Process development analyses

Realistically, the information available to perform risk studies varies over the lifetime of a process. During the early stages of process development, analysis teams may only have access to basic chemical reactivity hazard data, such as may be obtained from suppliers and literature resources. By the time a facility reaches the detailed design phase, most of the basic design and operating information should be available and used in any study of the facility hazards and risks. 

For process development, analysis tends to be exhaustive, since the optimal commercial synthesis often is different from the "best" laboratory method. When a cheap related compound is available, the analysis may be of the SM P type. 

This means an acquisition rate of 64 channels simultaneously, and 128 data channels as 2 frequencies are used. The acquisition speed is 140 points per second for each channel, meaning practically 6 to 12 points per rod mm. Since the method was developed 10 years ago, the processing and analysis time of this amount of information (20 Mbytes average) was long and difficult. 

The principal problem in using fault trees is that for reasonably compHcated processes the analysis is most likely to produce a huge fault tree. Eault trees involving hundreds or even thousands of intermediate events are not uncommon. The effort involved in fault tree development can also be substantial, requiring several years. 

Based on the bench-scale data, two coal-to-acetylene processes were taken to the pilot-plant level. These were the AVCO and Hbls arc-coal processes. The Avco process development centered on identifying fundamental process relationships (29). Preliminary data analysis was simplified by first combining two of three independent variables, power and gas flow, into a single enthalpy term. The variation of the important criteria, specific energy requirements (SER), concentration, and yield with enthalpy are indicated in Figure 12. As the plots show, minimum SER is achieved at an enthalpy of about 5300 kW/(m /s) (2.5 kW/cfm), whereas maximum acetylene concentrations and yield are obtained at about 7400 kW/(m /s) (3.5 kW/cfm). An operating enthalpy between these two values should, therefore, be optimum. Based on the results of this work and the need to demonstrate the process at... 

Whereas no quantitative consequence analysis is required by this legislation, the process ha2ards analysis must include a quaHtative evaluation of the possible effects of failure of controls on employees. Details concerning development and implementation of programs for these subjects are available (37-39). 

Eault tree analysis (ETA) is a widely used computer-aided tool for plant and process safety analysis (69). One of the primary strengths of the method is the systematic, logical development of the many contributing factors that might result ia an accident. This type of analysis requires that the analyst have a complete understanding of the system and plant operations and the various equipment failure modes. 

The problem is defined during process development as information becomes available and decisions are made. Initially, the definition is limited, vague, and brief and economic analysis involves a high level of uncertainty. As the project evolves, the definition becomes more complete, more highly specific, and lengthier. At the same time, the economic assessment tends to exhibit less uncertainty. 

Any pre-existing process hazards analysis from the pilot development or other tolling efforts... 

This type of chromatographic development will only be briefly described as it is rarely used and probably is of academic interest only. This method of development can only be effectively employed in a column distribution system. The sample is fed continuously onto the column, usually as a dilute solution in the mobile phase. This is in contrast to displacement development and elution development, where discrete samples are placed on the system and the separation is subsequently processed. Frontal analysis only separates part of the first compound in a relatively pure state, each subsequent component being mixed with those previously eluted. Consider a three component mixture, containing solutes (A), (B) and (C) as a dilute solution in the mobile phase that is fed continuously onto a column. The first component to elute, (A), will be that solute held least strongly in the stationary phase. Then the... 

Trade secrets may be used in developing the information for the process hazard analysis emergency planning and responses, and compliance audits. Materials that are developed involving trade secrets may be treated as proprietary and may require signed statements for tl protection. 

Every chromatographic investigation begins with the preparation of the sample and the chromatographic system. This is followed by the crux of the separation process (development of the chromatogram) which is in turn followed by the visualization of the separated substances and the preservation of the chromatogram and finally by the analysis of the results. 

Fault Tree Analysis Report for CoaF Coal Gasitication Failure rales (per year basts) for over 400 events Coal-gasification Process Development unit 50. 

Fault Tree Analysis Report for Coal-Gasification Process-Development... 

In this study detailed fault trees with probability and failure rate calculations were generated for the events (1) Fatality due to Explosion, Fire, Toxic Release or Asphyxiation at the Process Development Unit (PDU) Coal Gasification Process and (2) Loss of Availability of the PDU. The fault trees for the PDU were synthesized by Design Sciences, Inc., and then subjected to multiple reviews by Combustion Engineering. The steps involved in hazard identification and evaluation, fault tree generation, probability assessment, and design alteration are presented in the main body of this report. The fault trees, cut sets, failure rate data and unavailability calculations are included as attachments to this report. Although both safety and reliability trees have been constructed for the PDU, the verification and analysis of these trees were not completed as a result of the curtailment of the demonstration plant project. Certain items not completed for the PDU risk and reliability assessment are listed. 

Although the source of raw materials may not be at the plant site, it is an e.xtremcly important factor in the ultimate location of the plant. Process development work and economic studies will indicate the minimum standards for raw materials selection. When these standards have been determined, all possible sources of acceptable raw materials can be located and a detailed analysis can proceed. 

The steps in developing such a database are (1) collection of machine and process data and (2) database setup. Input requirements of the software are machine and process specifications, analysis parameters, data filters, alert/alarm limits, and a variety of other parameters used to automate the data-acquisition process. 

According to Cano-Ruiz and McRae, process design as a part of process development starts with problem framing. At this stage, the concept definition, scope of analysis, design objectives, constraints, evaluation and interruption criteria have to be determined. They argued that framing decisions are often made implicitly, whereas the critical importance... 

Calculations of economic profitability can only be predictive in the phase of process development, before a plant is on stream for a long time. Therefore, individual components of costs and market evaluations will bear some uncertainty. This uncertainty is relatively high for pharmaceuticals and agrochemicals. The impact of these uncertainties on the profitability of a process may be quantified by a sensitivity analysis. This analysis provides information about the sensitivity of the process economics to changes in parameters relevant for the profitability (investment costs, price and consumption of raw materials, utility unit costs, product value and demand, etc.), and therefore on the reliability of the result of the economic evaluation. In the early stages of process development, a high sensitivity indicates the areas requiring attention for continued R D work. 

---