Separation of substituents

The general chemical reasonableness of the results in Table 7-7 is gratifying, but this does not constitute a demonstration that the separation of substituent effects into inductive effects and resonance effects is quantitatively possible, for these effects may interact so as to be nonadditive. Ritchie and Sager express reservations about the approach in general, and other authors " have criticized results based on Eqs. (7-33) and (7-34). 

Chromatographic analysis ages G.l.c. separation of substituent, partially methylated alditol acetates On-line e.i.- or c.i.-m.s. analysis G.l.c. analysis after sequential hydrolysis, reduction, and acetylation... 

One point of debate in defining the magnitude of the captodative effect has been the separation of substituent effects on the radical itself as compared to that on the closed shell reference system. This is, as stated before, a general problem for all definitions of radical stability based on isodesmic reactions such as Eq. 1 [7,74,76], but becomes particularly important in multiply substituted cases. This problem can be approached either through estimating the substituent effects for the closed shell parents separately [77,78], or through the use of isodesmic reactions such as Eq. 5, in which only open shell species are present ... 

Hammett a values are adequate for reactions and equilibria involving separation of substituent and reaction centre by a phenylene grouping. Examination of aliphatic species necessitates a more sophisticated set of o values as transmission effects are now markedly different from the model. Resonance and inductive effects may be separated if we can use as models reactions with no resonance interactions so that a° type values may be defined. Entirely new approaches have led to the definition of an inductive scale of a parameters (O]). Although some of these parameters are now only of historic value we shall include a brief discussion of early attempts to define the a, scale. 

LEER suffer from an artificial separation of a molecule into skeleton, reaction site, and substituent. The physicochemical effects mentioned in section 3.4.1 and the methods presented in section 7.1 for their calculation consider a molecule as a... 

As mentioned previously, cellulosic phases as well as amylosic phases have also been used extensively for enantiomeric separations more recently (89,90). Most of the work ia this area has been with various derivatives of the native carbohydrate. The enantioresolving abiUties of the derivatized cellulosic and amylosic phases are reported to be very dependent on the types of substituents on the aromatic moieties that are appended onto the native carbohydrate (91). Table 3 fists some of the cellulosic and amylosic derivatives that have been used. These columns are available through Chiral Technologies, Inc. and J. T. Baker, Inc. 

The separation of Hquid crystals as the concentration of ceUulose increases above a critical value (30%) is mosdy because of the higher combinatorial entropy of mixing of the conformationaHy extended ceUulosic chains in the ordered phase. The critical concentration depends on solvent and temperature, and has been estimated from the polymer chain conformation using lattice and virial theories of nematic ordering (102—107). The side-chain substituents govern solubiHty, and if sufficiently bulky and flexible can yield a thermotropic mesophase in an accessible temperature range. AcetoxypropylceUulose [96420-45-8], prepared by acetylating HPC, was the first reported thermotropic ceUulosic (108), and numerous other heavily substituted esters and ethers of hydroxyalkyl ceUuloses also form equUibrium chiral nematic phases, even at ambient temperatures. 

It is always important to keep in mind the relative nature of substituent effects. Thus, the effect of the chlorine atoms in the case of trichloroacetic acid is primarily to stabilize the dissociated anion. The acid is more highly dissociated than in the unsubstituted case because there is a more favorable energy difference between the parent acid and the anion. It is the energy differences, not the absolute energies, that determine the equilibrium constant for ionization. As we will discuss more fully in Chapter 4, there are other mechanisms by which substituents affect the energy of reactants and products. The detailed understanding of substituent effects will require that we separate polar effects fiom these other factors. 

In general, the dissection of substituertt effects need not be limited to resonance and polar components, vdiich are of special prominence in reactions of aromatic compounds.. ny type of substituent interaction with a reaction center could be characterized by a substituent constant characteristic of the particular type of interaction and a reaction parameter indicating the sensitivity of the reaction series to that particular type of interactioa For example, it has been suggested that electronegativity and polarizability can be treated as substituent effects separate from polar and resonance effects. This gives rise to the equation... 

The existing series of substituent constants has been developed by analysis of experimental data. Separation of the various components has usually depended on correlation analysis designed to identify the contributions from various components of... 

The observed stereoehemistry of [2jc -I- 2jc] eyeloadditions is in accord with the stereochemieal predietions that ean be made on the basis of this model. For example, E-and Z-2-butene give stereoisomerie products with ethoxyketene. For monosubstituted alkenes, the substituent is vieinal and cis to the ethoxy group in the eyelobutanone product. This is exactly the stereoehemistry predicted by the model in Fig. 11.16, sinee it maximizes the separation of the alkyl and ethoxy substituents in the transition state. 

