Copper cyclopropanation

Diisobutylaluminum hydride zinc,copper Cyclopropanes from acetylene derivs. 

Simmons-Smith reagent Named after the duPont chemists who discovered that diiodo-mechane would react with an active zinc-copper couple in ether to give a reagent with molecular formula ICHiZnl. The reagent adds stereospecifically cis- to alkenes to give cyclopropanes in high yields. 

The majority of preparative methods which have been used for obtaining cyclopropane derivatives involve carbene addition to an olefmic bond, if acetylenes are used in the reaction, cyclopropenes are obtained. Heteroatom-substituted or vinyl cydopropanes come from alkenyl bromides or enol acetates (A. de Meijere, 1979 E. J. Corey, 1975 B E. Wenkert, 1970 A). The carbenes needed for cyclopropane syntheses can be obtained in situ by a-elimination of hydrogen halides with strong bases (R. Kdstcr, 1971 E.J. Corey, 1975 B), by copper catalyzed decomposition of diazo compounds (E. Wenkert, 1970 A S.D. Burke, 1979 N.J. Turro, 1966), or by reductive elimination of iodine from gem-diiodides (J. Nishimura, 1969 D. Wen-disch, 1971 J.M. Denis, 1972 H.E. Simmons, 1973 C. Girard, 1974),... 

Tertiary bismuthines appear to have a number of uses in synthetic organic chemistry (32), eg, they promote the formation of 1,1,2-trisubstituted cyclopropanes by the iateraction of electron-deficient olefins and dialkyl dibromomalonates (100). They have also been employed for the preparation of thin films (qv) of superconducting bismuth strontium calcium copper oxide (101), as cocatalysts for the polymerization of alkynes (102), as inhibitors of the flammabihty of epoxy resins (103), and for a number of other industrial purposes. 

Furan and thiophene undergo addition reactions with carbenes. Thus cyclopropane derivatives are obtained from these heterocycles on copper(I) bromide-catalyzed reaction with diazomethane and light-promoted reaction with diazoacetic acid ester (Scheme 41). The copper-catalyzed reaction of pyrrole with diazoacetic acid ester, however, gives a 2-substituted product (Scheme 42). 

In 1958 Simmons and Smith described a new and general synthesis of cyclopropanes by treatment of olefins with a reagent prepared from methylene iodide and a zinc-copper couple in ether solution. 

Catalytic, enantioselective cyclopropanation enjoys the unique distinction of being the first example of asymmetric catalysis with a transition metal complex. The landmark 1966 report by Nozaki et al. [1] of decomposition of ethyl diazoacetate 3 with a chiral copper (II) salicylamine complex 1 (Scheme 3.1) in the presence of styrene gave birth to a field of endeavor which still today represents one of the major enterprises in chemistry. In view of the enormous growth in the field of asymmetric catalysis over the past four decades, it is somewhat ironic that significant advances in cyclopropanation have only emerged in the past ten years. 

From a historical perspective it is interesting to note that the Nozaki experiment was, in fact, a mechanistic probe to establish the intermediacy of a copper carbe-noid complex rather than an attempt to make enantiopure compounds for synthetic purposes. To achieve synthetically useful selectivities would require an extensive exploration of metals, ligands and reaction conditions along with a deeper understanding of the reaction mechanism. Modern methods for asymmetric cyclopropanation now encompass the use of countless metal complexes [2], but for the most part, the importance of diazoacetates as the carbenoid precursors still dominates the design of new catalytic systems. Highly effective catalysts developed in... 

Whereas the utility of these methods has been amply documented, they are limited in the structures they can provide because of their dependence on the diazoacetate functionality and its unique chemical properties. Transfer of a simple, unsubstituted methylene would allow access to a more general subset of chiral cyclopropanes. However, attempts to utilize simple diazo compounds, such as diazomethane, have never approached the high selectivities observed with the related diazoacetates (Scheme 3.2) [4]. Traditional strategies involving rhodium [3a,c], copper [ 3b, 5] and palladium have yet to provide a solution to this synthetic problem. The most promising results to date involve the use of zinc carbenoids albeit with selectivities less than those obtained using the diazoacetates. 

Without question, the most powerful method for cyclopropane formation by methylene transfer is the well-known Simmons-Smith reaction [6]. In 1958, Simmons and Smith reported that the action of a zinc-copper couple on diiodomethane generates a species that can transform a wide variety of alkenes into the corresponding cyclopropanes (Scheme 3.3) [7]. 

More useful for synthetic purposes, however, is the combination of the zinc-copper couple with methylene iodide to generate carbene-zinc iodide complex, which undergoes addition to double bonds exclusively to form cyclopropanes (7). The base-catalyzed generation of halocarbenes from haloforms (2) also provides a general route to 1,1-dihalocyclopropanes via carbene addition, as does the nonbasic generation of dihalocarbenes from phenyl(trihalomethyl)mercury compounds. Details of these reactions are given below. 

