Oxidative addition aryl chlorides

Portnoy, M. Milstein, D. (1993) Mechanism of aryl chloride oxidative addition to chelated palladium(O) complexes, Organometallics, 12,1665-73. 

Usually, iodides and bromides are used for the carbonylation, and chlorides are inert. I lowever, oxidative addition of aryl chlorides can be facilitated by use of bidcntatc phosphine, which forms a six-membered chelate structure and increa.scs (he electron density of Pd. For example, benzoate is prepared by the carbonylation of chlorobenzene using bis(diisopropylphosphino)propane (dippp) (456) as a ligand at 150 [308]. The use of tricyclohexylphosphine for the carbonylation of neat aryl chlorides in aqueous KOH under biphasic conditions is also recommended[309,310]. 

Palladium(II) complexes provide convenient access into this class of catalysts. Some examples of complexes which have been found to be successful catalysts are shown in Scheme 11. They were able to get reasonable turnover numbers in the Heck reaction of aryl bromides and even aryl chlorides [22,190-195]. Mechanistic studies concentrated on the Heck reaction [195] or separated steps like the oxidative addition and reductive elimination [196-199]. Computational studies by DFT calculations indicated that the mechanism for NHC complexes is most likely the same as that for phosphine ligands [169], but also in this case there is a need for more data before a definitive answer can be given on the mechanism. 

As mentioned in the discussion of the reaction mechanism for this transformation, the active species is a dicoordinate Pd(0) complex, and it is unclear whether an associative or a dissociative process is operative for oxidative addition. In this context, different NHC complexes containing only one carbene ligand have been tested in the Mizoroki-Heck reaction. The most successful are those prepared by Beller, which were able to perform the Mizoroki-Heck reaction of non-activated aryl chlorides with moderate to good yields in ionic liquids (Scheme 6.13). The same compounds have also been applied to the Mizoroki-Heck reaction of aryldiazonium... 

As an example, consider the use of PVPy as a solid poison in the study of poly(noibomene)-supported Pd-NHC complexes in Suzuki reactions of aryl chlorides and phenylboroiuc acid in DMF (23). This polymeric piecatalyst is soluble under some of the reaction conditions employed and thus it presents a different situation from the work using porous, insoluble oxide catalysts (12-13). Like past studies, addition of PVPy resulted in a reduction in reaction yield. However, the reaction solution was observed to become noticeably more viscous, and the cause of the reduced yield - catalyst poisoning vs. transport limitations on reaction kinetics - was not immediately obvious. The authors thus added a non-functionalized poly(styrene), which should only affect the reaction via non-specific physical means (e.g., increase in solution viscosity, etc.), and also observed a decrease in reaction yield. They thus demonstrated a drawback in the use of the potentially swellable PVPy with soluble (23) or swellable (20) catalysts in certain solvents. 

Aryl Halides from Diazonium Ion Intermediates. Replacement of diazonium groups by halides is a valuable alternative to direct halogenation for the preparation of aryl halides. Aryl bromides and chlorides are usually prepared by a reaction using the appropriate Cu(I) salt, which is known as the Sandmeyer reaction. Under the classic conditions, the diazonium salt is added to a hot acidic solution of the cuprous halide.99 The Sandmeyer reaction occurs by an oxidative addition reaction of the diazonium ion with Cu(I) and halide transfer from a Cu(III) intermediate. 

In summary, these results demonstrate that air-stable POPd, POPdl and POPd2 complexes can be directly employed to mediate the rate-limiting oxidative addition of unactivated aryl chlorides in the presence of bases, and that such processes can be incorporated into efficient catalytic cycles for a variety of cross-coupling reactions. Noteworthy are the efficiency for unactivated aryl chlorides simplicity of use, low cost, air- and moisture-stability, and ready accessibility of these complexes. Additional applications of these air-stable palladium complexes for catalysis are currently under investigation. 

The low catalytic reactivity of aryl chlorides in cross-coupling reactions is usually attributed to their reluctance towards oxidative addition to Pd(0). For a discussion, see V. V. Grushin and H. Alper, Chem. Rev., 94, 1047-1062 (1994), and reference therein. 

Simple Pd salts and complexes which contain neither phosphines nor any other deliberately added ligands are well known to provide catalytic activity in cross-coupling reactions. Such catalytic systems (often referred to as ligand-free catalysts ) often require the use of water as a component of the reaction medium.17 In the majority of cases such systems are applicable to electrophiles easily undergoing the oxidative addition (aryl iodides and activated bromides), although there are examples of effective reactions with unactivated substrates (electron-rich aiyl bromides, and some aryl chlorides).18,470... 

These reactions to form aryl tin bonds could occur by initial oxidative addition of the aryl halide or the distannane. The stoichiometric reaction between [(PPh3)2Pd(Ph)(I)] and Me3SnSnMe3 in the presence of chloride generated good yields of the aryltin product. This result suggests that the reactions occur by initial oxidative addition of aryl halide. 

A study of the a-arylation of diazine mono iV-oxides, under Heck-like conditions, also gave emphasis to pyrazines but a number of examples using pyrimidines and pyridazines were also described (Scheme 1). A wide range of aryl chlorides, bromides and iodides was used and the products were easily deoxygenated by catalytic reduction. An interesting feature was the use of a copper additive, which was only required for the pyrimidine reactions, to give a very substantial improvement in yield <06AG(I)7781>. 

Recently, the groups of Fu and Buchwald have coupled aryl chlorides with arylboronic acids [34, 35]. The methodology may be amenable to large-scale synthesis because organic chlorides are less expensive and more readily available than other organic halides. Under conventional Suzuki conditions, chlorobenzene is virtually inert because of its reluctance to oxidatively add to Pd(0). However, in the presence of sterically hindered, electron-rich phosphine ligands [e.g., P(f-Bu)3 or tricyclohexylphosphine], enhanced reactivity is acquired presumably because the oxidative addition of an aryl chloride is more facile with a more electron-rich palladium complex. For... 

While the sequence of steps for the Heck reaction remains the same for many catalysts, the kinetics may vary enormously and also the detailed composition of all intermediates may vary in the type and number of ligands. It had often been assumed that the oxidative addition is the slowest step and that may well be true for many systems based on PPh3 definitely for aryl chlorides it seems to be the rule. 

Additional factors which lead to an increased stability of the carbene complexes towards reductive ehmination are the type of NHC ligand and the NA -substitution pattern. The stability of NHC complexes depends strongly on the electronic situation at the carbene center. The oxidative addition of p-tolyl chloride to linear Pd° complexes bearing two unsaturated imidazolin-2-ylidenes (type 5, Fig. 6) or two saturated imidazolidin-2-ylidenes (t3q>e 7, Fig. 6) proceeds readily. The Pd complex with the imidazolin-2-yhdene ligands is stable, while the one with the imida-zolidin-2-ylidene ligands reductively ehminates the C2-arylated imidazolidinium salt [134]. 

The reaction of aryl electrophiles with organomagnesium compounds is known as Kumada or Kumada-Tamao-Corriu reaction. The most common leaving groups in the electrophile are halogen atoms and, among them, chlorine is the most wanted due to the good availability and the low price of aryl or heteroaryl chlorides. Unfortunately, the oxidative addition of a metal center to an aryl chloride is a difficult reaction and many efforts have been made to overcome existing limitations. 

---