Radicals competition kinetic method

Competition Kinetic Method. Indirect, competition kinetic methods have become increasingly popular as the number of calibrated radical reactions has increased and the precision of the rate constants has improved.16 Any radical reaction with a known rate constant can serve as a basis reaction in a competition kinetic study. 

Onstein P, Stefan MI, Bolton JR (1999) Competition Kinetics Method for the Determination of Rate Constants for the Reaction of Hydroxyl Radicals with Organic Pollutants Using the UV/H2O2 Advanced Oxidation Technology The Rate Constants for the tert-Butyl Formate Ester and 2,4-Di-nitrophenol,/. Adv. Oxid. Technol. 4, No. 2 231-236. 

Because the H atom and the OH radical possess only small absorptions in the UV region [56], the first rate constants for their reactions with a variety of substrates were obtained by following the formation of an absorbing product or by using the competition kinetic method [60]. A prime example of the use of this method is the study of the rate of oxidation of hexacyanoferrate(II) by "OH as a function of the pH of the aqueous solution [61]. By following the formation of hexacyanoferrate(III) at 420 nm, Rabani and Matheson [61] measured the value of and found it to decrease sharply with increasing pH at pH > 12. 

Rates of radiation induced polymerizations are normally determined by dilatometric [85] or gravimetric [84] experiments. Some of the first quantitative results from cyclopentadiene [86] and a-methylstyrene [87] were obtained by competitive kinetic methods, based on the retarding effect of ammonia and amines. This approach tends to yield maximum values for Rp. More recently, however, a procedure combining stationary state kinetic and conductance measurements has been described [88, 89], and further refined [85]. Because the ions generated by 7-ray irradiation have a transient existence, the kinetic treatment leads to expressions which are very similar to those derived for homogeneous free radical polymerizations [90]. A simplified version of the kinetic scheme is as follows ... 

The radical carbonylation of alkyl and aryl radicals and the cyclization of the resulting acyl radicals onto tcrz-butyl sulfides leads to the formation of y-thiolac-tones with expulsion of the tert-butyl radical (Scheme 4-52) [89]. This process is applicable to a range of substituted 4-rerr-butylthiobutyl bromides and iodides giving moderate to excellent yields of the corresponding thiolactones. Using acyl selenide/tin hydride chemistry and competition kinetic methods, the rate constant for the cyclization was determined to be 7.5x10 s at 25 °C [89]. 

Here we plan to devote further attention to reaction intermediates. The methods used to verify the intervention of an intermediate include trapping. That is, the intermediate can be diverted from its normal course by a substance deliberately added. A new product may be isolated as a result, which may aid in the identification of the intermediate. One can also apply competition kinetics to construct a scale of relative reactivity, wherein a particular intermediate reacts with a set of substrates. Certain calibration reactions, such as free radical clocks, can be used as well to provide absolute reactivities. 

LFP-Clock Method. In this method, rate constants for the radical clock reactions are measured directly by LFP, and the clocks are used in conventional competition kinetic studies for the determination of second-order rate constants. The advantages are that the clock can be calibrated with good accuracy and precision in the solvent of interest, and light-absorbing reagents can be studied in the competition reactions. The method is especially useful when limited kinetic information is available for a class of radicals. 

The rate constants for reaction of Bu3SnH with the primary a-alkoxy radical 24 and the secondary ce-alkoxy radical 29 are in reasonably good agreement. However, one would not expect the primary radical to react less rapidly than the secondary radical. The kinetic ESR method used to calibrate 24 involved a competition method wherein the cyclization reactions competed with diffusion-controlled radical termination reactions, and diffusional rate constants were determined to obtain the absolute rate constants for the clock reactions.88 The LFP calibrations of radical clocks... 

The kinetic data reported in this chapter have been determined either by direct measurements, using for example kinetic EPR spectroscopy and laser flash photolysis techniques or by competitive kinetics like the radical clock methodology (see below). The method for each given rate constant will be indicated as well as the solvent used. An extensive compilation of the kinetics of reaction of Group 14 hydrides (RsSiH, RsGeH and RsSnH) with radicals is available [1]. 

