Flowsheeting, steady state

Products. The results of design processes such as process flowsheets, steady-state and dynamic simulations, etc. are represented by documents (ellipses). Documents are interdependent, e.g., a simulation model depends on the process flowsheet (PFD) to which it refers (arrows between ellipses). 

A systematic approach based on flowsheeting, steady state and dynamic, can be applied in view of eco-balances of impurities and hazards substances, both at the level of plants and industrial sites. Methods for assessing environmental performances of processes are desirable. Some new sustainability measures are discussed at the end of this chapter. 

With a one-product reaction system without inerts, the column has only a bottoms product because product component C is heavier than reactant components A and B. Figure 12.1 shows the flowsheet. Steady-state conditions and design parameters are given in Table 12.1. The steady state is the base case considered in Chapter 5. Figures 12.2 and 12.3 give composition and temperature profiles, respectively. 

Classification Process simulation refers to the activity in which mathematical models of chemical processes and refineries are modeled with equations, usually on the computer. The usual distinction must be made between steady-state models and transient models, following the ideas presented in the introduction to this sec tion. In a chemical process, of course, the process is nearly always in a transient mode, at some level of precision, but when the time-dependent fluctuations are below some value, a steady-state model can be formulated. This subsection presents briefly the ideas behind steady-state process simulation (also called flowsheeting), which are embodied in commercial codes. The transient simulations are important for designing startup of plants and are especially useful for the operating of chemical plants. 

Although, as explained in Chapter 9, many optimization problems can be naturally formulated as mixed-integer programming problems, in this chapter we will consider only steady-state nonlinear programming problems in which the variables are continuous. In some cases it may be feasible to use binary variables (on-off) to include or exclude specific stream flows, alternative flowsheet topography, or different parameters. In the economic evaluation of processes, in design, or in control, usually only a few (5-50) variables are decision, or independent, variables amid a multitude of dependent variables (hundreds or thousands). The number of dependent variables in principle (but not necessarily in practice) is equivalent to the number of independent equality constraints plus the active inequality constraints in a process. The number of independent (decision) variables comprises the remaining set of variables whose values are unknown. Introduction into the model of a specification of the value of a variable, such as T = 400°C, is equivalent to the solution of an independent equation and reduces the total number of variables whose values are unknown by one. 

Mahalec, V. H. Kluzik and L. B. Evans. Simultaneous Modular Algorithm for Steady State Flowsheet Simulation and Design. Paper presented at the 12th European Symposium on Computers in Chemical Engineering. Montreaux, Switzerland (1979). 

Steady-state process variables are related by mass and energy conservation laws. Although, for reasons of cost, convenience, or technical feasibility, not every variable is measured, some of them can be estimated using other measurements through balance calculations. Unmeasured variable estimation depends on the structure of the process flowsheet and on the instrument placement. Typically, there is an incomplete set of instruments thus, unmeasured variables are divided into determinable or estimable and indeterminable or inestimable. An unmeasured variable is determinable, or estimable, if its value can be calculated using measurements. Measurements are classified into redundant and nonredundant. A measurement is redundant if it remains determinable when the observation is deleted. 

Steady-state process simulation or process flowsheeting has become a routine activity for process analysis and design. Such systems allow the development of comprehensive, detailed, and complex process models with relatively little effort. Embedded within these simulators are rigorous unit operations models often derived from first principles, extensive physical property models for the accurate description of a wide variety of chemical systems, and powerful algorithms for the solution of large, nonlinear systems of equations. 

We first considered applications of this approach within process engineering. Steady-state flowsheeting or simulation tools are the workhorse for most process design studies the application of simultaneous optimization strategies has allowed optimization of these designs to be performed within an order of magnitude of the effort required for the simulation problem. An application of this strategy to an ammonia synthesis process was presented. Currently, flowsheet optimization is widely available commercially and has also been installed on the FLOWTRAN simulator for academic use. 

Benedek (Ed.), Steady State Flowsheeting of Chemical Plants, Elsevier, New York, 1980. 

As organic and aqueous phases are macroscopically separated by the membrane, HFM offer several hydrodynamic advantages over other contactors, such as the absence of flooding and entrainment, or the reduction of feed consumption (160, 161). The flowsheets tested in HFM were similar to those developed for centrifugal contactor tests. Computer codes based on equilibrium (162) and kinetics data, diffusion coefficients (in both phases and in the membrane pores), and a hydrodynamic description of the module, were established to calculate transient and steady-state effluent concentrations. It was demonstrated that, by selecting appropriate flow rates (as mass transfer is mainly controlled by diffusion), very high DFs (DI A 11 = 20,000 and DFrm = 830) could be achieved. Am(III) and Cm(III) back-extraction efficiency was up to 99.87%. 

