Alkenes, addition reactions carbocation intermediate

Fig. 2 Free energy reaction coordinate profiles for the stepwise acid-catalyzed hydration of an alkene through a carbocation intermediate (Scheme 5). (a) Reaction profile for the case where alkene protonation is rate determining (ks kp). This profile shows a change in rate-determining step as a result of Bronsted catalysis of protonation of the alkene. (b) Reaction profile for the case where addition of solvent to the carbocation is rate determining (ks fcp). This profile shows a change in rate-determining step as a result of trapping of the carbocation by an added nucleophilic reagent.

We may seem to have contradicted ourselves because Equation 10-1 shows a carbocation to be formed in bromine addition, but Equation 10-5 suggests a bromonium ion. Actually, the formulation of intermediates in alkene addition reactions as open ions or as cyclic ions is a controversial matter, even after many years of study. Unfortunately, it is not possible to determine the structure of the intermediate ions by any direct physical method because, under the conditions of the reaction, the ions are so reactive that they form products more rapidly than they can be observed. However, it is possible to generate stable bromonium ions, as well as the corresponding chloronium and iodonium ions. The technique is to use low temperatures in the absence of any strong nucleophiles and to start with a 1,2-dihaloalkane and antimony penta-fluoride in liquid sulfur dioxide ... 

Why does alkene hydroboration take place with non-Markovnikov regiochemistry, yielding the less highly substituted alcohol Hydroboration differs from many other alkene addition reactions in that it occurs in a single step without a carbocation intermediate. We can view the reaction as taking place through a four-center, cyclic transition state, as shown in Figure 7.6 p. 244). Since both C-H and C-B bonds form at the same time and from the same face of the alkene, syn stereochemistry is observed. 

When two substituents add to the same side of a double bond, the addition is called syn addition. When two substituents add to opposite sides of a double bond, the addition is called anti addition. Both syn and anti additions occur in alkene addition reactions that form a carbocation intermediate. Equal amounts of the four stereoisomers are obtained so the reaction is not stereoselective and, because the four stereoisomers formed by the cis alkene are identical to the four stereoisomers formed by the trans alkene, the reaction is also not stereospecific. 

Based on what we ve seen thus far, a possible mechanism for the reaction of bromine with alkenes might involve electrophilic addition of Br" " to the alkene, giving a carbocation intermediate that could undergo further reaction with Br to yield the dibromo addition product. 

The absence of rearrangement and the anti stereochemistry of the addition product must be accommodated in a proposed mechanism for the addition of a halogen to an alkene involving a carbocation intermediate. The first step of the reaction mechanism is the electrophilic addition of bromine to the Jt bond to give a three-membered ring called a tydic bromonium ion. 

The formation of alcohols by acid-catalyzed addition of water to alkenes is a fundamental organic reaction. At the most rudimentary mechanistic level, it can be viewed as involving a carbocation intermediate. The alkene is protonated, and the carbocation is then captured by water. 

The reaction begins with an attack on the electrophile, HBr, by the electrons of the nucleophilic tt bond. Two electrons from the 7t bond form a new u bond between the entering hydrogen and an alkene carbon, as shown by the curved arrow at the top of Figure 6.7. The carbocation intermediate that results is itself an electrophile, which can accept an electron pair from nucleophilic Br ion to form a C Brbond and yield a neutral addition product. 

Problem 6.18 What about the second step in the electrophilic addition of HCl to an alkene—the reaction of chloride ion with the carbocation intermediate Is this step exergonic or endergontc Does the transition state for this second step resemble the reactant (carbocation) or product (alkyl chloride) Make a rough drawing of what the transition-state structure might look like. 

Aikene chemistry is dominated by electrophilic addition reactions. When HX reacts with an unsymmetrically substituted aikene, Markovnikov s rule predicts that the H will add to the carbon having fewer alky) substituents and the X group will add to the carbon having more alkyl substituents. Electrophilic additions to alkenes take place through carbocation intermediates formed by reaction of the nucleophilic aikene tt bond with electrophilic H+. Carbocation stability follows the order... 

