Open-shell species

Llacay J, Veciana J, Vidal-Gancedo J, Bourdelande J L, Gonzalez-Moreno R and Rovira C 1998 Persistent and transient open-shell species derived from Cgg-TTF cyclohexane-fused dyads J. Org. Chem. 63 5201-10... 

Before addressing head-on the problem of how to best treat orbital optimization for open-shell species, it is useful to examine how the HF equations are solved in practice in terms of the LCAO-MO process. 

Structure, Magnetic Properties and Reactivity of Open-Shell Species from Density Functional and Self-Consistent Hybrid Methods Vincenzo Barone... 

So far there have not been any restrictions on the MOs used to build the determinantal trial wave function. The Slater determinant has been written in terms of spinorbitals, eq. (3.20), being products of a spatial orbital times a spin function (a or /3). If there are no restrictions on the form of the spatial orbitals, the trial function is an Unrestricted Hartree-Fock (UHF) wave function. The term Different Orbitals for Different Spins (DODS) is also sometimes used. If the interest is in systems with an even number of electrons and a singlet type of wave function (a closed shell system), the restriction that each spatial orbital should have two electrons, one with a and one with /3 spin, is normally made. Such wave functions are known as Restricted Hartree-Fock (RHF). Open-shell systems may also be described by restricted type wave functions, where the spatial part of the doubly occupied orbitals is forced to be the same this is known as Restricted Open-shell Hartree-Fock (ROHF). For open-shell species a UHF treatment leads to well-defined orbital energies, which may be interpreted as ionization potentials. Section 3.4. For an ROHF wave function it is not possible to chose a unitary transformation which makes the matrix of Lagrange multipliers in eq. (3.40) diagonal, and orbital energies from an ROHF wave function are consequently not uniquely defined, and cannot be equated to ionization potentials by a Koopman type argument. 

For open-shell species the UHF method is used, which in some cases suffers from spin contamination. To correct for this an empirical correction based on the... 

This paper is concerned with the structures of the simplest possible adducts of the Ceo and C70 fullerenes, namely the monohydrides, CmH and C H. These open shell species or radicals may be considered as the product of the addition of one atom of hydrogen or one of its isotopes, among which we include specifically the light pseudoisotope of hydrogen known as muonium. Mu = pfe. Although Ceo//has been observed [1], the stimulus for these calculations arose from the experiments on muon implantation in solid [2,3] and C70 [4]. 

Barone, V., 1995, Structure, Magnetic Properties and Reactivities of Open-Shell Species from Density Functional and Self-Consistent Hybrid Methods , in Recent Advances in Density Functional Methods, Part I, Chong, D. P. (ed.), World Scientific, Singapore. 

Ventura, O. N., 1997, Density Functional Studies of Open-Shell Species in The Molecular Modeling e-Confer-ence (TMMeC), 1, 57, available at www.tmmec.org.uy, and online at fcindy5.ncifcrf.gov/tmmec/current/. 

Rearrangements must be involved also in radical eliminations in which the open shell species X is not present as a structural unity of M+ but has to be created prior to the eventual dissociation step. Examples of such processes are the loss of HC = O from ionized methylvinylsulfide 6- 7i) or the elimination of both OH and HC = O from the cation radical of 8S,6> (the arrows in (2) indicate the atoms of 8 which are involved in the formation of the radicals OH and HCO. Both radicals are obviously not present as structural functions in the precursor. For HCO loss from 6 no labelling work has been reported). 

Because of the inherent limitations of such semiempirical procedures, they can only be relied upon for yielding predictions for a limited set of data, the range of which includes the set of experimental data used for their parametrization. As such data are less abundant for open-shell species, such as radical ions, it is not surprising that there are examples of dramatic failures of semiempirical methods in predicting their electronic spectra, some of which will be discussed later. Ab initio methods are not burdened by these limitations but, as mentioned above, they require additional computations to account for dynamic electron correlation. 