A carbene, R2C , is a neutral molecule containing a divalent carbon with only six valence electrons. Carbenes are highly reactive toward alkenes, adding to give cyclopropanes. Nonlialogenated cyclopropanes are best prepared by treatment of the alkene with CH212 and zinc-copper, a process called the Simmons-Smith reaction. 

The catalytic asymmetric cyclopropanation of an alkene, a reaction which was studied as early as 1966 by Nozaki and Noyori,63 is used in a commercial synthesis of ethyl (+)-(lS)-2,2-dimethylcyclo-propanecarboxylate (18) by the Sumitomo Chemical Company (see Scheme 5).64 In Aratani s Sumitomo Process, ethyl diazoacetate is decomposed in the presence of isobutene (16) and a catalytic amount of the dimeric chiral copper complex 17. Compound 18, produced in 92 % ee, is a key intermediate in Merck s commercial synthesis of cilastatin (19). The latter compound is a reversible... 

Similar results are observed in the conjugative addition of CH-acidic methylene compounds with the metal derivatives of 2-nitro-5,10,15.20-tetraphenylporphyrin (6). The nickel porphyrin 6 (M = Ni) yields with an excess of dimethyl malonate the cyclopropane derivative 7 whereas the copper porphyrin 6 (M — Cu) forms with two equivalents of malononitrile the bisadduct 8.111... 

Cyclopropane-fused chlorins are formed in good yields from copper porphyrins with ethyl diazoacetatc in benzene in the presence of copper(I) iodide.200,21 In the case of copper oc-taethylporphyrin 10, which gives a diastereomeric mixture of cyclopropane adducts 11, ethyl me o-porphyrincarboxylate 12 and a geminally dialkylated chlorin 13 (a rearrangement product of the cyclopropane chlorin 11) are observed as minor byproducts.200... 

The cyclopropanation of 1-trimethylsilyloxycyclohexene in the present procedure is accomplished by reaction with diiodomethane and diethylzinc in ethyl ether." This modification of the usual Simmons-Smith reaction in which diiodomethane and activated zinc are used has the advantage of being homogeneous and is often more effective for the cyclopropanation of olefins such as enol ethers which polymerize readily. However, in the case of trimethylsilyl enol ethers, the heterogeneous procedures with either zinc-copper couple or zinc-silver couple are also successful. Attempts by the checkers to carry out Part B in benzene or toluene at reflux instead of ethyl ether afforded the trimethylsilyl ether of 2-methylenecyclohexanol, evidently owing to zinc iodide-catalyzed isomerization of the initially formed cyclopropyl ether. The preparation of l-trimethylsilyloxybicyclo[4.1.0]heptane by cyclopropanation with diethylzinc and chloroiodomethane in the presence of oxygen has been reported. "... 

In addition to a-additions to isocyanides, copper oxide-cyclohexyl isocyanide mixtures are catalysts for other reactions including olefin dimerization and oligomerization 121, 125, 126). They also catalyze pyrroline and oxazoline formation from isocyanides with a protonic a-hydrogen (e.g., PhCH2NC or EtOCOCHjNC) and olefins or ketones 130), and the formation of cyclopropanes from olefins and substituted chloromethanes 131). The same catalyst systems also catalyze Michael addition reactions 119a). 

Muller et al. have also examined the enantioselectivity and the stereochemical course of copper-catalyzed intramolecular CH insertions of phenyl-iodonium ylides [34]. The decomposition of diazo compounds in the presence of transition metals leads to typical reactions for metal-carbenoid intermediates, such as cyclopropanations, insertions into X - H bonds, and formation of ylides with heteroatoms that have available lone pairs. Since diazo compounds are potentially explosive, toxic, and carcinogenic, the number of industrial applications is limited. Phenyliodonium ylides are potential substitutes for diazo compounds in metal-carbenoid reactions. Their photochemical, thermal, and transition-metal-catalyzed decompositions exhibit some similarities to those of diazo compounds. 

Chiral C2-symmetric semicorrins (structure 4), developed by Pfaltz [11], were proven to be highly efficient ligands for the copper-catalyzed enantio-selective cyclopropanation of olefins. Variations of the substituents at the stereogenic centers led to optimized structures and very high enantioselectiv-ities [12]. 

These two compounds with S configuration on their oxazohne rings were tested as copper(I) catalysts for the cyclopropanation of styrene, the hgand 9 with S axial chirality being much more enantioselective than 10 with the R configuration. Thus, the catalytic system CuOTf-(S,S)-bis(oxazolyl)-binaphthyl (9, R = Bu) led to excellent enantioselectivities, particularly for the cyclopropanation of styrene with (-menthyldiazoacetate 95% ee for the trans-cyclopropane and 97% ee for the cis, with trans/cis = 68/32. 

