Closed sequence reactions

Catalysis is a special type of closed-sequence reaction mechanism (Chapter 7). In this sense, a catalyst is a species which is involved in steps in the reaction mechanism, but which is regenerated after product formation to participate in another catalytic cycle. The nature of the catalytic cycle is illustrated in Figure 8.1 for the catalytic reaction used commercially to make propene oxide (with Mo as the catalyst), cited above. 

Using the Bodenstein steady state approximation for the intermediate enzyme substrate complexes derives reaction rate expressions for enzymatic reactions. A possible mechanism of a closed sequence reaction is ... 

Non-chain reactions are also called open sequence reactions, this adjective possibly better indicates their fundamental difference with closed sequence reactions, to which category so-called chain reactions and catalytic reactions belong, whether they are homogeneous or heterogeneous. 

Atoms and free radicals are highly reactive intermediates in the reaction mechanism and therefore play active roles. They are highly reactive because of their incomplete electron shells and are often able to react with stable molecules at ordinary temperatures. They produce new atoms and radicals that result in other reactions. As a consequence of their high reactivity, atoms and free radicals are present in reaction systems only at very low concentrations. They are often involved in reactions known as chain reactions. The reaction mechanisms involving the conversion of reactants to products can be a sequence of elementary steps. The intermediate steps disappear and only stable product molecules remain once these sequences are completed. These types of reactions are refeiTcd to as open sequence reactions because an active center is not reproduced in any other step of the sequence. There are no closed reaction cycles where a product of one elementary reaction is fed back to react with another species. Reversible reactions of the type A -i- B C -i- D are known as open sequence mechanisms. The chain reactions are classified as a closed sequence in which an active center is reproduced so that a cyclic reaction pattern is set up. In chain reaction mechanisms, one of the reaction intermediates is regenerated during one step of the reaction. This is then fed back to an earlier stage to react with other species so that a closed loop or... 

Equations 4.2.3 and 4.2.4 are the elementary reactions responsible for product formation. Each involves the formation of a chain carrying species (H- for 4.2.3 and Br- for 4.2.4) that propagates the reaction. Addition of these two relations gives the stoichiometric equation for the reaction. These two relations constitute a single closed sequence in the cycle of events making up the chain reaction. They are referred to as propagation reactions because they generate product species that maintain the continuity of the chain. 

A reaction mechanism may involve one of two types of sequence, open or closed (Wilkinson, 1980, pp. 40,176). In an open sequence, each reactive intermediate is produced in only one step and disappears in another. In a closed sequence, in addition to steps in which a reactive intermediate is initially produced and ultimately consumed, there are steps in which it is consumed and reproduced in a cyclic sequence which gives rise to a chain reaction. We give examples to illustrate these in the next sections. Catalytic reactions are a special type of closed mechanism in which the catalyst species forms reaction intermediates. The catalyst is regenerated after product formation to participate in repeated (catalytic) cycles. Catalysts can be involved in both homogeneous and heterogeneous systems (Chapter 8). 

Although all reactions showing a closed sequence could be considered to be catalytic, there is a difference between those in which the entity of the active site is preserved by a catalyst and those in which it survives for only a limited number of cycles. In the first category are the truly catalytic reactions, whereas the second comprises the chain reactions. Both types can be considered by means of the steady-state approximation, as in Christiansen s treatment. This important development dates to 1919 (reaction between hydrogen and bromine reported earlier by Bodenstein and Lind. 

Christiansen also noticed that some closed sequences would not yield an overall reaction and appropriately called such sequences cyclic. He was among the first to advance the viewpoint that the only possible stationary value for flow in such a sequence is zero and identified this with the principle of microscopic reversibility. 

In a closely related reaction the thioketene complex 106210 was reduced by sequential addition of H and H+ to give the thioketone complex 107. However, compared to the reaction of 104 the sequence of H+ and H addition is inverse. Complex 107 is coordinatively unsaturated and therefore added PPh3 rapidly (Scheme 25).109... 

If reaction by this pathway proceeds at a rate significant with respect to the uncatalysed rate such that the total rate is increased, X is a catalyst. In this sense, a catalytic reaction is a closed sequence of elementary steps similar to the propagation steps of a gas-phase chain reaction. 

A detailed study of the steps involved in the double ring-closing metathesis reaction has been carried out (Scheme 100). The sequence of reactions, selectivity, and mechanism are affected by the choice of catalyst.144... 

A feasible reaction scheme includes all the reactants and products, and it generally includes a variety of reaction intermediates. The validity of an elementary step in a reaction sequence is often assessed by noting the number of chemical bonds broken and formed. Elementary steps that involve the transformation of more than a few chemical bonds are usually thought to be unrealistic. However, the desire to formulate reaction schemes in terms of elementary processes taking place on the catalyst surface must be balanced with the need to express the reaction scheme in terms of kinetic parameters that are accessible to experimental measurement or theoretical prediction. This compromise between molecular detail and kinetic parameter estimation plays an important role in the formulation of reaction schemes for analyses. The description of a catalytic cycle requires that the reaction scheme contain a closed sequence of elementary steps. Accordingly, the overall stoichiometric reaction from reactants to products is described by the summation of the individual stoichiometric steps multiplied by the stoichiometric number of that step, ai. 

