Relative aromaticity

The solubility of a compound is thus affected by many factors the state of the solute, the relative aromatic and aliphatic degree of the molecules, the size and shape of the molecules, the polarity of the molecule, steric effects, and the ability of some groups to participate in hydrogen bonding. In order to predict solubility accurately, all these factors correlated with solubility should be represented numerically by descriptors derived from the structure of the molecule or from experimental observations. 

The PAS is located at the rim of the aromatic gorge, on the protein s surface. It spans six AChE residues Tyr 72, Tyr 124, Glu 285 and Tip 286, on one side of the gorge entrance, and Asp 74 and Tyr 341, on its opposite side. Its core is comprised of Tip 286 and Asp 74, which accommodates many distinct ligands. BChE also has a PAS, but its relatively aromatic content and the response upon ligand-binding differ significantly from those of AChE. 

Thiophene-1-oxide and 1 -substituted thiophenium salts present reduced aromaticity.144 A variety of aromaticity criteria were used in order to assess which of the 1,1-dioxide isomers of thiophene, thiazole, isothiazole, and thiadiazole was the most delocalized (Scheme 46).145 The relative aromaticity of those molecules is determined by the proximity of the nitrogen atoms to the sulfur, which actually accounts for its ability to participate in a push-pull system with the oxygen atoms of the sulfone moiety. The relative aromaticity decreases in the series isothiazole-1,1-dioxide (97) > thiazole-1,1 -dioxide (98) > thiophene-1-dioxide (99) then, one has the series 1,2,5 -thiadiazole-1,1 -dioxide (100) > 1, 2,4-thiadiaz-ole-1,1-dioxide (101) > 1,2,3-thiadiazole-1,1 -dioxide (102) > 1,3,4-thiadiazole-l,1-dioxide (103) in the order of decreasing aromaticity. As 1,2,5-thiadiazole-1,1-dioxide (100) was not synthesized, the approximations used extrapolations of data obtained for its 3,4-dimethyl-substituted analogue 104 (Scheme 46). 

The first attempts at predicting solubility were largely empirical. Paint technologists employed various approaches. In one approach kauri-butanol values were equal to the minimum volume of test solvent that produced turbidity when added to a standard solution of kauri-copal resin in 1-butanol. The aniline point is the lowest temperature where equal volumes of aniline and the test solvent are completely miscible. Both tests are measures of the relative aromaticity of the test solvent. 

The following important conclusions can be drawn from the above results [88JST(163)173]. First, the values of [2A ]n are nearly equal for furan and pyrrole hence the correct aromaticity trend can be ascertained only if the [XAE], contributions are also taken into account. Thus, the relative aromatic character of the compounds under discussion is determined by the sum of the stabilizing effects of the two electron interactions. These are the stabilization energy AE, referring to the interaction be-... 

Subsequently, DFT methods (B3LYP functional ) were employed to compute (1) natural charges from which changes in charges are mapped out for comparison with the NMR-based conclusions, (2) GIAO-NMR to predict the chemical shifts for comparison with the experimental results, and (3) nuclear-independent chemical shift (NICS) in order to evaluate relative aromaticity in different rings. Finally, solvent effects were estimated by the polarized continuum model (PCM). In selected cases, parallel DNA-binding studies (with MCF-7 human mammary... 

Effect of Ag+ complexation on relative aromaticity in various rings was examined by NICS in two representative cases. Structures and energies of the acetyl pyrene-Ag -pyrene hetero-dimer and acetyl pyrene-Ag -acetyl pyrene homo-dimer complexes were determined with the same model. Interestingly, only sandwich complexes were formed and no stable structures in which the silver ion was not sandwiched between two PAH units could be found. 

While it is clear that 1,2,5-thiadiazoles are clearly aromatic in nature, efforts have been made to quantify the degree of aromaticity. Three detailed comparative studies of relative aromaticity in five membered heterocyclic rings have been carried out by Bird <85T1409>, Katritzky <90JPR885>, and... 

Magnetic susceptibility anisotropy has been used for the estimation of relative aromaticity of some azines in comparison with benzene (77JCS(P2)897). If the extent of ir-electron delocalization for benzene is taken as 1.0, the corresponding values for azines are pyridine 0.7, pyridazine 0.7, pyrimidine 0.5, and 1,3,5-triazine 0.3. 

All of the parent heterocycles possess some degree of aromaticity, as based upon chemical behavior such as their proclivity to undergo substitution reactions with electrophilic reagents. Quantification of the relative aromaticities of these heterocycles is less easily achieved. The wide range of potential criteria available for this purpose has been surveyed in Section 2.2.4.2. 