The following carbocation is an intermediate in the electrophilic addition reaction of HCl with two different alkenes. Identify both, and tell which C-H bonds in the carbocation are aligned for hyperconjugation with the vacant p orbital on the positively charged carbon. 

Water adds to alkenes to yield alcohols, a process called hydration. The reaction takes place on treatment of the alkene with water and a strong acid catalyst (HA) by a mechanism similar to that of HX addition. Thus, protonation of an alkene double bond yields a carbocation intermediate, which reacts with water to yield a protonated alcohol product (ROH2+). Loss of H+ from this protonated alcohol gives the neutral alcohol and regenerates the acid catalyst (Figure 7.2). 

The mechanism of alkyne additions is similar but not identical to that of alkene additions. When an electrophile such as HBr adds to an alkene (Sections 6.7 and 6.8), the reaction takes place in two steps and involves an alkyl carbocation intermediate. If HBr were to add by the same mechanism to an alkyne, an analogous vinylic carbocation would be formed as the intermediate. 

Two SN1 reactions occur during the biosynthesis of geraniol, a fragrant alcohol found in roses and used in perfumery. Geraniol biosynthesis begins with dissociation of dimethylallyl diphosphate to give an allylic carbocation, which reacts with isopentenyl diphosphate (Figure IT 15). From the viewpoint of isopentenyl diphosphate, the reaction is an electrophilic alkene addition, but from tile viewpoint of dimethylallyl diphosphate, the process in an Sjjl reaction in which the carbocation intermediate reacts with a double bond as the nucleophile. 

A second difference between alkene addition and aromatic substitution occurs after the carbocation intermediate has formed. Instead of adding Br- to give an addition product, the carbocation intermediate loses H+ from the bromine-bearing carbon to give a substitution product. Note that this loss of H+ is similar to what occurs in the second step of an El reaction (Section 11.10). The net effect of reaction of Br2 with benzene is the substitution of H+ by Br+ by the overall mechanism shown in Figure 16.2. 

Synthetic polymers can be classified as either chain-growth polymen or step-growth polymers. Chain-growth polymers are prepared by chain-reaction polymerization of vinyl monomers in the presence of a radical, an anion, or a cation initiator. Radical polymerization is sometimes used, but alkenes such as 2-methylpropene that have electron-donating substituents on the double bond polymerize easily by a cationic route through carbocation intermediates. Similarly, monomers such as methyl -cyanoacrylate that have electron-withdrawing substituents on the double bond polymerize by an anionic, conjugate addition pathway. 

As we saw in the previous section, Markovnikov s rule tells us to place the H on the less substituted carbon, and to place the X on the more substituted carbon. The rule is named after Vladimir Markovnikov, a Russian chemist, who first showed the regiochemical preference of HBr additions to alkenes. When Markovnikov recognized this pattern in the late 19th century, he stated the rule in terms of the placement of the proton (specifically, that the proton will end up on the less substituted carbon atom). Now that we understand the reason for the regiochemical preference (carbocation stability), we can state Markovnikov s rule in a way that more accurately reflects the underlying principle The regiochemistry will be determined by the preference for the reaction to proceed via the more stable carbocation intermediate. 

Clearly, we must be able to predict when to expect a carbocation rearrangement. There are two common ways for a carbocation to rearrange either through a hydride shift or through a methyl shift. Your textbook will have examples of each. Carbocation rearrangements are possible for any reaction that involves an intermediate carbocation (not just for addition of HX across an alkene). Later in this chapter, we will see other addition reactions that also proceed through carbocation intermediates. In those cases, you will be expected to know that there will be a possibility for carbocation rearrangements. 

A common feature of these intermediates is that they are of high energy, compared to structures with completely filled valence shells. Their lifetimes are usually very short. Bond formation involving carbocations, carbenes, and radicals often occurs with low activation energies. This is particularly true for addition reactions with alkenes and other systems having it bonds. These reactions replace a tt bond with a ct bond and are usually exothermic. 