The trapping of allyl radicals with other open-shell species can be studied in all reactions in which a sufficiently high concentration of radicals is created and in which the concentration of nonradical trapping agents is low. This prerequisite has been met in Kolbe electrolysis reactions, in which radicals are generated by one-electron oxidation of carboxylate anions. One of the simplest systems, the reaction of methyl radicals with... 

Table 4.6. Geometries and NBO descriptors 0/MH2 and MH3 metal hydrides of the third transition series of various spin multiplicities (IS + I), illustrating the correlations of metal charge (Qu) with metal hybrid d character (%d, taken as the average of a and 3 hybrids for open-shell species), bond length (Ruw) and angle (9hmh)> and average absolute deviation (Dev. = average %mh — 90" ), from idealized covalent geometry...

One point of debate in defining the magnitude of the captodative effect has been the separation of substituent effects on the radical itself as compared to that on the closed shell reference system. This is, as stated before, a general problem for all definitions of radical stability based on isodesmic reactions such as Eq. 1 [7,74,76], but becomes particularly important in multiply substituted cases. This problem can be approached either through estimating the substituent effects for the closed shell parents separately [77,78], or through the use of isodesmic reactions such as Eq. 5, in which only open shell species are present ... 

With ESR spectroscopy, open-shell species can be observed and characterized as long as their total spin differs from zero. With variable-temperature ESR spectroscopy, it is possible to deduce whether the observed multiplicity is a thermally populated excited state or is the ground state [69]. From such experiments, the T-S splittings of a variety of biscarbene and bisnitrenes have been determined. ESR spectroscopy is very sensitive to paramagnetic species, and because it does not see any singlet impurities or by-products, it is relatively easy to pick out the desired signals. At the same time, analysis of ESR spectra is not trivial and special simulations are required for their interpretation. 

Photoinduced intramolecular electron transfer in the donor-acceptor complex 87 (R = H) generates transient charge-separated open-shell species with the remarkably long lifetime of about 75 ps [89]. Dyads that contain Tt-extended tetrathiafulvalene units also form stable cationic species upon oxidation [90]. The dumbbell shaped triad 91 [91-93] (Scheme 4.13) was obtained by carrying out the reaction with the in situ generated bis-diene at room temperature, in the dark and in o-dichlorobenzene as a solvent in 50% yield. The product is thermally unstable and easily undergoes a retro-Diels-Alder reaction [91]. 

The CNDO and CNDO/S methods apply the ZDO approximation to all integrals, regardless of whether the orbitals are located on the same atom or not. In the INDO method, which was designed to improve the treatment of spin densities at nuclear centers and to handle singlet-triplet energy differences for open-shell species, exchange integrals... 

Figure 6.5. Schematic rationalization for lower energy (vis or near-IR) electronic transitions observed for open-shell species with singly occupied bonding (radical cations, left) or antibonding orbitals (radical anions, right).

A wholly different setup is required for ESR smdies of matrix isolated open-shell species, because the cavities of ESR spectrometers are too narrow to accept the standard vacuum shrouds. Therefore, these shrouds have to be fitted with a small extension mbe at the bottom into which a sapphire rod can be lowered after the gas sample mixture is deposited on that rod. This modification requires in turn a special shroud that can be raised and lowered without breaking the vacuum. Such equipment is available commercially and is described in various books and reviews on matrix isolation. 

With few exceptions, all investigations of matrix-isolated reactive intermediates are done by absorption spectroscopy, in the UV-vis and/or in the IR spectral range, or, in the case of open-shell species, by ESR. Occasionally, one also finds studies where emission or Raman scattering of reactive intermediates is probed in matrices, but these studies are few and far between, so we will focus in this section on the first group of techniques that can be easily implemented with commercially available equipment. 

In DFT, Koopmans theorem does not apply, but the eigenvalue of the highest KS orbital has been proven to be the IP if the functional is exact. Unfortunately, with the prevailing approximate functionals in use today, that eigenvalue is usually a rather poor predictor of the IP, although use of linear correction schemes can make this approximation fruitful. ASCF approaches in DFT can be successful, but it is important that the radical cation not be subject to any of the instabilities that can occasionally plague the DFT description of open-shell species. 

---