Cyclopropanation, copper compounds

Although a metal catalysed decomposition of ethyl diazoacetate was originally described by Silberrad and Roy in 19061, it was to be many years before the value of this type of process for cyclopropanation of alkenes using transition metal catalysts was widely appreciated and reliable, efficient methods were developed. By the early 1960s, the reaction had become important in organic synthesis. Various transition metal compounds have been screened for catalytic cyclopropanation. Copper, rhodium and palladium compounds have... 

This review details the utility of copper compounds in a variety of organic transformations wherein their principal function is as a Lewis acid. Other important organic transformations such as conjugate additions, cyclopropanations, oxidations, and aziri-dinations are also mediated by copper species. Copper does not, however, function as a Lewis acid in these reactions but acts as a reagent and these reactions are not discussed here. The chemistry described in this review highlights the role of copper in facilitating synthetic transformations and the readers should consult the primary literature for experimental details. 

The nickel(O) complex Ni4(CNBu07 catalyzes reduction of acetylenes to olefins, isocyanides and cyanides to amines, as well as cyclotrimerization of acetylene and cyclodimerization of butadiene. Reduction of isocyanides is also catalyzed by other clusters (Chapter 13). Isocyanide copper compounds catalyze addition of CH2CIY (Y = COOR, COR, CN) to olefins leading to the formation of cyclopropane derivatives... 

The majority of preparative methods which have been used for obtaining cyclopropane derivatives involve carbene addition to an olefmic bond, if acetylenes are used in the reaction, cyclopropenes are obtained. Heteroatom-substituted or vinyl cydopropanes come from alkenyl bromides or enol acetates (A. de Meijere, 1979 E. J. Corey, 1975 B E. Wenkert, 1970 A). The carbenes needed for cyclopropane syntheses can be obtained in situ by a-elimination of hydrogen halides with strong bases (R. Kdstcr, 1971 E.J. Corey, 1975 B), by copper catalyzed decomposition of diazo compounds (E. Wenkert, 1970 A S.D. Burke, 1979 N.J. Turro, 1966), or by reductive elimination of iodine from gem-diiodides (J. Nishimura, 1969 D. Wen-disch, 1971 J.M. Denis, 1972 H.E. Simmons, 1973 C. Girard, 1974),... 

From a historical perspective it is interesting to note that the Nozaki experiment was, in fact, a mechanistic probe to establish the intermediacy of a copper carbe-noid complex rather than an attempt to make enantiopure compounds for synthetic purposes. To achieve synthetically useful selectivities would require an extensive exploration of metals, ligands and reaction conditions along with a deeper understanding of the reaction mechanism. Modern methods for asymmetric cyclopropanation now encompass the use of countless metal complexes [2], but for the most part, the importance of diazoacetates as the carbenoid precursors still dominates the design of new catalytic systems. Highly effective catalysts developed in... 

Whereas the utility of these methods has been amply documented, they are limited in the structures they can provide because of their dependence on the diazoacetate functionality and its unique chemical properties. Transfer of a simple, unsubstituted methylene would allow access to a more general subset of chiral cyclopropanes. However, attempts to utilize simple diazo compounds, such as diazomethane, have never approached the high selectivities observed with the related diazoacetates (Scheme 3.2) [4]. Traditional strategies involving rhodium [3a,c], copper [ 3b, 5] and palladium have yet to provide a solution to this synthetic problem. The most promising results to date involve the use of zinc carbenoids albeit with selectivities less than those obtained using the diazoacetates. 

More useful for synthetic purposes, however, is the combination of the zinc-copper couple with methylene iodide to generate carbene-zinc iodide complex, which undergoes addition to double bonds exclusively to form cyclopropanes (7). The base-catalyzed generation of halocarbenes from haloforms (2) also provides a general route to 1,1-dihalocyclopropanes via carbene addition, as does the nonbasic generation of dihalocarbenes from phenyl(trihalomethyl)mercury compounds. Details of these reactions are given below. 

