Styrene carbene

The preparation of cyclopropane derivatives has been greatly facilitated by the development of carbene-type intermediates (see Chapter 13) and their ready reaction with olefins. The preparation of phenylcyclopropane from styrene and the methylene iodide-zinc reagent proceeds in only modest yield, however, and the classical preparation of cyclopropane derivatives by the decomposition of pyrazolines (first employed by Buchner in 1890) is therefore presented in the procedure as a convenient alternative. 

These complexes can be isolated in some cases in others they are generated in situ from appropriate precursors, of which diazo compounds are among the most important. These compounds, including CH2N2 and other diazoalkanes, react with metals or metal salts (copper, palladium, and rhodium are most commonly used) to give the carbene complexes that add CRR to double bonds. Ethyl a-diazoacetate reacts with styrene in the presence of bis(ferrocenyl) bis(imine), for example, to give ethyl 2-phenylcyclopropane-l-carboxylate. Optically active complexes have... 

Ruthenium porphyrin complexes are also active in cyclopropanation reactions, with both stoichiometric and catalytic carbene transfer reactions observed for Ru(TPP)(=C(C02Et)2> with styrene. Ru(Por)(CO)orRu(TMP)(=0)2 catalyzed the cyclopropanation of styrene with ethyidiazoacetate, with aiiti.syn ratios of 13 1... 

Davies [30] studied the PyBOx-induced conformational effects by testing several ligands sterically hindered on the oxazoUne moieties (Scheme 11, structures 18 and 19). However, these new ligands gave poorer results in terms of yields and enantioselectivities than ligand 16 for the Ru-catalyzed cyclopropanation reaction, indicating unfavorable steric interactions between styrene and the carbene complex. 

Pyrolysis of bis(trimethylsilyl)phenyl methanol 1668 at 500 °C leads, via elimination of trimethylsilanol 4, to the carbene intermediate 1669, which rearranges, via the carbene intermediate 1670, to give l,2-dimethyl-2,3-benzo-l-silacyclopent-2-ene 1671, in 25% yield, or rearranges via olefin 1672 and adds 4 to give the siloxane 1673 in 29% yield and smaller amounts of benzyltrimethylsilane 83 and styrene [43, 44]. Pyrolysis of l,l-bis(trimethylsilyl) cyclohexylalcohol 1674 furnishes, via the carbene intermediate 1675, 90% of olefin 1676 [43, 44] (Scheme 10.20). 

Treatment of aromatic aldehydes such as p-anisaldehyde with Zn-powder and l,2-bis(chlorodimethylsilyl)ethane 45 give Zn-carbene adducts such as 2096 which add readily to olefins such as cyclohexene [22, 26] or styrene [26] to give high yields of cyclopropanes such as 2097 and the oxide 47 [26]. Acetals such as 2098 react analogously with cyclohexene to afford the endo and exo cyclopropanes 2099 and 2100 [22, 27] (Scheme 13.11). 

Aryldiazomethane can also be used for iron porphyrin-catalyzed alkene cyclopropanation [55]. For example, the treatment of p-tolyldiazomethane with styrene in the presence of [Fe(TTP)] afforded the corresponding arylcyclopropapane in 79% yield with a high transicis ratio of 14 1 (eq. 1 in Scheme 11). Interestingly, when bulkier mesityldiazomethane was used as carbene source, ds-selectivity was observed (cisitrans = 2.0 1). Additionally, mesityldiazomethane was found to react with frans-p-styrene, the latter was found not to react with EDA or trimethyl-silyldiazomethane under the similar reaction conditions, to give l-mesityl-2-methyl-3-phenylcyclopropane in 35% yield. Trimethylsilyldiazomethane is also an active carbene source for [Fe(TTP)]-catalyzed cyclopropanation of styrene, affording l-phenyl-2-trimethylsilylcyclopropane in 89% yield with transicis ratio of 10 1 (eq. 2 in Scheme 11). 

More recently, Carreira reported a [Fe(TPP)Cl]-catalyzed diastereoselective synthesis of trifluoromethyl-substituted cyclopropane in aqueous media [56]. The carbene precursor trifluoromethyl diazomethane is difficult to be handled, generated in situ from trifluoroethyl amine hydrochloride, and reacts with styrene in the presence of [Fe(TPP)Cl] to give the corresponding cyclopropanes in high yields and with excellent diastereoselectivities (Scheme 12). 

Interestingly, the cyclopropanation of styrenes with EDA catalyzed by the half sandwich iron complex [CpFe(CO)2(THF)] BF4 afforded cyclopropanes in good yields and with ds-selectivity cisitrans = 80 20) [62]. With phenyldiazomethane as a carbene source, excellent cA-selectivity (92-100%) was achieved (Scheme 15) [63]. 

There are a number of reports of NHC complexes of mid-late transition metals being used as catalysts for atom transfer radical polymerisation (ATRP) of acrylates and styrene. Grubbs reported Fe(II) complexes of a simple monodentate carbene. 

