The Selectivity Problem

Although alkene hydrogenation is one of the easiest organic reactions, the partial hydrogenation of vegetable oils presents some selectivity problems to get the desired properties. For example, while it is necessary to reduce the number of unsaturations in order to harden the oil and reduce the sensitivity to oxidation, unsaturated acids are fundamental in our diet and thus it is important to keep at least part of them. 

---

The ease of oxidation varies considerably with the nature and number of ring substituents thus, although simple alkyl derivatives of pyrazine, quinoxaline and phenazine are easily oxidized by peracetic acid generated in situ from hydrogen peroxide and acetic acid, some difficulties are encountered. With unsymmetrical substrates there is inevitably the selectivity problem. Thus, methylpyrazine on oxidation with peracetic acid yields mixtures of the 1-and 4-oxides (42) and (43) (59YZ1275). In favourable circumstances, such product mixtures may be separated by fractional crystallization. Simple alkyl derivatives of quinoxalines are... 

Many authors contributed to the field of diffusion and chemical reaction. Crank (1975) dealt with the mathematics of diffusion, as did Frank-Kamenetskii (1961), and Aris (1975). The book of Sherwood and Satterfield (1963) and later Satterfield (1970) discussed the theme in detail. Most of the published papers deal with a single reaction case, but this has limited practical significance. In the 1960s, when the subject was in vogue, hundreds of papers were presented on this subject. A fraction of the presented papers dealt with the selectivity problem as influenced by diffitsion. This field was reviewed by Carberry (1976). Mears (1971) developed criteria for important practical cases. Most books on reaction engineering give a good summary of the literature and the important aspects of the interaction of diffusion and reaction. 

It has been discovered recently that the spectrum of solutions for growth in a channel is much richer than had previously been supposed. Parity-broken solutions were found [110] and studied numerically in detail [94,111]. A similar solution exists also in an unrestricted space which was called doublon for obvious reasons [94]. It consists of two fingers with a liquid channel along the axis of symmetry between them. It has a parabolic envelope with radius pt and in the center a liquid channel of thickness h. The Peclet number, P = vp /2D, depends on A according to the Ivantsov relation (82). The analytical solution of the selection problem for doublons [112] shows that this solution exists for isotropic systems (e = 0) even at arbitrary small undercooling A and obeys the following selection conditions ... 

The epoxidation method developed by Noyori was subsequently applied to the direct formation of dicarboxylic acids from olefins [55], Cyclohexene was oxidized to adipic acid in 93% yield with the tungstate/ammonium bisulfate system and 4 equivalents of hydrogen peroxide. The selectivity problem associated with the Noyori method was circumvented to a certain degree by the improvements introduced by Jacobs and coworkers [56]. Additional amounts of (aminomethyl)phos-phonic acid and Na2W04 were introduced into the standard catalytic mixture, and the pH of the reaction media was adjusted to 4.2-5 with aqueous NaOH. These changes allowed for the formation of epoxides from ot-pinene, 1 -phenyl- 1-cyclohex-ene, and indene, with high levels of conversion and good selectivity (Scheme 6.3). 

An alternative approach (Matveev et al., 1995), which avoids the selectivity problem mentioned above, is shown in Fig. 2.19. In this route, 1-naphthol is selectively methylated at the 2-position using methanol over a solid catalyst in the vapour phase. The product undergoes selective oxidation to menadione with O2 and a heteropolyanion catalyst. 

Mass transfer-limited processes favour slurry reactors over monoliths as far as the overall process rates are concerned. Moreover, slurry reactors are more versatile and less sensitive to gas flow rates. However, the productivity per unit volume is not necessarily higher for slurry reactors because of the low concentration of catalyst in such reactors. There also is no simple answer to the selectivity problem, and again, each process should be compared in detail for both reactors. 

It was shown in the preceding text that even in the simplest systems many different chemisorbed particles originate on the surface during the catalytic reaction. In principle most of them can interact with each other and probably with gaseous reaction components as well. As a consequence, any catalytic reaction represents a system of simultaneous reactions, and the problem is how to influence the course of a particular reaction—in other words, it is essentially the selectivity problem. Thus in catalysis by metals, probably the modification of the surface properties (by forming the alloys, stable surface complexes, or by the addition of promotors, etc.) seems to be the most promising direction of the further fundamental research. 

We leave the first step (AC—>An) inclusive the selectivity problem to the chemists. 

The selectivity problem is particularly important in the dimerization of two different olefins when, in addition to the required codimers, a mixture of the two possible homodimers may be produced. 

