Bismuth molybdate oxidation

Grasselli, R.K., Selectivity and Activity Factors in Bismuth-molybdate Oxidation Catalysts,A ppZ. Catal. 

Grasselli, R.K. Selectivity and activity factors in bismuth-molybdate oxidation catalysts.Catal. 1985, 15, 127-139. 

In 1957 Standard Oil of Ohio (Sohio) discovered bismuth molybdate catalysts capable of producing high yields of acrolein at high propylene conversions (>90%) and at low pressures (12). Over the next 30 years much industrial and academic research and development was devoted to improving these catalysts, which are used in the production processes for acrolein, acryUc acid, and acrylonitrile. AH commercial acrolein manufacturing processes known today are based on propylene oxidation and use bismuth molybdate based catalysts. 

Many key improvements and enhancements to the bismuth molybdate based propylene oxidation catalysts have occurred over the past thirty years. These are outlined in the following tabulation. 

Patents claiming specific catalysts and processes for thek use in each of the two reactions have been assigned to Japan Catalytic (45,47—49), Sohio (50), Toyo Soda (51), Rohm and Haas (52), Sumitomo (53), BASF (54), Mitsubishi Petrochemical (56,57), Celanese (55), and others. The catalysts used for these reactions remain based on bismuth molybdate for the first stage and molybdenum vanadium oxides for the second stage, but improvements in minor component composition and catalyst preparation have resulted in yields that can reach the 85—90% range and lifetimes of several years under optimum conditions. Since plants operate under more productive conditions than those optimum for yield and life, the economically most attractive yields and productive lifetimes maybe somewhat lower. 

Fig. 2. Mechanism of selective ammoxidation and oxidation of propylene over bismuth molybdate catalysts. (31).

Oxidation Catalysis. The multiple oxidation states available in molybdenum oxide species make these exceUent catalysts in oxidation reactions. The oxidation of methanol (qv) to formaldehyde (qv) is generally carried out commercially on mixed ferric molybdate—molybdenum trioxide catalysts. The oxidation of propylene (qv) to acrolein (77) and the ammoxidation of propylene to acrylonitrile (qv) (78) are each carried out over bismuth—molybdenum oxide catalyst systems. The latter (Sohio) process produces in excess of 3.6 x 10 t/yr of acrylonitrile, which finds use in the production of fibers (qv), elastomers (qv), and water-soluble polymers. 

The first catalysts used commercially to convert the propylene with high selectivity were mixed oxides of bismuth and molybdenum, referred to as bismuth molybdates. Improved catalysts consisting of a number of soHd phases have been developed, with each generation becoming more compHcated than its predecessor. Among the catalysts cited in a patent is the following Co gNi 2"Fe 3Bi (Mo0 22 Si02 with some P and K (88). Sihca is the... 

These enable temperature control with built-in exchangers between the beds or with pumparound exchangers. Converters for ammonia, 80.3, cumene, and other processes may employ as many as five or six beds in series. The Sohio process for vapor-phase oxidation of propylene to acrylic acid uses hvo beds of bismuth molybdate at 20 to 30 atm (294 to 441 psi) and 290 to 400°C (554 to 752°F). Oxidation of ethylene to ethylene oxide also is done in two stages with supported... 

Much work has been invested to reveal the mechanism by which propylene is catalytically oxidized to acrolein over the heterogeneous catalyst surface. Isotope labeling experiments by Sachtler and DeBoer revealed the presence of an allylic intermediate in the oxidation of propylene to acrolein over bismuth molybdate. In these experiments, propylene was tagged once at Ci, another time at C2 and the third time at C3. 

Another industrially important reaction of propylene, related to the one above, is its partial oxidation in the presence of ammonia, resulting in acrylonitrile, H2C=CHCN. This ammoxidation reaction is also catalyzed by mixed metal oxide catalysts, such as bismuth-molybdate or iron antimonate, to which a large number of promoters is added (Fig. 9.19). Being strongly exothermic, ammoxidation is carried out in a fluidized-bed reactor to enable sufficient heat transfer and temperature control (400-500 °C). 

In the case of selective oxidation catalysis, the use of spectroscopy has provided critical Information about surface and solid state mechanisms. As Is well known( ), some of the most effective catalysts for selective oxidation of olefins are those based on bismuth molybdates. The Industrial significance of these catalysts stems from their unique ability to oxidize propylene and ammonia to acrylonitrile at high selectivity. Several key features of the surface mechanism of this catalytic process have recently been descrlbed(3-A). However, an understanding of the solid state transformations which occur on the catalyst surface or within the catalyst bulk under reaction conditions can only be deduced Indirectly by traditional probe molecule approaches. Direct Insights Into catalyst dynamics require the use of techniques which can probe the solid directly, preferably under reaction conditions. We have, therefore, examined several catalytlcally Important surface and solid state processes of bismuth molybdate based catalysts using multiple spectroscopic techniques Including Raman and Infrared spectroscopies, x-ray and neutron diffraction, and photoelectron spectroscopy. 

Selective oxidation and ammoxldatlon of propylene over bismuth molybdate catalysts occur by a redox mechanism whereby lattice oxygen (or Isoelectronlc NH) Is Inserted Into an allyllc Intermediate, formed via or-H abstraction from the olefin. The resulting anion vacancies are eventually filled by lattice oxygen which originates from gaseous oxygen dlssoclatlvely chemisorbed at surface sites which are spatially and structurally distinct from the sites of olefin oxidation. Mechanistic details about the... 