Fig. 4.15), are active for ATRP of both styrene and methylmethacrylate (MMA) [46]. Polymerisation was well controlled with polydispersities ranging from 1.05 to 1.47. The rates of polymerisation 1 x 10 s ) showed the complexes to be more active than phosphine and amine ligated Fe complexes, and were said to rival Cu-based ATRP systems. It was quite recent that Cu(I) complexes of NHCs were tested as ATRP catalysts [47]. In this work, tetrahydropyrimidine-based carbenes were employed to yield mono-carbene and di-carbene complexes 42 and 43 (Fig. 4.15), which were tested for MMA polymerisation. The mono-carbene complex 42 gave relatively high polydispersities (1.4-1.8) and a low initiation efficiency (0.5), both indicative of poor catalyst control. The di-carbene complex 43 led to nncontrolled radical polymerisation, which was ascribed to the insolubility of the complex. 

The related [1,2]-H shift in the isomeric triplet 1-phenylethylidene (53) was also investigated. The triplet carbene, generated from irradiation of the corresponding diazo compound, was characterized in low temperature inert matrices by EPR, IR, and UV/VIS spectroscopy. In this case, the carbene was stable in Ar up to the temperature limits of the matrix (36 K). Irradiation, however, readily converted the carbene to styrene. 

The thermal conversion of carbene 53 to styrene could also be observed in Xe matrices. Although stable at 12 K for at least 24 h, increasing amounts of carbene were observed to convert to styrene as the temperature was raised gradually to ca. 60 K. At each intermediate temperature between 12 and 60 K, site clearing behavior was detected, where some amounts of carbene disappeared rapidly, followed by no further decay. At around 60 K, the carbene rearranged with exponential first-order... 

Photolysis of acyldisilanes at A > 360 nm (103,104) was shown, based on trapping experiments, to yield both silenes 22 and the isomeric siloxy-carbenes 23, but with polysilylacylsilanes only silenes 24 are formed, as shown by trapping experiments and NMR spectroscopy (104,122-124) (see Scheme 4). These silenes react conventionally with alcohols, 2,3-dimethylbutadiene (with one or two giving some evidence of minor amounts of ene-like products), and in a [2 + 2] manner with phenyl-propyne. Ketones, however, do not react cleanly. Perhaps the most unusual behavior of this family of silenes is their exclusive head-to-head dimerization as described in Section V. More recently it has been found that these silenes undergo thermal [2 + 2] reactions with butadiene itself (with minor amounts of the [2 + 4] adduct) and with styrene and vinyl-naphthalene. Also, it has been found that a dimethylsilylene precursor will... 

Diazomethane is also decomposed by N O)40 -43 and Pd(0) complexes43 . Electron-poor alkenes such as methyl acrylate are cyclopropanated efficiently with Ni(0) catalysts, whereas with Pd(0) yields were much lower (Scheme 1)43). Cyclopropanes derived from styrene, cyclohexene or 1-hexene were formed only in trace yields. In the uncatalyzed reaction between diazomethane and methyl acrylate, methyl 2-pyrazoline-3-carboxylate and methyl crotonate are formed competitively, but the yield of the latter can be largely reduced by adding an appropriate amount of catalyst. It has been verified that cyclopropane formation does not result from metal-catalyzed ring contraction of the 2-pyrazoline, Instead, a nickel(0)-carbene complex is assumed to be involved in the direct cyclopropanation of the olefin. The preference of such an intermediate for an electron-poor alkene is in agreement with the view that nickel carbenoids are nucleophilic 44). 

Pd(OAc)2 works well with strained double bonds as well as with styrene and its ring-substituted derivatives. Basic substituents cannot be tolerated, however, as the failures with 4-(dimethylamino)styrene, 4-vinylpyridine and 1 -vinylimidazole show. In contrast to Rh2(OAc)4, Pd(OAe)2 causes preferential cyclopropanation of the terminal or less hindered double bond in intermolecular competition experiments. These facts are in agreement with a mechanism in which olefin coordination to the metal is a determining factor but the reluctance or complete failure of Pd(II)-diene complexes to react with diazoesters sheds some doubt on the hypothesis of Pd-olefin-carbene complexes (see Sect. 11). 

The common by-products obtained in the transition-metal catalyzed reactions are the formal carbene dimers, diethyl maleate and diethyl fumarate. In accordance with the assumption that they owe their formation to the competition of olefin and excess diazo ester for an intermediate metal carbene, they can be widely suppressed by keeping the actual concentration of diazo compound as low as possible. Usually, one attempts to verify this condition by slow addition of the diazo compound to an excess (usually five- to tenfold) of olefin. This means that the addition rate will be crucial for the yields of cyclopropanes and carbene dimers. For example, Rh6(CO)16-catalyzed cyclopropanation of -butyl vinyl ether with ethyl diazoacetate proceeds in 69% yield when EDA is added during 30 minutes, but it increases to 87 % for a 6 h period. For styrene, the same differences were observed 65). 