The catalytic asymmetric cyclopropanation of an alkene, a reaction which was studied as early as 1966 by Nozaki and Noyori,63 is used in a commercial synthesis of ethyl (+)-(lS)-2,2-dimethylcyclo-propanecarboxylate (18) by the Sumitomo Chemical Company (see Scheme 5).64 In Aratani s Sumitomo Process, ethyl diazoacetate is decomposed in the presence of isobutene (16) and a catalytic amount of the dimeric chiral copper complex 17. Compound 18, produced in 92 % ee, is a key intermediate in Merck s commercial synthesis of cilastatin (19). The latter compound is a reversible... 

Similar results are observed in the conjugative addition of CH-acidic methylene compounds with the metal derivatives of 2-nitro-5,10,15.20-tetraphenylporphyrin (6). The nickel porphyrin 6 (M = Ni) yields with an excess of dimethyl malonate the cyclopropane derivative 7 whereas the copper porphyrin 6 (M — Cu) forms with two equivalents of malononitrile the bisadduct 8.111... 

Muller et al. have also examined the enantioselectivity and the stereochemical course of copper-catalyzed intramolecular CH insertions of phenyl-iodonium ylides [34]. The decomposition of diazo compounds in the presence of transition metals leads to typical reactions for metal-carbenoid intermediates, such as cyclopropanations, insertions into X - H bonds, and formation of ylides with heteroatoms that have available lone pairs. Since diazo compounds are potentially explosive, toxic, and carcinogenic, the number of industrial applications is limited. Phenyliodonium ylides are potential substitutes for diazo compounds in metal-carbenoid reactions. Their photochemical, thermal, and transition-metal-catalyzed decompositions exhibit some similarities to those of diazo compounds. 

These two compounds with S configuration on their oxazohne rings were tested as copper(I) catalysts for the cyclopropanation of styrene, the hgand 9 with S axial chirality being much more enantioselective than 10 with the R configuration. Thus, the catalytic system CuOTf-(S,S)-bis(oxazolyl)-binaphthyl (9, R = Bu) led to excellent enantioselectivities, particularly for the cyclopropanation of styrene with (-menthyldiazoacetate 95% ee for the trans-cyclopropane and 97% ee for the cis, with trans/cis = 68/32. 

Esters of a-diazoalkylphosphonic acids (95) show considerable thermal stability but react with acids, dienophiles, and triphenylphosphine to give the expected products. With olefinic compounds in the presence of copper they give cyclopropane derivatives (96), but with no such compounds present vinylphosphonic esters are formed by 1,2-hydrogen shift, or, when this route is not available, products such as (97) or (98) are formed, resulting from insertion of a carbenoid intermediate into C—C or C—H bonds. The related phosphonyl (and phosphoryl) azides (99) add to electron-rich alkynes to give 1,2,3-triazoles, from which the phosphoryl group is readily removed by hydrolysis. 

Metal-Catalyzed. Cyclopropanation. Carbene addition reactions can be catalyzed by several transition metal complexes. Most of the synthetic work has been done using copper or rhodium complexes and we focus on these. The copper-catalyzed decomposition of diazo compounds is a useful reaction for formation of substituted cyclopropanes.188 The reaction has been carried out with several copper salts,189 and both Cu(I) and Cu(II) triflate are useful.190 Several Cu(II)salen complexes, such as the (V-f-butyl derivative, which is called Cu(TBS)2, have become popular catalysts.191... 

The catalytic cyclopropanation of 1,3-dienes leads exclusively or nearly so to mono-cyclopropanation products, as long as no excess of diazocarbonyl compound is applied. The regioselectivity has been tested for representative rhodium, copper and palladium catalysts 59 7 ,72), and the results are displayed in Table 9. 

As it is known from experience that the metal carbenes operating in most catalyzed reactions of diazo compounds are electrophilic species, it comes as no surprise that only a few examples of efficient catalyzed cyclopropanation of electron-poor alkeiies exist. One of those examples is the copper-catalyzed cyclopropanation of methyl vinyl ketone with ethyl diazoacetate 140), contrasting with the 2-pyrazoline formation in the purely thermal reaction (for failures to obtain cyclopropanes by copper-catalyzed decomposition of diazoesters, see Table VIII in Ref. 6). 

