YBR) [235], and other [242] linear least-squares procedures have been developed for the treatment of initial polymer composition data. Naturally, the application of the non-linear procedures allows one to obtain more accurate estimates of the reactivity ratios. However, majority of the calculation procedures suffers from the fact that the measurement errors of the independent variable (the monomer feed composition) are not considered. This simplification can lead in certain cases to significant errors in the estimated kinetic parameters [239]. Special methods [238, 239, 241, 247] were developed to avoid these difficulties. One of them called error-in-variables method (EVM) [239, 241, 247] seems to be the best. EVM implies a statistical approach to the general problem of estimating parameters in mathematical models when the errors in all measured variables are taken into account. Though this method requires more information than do ordinary non-linear least-squares procedures, it provides more reliable estimates of rt and r2 as well as their confidence limits. 

More recently, Albery et al. [203] carried out an improved analysis of experimental data for dilute acidic solutions which was based on an extension of McCauley and King s treatment [204] of kinetic data for the reaction of diazoacetone with water and halide ions. Albery et al. determined rate coefficients as well as product ratios, p - (moles ethyl halogenoacetate formed)/(moles ethyl glycollate formed), with the aid of UV spectrophotometric and gas—liquid chromatographic methods. In eqn. (48), the logarithms of the activity coefficient ratios were considered to be linearly dependent on the ionic strength, viz. 

From the analysis of the data in the LIPID AT database (41), more than 150 different methods and method modifications have been used to collect data related to the lipid phase transitions. Almost 90% of the data is accounted for by less than 10 methods. Differential scaiming calorimetry strongly dominates the field with two thirds of all phase transition records. From the other experimental techniques, various fluorescent methods account for 10% of the information records. X-ray diffraction, nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), Raman spectroscopy, electron spin resonance (ESR), infrared (IR) spectroscopy, and polarizing microscopy each contribute to about or less than 2-3% of the phase transition data records in the database. Especially useful in gaining insight into the mechanism and kinetics of lipid phase transitions has been time-resolved synchrotron X-ray diffraction (62,78-81). 

The modelling of gas permeation has been applied by several authors in the qualitative characterisation of porous structures of ceramic membranes [132-138]. Concerning the difficult case of gas transport analysis in microporous membranes, we have to notice the extensive works of A.B. Shelekhin et al. on glass membranes [139,14] as well as those more recent of R.S.A. de Lange et al. on sol-gel derived molecular sieve membranes [137,138]. The influence of errors in measured variables on the reliability of membrane structural parameters have been discussed in [136]. The accuracy of experimental data and the mutual relation between the resistance to gas flow of the separation layer and of the support are the limitations for the application of the permeation method. The interpretation of flux data must be further considered in heterogeneous media due to the effects of pore size distribution and pore connectivity. This can be conveniently done in terms of structure factors [5]. Furthermore the adsorption of gas is often considered as negligible in simple kinetic theories. Application of flow methods should always be critically examined with this in mind. 

Experimental data on distance dependence continue to be gathered from studies of the nonexponential kinetics observed in rigid media and a new method has recently been claimed, based on the simultaneous analysis of kinetic and ESR data. The major development in recent years, however, has been the study of unimolecular electron transfer rates in specially synthesized binuclear complexes of known structure. Early work mostly involved systems with nonrigid, or not quite rigid, bridging groups, so that some doubt remained as to the operative electron transfer distance. In recent work this limitation has been removed in... 

Analysis of tga data for thermal decomposition reactions has been the subject of a major comparative review (the ITACT project) of the application of various methods to both experimental and simulated data (34 7). The final conclusion is that isoconversional analyses tend to work fairly well and that kinetic analysis using single heating rate methods should no longer be considered acceptable (37). 

The approach used in the analysis of voltammetric data, and which has evolved over the past 50 years, is briefly surveyed in schematic form in Figure 2.16. At this point, it is deemed necessary to emphasize the importance of varying the concentration in any experiment aimed at studying the kinetics - a simple experimental rule which has often been overlooked in many years. Furthermore, as shown in the final step of the diagram in Figure 2.16, an experimentalist should always seek to reconcile conclusions from voltammetric analysis with the results obtained from independent methods. 

One of the most important branches of theoretical organic chemistry deals specifically with the determination of these parameters. It should be noted that they cannot, with rare exceptions, be determined by experimental methods. Indeed, studying of reaction kinetics and isotopic effects, analysis of various correlational relationships of the steric structure of reaction products etc. give data which allow only indirect conclusions as to the overall reaction pathway since they all are invariably based on the studies of only the initial and the final state of every elementary step of the reaction. This situation may remind one of the black box direct access to the information therein is impossible, it can be deduced only through a comparison between the input and the output data. 

In this review we put less emphasis on the physics and chemistry of surface processes, for which we refer the reader to recent reviews of adsorption-desorption kinetics which are contained in two books [2,3] with chapters by the present authors where further references to earher work can be found. These articles also discuss relevant experimental techniques employed in the study of surface kinetics and appropriate methods of data analysis. Here we give details of how to set up models under basically two different kinetic conditions, namely (/) when the adsorbate remains in quasi-equihbrium during the relevant processes, in which case nonequilibrium thermodynamics provides the needed framework, and (n) when surface nonequilibrium effects become important and nonequilibrium statistical mechanics becomes the appropriate vehicle. For both approaches we will restrict ourselves to systems for which appropriate lattice gas models can be set up. Further associated theoretical reviews are by Lombardo and Bell [4] with emphasis on Monte Carlo simulations, by Brivio and Grimley [5] on dynamics, and by Persson [6] on the lattice gas model. 

---