The Effects of Solvent Dynamics

Calef and Maroncelli et have published very readable reviews, the former summarizing the basic theory of coupling between electron transfer and 

Kosower and co-workers have found the photoinduced, barrierless charge separation processes of substituted polyaromatics to be controlled by solvent relaxation behavior over a large temperature range in alcohol solvents. Heitele and Michel-Beyerle reported on the complex solvent- and temperature-dependent electron transfer fluorescence quenching in some covalently linked aromatic donor-acceptor compounds in viscous solvents. These authors have attempted a critical comparison between current theoretical models and their experimental results, and the limitations of current theoretical models are discussed. 

MetaUto-Metal and Ligand-to-Ligand Charge Transfer CTntervalence Transfer) 

Piepho has treated intervalence transitions using a relatively simple three-center molecular orbital model in which vibronic coupling is introduced as a pseudo-Jahn-Teller perturbation. This could be a valuable approach, and it can probably be generalized to a great variety of problems. In this report, Piepho uses the approach to calculate intervalence transition band shapes for a range of vibronic couplings, and she discusses the vibronic criteria for valence trapped and delocalized systems. 

Zhang et have published a quantum-mechanical treatment of absorption line shapes in bridged, mixed valent dimers. This treatment allows vibronic perturbations to mix the electronic potential-energy surfaces in complexes in which the exchanging electron is completely or partially delocalized. When this three-center treatment is applied to the Creutz-Taube ion, it is consistent with complete delocalization of the odd electron and with very little mixing of the three-center electronic states in this complex. 

---

However, a very limited number of studies focused on the effect of solvent dynamics on electron transfer reactions at electrodes.Smith and Hynes" introduced the effect of electronic friction (arising from the interaction between the excited electron hole pairs in the metal electrode) and solvent friction (arising from the solvent dynamic [relaxation] effect) in the electron transfer rate at metallic electrodes. The consideration of electron-hole pair excitation in the metal without illumination by light seems unrealistic. 

Forty years after Kramers seminal paper on the effect of solvent dynamics on chemical reaction rates (Kramers, 1940), Zusman (1980) was the first to consider the effect of solvent dynamics on ET reactions, and later treatments have been provided by Friedman and Newton (1982), Calef and Wolynes (1983a, 1983b), Sumi and Marcus (1986), Marcus and Sumi (1986), Onuchic et al. (1986), Rips and Jortner (1987), Jortner and Bixon (1987) and Bixon and Jortner (1993). The response of a solvent to a change in local electric field can be characterised by a relaxation time, r. For a polar solvent, % is the longitudinal or constant charge solvent dielectric relaxation time given by, where is the usual constant field dielectric relaxation time... 

It is important to realize that not only does the solvent environment modify the equilibrium properties and the dynamics of the chemical process, it often changes the nature of the process and therefore the questions we ask about it. The principal object in a bimolecular gas phase reaction is the collision process between the molecules involved. In studying such processes we focus on the relation between the final states of the products and the initial states of the reactants, averaging over the latter when needed. Questions of interest include energy flow between different degrees of freedom, mode selectivity, and yields of different channels. Such questions could be asked also in condensed phase reactions, however, in most circumstances the associated observable cannot be directly monitored. Instead questions concerning the effect of solvent dynamics on the reaction process and the inter-relations between reaction dynamics and solvation, diffusion and heat transport become central. 

In summary, we are primarily concerned with two classes of reactions (/) bimolecular reactions with a steep chemical barrier or possibly a steric constraint to reaction, and (2) recombination reactions in which motion of the atoms in the strongly attractive well must be treated. In both instances we assume that only the strongly repulsive solute-solvent and solvent-solvent forces need to be taken into account. We present a type of kinetic theory that is capable of handling more general cases, but the two reaction classes suffice to illustrate the use of the theory without overly elaborate calculations. Our goal is a detailed treatment of the effects of solvent dynamics on the reaction. 

The pseudo-Liouville operator does couple these doublet fields to triplet fields such as 8 abs cds involving the solvent molecules. Thus one of the simplest forms for the pair kinetic equation can be obtained by explicitly including doublet and triplet fields in the generalized Langevin equation. This procedure yields a treatment of the effects of solvent dynamics on the motion of the reactive pair that is much more sophisticated than that given in the singlet kinetic equation discussed in the preceding... 

At present, we have a theory for weak coupling on the basis of first-order perturbation, and for strong coupling, on the basis of the adiabatic limit. However, the intermediate case is unexplored in particular, we do not fully know how the rate constant will behave as a function of the electronic coupling. A recent paper by Mohr and Schmickler [38] investigates this behavior, but the effects of solvent dynamics are not included in this work so that it will apply to very short timescales only. 

The coupling between electron transfer rates and solvent dynamics has also been the subject of reviews. Fleming and Wolynes have written a general overview of theoretical work and experimental observations concerning the effect of solvent dynamics on the kinetic behavior of very fast chemical processes.Weaver and McManis have reviewed their experimental investigations of the coupling between solvent frictional effects and the adiabaticity of electron transfer rates of ftw-cyclopentadienyl complexes. 