The key cis stereochemical relationship is created by an alkylation reaction that sets a tram stereochemical relationship, which is then reversed in the subsequent ringopening and closing sequence. Although this route replaced both the quinuclidine and the benzhydryl group of CP-96,345 (2), it produced a very potent NKi receptor antagonist, CP-99,994 (17). This simplified structure then served as a starting point for many variants, including clinical candidates CP-122,721 (18)5 (Pfizer) and GR-205,171 (19)6 (GSK). 

Substantial tolerance can be built up by repeated doses taken in close sequence. In 1961, Dr. Leo Hollister gave psilocybin to a subject on a daily basis for twenty-one days, starting with 1.5 rng. and increasing it to 27 mg. On the twenty-second day, the subject showed hardly any reaction to 15 mg. After a rest of several weeks, however, the same dose produced the normal degree of psychoactivity. 

For reasons evident from the figure we call the two types of sequences respectively open and closed sequences. Since 1921 the latter type of sequences has been called chain reactions (11,12), a name which should be reserved for sequences of the closed type. Sometimes it has been used also for open sequences, but as the characteristics of the two types are very different this use may cause confusion and should be abandoned. 

For the closed sequence (p. 319) the situation is totally different. Here the first intermediate Yi must be formed by a reaction which is different from those constituting the sequence, and is not used up during the reaction. On the contrary when the sequence has been gone through once, or as we may say, when one revolution of the closed sequence has been performed, it reappears and the reactions take place again in the same order as before, and so on. 

However as mentioned in a paper by Christiansen and Kramers (13) and shown experimentally, notably by Hinshelwood (14) and Semenoff (15), cases are known in which the number of intermediates is increased by one revolution of the closed sequence. In that case it is impossible to fulfil the stationarity conditions, which means that the reaction goes on with ever increasing speed, i.e., we get an explosion. Only by adding inhibitors which remove one or more of the intermediates can the reaction be turned into an ordinary smooth reaction. 

For such reasons the author would prefer the wider definition of catalysis, but the question of a suitable definition is in this case, as in many others, not only a question of principles but also one of convenience. In any case it is easily seen by reversing the argument that the mechanism of a catalytic reaction can always be represented by a closed sequence. 

The mechanism of the reaction leading to the formation of hydrogen bromide may be pictured as in Fig. 3. This represents not only the closed sequence... 

If the chains are started by the formation of one intermediate and broken by the disappearance of another, the case becomes somewhat more complicated as in Fig. 5 showing a closed (linear) sequence with two open branches. We may characterize the closed sequence by the symbol (23452). This means that the component reactions are (23), (34), (45), (52) in that not irrelevant order. 

In reaction kinetics the order of the partial reactions is relevant, and it is therefore natural to number them 1, 2, 3 . The corresponding reversed reactions may then be numbered — 1, — 2, — 3 . For a linear open or closed sequence this numbering is satisfactory, but when we come to cases of branched sequences the principle fails. In that case it becomes necessary to number substances (states), usually the intermediates, instead of reactions, which then must be characterized by a pair of numbers whose order defines the direction of the reaction. For example, if the states are 1 and 2, the transition from 1 to 2 is symbolized by 12 and the opposite by 21. 

We thus have two (one tail, one closed sequence) stoichiometrically independent reactions. The condition of stationarity may then be written... 

Let us revert to the case of linear, open or closed sequences with only one overall reaction, and let us assume that the reaction has been followed nearly to completion. It will follow from the sequel that in kinetic experiments it is always advisable to plan the experiments so that the determination of the degree or the number of advancement takes place at equidistant times even when the reaction comes near to completion, where the change is slow. 

The methods described above have been developed during a period of many years. They came as natural consequences of efforts to clear up as easily as possible the mechanisms of reactions which had more or less unorthodox kinetics. Some of the ideas are therefore old while others, for example the representation of a closed sequence by means of a screw line, are of quite recent date. The same is true also of the construction and application of the partition matrix. 

Other scientists, among them Hearon (36), have simply taken up the fundamental ideas, especially the expressions for the reciprocal velocity of linear (open or closed) sequences and used them as they stand for their special purposes or have developed them in several directions. In this connection it may be mentioned that Hammett (37) recommends the use of such expressions. As a more recent example it may also be mentioned that Sch0nheyder (38) with the same method arrived at a rather unexpected mechanism for an enzymatic reaction, the saponification of racemic i-caprylyl glycerol, by means of a certain lipase. 

Spiro-cyclobutene derivatives prepared from the intramolecular Wittig reaction of DMAD with ethyl oxo-(2-oxocycloalkyl)ethanoates yield cycloalka[6]pyrans via a thermal electrocyclic ring-opening - ring-closing sequence (Scheme 1) <03X2001 >. 

An individual molecular event such as a collision, break-up, or rearrangement is called a step. A sequence of steps is a pathway. If reactants or intermediates can react in different ways, the combination of steps is called a network, with nodes at which pathways branch. Linear portions between nodes, or between nodes and end members, are called segments. A network with parallel pathways is said to contain a loop. Catalytic or chain reactions contain closed sequences of steps in which a catalyst or chain carrier reappears after having been consumed. Such sequences are called cycles. 

---