Taft began the LFER attack on steric effects as part of his separation of electronic and steric effects in aliphatic compounds, which is discussed in Section 7.3. For our present purposes we abstract from that treatment the portion relevant to aromatic substrates. Hammett p values for alkaline ester hydrolysis are in the range +2.2 to +2.8, whereas for acid ester hydrolysis p is close to zero (see Table 7-2). Taft, therefore, concluded that electronic effects of substituents are much greater in the alkaline than in the acid series and. in fact, that they are negligible in the acid series. This left the steric effect alone controlling relative reactivity in the acid series. A steric substituent constant was defined [by analogy with the definition of cr in Eq. (7-22)] by Eq. (7-43), where k is the rate constant for acid-catalyzed hydrolysis of an orr/to-substituted benzoate ester and k is the corresponding rate constant for the on/to-methyl ester note that CH3, not H, is the reference substituent. ... 

Research on the nature of substituent constants continues, with results that can bewilder the nonspecialist. The dominant approach is a statistical one, and the main goal is to dissect substituent effects into separate electronic causes. This has led to a proliferation of terms, symbols, and conclusions. A central issue is (here we change terminology somewhat from our earlier usage) to determine the balance of field and inductive effects contributing to the observed polar electronic effect. In... 

The separation of mixtures involving N-methyl-JLtetrahydropyridines into their pure components by means of gas-liquid chromatography was discussed in a report by Holik et al. (87). They found that, using tris(/3-cyanoethoxymethyl)-y-picoline as the stationary phase, the primary factors involved in the specific retention volumes of these enamines is the electronic effect of a methyl substituent and the nitrogen atom on the carbon-carbon double bond. It was observed that 1,3-dimethyl-Zl -tetrahydropyridine (141) has a smaller specific retention volume and, hence, is eluted before... 

The aforementioned conditions make an analysis of the effect of substituents in thiophene on the UV spectrum more difficult than in the benzene series. In benzene there are two widely separated areas of absorption with different intensities. In thiophene there are instead two or three absorption bands due to electronic transitions which overlap and are of similar intensity. Finally, two very low-intensity bands at 313 and 318 mja have been found in thiophene. ... 

Although many attempts have been made to separate or exclusively synthesize one isomer of an unsymmetrically substituted phthalocyanine,72-89-296,297 the product mixture has been separated in only two cases.96 103,104 Besides the chromatographic separation of the statistical product mixture it is also possible to prepare exclusively the D4h isomer by use of steric hindrance of bulky substituents, e.g. 7-ferr-butylnaphthalene-l,2-dicarbonitrile only forms the respective An isomer of the tetra(to -butyl)-substituted 1,2-NcFe by heating in hexan-l-ol.73 Recently, some 1,8,1 5,22-substituted pure isomers have also been synthesized by the use of bulky substituents in 3-substituted phthalonitriles298,299 at low temperature (see Section 2.1.4.).94... 

In contrast to phthalocyanines (tetra- or octasubstituted) in which the isoindoline units carry all the same substituents, reports of phthalocyanines with lower symmetry, which have been prepared by using two different phthalonitriles, have rarely appeared. This is due to the problems which are associated with their preparation and separation. For the preparation of unsymmetrical phthalocyanines with two different isoindoline units four methods are known the polymer support route,300 " 303 via enlargement of subphthalocyanines,304 " 308 via reaction ofl,3,3-trichloroisoindoline and isoindolinediimine309,310 and the statistical condensation followed by a separation of the products.111,311 319 Using the first two methods, only one product, formed by three identical and one other isoindoline unit, should be produced. The third method can be used to prepare a linear product with D2h symmetry formed by two identical isoindoline units. For the synthesis of the other type of unsymmetrical phthalocyanine the method of statistical condensation must be chosen. In such a condensation of two phthalonitriles the formation of six different phthalocyanines320 is possible. 

DSP treatments allow one to separate the field and mesomeric effects of substituents on chemical reactivities and physical properties (electronic and NMR spectra, etc.) of organic compounds. In Section 8.3 we will discuss heterolytic dediazoniation of substituted benzenediazonium ions. For this series of reactions the classical Hammett equation completely fails to give useful results (see Fig. 8-1), but the DSP treatment yields a good and mechanistically very meaningful correlation. 

B. The Separation of Inductive and Resonance Effects Substituent Constants from Spectroscopic Studies. 

For any given reaction series the equation is applied to meta- and para-substituents separately, and so values of p, and pR characteristic both of reaction and of substituent position are obtained. The various crR-type scales are linearly related to each other only approximately. In any given application the scale which gives the best correlations must be found65. ... 

Due to the steric requirement of these substituents the formation of a columnar structure with infinite M M interactions is inhibited, and only the association of pairs of molecular units is allowed. The Ni Ni distance is 3.21 A [164]. If the same compound is crystallized in the presence of benzimidazole, the [Ni(dmg-BF2)2]2 dimer units are sandwiched between sheets of benzimidazole molecules due to n-n interactions resulting in an increased Ni Ni separation of 3.358 A [165]. With anthracene the n-n interactions seem to be stronger, because in this case the parent dimer molecule is cleaved. Each monomer now has a conformation of type B (Fig. 32) and is sandwiched by anthracene molecules [166]. Compound 121 has the same configuration [163d]. 

Another model can be used to predict diastereoselectivity, which assumes reactant-like transition states and that the separation of the incoming group and any electronegative substituent at the a carbon is greatest. Transition state models 45 and 46 are used to predict diastereoselectivity in what is known as the Felkin Ahn model ... 

---