Pyridine-based N-containing ligands have been tested in order to extend the scope of the copper-catalyzed cyclopropanation reaction of olefins. Chelucci et al. [33] have carefully examined and reviewed [34] the efficiency of a number of chiral pyridine derivatives as bidentate Hgands (mainly 2,2 -bipyridines, 2,2 6, 2 -terpyridines, phenanthrolines and aminopyridine) in the copper-catalyzed cyclopropanation of styrene by ethyl diazoacetate. The corresponding copper complexes proved to be only moderately active and enantios-elective (ee up to 32% for a C2-symmetric bipyridine). The same authors prepared other chiral ligands with nitrogen donors such as 2,2 -bipyridines 21, 5,6-dihydro-1,10-phenanthrolines 22, and 1,10-phenanthrolines 23 (see Scheme 14) [35]. 

Chan et al. [38] prepared optically active atropoisomeric 2,2 -bipyridine by nickel(0)-catalyzed homo-couphng of 2-bromopyridylphenol derivatives (structure 28 in Scheme 16). Tested in the model test reaction, the copper catalyst led to frans-cyclopropanes as major products with up to 86% ee. 

Kwong and Lee [39] prepared various chiral 2,2 6, 2"-terpyridines and tested them as copper ligands for the cyclopropanation of alkenes. High enantioselectivities were obtained, the presence of bulky alkyl groups at the 8-position of the tetrahydroquinoline ring being crucial (structure 29 in Scheme 17). Thus when = Bu, up to 90% ee for the trans and 94% for the cis isomer were obtained by performing the reaction at 0 °C (transIds = 69/31). 

Chelucci et al. [41] synthesized further chiral terpyridines derived from (-)-yd-pinene, (-i-)-camphor, and (-l-)-2-carene and tested their ability to chelate copper or rhodium for the asymmetric cyclopropanation of styrene. The copper catalysts were poorly efficient and selective in this reaction. The corresponding rhodium complexes led to the best result (64% ee) with the ligand derived from (-l-)-2-carene (ligand 33 in Scheme 17). 

In conclusion, many chiral pyridine-based ligands have been prepared from the chiral pool and have been successfully tested as ligands for the copper- or rhodium-catalyzed cyclopropanation of olefins. Alfhough efficient systems have been described, sometimes leading interestingly to the major cis isomer, the enantioselectivities usually remained lower than those obtained with the copper-bis(oxazoline) system. 

Other types of new AT-containing ligands have been described as effective chiral inductors for copper-catalyzed asymmetric cyclopropanation. Hence, Fu and Lo [42] prepared a new planar-chiral hgand, namely the C2-symmetric bisazaferrocene (structure 34 in Scheme 18), which was fbimd to be efficient for the cyclopropanation of various olefins with large diastereomeric excesses and ee values up to 95%. 

Scott et al. [45] prepared diimine derivatives of 2,2 -diamino-6,6 -dimethyl-biphenyl (as structure 37 in Scheme 19) as copper chelates for the catalyzed cyclopropanation reaction. All catalysts were active in this reaction but enan-tioselectivities varied importantly according to the substitution pattern of the imine aryl group only ortho-substituted ligands (by chloride or methyl groups) led to products with measurable enantioselectivity for the model test reaction (up to 57% ee with 37). 

Clarke and Shannon also supported copper bis(oxazoline) complexes onto the surfaces of inorganic mesoporous materials, such as MCM-41 and MCM-48, through the covalent binding of the ligand, modified by alkoxysilane functionalities [59]. The immobilized catalysts allowed the cyclopropanation of styrene with ethyldiazoacetate to be performed as for the corresponding homogeneous case, and were reused once with almost no loss of activity or selectivity. 

The copper complexes of these ligands were tested in the cyclopropanation of styrene with ethyl diazoacetate (Scheme 7) and the ene reaction between a-methylstyrene and ethyl glyoxylate (Scheme 8). hi both cases moderate enantioselectivities were obtained but these were lower than those foimd with the parent hgand. 

The solids were used as catalysts in the benchmark cyclopropanation reaction between styrene and ethyl diazoacetate (Scheme 7). As far as the nature of the clay is concerned, laponite was foimd to be the best support for the catalytic complexes. The best enantioselectivity results (Table 7) were obtained with ligand 6b (69% ee in trans cyclopropanes and 64% ee in cis cyclopropanes) but the recovered solid showed a lower activity and enantioselectivity, which was attributed to partial loss of the chiral ligand from the support. In general, the use of the three chiral ligands led to enantioselectivity results that were intermediate between those obtained in homogeneous phase with CuCl2 and Cu(OTf)2 as catalyst precursors. This seemed to indicate that the sohd behaved as a counterion with an intermediate coordinating abihty to the copper centers. 

Table 8 Results of cyclopropanation reactions with copper complexes exchanged on anionic supports ...

---