There are, however, serious problems that must be overcome in the application of this reaction to synthesis. The product is a new carbocation that can react further. Repetitive addition to alkene molecules leads to polymerization. Indeed, this is the mechanism of acid-catalyzed polymerization of alkenes. There is also the possibility of rearrangement. A key requirement for adapting the reaction of carbocations with alkenes to the synthesis of small molecules is control of the reactivity of the newly formed carbocation intermediate. Synthetically useful carbocation-alkene reactions require a suitable termination step. We have already encountered one successful strategy in the reaction of alkenyl and allylic silanes and stannanes with electrophilic carbon (see Chapter 9). In those reactions, the silyl or stannyl substituent is eliminated and a stable alkene is formed. The increased reactivity of the silyl- and stannyl-substituted alkenes is also favorable to the synthetic utility of carbocation-alkene reactions because the reactants are more nucleophilic than the product alkenes. 

The hydration of an alkene double bond under strongly acidic conditions is again a classical reaction that involves a carbocation intermediate, which often leads to various competing reaction products.27 The regiochemistry of the water addition follows the Markovnikov rule.28... 

The quantitation of products that form in low yields requires special care with HPLC analyses. In cases where the product yield is <1%, it is generally not feasible to obtain sufficient material for a detailed physical characterization of the product. Therefore, the product identification is restricted to a comparison of the UV-vis spectrum and HPLC retention time with those for an authentic standard. However, if a minor reaction product forms with a UV spectrum and HPLC chromatographic properties similar to those for the putative substitution or elimination reaction, this may lead to errors in structural assignments. Our practice is to treat rate constant ratios determined from very low product yields as limits, until additional evidence can be obtained that our experimental value for this ratio provides a chemically reasonable description of the partitioning of the carbocation intermediate. For example, verification of the structure of an alkene that is proposed to form in low yields by deprotonation of the carbocation by solvent can be obtained from a detailed analysis of the increase in the yield of this product due to general base catalysis of carbocation deprotonation.14,16... 

The behavior of members of the bicyclo[2.2.1]heptene family is also different from that of other common 1,2-disubstituted alkenes.230 The parent bicy-clo[2.2.1]heptene gives bicyclo[2.2.1]heptane in only 3.5% yield when it is treated with Et3SiH/TFA. The major product is reported to be a 2-bicyclo[2.2.1]heptyl trifluoroacetate of unspecified configuration (Eq. 70).230 The carbocation intermediate is presumably the 2-norbornyl cation. Addition of small amounts of boron trifluoride etherate to the reaction mixture causes the yield of hydrocarbon product to rise to 22% after a reaction time of 24 hours at room temperature. Further... 

Hydride transfer from alkenes was also proposed to occur during sulfuric acid-catalyzed alkylation modified with anthracene (77). Then the butene loses a hydride and forms a cyclic carbocation intermediate, yielding—on reaction with isobutene—trimethylpentyl cations. This conclusion was drawn from the observation of a sharp decrease in 2,2,3-TMP selectivity upon addition of anthracene to the acid. 

In the early days of alkene chemistry, some researchers found that the hydrohalogenation of alkenes followed Markovnikov s rule, while others found that the same reaction did not. For example, when freshly distilled but-l-ene was exposed to hydrogen bromide, the major product was 2-bromopropane, as expected by Markovnikov s rule. However, when the same reaction was carried out with a sample of but-l-ene that had been exposed to air, the major product was 1-bromopropane formed by antl-Markovnikov addition. This caused considerable confusion, but the mystery was solved by the American chemist, Morris Kharasch, in the 1930s. He realised that the samples of alkenes that had been stored in the presence of air had formed peroxide radicals. The hydrohalogenation thus proceeded by a radical chain reaction mechanism and not via the mechanism involving carbocation intermediates as when pure alkenes were used. 

---