The structure of the single phase bismuth-iron molybdate compound of composition Bl3FeMo20.2 related to the scheellte structure of Bi2Mo30-2( ). It is reported(, ) that the catalytic activity and selectivity of bismuth-iron molybdate for propylene oxidation and ammoxidatlon is not greater than that of bismuth molybdate. 

Analytical electron microscopy permits structural and chemical analyses of catalyst areas nearly 1000 times smaller than those studied by conventional bulk analysis techniques. Quantitative x-ray analyses of bismuth molybdates are shown from lOnm diameter regions to better than 5% relative accuracy for the elements 61 and Mo. Digital x-ray images show qualitative 2-dimensional distributions of elements with a lateral spatial resolution of lOnm in supported Pd catalysts and ZSM-5 zeolites. Fine structure in CuLj 2 edges from electron energy loss spectroscopy indicate d>ether the copper is in the form of Cu metal or Cu oxide. These techniques should prove to be of great utility for the analysis of active phases, promoters, and poisons. 

The following data given in Tables 16.15, 16.16 and 16.17 on the oxidation of propylene over bismuth molybdate catalyst were obtained at three temperatures, 350,375, and 390°C (Watts, 1994). 

Bismuth Molybdates. Bismuth molybdates are used as selective oxidation catalysts. Several phases containing Bi and/or Mo may be mixed together to obtain desired catalytic properties. While selected area electron diffraction patterns can identify individual crystalline particles, diffraction techniques usually require considerable time for developing film and analyzing patterns. X-ray emission spectroscopy in the AEM can identify individual phases containing two detectable elements within a few minutes while the operator is at the microscope. 

A continuous process based on hydrodynamic cavitation can be employed to prepare a wide variety of metal oxides in grain sizes of 1 -10 nm, such as iron oxide, bismuth molybdate, perovskites, platinum-loaded zeolite, and other ceramics and superconductors [170]. The method uses a microfluidiser for mechanically generating hydrodynamic cavitation and the internal pressure of the liquid media is elevated from ambient pressure to between 1000 to 25 000 psi. 

Three well known examples of processes employing fluidised-bed operations are the oxidations of naphthalene and xylene to phthalic anhydride using a supported V2O5 catalyst and ammoxidation of propylene utilising a mixed oxide composition containing bismuth molybdate. Typically, this latter reaction is executed by passing a mixture of ammonia, air and propylene to a fluidised bed operating at about 0.2 MPa pressure, 400—500°C and a few seconds contact time between gas and fluidised catalyst peirticles. 

Acrolein Production. Adams et al. [/. Catalysis, 3,379 (1964)] studied the catalytic oxidation of propylene on bismuth molybdate catalyst to form acrolein. With a feed of propylene and oxygen and reaction at 460°C, the following three reactions occur. 

Mechanisms There is a derth of knowledge about the mechanisms operative in selective oxidation reactions. The only exceptions are the reactions of ethylene to ethylene oxide on supported silver catalysts and of propylene to acrolein on bismuth molybdate type catalysts. For the latter, it is well established through isotopic labeling experiments that a symmetric allyl radical is an intermediate in the reaction and that its formation is rate-determining. Many studies simply extrapolate the results substantiated for this case to other reactions. New ideas on mechanisms are presented by Oyama, et oL, Parmaliana, et aL, and Laszlo. 

Although this report describes the preparation of a wide variety of oxidation catalysts, only the iron modified bismuth molybdates will be described in detail. Other preparations are described in this section through an indication of the starting soluble salts and their synthesis temperatures which are the key process parameters. Other aspects of their HTAD preparations are similar to that described for the iron bismuth molybdates which follows. 

Finally, Arrhenius treatments of the catalytic data were examined for the HTAD synthesized substitutional series, Bi(2-2x) 2x 030i2, and the binary bismuth molybdate series where Bi/Mo ratios were varied fi-om pure Mo oxide to pure Bi oxide. The noteworthy aspect of the oxidation results is that in the most reactive regime of x = 0-5% atom fi-action Fe, before separate phase Fe3Mo30j2 begins to dominate the catalyst composition in the iron series, the apparent activation energies were all in the range of 19-20 kcal/mol. Furthermore, the activation energies for the pure Bi-Mo series were between 19-20 kcal/mol while the activities were considerable different. Thus, the chief difference in the reactivities in both series is in the preexponential factor, i.e. the number of active sites. 

The oxidation of propene to acrolein has been one of the most studied selective oxidation reaction. The catalysts used are usually pure bismuth molybdates owing to the fact that these phases are present in industrial catalysts and that they exhibit rather good catalytic properties (1). However the industrial catalysts also contain bivalent cation molybdates like cobalt, iron and nickel molybdates, the presence of which improves both the activity and the selectivity of the catdysts (2,3). This improvement of performances for a mixture of phases with respect to each phase component, designated synergy effect, has recently been attributed to a support effect of the bivalent cation molybdate on the bismuth molybdate (4) or to a synergy effect due to remote control (5) or to more or less strong interaction between phases (6). However, this was proposed only in view of kinetic data obtained on a prepared supported catalyst. 

These results and the comparison between the catalyst particles before and after catalytic run point out the ability for these particles both to exchange electrons and oxygen anions and to change morphology under the conditions of the catalytic reaction with spreading of the oxides one over the other. These two phenomena should be at the basis of the explanation of synergy effect in molybdates based catalysts. The fact that some FexCoi.xMo04 particles remain free (i.e. not deposited on bismuth molybdate particles) show that even more active and selective catalysts may be obtained in more reliable preparation conditions. 

---