The PTOC carbamate method for efficient and controlled generation of aminyl radicals allows kinetic studies that previously were not possible with tetrazene precursors. As is the case with carbon radicals, optimum synthetic utility of chain reaction sequences is found when absolute rate constants or ratios of rate constants for competing reactions are known, i.e., Scheme 8, step D vs step E. If an absolute rate constant is known for one reaction, then other absolute rate constants can be determined for other reactions from the product distributions in competitions of the reactions of interest with the reaction with a known rate constant. 

Since the crocin-bleaching method is based on competition kinetics, it can also be used to detect pro-oxidant activity (POA), for example, of early MRPs the DPPH method cannot. In fact, in the presence of antioxidants, the crocin-bleaching rate [reaction (1)] is slowed down, because the antioxidant reacts with the radical first and the antioxidant radical formed [reaction (2)] reacts only slowly with the crocin [reaction (3) ]. On the contrary, the pro-oxidant competes with the radical for the crocin [reaction (4)], thus increasing the extent of crocin bleaching 446... 

Some reactions are difficult to study directly because the required instrumentation is not available or the changes in standard physical properties (light absorption, conductivity etc.) typically used in kinetic measurements are too small to be useful. Competition kinetics can provide important information in such cases. In some situations, the chemistry itself makes direct measurement inconvenient or even impossible. This is the case, for example, in studies of slow reactions of free radicals. Because of the ever-present radical-depleting second-order decomposition reactions, slow reactions of free radicals with added substrates are possible only at very low, steady-state radical concentrations. The standard methods of radical generation (pulse radiolysis and flash photolysis) are not useful in such cases, because they require micromolar levels of radicals for a measurable signal. The self-reactions usually have k > 10 M s , so that the competing reactions must have a pseudo-first-order rate constant of lO s or higher (or equivalent, if conditions are not pseudo-first order) to be observed. Competition experiments, on the other hand, can handle much lower rate constants, as described later for some reactions of C(CH3)20H radicals with transition metal complexes. 

The evolution of kinetic scales has been highly dependent on radical clock and, more generally, indirect competition kinetic studies [6], These types of studies provide ratios of rate constants as discussed above. One can build an extensive series of relative rate constants for unimolecular clocks and bimolecular reactions, and the relative rate constants often are determined with very good to excellent precision. At some point, however, absolute rate constants are necessary to provide real values for the entire kinetic scale. These absolute kinetic values are the major source of error in the kinetics, but the absolute values are becoming more precise and, one certainly hopes, more accurate as increasingly refined techniques are introduced and multiple methods are applied in studies of specific reactions. 

The availability of radical clocks for -hybridized carbon systems has been limited by the high reactivity of phenyl and vinyl radicals and by the lack of appropriate methods for preparation of these radicals for direct kinetic studies. Competition kinetic studies have given relative rate constants for some radical clocks in this group, but absolute rate constants for the radical-trapping reactions used in the competitions are not generally available. In that regard, one should note that reported rate constants for reactions of BuySnH with the phenyl and 2,2-dimethylvinyl radicals [29] were later vitiated when it was found that these radicals had not been produced cleanly. 

Rate constants for some alkoxyl radical fragmentations are shown in Fig. 9. The tcrt-butoxyl radical (26) fragmentation to acetone and the methyl radical has been studied for years, but the rate constant shown below is from a very recent work that employed time-resolved ESR methods [2]. The cumyloxyl radical (27) fragmentation was studied directly by LFP methods, taking advantage of the IR and UV absorbances of this radical [57]. The rate constants for the reversible ring opening of the cyclopentyloxyl radical (28) were determined by competition kinetics [58], and one should note that the kinetic values are at 80 °C. 

The transient character of unstable species is intrinsically because of at least one fast reaction which they undergo as soon as they are formed (for example coalescence reaction in the case of atoms and clusters). This reaction therefore induces competition with any redox reaction which could be regarded as determining the redox potential of a transient entity. In particular, the competition does not enable the establishment of a reversible equilibrium of electron transfer with another suitable system. Thus, the redox potential of short-hved species must be evaluated from kinetic methods - the pulse technique enables us to observe whether or not electron transfer involving the transient species and a series of donor/acceptor couples, used as monitors, is elfective, and thus to establish by a bracketing method the value of the imknown redox potential. Only elementary monoelectronic transfers are considered. Thus, note that one of the forms of the reference couple, reduced or oxidized, can also be a transient radical. 