The use of computer simulations to study internal motions and thermodynamic properties is receiving increased attention. One important use of the method is to provide a more fundamental understanding of the molecular information contained in various kinds of experiments on these complex systems. In the first part of this paper we review recent work in our laboratory concerned with the use of computer simulations for the interpretation of experimental probes of molecular structure and dynamics of proteins and nucleic acids. The interplay between computer simulations and three experimental techniques is emphasized (1) nuclear magnetic resonance relaxation spectroscopy, (2) refinement of macro-molecular x-ray structures, and (3) vibrational spectroscopy. The treatment of solvent effects in biopolymer simulations is a difficult problem. It is not possible to study systematically the effect of solvent conditions, e.g. added salt concentration, on biopolymer properties by means of simulations alone. In the last part of the paper we review a more analytical approach we have developed to study polyelectrolyte properties of solvated biopolymers. The results are compared with computer simulations. 

In this volume not all stress types are treated. Various aspects have been reviewed recently by various authors e.g. The effects of oxygen on recombinant protein expression by Konz et al. [2]. The Mechanisms by which bacterial cells respond to pH was considered in a Symposium in 1999 [3] and solvent effects were reviewed by de Bont in the article Solvent-tolerant bacteria in biocatalysis [4]. Therefore, these aspects are not considered in this volume. Influence of fluid dynamical stresses on micro-organism, animal and plant cells are in center of interest in this volume. In chapter 2, H.-J. Henzler discusses the quantitative evaluation of fluid dynamical stresses in various type of reactors with different methods based on investigations performed on laboratory an pilot plant scales. S. S. Yim and A. Shamlou give a general review on the effects of fluid dynamical and mechanical stresses on micro-organisms and bio-polymers in chapter 3. G. Ketzmer describes the effects of shear stress on adherent cells in chapter 4. Finally, in chapter 5, P. Kieran considers the influence of stress on plant cells. 

We emphasize that the critical ion pair stilbene+, CA in the two photoactivation methodologies (i.e., charge-transfer activation as well as chloranil activation) is the same, and the different multiplicities of the ion pairs control only the timescale of reaction sequences.14 Moreover, based on the detailed kinetic analysis of the time-resolved absorption spectra and the effect of solvent polarity (and added salt) on photochemical efficiencies for the oxetane formation, it is readily concluded that the initially formed ion pair undergoes a slow coupling (kc - 108 s-1). Thus competition to form solvent-separated ion pairs as well as back electron transfer limits the quantum yields of oxetane production. Such ion-pair dynamics are readily modulated by choosing a solvent of low polarity for the efficient production of oxetane. Also note that a similar electron-transfer mechanism was demonstrated for the cycloaddition of a variety of diarylacetylenes with a quinone via the [D, A] complex56 (Scheme 12). 

The critical role of the ion-radical pair in the cycloaddition reactions in equation (75) is demonstrated by a careful measurement of the quantum yields as a function of the dienophile concentration and by a study of the effect of solvent and salt on the dynamics of the ion pair ANT+ , MA-. 212 However, in the reported cases, back electron transfer effectively competes with the coupling within the ion-radical pair and thus limits the quantum yields for the formation of the Diels-Alder adduct.212... 

The dynamics of carbon-halogen bond reductive cleavage in alkyl halides was studied by MP3 ab initio calculations, using pseudopotentials for the halogens and semidiffuse functions for the heavy atoms [104], The effect of solvent was treated by means of the ellipsoidal cavity dielectric continuum model. Both a concerted (i.e., a one-step) and a stepwise mechanism (in which an anion radical is formed at first) were... 

Molecular dynamics (MD) simulation has been broadly used for exploration of structure dynamics of biomolecules, protein/DNA interaction, and the effect of solvent as well as interaction between CNTs and biomolecules. 

Temperature effect on ion-radical stability and the very possibility of ion-radical organic reactions have already been discussed in the preceding chapters. Flowever, one topic of the problem deserves a special consideration, namely, the effect of solvent temperature on dynamics of IRPs. In a definite sense, IRPs are species close to CTCs. As known, the lower the medium temperature, the higher is the stability of CTCs. And what about IRPs ... 

TvaroSka, KoS r and Hricovini in this book). One way to account for the effect of solvent on conforxnation might be to represent the molecule without environmental influences, and then explicitly include the solvent or other environmental molecules in the calculation. While avoiding built-in influences of environment is a satisfying concept, it is difficult to obtain by experiment parameters that lack those influences. Several methods have been used to study solvation effects, including continuum descriptions (24) and the explicit treatment of solvent molecules in Monte Carlo and molecular dynamics simulation. 

Many questions in the analysis of solvent dynamics effects for isomer-izations in solution have arisen, such as (1) when is a frequency-dependent friction needed (2) when does a change of solvent, of pressure, or of temperature change the barrier height (i.e., the threshold energy), and (3) when is the vibrational assistance model needed, instead of one based on Eq. (1.1) or its extensions ... 

From its inception, the combined Quantum Mechanics/Molecular Mechanics (QM/MM) method [1-3] has played an important roll in the explicit modeling of solvent [4], Whereas Molecular Mechanics (MM) methods on their own are generally only able to describe the effect of solvent on classical properties, QM/MM methods allow one to examine the effect of the solvent on solute properties that require a quantum mechanical (QM) description. In most cases, the solute, sometimes together with a few solvent molecules, is treated at the QM level of theory. The solvent molecules, except for those included in the QM region, are then treated with an MM force field. The resulting potential can be explored using Monte Carlo (MC) or Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations. Besides the modeling of solvent, QM/MM methods have been particularly successful in the study of biochemical systems [5] and catalysis [6],... 

Kim BC, T Young, E Harder, RA Friesner, BJ Berne (2005) Structure and dynamics of the solvation of bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor in explicit water A comparative study of the effects of solvent and protein polarizability. J. Phys. Chem. B 109 (34) 16529-16538... 

---