Rigorous simulation

The calculation procedures can be extended to multicomponent systems using shortcut or rigorous simulation of the column as the batch progresses6. 

The various solution methods were applied to a set of measurements taken at different reactor conditions. Table 5 gives the data used for the reconciliation. The value corresponding to the specific heat is an effective specific heat, calculated from rigorous simulations using the Phenics package, and takes into account the heat of reaction. 

Both routes have their limitations. The basic theory of complex structures, which are encountered with macromolecules, often does not allow analytic solutions. Incisive, though reasonable, approximations have to be introduced. On the other hand, rigorous simulations can be made by means of molecular dynamics, but this technique has the limitation that only rather small and fast moving objects can be treated within a reasonable time, even with the fastest computers presently available. This minute scale gives valuable information on the local structure and local dynamics, but no reliable predictions of the macro-molecular properties can be made by this technique. All other simulations have to start with some basic assumptions. These in turn are backed by results obtained from basic theories. Hence both approaches are complementary and are needed when constructing a reliable framework for macromolecules that reflects the desired relation to the materials properties. 

Later in the rigorous simulations, the dynamics of the heat exchanger are included because of the significant thermal capacitance of the metal tubes in this very large unit. 

Each potential split selected at the step 3 can be the subject of a design procedure, which can be of shortcut type or based on rigorous simulation. For some particular or innovative separators the sizing algorithm might not be available, but this fact should not hinder the procedure. It suffices that the feasibility of the task can be guaranteed by an equipment supplier, or this is put on the list of equipment for which suppliers are searched. 

Select the optimal sequence. Use rigorous simulation for the final assessment... 

Column process design proceeds stepwise. The shortcut step eliminates the least-desirable options and provides a starting point for the rigorous step. The rigorous step fine-tunes the design and completes the column optimization. This chapter addresses the shortcut step. Graphical shortcut techniques were covered in the previous chapter. Rigorous simulation is addressed in detail in the next chapter. 

Luyben et al. Q996) explored this question in detail by developing a rigorous simulation of such a process. Their results demonstrate that the proposed control structure does provide effective control for processes with fast reactor dynamics. The time constant of the separation section is about 30 minutes. The reactor time constant was reduced to 3 minutes, and control was still good. 

Group (1) in based on the tree-like model with uncorrelated circuit closing in the gel, while the theories of group (2) more or less rigorously simulate spatial correlations manifested particularly by cyclization. 

Figure 26 is a sketch of the results obtained by carrying out these rigorous simulations. (It should be noted that some of these simulations can be very difficult to converge.) For small D/F, the top product of our column is pure acetone, the most volatile species in the region of the feed. At D/F = 0, the bottoms product is, in fact, the feed. As we take more and more overhead, the bottoms product moves on a trajectory away from the feed composition in the direction opposite the pure acetone vertex, continuing either until all the acetone is removed or until the bottoms product hits a distillation boundary. If we do not hit a distillation boundary, we should continue to get pure acetone until D/F = 0.36, the fraction of the feed that is acetone. However, at D/F values... 

We use rigorous simulation to determine feasible separations using water as a solvent. For a theoretical ten-stage liquid/liquid extraction process, we find that rather little water is needed to recover virtually all methanol from the pentane. At higher solvent flowrates the water-rich extract contains more and more acetone, but it cannot produce a complete separation of acetone and pentane. Thus, we select the solvent flow at which the methanol-pentane separation is sufficiently sharp. Figure 35 gives the separation selected. 

Figure 37 shows the results from carrying out a rigorous simulation for this option. Because pentane forms azeotropes with acetone and methanol, these species appear in both products. Noting that although F31 is a much smaller stream than F21. it has similar compositions, we decide to recycle it back to the extractor feed also. The bottom product of column DI-3 consists of acetone, methanol, and water-with no pentane. 

Finally, the bottom product of the extractive distillation column, ED-4, can be separated in a simple column since it contains the nonazeotropic species methanol and water only. This column is shown is Fig. 39, again based on a rigorous simulation. 

We now need to put in the proposed recycle flows to see if the structure discovered is possible when they are present. Rigorous simulation gives the results shown in Fig. 41. It is noteworthy that, despite the complexity of the nonideal mixture behavior, it has been possible to obtain all species as highly pure single-species products using only water which is already present as the separating agent. 

Continuing the problem defined in Example 4.3, use a rigorous simulation to carry out tray sizing and estimate the required column diameter. 

Solvent-based separation through extractive distillation consists of two distillations. The first is an extraction column with two feed (Aspen Distill was used designing this column), while the second is a simple distillation column (the driving force concept was used for designing this column). The design was then verified by rigorous simulation using Aspen Plus . The residue curve map (see Fig. 3) was used... 

Keywords Bio-ethanol Purification Plant, Evolutionary Optimisation, Conceptual Design, Rigorous Simulation. 

A cost effective design for a bio-ethanol separation plant using conceptual design followed by rigorous simulation is found. The minimum in the operation costs corresponds to a minimum in the steam flow rate of the hybrid column (1600 kg/h). The minimum in steam flow rate can be only explained by the presence of the fusel component, which influences both the energy demand and feasible products of the process. Therefore, designs based on the binary system ethanol-water do not represent the system behaviour in an accurate way. 

Developing such as model is a preliminary and necessary stage in achieving real time plant optimization which involves treating data reconciliation and rigorous simulation simultaneously by means of optimization techniques, whose objective is to maximize process profitability (Perunicic et.al.,2007). 

Once a small number of reactor configurations have been short-listed based on the CFD models discussed above, more rigorous simulations and rigorous experimental verification (and calibration, if necessary) of the computational models can be undertaken. The behavior of gas-liquid dispersions is known to be very sensitive to impurities and therefore it is essential to undertake a systematic experimental program at this stage. Scale-down methodologies should be used to arrive at a suitable experimental program. These small-scale experiments are invariably carried out in... 

Product purities and productivities for all three processes have been determined by rigorous simulation. Figure 8.15 shows the dependency of the maximum achievable productivity on the purity for each concept. For low fructose purities, both four-section processes reach a maximum productivity, which is caused by the additional external recycle stream. 

For these simple processes, certain rules can be used to select a number of preferred sequences from which an optimum could be chosen. The rules are not absolute and will generally generate several options. Many factors that influence the final decision are specific to the particular process and its economics, and so on, and are not considered in the selection rules. The final selection should be based on rigorous simulation models of the chosen sequences. 

---