A number of alkene radical cations have been generated in matrices at low temperature and have also been studied by ESR, CIDNP, and electrochemical methods. However, until recently very little absolute kinetic data have been available for the reactions of these important reactive intermediates in solution under conditions comparable to those used in mechanistic or synthetic studies. In a few cases, competitive kinetic techniques have been used to estimate rates for nucleophilic additions or radical cation/alkene cycloaddition reactions. In addition, pulse radiolysis has been used to provide rate constants for some of the radical cation chemistry relevant to the pho-topolymerization of styrenes. More recently, wc and others have used laser flash photolysis to generate and characterize a variety of alkene radical cations. This method has been extensively applied to the study of other reactive intermediates such as radicals, carbenes, and carbenium ions and is particularly well-suited for kinetic measurements of species that have lifetimes in the tens of nanoseconds range and up and that have at least moderate extinction coeffleients in the UV-visible region. 

Newcomb M. Competition methods and scales for alkyl radical reaction kinetics. Tetrahedron. 1993 49 1151-1176. 

The CL methods can be applied with very good results for the analysis of lipid peroxides in food quality assessment and also to measure the ability of the natural or synthetic food antioxidants to quench free radicals in foods. For antioxidant capacity determination of foods, the measurements are based on competitive kinetics, in which the antioxidants compete with a CL reagent for the free radicals, resulting in a decrease in the light emission compared with the CL intensity obtained in the absence of the antioxidants. 

Structure-reactivity relationships can be probed by measurements of rates and equiUbria, as was diseussed in Chapter 4. Direct comparison of reaction rates is used relatively less often in the study of radical reactions than for heterolytic reactions. Instead, competition methods have frequently been used. The basis of competition methods lies in the rate expression for a reaction, and the results can be just as valid a comparison of relative reactivity as directly measured rates, provided the two competing processes are of the same kinetic order. Suppose that it is desired to compare the reactivity of two related compounds, B—X and B—Y, in a hypothetical sequence ... 

In principle, EPR spectrometry is well suited as a method to monitor kinetic events however, in practice, the time required to tune the spectrometer, and its intrinsically low sensitivity compared to fluorescence or light-absorption spectrometry, affect its competitiveness. Relatively slow reactions on the timescale of minutes, such as the decomposition of the DMPO-superoxide adduct and the subsequent formation of the hydroxyl radical adduct (cf. Pou et al. 1989) are readily followed, either as the first-order disappearance of the DMPO/ OOH signal... 

The orbital coefficients obtained from Hiickel calculations predict the terminal position to be the most reactive one, while the AMI model predicts the Cl and C3 positions to be competitive. In polyenes, this is true for the addition of nucleophilic as well as electrophilic radicals, as HOMO and LUMO coefficients are basically identical. Both theoretical methods agree, however, in predicting the Cl position to be considerably more reactive as compared to the C2 position. It must be remembered in this context that FMO-based reactivity predictions are only relevant in kinetically controlled reactions. Under thermodynamic control, the most stable adduct will be formed which, for the case of polyenyl radicals, will most likely be the radical obtained by addition to the C1 position. 

The kinetic data for these reactions are numerous, as shown in Table VI. Most of values were obtained by radical clock methods. The ring expansion of radical 7 has been employed as the clock in a study that provided much of the data in Table VI.74 Cyclizations of 5-hexenyl-type radicals also have been used as clocks,75-77 and other competition reactions have been used.78 Hydrogen atom abstraction from n-Bu3GeH by primary alkyl radicals containing a trimethylsilyl group in the a-, >8-, or y-position were obtained by the indirect method in competition with alkyl radical recombi-... 

Several reactions of halogen-substituted carbon-centered radicals with silanes have been studied, but limited kinetic information is available for reactions of halogen-substituted radicals with tin hydrides. A rate constant for reaction of the perfluorooctyl radical with Bu3SnH was determined by competition against addition of this radical to styrenes, reactions that were calibrated directly by LFP methods.93 At ambient temperature, the n-C8F17 radical reacts with tin hydride two orders of magnitude faster than does an alkyl radical, consistent with the electron-deficient nature of the perflu-oroalkyl radical and the electron-rich character of the tin hydride. Similar behavior was noted previously for reactions of silanes with perhaloalkyl radicals. 

---