Chapters 4 and 5 are devoted to molecular and biomolecular catalysis of electrochemical reactions. As discussed earlier, molecular electrochemistry deals with transforming molecules by electrochemical means. With molecular catalysis of electrochemical reactions, we address the converse aspect of molecular electrochemistry how to use molecules to produce better electrochemistry. It is first important to distinguish redox catalysis from chemical catalysis. In the first case, the catalytic effect stems from the three-dimensional dispersion of the mediator (catalyst), which merely shuttles the electrons between the electrode and the reactant. In chemical catalysis, there is a more intimate interaction between the active form of the catalyst and the reactant. The differences between the two types of catalysis are illustrated by examples of homogeneous systems in which not only the rapidity of the catalytic process, but also the selectivity problems, are discussed. 

The significance of the proposition is the following statement (a) yields immediately that for a Pareto-character rationality is equivalent to harmonicity. Statement (b) demonstrates that the above-mentioned problematic feature of a hierarchical character, namely to require a full ranking of aspects, vanishes exactly on harmonic bundles. Similarly with statement (c), which shows that the selection problem for cardinal aggregation devices, mentioned earlier, vanishes exactly on harmonic bundles. The utilitarian aggregation device is one example covered by (c), but there are others (e.g. some kinds of modified Rawls aggregation devices such as w - / , with mtj > 0). 

Statement (d) exhibits in precise form a peculiar feature of the Rawls aggregation device which we already observed earlier (see the example at the end of the last section). The selection problem for the Rawls-device does not vanish, except, of course, for trivial bundles. Or, to put it in the language of Social or Public Choice, the Rawls device depends crucially on interpersonal comparison (trivial cases excepted). (In fact, statements (c) and (d) are strongly related to questions raised in the theory of Social or Public Choice. Thus (c) provides a precise answer to the question of a purely ordinal behaviour of the utilitarian device, which is discussed e.g. by Mueller 1979, p. 176.)... 

As was discussed in Section 3, the multiobjective framework of the proposed algorithm allows us to incorporate additional constraints in the selection problem. In this section, we have addressed two such constraints, namely the experimental resources constraint and the exclusion/inclusion constraint. 

It is now possible to understand the curious phenomenon whereby the reaction of palladium acetate with I in vacuo first rapidly produces a metal precipitate and then slows at about 20% conversion and finally stops with much of the palladium (II) unreacted. These stages in the reaction correspond to oxidation first by Pd3(OAc)6 and then by IVa with ultimate formation of the inert species Va. A complex mixture of hexenyl acetates is formed in the oxidation of which the major constituent l-hexen-2-yl acetate (VI) is 0.68 mole fraction of the whole mixture. Overall the mixture is closely similar to that obtained in the catalytic reactions of 02 described later, suggesting that the same active palladium-containing species is involved. Much of I is isomerized to a 5 1 mixture of trans- and ds-2-hexene (85% at 6 hrs) with only 3% each of the 3-hexene isomers. This aspect of the selectivity problem in which only one shift of the double bond takes place is also reproduced in the catalytic reaction, but oxygen suppresses the rate of isomerization relative to oxidation. 

We have already seen the solution to this problem in Chapter 43. If we use symmetrical hydrazine, we can deal with the selectivity problem by alkylation. Dimethyl sulfate turns out to be the best... 

In this work, the basis for a proper answer to the selectivity problem between the two cited compounds is set. For this purpose, a high-pressure vapor-liquid equilibria circulation-type apparatus was designed and constructed. Some vapor-liquid equilibria (VLE) data of the binary systems C02-limonene and C02-linalool were determined and compared with data available in the literature. The results obtained were accurately correlated by a modified SRK equation of state that avoids the use of critical constants [16]. 

The reaction is acid catalyzed and both Bronsted and Lewis acids have been used. It has been claimed in the literature [78] that the choice of a proper catalyst would be a solution to the selectivity problem. However, the literature is contradictory and bewildering on this point [79]. 

In essence, the selection problem can be viewed as a heuristic search in which each state of the search space represents a particular subset of the virtual library. This section highlights a few common methods of subset selection. 

The next step involved the selective reduction of one of the double bonds in 12, specifically the double bond in ring C. No reliable method existed to secure the required hydrogenation selectivity. Therefore, the double bond in ring D was hydroxylated with osmium tetroxide and the resulting diol converted into the corresponding acetal 13. In addition to simplifying the selectivity problem... 

---