Detailed factorial estimates

To make a more accurate estimate, the cost factors that are compounded into the Lang factor are considered individually. The direct-cost items that are incurred in the construction of a plant, in addition to the cost of equipment are  

Equipment erection, including foundations and minor structural work. 

Ancillary buildings, offices, laboratory buildings, workshops. 

Utilities (Services), provision of plant for steam, water, air, firefighting services (if not costed separately). 

The contribution of each of these items to the total capital cost is calculated by multiplying the total purchased equipment by an appropriate factor. As with the basic Lang factor , these factors are best derived from historical cost data for similar processes. Typical values for the factors are given in several references, Happle and Jordan (1975) and Garrett (1989). Guthrie (1974), splits the costs into the material and labour portions and gives separate factors for each. In a booklet published by the Institution of Chemical Engineers, IChemE (1988), the factors are shown as a function of plant size and complexity. 

---

Hereafter we present a simpler method, used in preliminary cost estimations, known as percentage of delivered-equipment cost (Peters Timmerhaus, 1991), or detailed factorial method (Sinnott, 1993). The fundamental element is the cost of basic equipment identified at the conceptual design stage, which includes the main items as reactors, mixers, separators, heat exchangers, intermediate storage vessels, compressors, pumps, filters, centrifuges, furnaces, dryers, etc. 

In this chapter we explore factorial-based experimental designs in more detail. We will show how these designs can be used in their full factorial form how factorial designs can be taken apart into blocks to minimize the effect of (or, if desired, to estimate the effect of) an additional factor and how only a portion of the full factorial design (a fractional replicate) can be used to screen many potentially useful factors in a very small number of experiments. Finally, we will illustrate the use of a Latin square design, a special type of fractionalized design. 

This section is organized into two subsections. In the first, we will illustrate the notion of variance component estimation through an example of a nested or hierarchical data collection scheme. In the second, we will discuss some general considerations in the planning of experiments to detail the pattern of influence of factors on responses, consider so-called factorial and fractional factorial experimental designs, illustrate response surface fitting and... 

Finally it is often useful to be able estimate the experimental error (as discussed in Section 2.2.2), and one method is to perform extra replicates (typically five) in the centre. Obviously other approaches to replication are possible, but it is usual to replicate in the centre and assume that the error is the same throughout the response surface. If there are any overriding reasons to assume that heteroscedasticity of errors has an important role, replication could be performed at the star or factorial points. However, much of experimental design is based on classical statistics where there is no real detailed information about error distributions over an experimental domain, or at least obtaining such information would be unnecessarily laborious. 

Using a predictive model developed from mesothelioma data from studies of asbestos insulation workers (Peto et al. 1982), asbestos textile workers (Peto 1980), amosite factory workers (Seidman 1984), and asbestos-cement workers (Finkelstein 1983), EPA (1986a) estimated that continuous lifetime exposure to air containing 0.0001 f/mL of asbestos would result in about 2-3 cases of mesothelioma per 100,000 persons. The corresponding cumulative lifetime exposures associated with excess risks of 10 " -10 are shown in Figure 3-1. Cumulative exposure levels of 0.031, 0.0031, 0.00031, and 0.000031 f-yr/mL represent excess mesothelioma risks of 10" , 10 , 10, and 10 ", respectively. Appendix D provides further details on the derivation of these risk estimates. Currently (in 2001), EPA is in the process of reviewing their cancer risk estimates for asbestos fibers. 

The use of the first point is that it enables us to pool data for all factories within an acid group for any detailed comparison e.g., for comparisons between formdries, in some instances there are 10 pots of foundry A and 1 pot of foundry B at one factory, 1 pot of foundry A and 10 pots from foundry C at a second factory, and so on. So long as we are confined to comparisons within a factory, our estimates of foundry differences will be very inaccurate. Having proved that we can pool the data for all factories within an acid group, our comparisons will be much more useful. 

The smallest fraction of a full factorial still able to estimate the factor effects needs at least one expen ment more than the number of factors considered. Such a design is called a saturated fractional factorial design. Detailed guidelines to create a specific fractional factorial design can be found in 127.35]. The number of experiments N in... 

Operation and maintenance (O M) costs A detailed estimate has not been performed yet. Factors that could contribute to the minimization of O M costs are the following Reduced number of the operation personnel The refuelling, repair and maintenance performed at a centralized factory. 

After some experimentation, it can be determined that the basic factors are A, B, C, and D, while the dependent factor is E. The generator for this experiment can be written as E = ABCD. The complete defining relationship is then 1 = ABCDE. Based on the above analysis, it can be concluded that this is a A-fractional factorial experiment with a resolution of V, that is, 2y . It should be noted here that not all of the parameters can be estimated since they will be confounded with others. Without going into the details here, all of the zero-, first-, and second-order interactions are estimable. They will be confounded with various higher-order interactions. 

The most important details in the technology of ammonia synthesis were kept confidential until the factory in Oppau was opened publicly, thus allowing outsiders to visit. The British Nitrogen Products Committee had estimated that the cost of ammonia synthesized from its elements would be about 50% more expensive than that from calcium cyanamide. This is why calcium cyanamide factories were built during, and even after, the First World War. 

The project discusses certain details for a self-replicating limar factory to be feasible. For one, the seed of the lunar factory that would need to be transported from Earth would likely weigh one hundred tons. Additionally, not all of the machinery could be built on the Moon. Certain items, such as computer boards, would need to be brought from Earth since those parts are much too complex to manufacture on the lunar factory. These additional, externally synthesized items are similar to vitamins, which are compounds organisms need to survive but cannot usually synthesize themselves. Scientists estimated that this project would be feasible in the 21st century. 

---