According to the indices, pyrazole is more aromatic than imidazole. The stability of azoles generally increases with an increasing number of aza-groups, though some exceptions are known. The relative aromaticities of triazoles and tetrazole are questionable. 2H-1,2,3-Triazole (/= 88%) which is the more stable in the gas phase reveals more bond levelling than 1//-1,2,3-triazole (1=13%). 

TT-Electron delocalization in isoxazole seems to be more effective than in oxazole however, isothiazole is less aromatic than thiazole thus it is not a general rule that 1,2-diazoles possess higher aromaticity in comparison with 1,3-diazoles. Oxygen-containing heterocycles are always less aromatic than their sulfur and nitrogen counterparts, e.g. thiazole > imidazole > > oxazole. At the same time, the relative aromaticity of S- and N-containing heterocycles can interchange (pyrazole > isothiazole > isoxazole). 

Magnetic criteria have received wide application mainly as a qualitative test for aromaticity and antiaromaticity. The values of the exaltation of diamagnetic susceptibility (in 10-6A cm-3 mol-1), and therefore aromaticity, decrease in the sequence thiazole (17.0) > pyrazole (15.5) > sydnone (14.1). The relative aromaticity of heterocycles with a similar type of heteroatom can be judged from values of the chemical shifts of ring protons. The latter reveals paramagnetic shifts when Tr-electron delocalization is weakened. For example, in the series of isomeric naphthoimidazoles aromaticity decreases in the sequence naphthof 1,2-djimidazole (8 = 7.7-8.7 ppm) > naphtho[2,3- perimidine (8 = 6.1-7.2 ppm). This sequence agrees with other estimates, in particular with energetic criteria. 

Philip X. Masciantonio All of the model compounds have aromatic structural units however, no data are available on the relative aromaticity of these model compounds. Dr. Neuworth s suggestion may be helpful in getting a better correlation of the data if aromaticity could be evaluated quantitatively for these compounds. 

A theoretical evaluation of the aromaticity of the pyrones pyromeconic acid, maltol, and ethylmaltol along with their anions and cations was carried out at several levels (Hartree-Fock, SVWN, B3LYP, and B1LYP) using the 6-311++G(d,p) basis set <2005JP0250>. The relative aromaticity of these compounds was evaluated by harmonic oscillator model of aromaticity (HOMA), nucleus-independent chemical shifts (NICSs), and /6 indexes and decreases in the order cation > neutral molecule > anion. 

How does this concept of aromaticity apply to typical heterocycles such as pyridine 5.1 and pyrrole 2.1 Pyridine can formally be derived from benzene by replacement of a CH unit by an sp2 hybridised nitrogen atom. Consequently, pyridine has a lone pair of electrons instead of a hydrogen atom. However the six 7t electrons are essentially unchanged, and the pyridine is a relatively aromatic heterocycle. 

In fact the thorny problem as to how aromatic is a particular heterocycle or series of heterocycles has been a preoccupation of physical organic chemists for some time. Bond lengths, heats of combustion, spectroscopic data, and theoretically-calculated resonance energies have all been invoked, but an absolute measure of aromaticity remains elusive. Nevertheless, trends regarding relative aromaticity will be alluded to in this text as they arise. 

While there are no extensive reports on the relative aromaticity of the heterocycles covered in this chapter, the general reactivity of these systems can be predicted based on first principles. By assuming that these fused systems are comprised of a five-membered rc-excessive heterocyclic system and a five-membered -deficient heterocyclic system, electrophilic agents are expected to react on the n-excessive subunit. Ab initio calculations on the thienothiazoles and furothiazoles predicted that electrophilic substitutions should occur exclusively on the furan or thiophene subunit with the regioselectivity being a function of the resonance-stabilization of the reactive intermediates <76KGS1202>. A priori, C-H deprotonation by a nonnucleophilic base should occur preferentially on the -deficient heterocyclic component. 

Since there are no extensive studies on the relative aromaticity of the heterocycles covered in this chapter, the relative order of aromaticity of these systems has been gleaned from disparate studies. A priori, the combined effects of the 7i-electron-deficient five-membered heterocycles annelated to a pyridine nucleus provides a series of bicyclic heterocycles with low reactivity towards electrophiles. In the presence of suitable leaving groups, they are prone to undergo nucleophilic substitution. Since these heterocycles are readily obtained from either appropriately substituted pyridines or five-membered heterocycles, methods for direct functionalization of the parent heterocycles are not frequently studied. Based on the diversity of reactions these heterocycles undergo, it can be inferred that the pyridofuroxans are the least aromatic. 

---