Process-scale models represent the behavior of reaction, separation and mass, heat, and momentum transfer at the process flowsheet level, or for a network of process flowsheets. Whether based on first-principles or empirical relations, the model equations for these systems typically consist of conservation laws (based on mass, heat, and momentum), physical and chemical equilibrium among species and phases, and additional constitutive equations that describe the rates of chemical transformation or transport of mass and energy. These process models are often represented by a collection of individual unit models (the so-called unit operations) that usually correspond to major pieces of process equipment, which, in turn, are captured by device-level models. These unit models are assembled within a process flowsheet that describes the interaction of equipment either for steady state or dynamic behavior. As a result, models can be described by algebraic or differential equations. As illustrated in Figure 3 for a PEFC-base power plant, steady-state process flowsheets are usually described by lumped parameter models described by algebraic equations. Similarly, dynamic process flowsheets are described by lumped parameter models comprising differential-algebraic equations. Models that deal with spatially distributed models are frequently considered at the device... 

In this chapter we have studied the dynamic controllability of CSTRs with several types of reactions and with several types of heat removal schemes. The control of a CSTR in a flowsheet with other units is also explored. The predictions made from the steady-state results of Chapter 2 have been quantitatively confirmed ... 

The four types of tubular reactor systems designed in Chapter 5 are investigated for dynamic controllability in this chapter. The four flowsheets are given in Figures 6.1 -6.4 with stream conditions and equipment sizes shown. These are the optimum economic flowsheets for the expensive catalyst cases. A three-bed cold-shot system is shown, but a seven bed system is the optimum steady-state design. As we will show, the seven bed system is uncontrollable. 

A flow controller is installed on the feedstream to the reactor. Figure 6.49 shows that the action is reverse and the typical flow controller tuning constants are used (Kc = 0.5 and Tj = 0.3 min). Figure 6.50 shows the final flowsheet, the three controller faceplates, and the steady-state temperature profile. The setpoint of the peak temperature controller is 441 K, and the coolant temperature is 400 K. 

Note that the flowsheet in Figure 6.77 shows a number of valves that are installed between the various units. These valves are not needed for a steady-state design. However, they must be used for a pressure-driven dynamic simulation to provide some... 

However, switching to the FS2 flowsheet with the presence of the furnace preventing the quench, the simulation was rather easily converged to a steady state. These startup experiences indicate that the FS2 flowsheet is much more robust than the FS1 flowsheet. 

The optimum steady-state economic design was determined with these new kinetic parameters, and the parameters are given in Table 7.4. The FS2 flowsheet is used with a ratio (2p,/2totai = 0.1. The impact of the kinetic parameters on the optimum design is striking. The hotter reaction requires a much larger recycle flowrate and a higher reactor inlet temperature for the same reactor exit temperature 7 ollt = 500 K. These lead... 

Perspective, The use of a mathematical model on a computer to simulate a chemical process is now approximately two decades old. The field, which has been referred to as steady state chemical process simulation, flowsheeting or computer aided chemical process design to emphasize various shadings and meanings has had a major impact on moving chemical process design from essentially an art form of the 1950 s to an accepted engineering science today. 

The User Interface. A wide variety of stand alone steady state simulation programs and flowsheet systems are available to the process engineer. These have been reported in a series of articles by Peterson, Chen and Evans in 1978 (j>) and by Chen and Evans in 1979 (6). Some practical advice on the use of the computer Tn design is reported by Weismantel (7 ). A course in the use of several commercially available systems is given in the AIChE Today Series ( ). A report on the use of networks to share chemical engineering programs among educators was recently issued (9 ). ... 

Mahalec, V. Kluzik, H. Evans, L. B., "Simultaneous Modular Algorithm for Steady State Flowsheet Simulation and Design", CACE 79, EFCE Montreux, April 8-11, 1979. 

Completing the flowsheet allows the generation of a steady-state simulation model. A dynamic simulation model may be developed for supporting process control implementation and for the assessment of operation strategies. 

Kinetic data are necessary for sizing the chemical reactor and for assessing the key features of process dynamics. However, the absence of kinetic data does not prevent the development of a process flowsheet, although the reactor will be described as a black-box steady-state unit, on stoichiometric or yield basis. 

This book is intended for use by students in senior design courses in which dynamics and control are incorporated with the traditional steady-state coverage of flowsheet synthesis, engineering economics, and optimization. A modern chemical engineering design course should include all three aspects of design (steady-state synthesis, optimization, and control) if our students are going to be well-prepared for what they will deal with in industry. 

Most real processes contain recycle streams. In this case the plantwide control problem becomes much more complex and its solution is not intuitively obvious. The presence of recycle streams profoundly alters the plant s dynamic and steady-state behavior. To gain an understanding of these effects, we look at some very simple recycle systems. The insight we obtain from these idealized, simplistic systems can be extended to the complex flowsheets of typical chemical processes. First we must lay the groundwork and have some feel for the complexities and phenomena that recycle streams produce in a plant. 

This control scheme is probably what most engineers would devise if given the problem of designing a control structure for this simple plant. Our tendency is to start with setting the flow of the fresh reactant feed stream as the means to regulate plant production rate. We would then work downstream from there as if looking at a steady-state flowsheet and simply connect the recycle stream back to the reactor based upon a standard control strategy for the column. 

In the simple binary process considered above, the 2500 ft3 reactor with a 17-tray stripper gives the process with the smallest total annual cost 936,000/yr versus 1,550,000,Nr for the best of the CSTR-in-series flowsheets. Thus this process with recycle is more economical, from the viewpoint of steady state, than the alternative process consisting of reactors in series. This is the point we made in Sec. 2.2 about the economic advantage for recycle. 

---