Skell hypothesis

From an historical point of view, the earliest indication of spin-selective reactivity of carbenes was exhibited by the stereochemistry of the cyclo-propanation reaction. The Skell Hypothesis (Skell and Woodworth, 1956) suggests that a spin-prohibition requires the addition of a triplet carbene to an olefin to occur in at least two steps. In turn, the obligatory formation of an... 

A complicating factor associated with experimental application of the Skell Hypothesis is that triplet carbenes abstract hydrogen atoms from many olefins more rapidly than they add to them. Also, in general, the two cyclopropanes that can be formed are diastereomers, and thus there is no reason to expect that they will be formed from an intermediate with equal efficiency. To allay these problems, stereospecifically deuteriated a-methyl-styrene has been employed as a probe for the multiplicity of the reacting carbene. In this case, one bond formation from the triplet carbene is expected to be rapid since it generates a particularly well-stabilized 1,3-biradical. Also, the two cyclopropane isomers differ only in isotopic substitution and this is anticipated to have only a small effect on the efficiencies of their formation. The expected non-stereospecific reaction of the triplet carbene is shown in (15) and its stereospecific counterpart in (16). 

Skell s hypothesis proved to be extremely useful in carbene chemistry even though it was frequently opposed. The principal significance of these rules is represented in the scheme below. The singlet reaction occurs in a concerted step, the cis-addition product being formed in a stereospeciiic manner. In the triplet addition, which is a two-step reaction, rotation is thought to be faster than intersystem crossing (spin inversion) and ring closure, i.e., which would... 

---