By contrast, much of the work performed using ruthenium-based catalysts has employed well-defined complexes. These have mostly been studied in the ATRP of MMA, and include complexes (158)-(165).400-405 Recent studies with (158) have shown the importance of amine additives which afford faster, more controlled polymerization.406 A fast polymerization has also been reported with a dimethylaminoindenyl analog of (161).407 The Grubbs-type metathesis initiator (165) polymerizes MMA without the need for an organic initiator, and may therefore be used to prepare block copolymers of MMA and 1,5-cyclooctadiene.405 Hydrogenation of this product yields PE-b-PMMA. N-heterocyclic carbene analogs of (164) have also been used to catalyze the free radical polymerization of both MMA and styrene.408... 

The course of decomposition of confirmed or presumed metallocyclo-butane intermediates is important, but most results reported deal with stoichiometric rather than catalytic processes. Retention of the 3-carbon skeleton via pathways d or f in Eq. (26) occurs much more frequently than does cleavage to metathesis-related products. For example, thermolysis of phenyl-substituted platinocyclobutanes yields propenylben-zenes and phenyl-cyclopropane, but no styrene or ethylene (77). Similarly, the decomposition of tantalum carbene adducts (8) with olefins... 

The additional reactive intermediate responsible for the curvature was postulated17,33 to be a CAC.30 The mechanism of Scheme 2 was proposed, in which carbene 10a was in equilibrium with the CAC. Thus, styrenes 11a and 12a can be formed by two pathways from the free carbene (kj) and from the CAC (k-). A steady-state kinetic analysis of Scheme 2 affords Eq. 11, which predicts that a correlation of rearr/addn with l/[alkene] should be linear the behavior actually observed by Tomioka and Liu.17,33 The CAC mechanism also accounts for the observation that the lla/12a product ratio depends upon the identity and concentration of the added alkene both k[ and k2, which define the Y-intercept of Eq. 11, depend on the added alkene. The dependence has been observed,19,33-37 albeit with only small variations in the Y-intercepts. 

The photolyses of diazirines 9a and 9b were similarly studied in Ar matrices at 10-34.5 K 59 Eq. 10. Benzylchlorocarbene (10a) and its ct,a-d2 analogue (10b) were observed by UV or IR (10b) spectroscopy, and their decay to styrenes 11 and 12 could be monitored. Tunneling in these 1,2-H(D) shifts was indicated by (a) much higher rates of carbene decay at 10 K than could be anticipated from extrapolation of the 298 K LFP kinetic data, (b) a kinetic isotope effect (KIE) for the 1,2-H(D) shifts estimated at 2000, and (c) little temperature dependence of the rate at low temperature.59 Accepting that QMT is important in the very low temperature H shifts of carbenes 10 and 18, the obvious question becomes is QMT important at higher or even ambient temperatures ... 

It was also found that the ring expansion could be accomplished photo-chemically, from either phenyldiazomethane or triplet phenylcarbene.7 Both the thermal and photochemical ring expansions were found to be reversible,5c, thus providing rare examples of carbene-to-carbene interconversions. One remarkable example of this reversibility is the interconversion of the isomeric tolylcarbenes upon pyrolysis — the ultimate products of which include styrene and benzocyclobutene (Scheme 3).6,8,9... 

A complicating factor associated with experimental application of the Skell Hypothesis is that triplet carbenes abstract hydrogen atoms from many olefins more rapidly than they add to them. Also, in general, the two cyclopropanes that can be formed are diastereomers, and thus there is no reason to expect that they will be formed from an intermediate with equal efficiency. To allay these problems, stereospecifically deuteriated a-methyl-styrene has been employed as a probe for the multiplicity of the reacting carbene. In this case, one bond formation from the triplet carbene is expected to be rapid since it generates a particularly well-stabilized 1,3-biradical. Also, the two cyclopropane isomers differ only in isotopic substitution and this is anticipated to have only a small effect on the efficiencies of their formation. The expected non-stereospecific reaction of the triplet carbene is shown in (15) and its stereospecific counterpart in (16). 

The transient triplet carbene formed from irradiation of DABA in benzene can be observed to react with styrene. For this process laser spectroscopy reveals a bimolecular rate constant (ksty) equal to 1.2 x 107M-1s-1. The product of the reaction is the expected cyclopropane. This observation clearly supports the spectral assignment of the carbene made above. When deuteriated a-methylstyrene is substituted for styrene as a trap for the carbene, the cyclopropane that results is a 1 1 mixture of stereoisomers, (20) (Table 6). This finding indicates that BA is reacting in this sequence exclusively from its ground triplet state. 

The species identified as XA reacts with styrene to give the expected cyclopropane. The rate constant for this reaction is ca 200 times less than the corresponding rate constant for 3BA (Table 6). Also, use of the deuterium-labeled a-methylstyrene reveals that the cyclopropanation occurs with essentially total retention of stereochemistry. Moreover, precisely the same result is obtained when this carbene is formed by triplet sensitization rather than by direct irradiation. These findings also point to a reaction originating from a singlet carbene. 

A plausible mechanism for the Ru-catalyzed process is illustrated in Scheme 10. With terminal styrenes such as 40, reaction begins regioselectively with the formation of metal-carbene 42 (Scheme 10) [18]. Subsequent rear-... 

---