Enantioselective carbenoid cyclopropanation can be expected to occur when either an olefin bearing a chiral substituent, or such a diazo compound or a chiral catalyst is present. Only the latter alternative has been widely applied in practice. All efficient chiral catalysts which are known at present are copper or cobalt(II) chelates, whereas palladium complexes 86) proved to be uneflective. The carbenoid reactions between alkyl diazoacetates and styrene or 1,1 -diphenylethylene (Scheme 27) are usually chosen to test the efficiency of a chiral catalyst. As will be seen in the following, the extent to which optical induction is brought about by enantioselection either at a prochiral olefin or at a prochiral carbenoid center, varies widely with the chiral catalyst used. 

It has already been mentioned that prochirality of the olefin is not necessary for successful enantioselective cyclopropanation with an alkyl diazoacetate in the presence of catalysts 207. What happens if a prochiral olefin and a non-prochiral diazo compound are combined Only one result provides an answer to date The cyclopropane derived from styrene and dicyanodiazomethane shows only very low optical induction (4.6 % e.e. of the (25) enantiomer, catalyst 207a) 9S). Thus, it can be concluded that with the cobalt chelate catalysts 207, enantioface selectivity at the olefin is generally unimportant and that a prochiral diazo compound is needed for efficient optical induction. As the results with chiral copper 1,3-diketonates 205 and 2-diazodi-medone show, such a statement can not be generalized, of course. 

Furans and some of its derivatives have been cyclopropanated with the ketocarbenoids derived from ethyl diazoacetate and copper catalysts. The 2-oxabicyclo[3.1.0]hex-3-enes thus formed are easily ring-opened to 1,4-diacylbutadienes thermally, thermo-catalytically or by proton catalysis 14,136). The method has been put to good use by Rh2(OAc)4-catalyzed cyclopropanation of furan with diazoketones 275 to bicyclic products 276. Even at room temperature, they undergo electrocyclic ring-opening and cis, trans-dienes 277a are obtained with fair selectivity 257,258). These compounds served as starting materials in the total syntheses 257 259) of some HETE s (mono-... 

Aziridines have been synthesized, albeit in low yield, by copper-catalyzed decomposition of ethyl diazoacetate in the presence of an inline 260). It seems that such a carbenoid cyclopropanation reaction has not been realized with other diazo compounds. The recently described preparation of 1,2,3-trisubstituted aziridines by reaction of phenyldiazomethane with N-alkyl aldimines or ketimines in the presence of zinc iodide 261 > most certainly does not proceed through carbenoid intermediates rather, the metal salt serves to activate the imine to nucleophilic attack from the diazo carbon. Replacement of Znl2 by one of the traditional copper catalysts resulted in formation of imidazoline derivatives via an intermediate azomethine ylide261). 

Synthesis of a-alkoxyketones from a-diazocarbonyl compounds and alcohols under the influence of copper or rhodium catalysts is well established as an alternative to the Lewis or proton acid catalyzed variant of this synthetic transformation. The sole recent contribution to the aspect of general reactivity deals with the competition between O/H insertion and cyclopropanation of unsaturated alcohols 162). The results... 

In 1966, Nozaki et al. reported that the decomposition of o-diazo-esters by a copper chiral Schiff base complex in the presence of olefins gave optically active cyclopropanes (Scheme 58).220 221 Following this seminal discovery, Aratani et al. commenced an extensive study of the chiral salicylaldimine ligand and developed highly enantioselective and industrially useful cyclopropanation.222-224 Since then, various complexes have been prepared and applied to asymmetric cyclo-propanation. In this section, however, only selected examples of cyclopropanations using diazo compounds are discussed. For a more detailed discussion of asymmetric cyclopropanation and related reactions, see reviews and books.17-21,225... 

In 1986, Pfaltz et al. introduced a new type of pseudo C2-symmetrical copper-semicorrin complex (68) as the catalyst (Scheme 60).227 228 The complexes (68) are reduced in situ by the diazo compound or by pretreatment with phenylhydrazine to give monomeric Cu1 species (69), which catalyze cyclopropanation. Of the semicorrin complexes, complex (68a) (R = CMe2OH) showed the best enantioselectivity in the cyclopropanation of terminal and 1,2-disubstituted olefins.227,228,17 It is noteworthy that complex (68a) catalyzes cyclopropanation, using diazomethane as a carbene source, with good enantioselectivity (70-75% ee).17... 

---