Valence bond theory structures

Vol. 34 N.D. Epiotis, Unified Valence Bond Theory Structure Applications. VIII, 585 pages. 1983. 

Phosphine oxides, R3PO, have a P—O bond distance shorter than that for a single bond. Draw Lewis, VSEPR, and VBT (valence-bond theory) structures for these compounds. Discuss the unusually short P—O bond distance in terms of these structures. 

Oxygen is a colourless gas which condenses to a pale blue liquid, b.p. 90 K, which is markedly paramagnetic indicating the presence of unpaired electrons (p. 229). Simple valence bond theory (as used in this book) would indicate the structure... 

Structure. The straiued configuration of ethylene oxide has been a subject for bonding and molecular orbital studies. Valence bond and early molecular orbital studies have been reviewed (28). Intermediate neglect of differential overlap (INDO) and localized molecular orbital (LMO) calculations have also been performed (29—31). The LMO bond density maps show that the bond density is strongly polarized toward the oxygen atom (30). Maximum bond density hes outside of the CCO triangle, as suggested by the bent bonds of valence—bond theory (32). The H-nmr spectmm of ethylene oxide is consistent with these calculations (33). 

The examples that have been presented in this section illustrate the approach that is used to describe structure and reactivity effects within the framework of MO description of structure. In the chapters that follow, both valence bond theory and MO theory will be used in the discussion of structure and reactivity. Qualitative valence bond terminology is normally most straightforward for saturated systems. MO theory provides useful insights into conjugated systems and into effects that depend upon the symmetry of the molecules under discussion. 

D. J. Klein and N. Trinajstic, eds.. Valence Bond Theory and Chemical Structure, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1990. 

Several methods of quantitative description of molecular structure based on the concepts of valence bond theory have been developed. These methods employ orbitals similar to localized valence bond orbitals, but permitting modest delocalization. These orbitals allow many fewer structures to be considered and remove the need for incorporating many ionic structures, in agreement with chemical intuition. To date, these methods have not been as widely applied in organic chemistry as MO calculations. They have, however, been successfully applied to fundamental structural issues. For example, successful quantitative treatments of the structure and energy of benzene and its heterocyclic analogs have been developed. It remains to be seen whether computations based on DFT and modem valence bond theory will come to rival the widely used MO programs in analysis and interpretation of stmcture and reactivity. 

Both the language of valence bond theory and of molecular orbital theory are used in discussing structural effects on reactivity and mechanism. Our intent is to illustrate both approaches to interpretation. A decade has passed since the publication of the Third Edition. That decade has seen significant developments in areas covered by the text. Perhaps most noteworthy has been the application of computational methods to a much wider range of problems of structure and mechanism. We have updated the description of computational methods and have included examples throughout the text of application of computational methods to specific reactions. 

Benzene is described by valence-bond theory as a resonance hybrid of two equivalent structures. 

In Chapter 7, we used valence bond theory to explain bonding in molecules. It accounts, at least qualitatively, for the stability of the covalent bond in terms of the overlap of atomic orbitals. By invoking hybridization, valence bond theory can account for the molecular geometries predicted by electron-pair repulsion. Where Lewis structures are inadequate, as in S02, the concept of resonance allows us to explain the observed properties. 

Valence bond theory (Chapter 7) explains the fact that the three N—O bonds are identical by invoking the idea of resonance, with three contributing structures. MO theory, on the other hand, considers that the skeleton of the nitrate ion is established by the three sigma bonds while the electron pair in the pi orbital is delocalized, shared by all of the atoms in the molecule. According to MO theory, a similar interpretation applies with all of the resonance hybrids described in Chapter 7, including SO S03, and C032-. 

McWeeny, R., Proc. Roy. Soc. London) A223, 306, The valence-bond theory of molecular structure. II. Reformulation of the theory."... 

According to Lewis s approach and valence-bond theory, we should describe the bonding in 02 as having all the electrons paired. However, oxygen is a paramagnetic gas (Fig. 3.24 and Box 3.2), and paramagnetism is a property of unpaired electrons. The paramagnetism of 02 therefore contradicts both the Lewis structure and the valence-bond description of the molecule. 

Lewis s theory also fails to account for the compound diborane, B2H6, a colorless gas that bursts into flame on contact with air. The problem is that diborane has only 12 valence electrons (three from each B atom, one from each H atom) but, for a Lewis structure, it needs at least seven bonds, and therefore 14 electrons, to bind the eight atoms together Diborane is an example of an electron-deficient compound, a compound with too few valence electrons to be assigned a valid Lewis structure. Valence-bond theory can account for the structures of electron-deficient compounds in terms of resonance, but the explanation is not straightforward. 

Finally, the use of simple valence bond theory has led recently to a significant discovery concerning the nature of metals. Many years ago one of us noticed, based on an analysis of the experimental values of the saturation ferromagnetic moment per atom of the metals of the iron group and their alloys, that for a substance to have metallic properties, 0.72 orbital per atom, the metallic orbital, must be available to permit the unsynchronized resonance that confers metallic properties on a substance.34 38 Using lithium as an example, unsynchronized resonance refers to such structures as follows. 

The resonating-valence-bond theory of metals discussed in this paper differs from the older theory in making use of all nine stable outer orbitals of the transition metals, for occupancy by unshared electrons and for use in bond formation the number of valency electrons is consequently considered to be much larger for these metals than has been hitherto accepted. The metallic orbital, an extra orbital necessary for unsynchronized resonance of valence bonds, is considered to be the characteristic structural feature of a metal. It has been found possible to develop a system of metallic radii that permits a detailed discussion to be given of the observed interatomic distances of a metal in terms of its electronic structure. Some peculiar metallic structures can be understood by use of the postulate that the most simple fractional bond orders correspond to the most stable modes of resonance of bonds. The existence of Brillouin zones is compatible with the resonating-valence-bond theory, and the new metallic valencies for metals and alloys with filled-zone properties can be correlated with the electron numbers for important Brillouin polyhedra. 

The generally accepted theory of electric superconductivity of metals is based upon an assumed interaction between the conduction electrons and phonons in the crystal.1-3 The resonating-valence-bond theory, which is a theoiy of the electronic structure of metals developed about 20 years ago,4-6 provides the basis for a detailed description of the electron-phonon interaction, in relation to the atomic numbers of elements and the composition of alloys, and leads, as described below, to the conclusion that there are two classes of superconductors, crest superconductors and trough superconductors. 

The resonating-valence-bond theory of the electronic structure of metals is based upon the idea that pairs of electrons, occupying bond positions between adjacent pairs of atoms, are able to carry out unsynchronized or partially unsynchronized resonance through the crystal.4 In the course of the development of the theory a wave function was formulated describing the crystal in terms of two-electron functions in the various bond positions, with use of Bloch factors corresponding to different values of the electron-pair momentum.5 The part of the wave function corresponding to the electron pair was given as... 

The structural formulas used to represent molecules are based on valence bond theory. Double and triple bonds are just additional... 

There are several ways in which valence bond theory is superior to Lewis structures in... 

Nevertheless, even today, we often discuss the bonding of organic compounds in terms of Lewis structures and valence bond theory. 

Valence bond theory was initially the most widely accepted approach, probably because it depended on familiar concepts of mesomeric effects in conjugated systems. The theory assumed that the true wave function for the mesomeric state of a molecule is a linear sum of those of the contributing canonical forms. The technique was never successful for quantitative calculation of the absorption spectra of dyes, however, because of the difficulties encountered when introducing the numerous canonical structures necessary for computational precision. 

---